10 Awesome TV Shows That Survived A Disastrous Pilot Episode

211 A TV pilot has an incredibly difficult job - it has to introduce a whole new set of characters and a premise within a short amount of time, all while simultaneously trying not to seem like an advertisement to the viewer (even though it is). The pilot is the make or break episode and, I'll be honest, I have given up on so many TV shows after watching the pilot and being underwhelmed. The truth is that a lot of people just don't see the point in carrying on with a show that they didn't enjoy the first episode of. The thinking behind it's true, after all, if you don't like one episode, why would you enjoy the rest? Some shows have brilliant pilots but fail to reach their potential and quietly shuffle off into mediocrity, like Aaron Sorkin's Studio 60 On The Sunset Strip or Revolution, but a lot of shows have really bad pilot episodes and become something truly great or unmissable despite that. It is those shows that are the most intriguing, given their defiance of the usual rules of TV, and their enduring success despite inauspicious starts, which is why they come into focus here...

10. Scrubs (2001-2010)

115What Was So Bad? The Pilot of Scrubs is tonally all over the place. We would come to love Scrubs as a quirky comedy that could also do serious drama and a serialised storyline if it needed to, but in the pilot, it feels more like an episode of ER with jokes in it. The problem is it tries to introduce too many style hallmarks at once - first person narrative, flashbacks, narration and fantasy sequences, and it's just exhausting to watch. Zach Braff also isn't yet comfortable in JD's shoes and it really shows, and the hospital is completely different and as a result so is the geography, which is confusing to the viewer if they've seen any other episodes. It might just be the script, but it really feels like the actors are being restrained, which can be best seen with Neil Flynn's portrayal of Janitor, which is almost completely different to what it would become. How Did They Fix It? After the pilot there was a conscience effort to bring a more quirky style to the series, which really works, and by letting the actors portray the characters the way they think they should be, there is a more genuine and real style of comedy going on. Once the actors settle into the groove in Episode 2, it feels like we're watching old friends or colleagues who've worked together for years instead of just a few weeks, and it really makes the audience more comfortable. More comedy characters were brought into the fold, like Todd, Hooch and Ted (who really only had a bit part in the Pilot), thus allowing the introduction of 'B' plots, providing a comedy alternative if there's a dramatic main narrative.

9. Doctor Who (2005-Present)

123What Was So Bad? So, technically, "Rose" - the first episode of the first series of New Who - isn't strictly a pilot, but in a way it had to do all the same things a pilot had to. I recently re-watched the entire New Who run in preparation for the 50th Anniversary and I couldn't help but feel bored by "Rose". Compared to the rest of the show it's very dull and very little of note actually happens, to the extent that we don't even meet the Doctor until a good way through the episode. Also, the villains are an issue: the Autons are great villains ("Spearhead From Space" being a highlight episode) but if we're being honest, they're not suitable for the 2000s, and they're really not the villain you'd pick to introduce a sci-fi series to a new generation, are they? They're walking mannequins that look like Bruce Forsyth after a plastic surgery mishap. No thanks. Eccleston's performance is all over the shop as well, almost as if he's just been chucked onto the set and doesn't know whether to play it completely serious or with touches of humour, and the result is that his performance comes off a little fake. Let's talk about set design - the lighting is so poor, at times it feels like we're watching a documentary. If you look at the TARDIS interior in "Rose" compared to "The End of the World" you'll see a noticeable difference. In "Rose", the interior lighting is all pink and green, making it look cheap, a bit like a 50s low-budget sci-fi film, it really undersells the massive scale of the TARDIS and, unfortunately, harks back to the 1970s and wobbly sets in TV Centre. How Did They Fix It? Eccleston's performance is much more nuanced and less in-your-face in subsequent episodes and we actually get to go into space. Imagine that, going into space in a sci-fi programme. Whatever next? The lighting and, it seems, the video quality also much improved, apparently due to their budget being increased and thus they could afford better cameras and lighting. Much more humour and less romance was brought into subsequent Season 1 episodes, along with a vein of darkness and the introduction of a story arc - Bad Wolf - which only helps us anticipate the finale even more and builds up suspense throughout the season. Russell T. Davies, the showrunner, also injected some much needed continuity nods for the fans, and as a result it feels more like a continuation of the classic series and not a rejig for a new generation.

8. How I Met Your Mother (2005-2014)

131What Was So Bad? It's hard to believe that one of the funniest and most innovative shows on TV started out life as a Friends rip-off, but if you watch the pilot of How I Met Your Mother, that should be far from a shocking revelation. Even though we meet our characters several years into their romantic relationships and bromances, there's little chemistry between the actors and thus the characters, and it really shows on screen. There's some good gags scattered throughout the episode, but it's excruciating at times with the awkwardness and cynicism going on. How Did They Fix It? Neil Patrick Harris' Barney Stinson was recognised as the standout character of the show and was used a lot more in subsequent episodes, meaning we got to find out more about the character as time went on, instead of him just being the creepy single guy who hangs around with two couples. The other actors also seem to fit more into their roles and better chemistry is the consequence, making it a much better show. More 'fantasy' and cutaway scenes were introduced, and the premise itself was simplified and the narration reduced, with the show now feeling less like an extended flashback and more like a current TV show.

7. Bones (2005-present)

141What Was So Bad? The pilot of Bones isn't bad it's just a bit wrong. It takes far too long setting up the premise, which is really clever, but never really pulls it off quite right, and quickly becomes derivative of every other show that's on, like CSI and even The X Files. There's little chemistry between Booth and Brennan in the first episode, which is something we'd come to love as part of the show, and it really shows on screen. The dialogue is wordy and doesn't really go anywhere, making it an ordeal to get through. How Did They Fix It? Honestly, i's not terrible by any means, it's just different to what the series would become and the pilot blends in with the scenery of other crime shows. After the pilot there seemed to be a reshuffle behind the scenes and the show really started using its premise well, and as a result it's going strong after nine seasons. The cinematography, lighting and performances are also markedly better after the Pilot, a result of confidence and an increased budget, as well as the series finding its feet and settling into its own style. More characters were introduced throughout the season and gave the show a real feeling of being like a family. The police procedural element was continuously changed week-in week-out to keep the format fresh, too.

6. 30 Rock (2006-2013)

49What Was So Bad? 30 Rock is one of the most subversive, irreverent and genuinely funny shows on television, and any show that allows Alec Baldwin to lampoon his left-wing leanings by playing a right-wing blowhard has got to be good. What isn't good, however, is the pilot. It's funny, don't get me wrong, but you can tell it was really mellowed to get onto TV and had none of the craziness we came to love. There's far too much of Tina Fey trying to be Mary Tyler Moore instead of becoming her own character - though thankfully, this was rectified in later episodes and Liz Lemon became an icon in her own right. 30 Rock's pilot also suffered from recasting and thus reshooting. Jenna was originally played by Rachel Dratch, but network executives felt Jane Krakowski would be a better fit in the role and provide some much-needed contrast in the Liz-Jack-Jenna dynamic. For once, they were right. However the last minute re-shooting really shows and the words coming out of Jenna's mouth don't really fit with her changed character (she's much too nice!) How Did They Fix It? Simply by not trying to be popular: in its first 6 episodes the show is like that kid at school that really tries too hard to be liked and just comes off phoney. The first episode of what we'll call 'classic' 30 Rock is 1x07 - Tracy Does Conan. It's 30 Rock as we know and love it - quirky, humour about Liz's eating and a plot involving Dr Spaceman. Some of the meta humour about TV making was toned down as well, and it became less about TGS and more about Liz's personal life, her relationship with Jack and there was much more humour forged from these connections. The quirky comedy really starts to shine through and the 'Floyd' story arc showed that 30 Rock was a different animal with a much more serialised nature, not just a turn in and switch off sitcom like it was expected to be. It became less afraid of being what it wanted to be - a story about Jenna trying to marry a foreign prince to 'Grace Kelly' herself? Go for it. An episode where Jack shoots Wayne Brady at the Source Awards? Why not! Jack's boss getting reincarnated as a peacock... Yep. Alec Baldwin's role of Jack Donaghy is also increased and written differently throughout Season 1, becoming less of an antagonist to the TGS team and more of a - in Jack's own words - a subordifriend. And, let's be honest, more of the instantly quotable Jack Donaghy can never be a bad thing.

5. Seinfeld (1989-1998)

19What Was So Bad? It might come as something of a painful revelation, but it's true. The pilot for Seinfeld (or The Seinfeld Chronicles as it was then known) is truly disastrous. If you watch the pilot, and then the rest of the series as I did, it's like watching two completely different shows. First off, Kramer is actually called Kessler and, for no reason whatsoever, has a dog. Kramer genuinely feels a little creepy in this episode, more of a stalker than a loveable idiot, and it's only down to the good acting of Michael Richards that he doesn't come off as a complete loon and potential serial killer. There's no Elaine either - seriously, one of the best characters of the entire show isn't in the pilot, and instead, we get a waitress at Pete's Luncheonette - not Monk's Cafe - called Claire, who really contributes nothing to the show. The complete difference between sets and characters aside, the episode is almost entirely humour free. Sure, there's a few snickers here and there, but no signs of the monumental and iconic TV show it would become. In fact, if not for NBC executive Rick Ludwin giving it a rerun airing during pilot season and using his own budget for specials to fund season 1, we might not even be talking about it on this list. It might have been on "The 6 Worst Pilots Ever". Just think about that. How Did They Fix It? Julia Louis-Dreyfus, basically. Elaine is one of the central figures of the show and her absence in the pilot is really jarring, she brought such a different dynamic to the group of Jerry, George and Kramer that it's weird not seeing her there. Elaine was the much-needed female character in what was essentially a male-dominated show, she and the guys could agree and disagree in endless combinations without it ever getting boring. Larry David also took a much more hands-on producing role and broke away some of the sitcom shackles, making it a lot less conventional and more dark-humoured. There were also less conventional sitcom plots, and they invented a lot of them. When "The Chinese Restaurant" aired in 1991, it was unthinkable to have an entire episode set in real-time without a very interesting plot, but Seinfeld made it work by focusing on the humour of real life - we've all stood in line at restaurants getting frustrated and arguing with our friends.

4. Star Trek: The Next Generation (1987-1994)

317What Was So Bad? Let me preface this by saying that I'm a huge Star Trek fan and that Picard is my all-time favourite captain (closely followed by Archer) - but with that said, let's get into why this is a bad pilot episode. Firstly, it's very dated and immediately screams '1980s pilot,' thanks to the shag carpeting in the bridge, the pink lighting, and of course the poor special effects. The thing with 'Encounter At Farpoint' is that it tries too hard to be different. Sure, at this point Star Trek was trying to break away from its wobbly sets and bad puppets roots of The Original Series, but to completely disregard a lot of tradition in the pilot episode was a bit much. The villain they chose to star in this episode €“ Q €“ would obviously become a much-loved recurring villain in the show, but here he is very watered down and subdued, and for some reason appears in a Renaissance costume. It's a very slow and talky episode, which gets bogged down in the technobabble and can never seem to strike the right balance between the threat of Q and introducing its new crew. The over-dramatic music and obviously fake planet exteriors don't really help either, and if it wasn't for Patrick Stewart's taking everything as though it's Shakespeare and the Trek name attached, I doubt it would've survived past its first season. It's adequate, but just that €“ nothing more and nothing less. How Did They Fix It? Instead of rehashing old plots for a new generation, the TNG writers started writing more action-oriented and sci-fi plots, and introducing new Alien characters. The creation of the Borg was one of the most inspired writing decisions and gave the series its primary threat, much like TOS had with the Klingons, and after Season 1 it 'grew the beard' and stopped living in the shadows of its predecessor. A new writing staff was brought in and the show dealt with a lot more serious themes and had many multi-part episodes, which allowed the writers to explore new ideas in a longer form. With an increased budget after the pilot and improved filming equipment, the series genuinely looked cinematic, and the introduction of the new holodeck allowed episodes to take place off-planet and off-ship, meaning we get a lot of period episodes with Picard in his Dixon Hill guise, which is only a good thing. Also, the stopped the men wearing skirts. No, seriously - in season 1 some of the male background extras wear skirts.

3. The Office (2005-2013)

57What Was So Bad? The Office USA didn't just have a bad pilot, it had a bad first season. The opener is clunky and has way too much exposition, the writers make the mistake of trying to introduce us to all the characters at once and haven't really gotten the hang of the mockumentary format yet (the actors either play it too much like single-camera or play up to the cameras completely). Michael Scott is a complete creep in season 1 €“ with his Gordon Gecko slicked back hair and sloppy dress, he's like the creepy boss who always comes on to you at a Christmas party and shows no signs of what he later became - the genuinely likeable worker who got promoted out of his ability and is trying desperately to pretend he knows what he's doing. How Did They Fix It? The show was also still in the shadow of its UK counterpart, and frankly this only harmed it. A lot of Season 1 scripts are re-workings or adaptations of the UK episodes, and thus much of the content doesn't play well on the other side of the pond. As strange as it sounds, the UK version was just a little too acerbic for American tastes and it wasn't really until Season 2 that the sweeter side of The Office was brought out and we got to see more of the inter-personal relationships and get to love the characters. The rivalry between Jim and Dwight was also amped up more and brought a lot more humour to the show that didn't necessarily focus on Michael, meaning B-Plots could be utilised a lot better.

2. Buffy The Vampire Slayer (1997-2003)

66What Was So Bad? Buffy is a strange case: not only did Joss Whedon (praise Joss!) have to introduce his characters to a new audience, he also had to retcon the events of the 1992 film for anyone who'd seen that (not a lot of people, and it's probably best you give it a miss). It's not completely disastrous, it's just that it didn't really know what it wanted to be. Was it going to be a teenage angst dramedy balancing puberty and boys with vampires, or a quirky comedy about the cheerleader who also goes out at night to slay demons, or maybe even a completely serious vampire-hunting drama? In the pilot, we get all of these. At one point in the 'Welcome To Hellmouth', the plot veers from 'Clueless' into a completely serious film, and that really affects the overall tone. Also, the low-budget really shows in this pilot. It's quite obvious the film used was of a lower quality and a lot of effects were rushed to get done in time for broadcast. The action scenes really fall flat and we never believe that Buffy is going to fail in her mission. It's only as Whedon got more comfortable with the characters that the show really hit its stride and became one of the better dramas that The WB/The CW ever produced. How Did They Fix It? Less focus was put on the teenage elements - Xander stops using a skateboard, for one - and, whilst there were still plots that focused on Buffy's teenage problems, a lot more focus was put on the Vampire-hunting theme of the series, and Buffy was made into more of an action girl. Giles is also less bookish as time goes on and becomes a real bad-ass and hilarious character. With an increased budget, they were able to create more arc episodes and themed episodes, like 'Once More with Feeling' and 'Hush'. It also started to balance better the line between comedy and horror and sometimes wasn't afraid to go completely one way or the other, making for some genuinely scary and hilarious episodes. It was this crazy format that made Buffy so popular, you could tune in each week and not really know what you were going to get.

1. Blackadder (1983-1989)

92What Was So Bad? The pilot of Blackadder (and, in fact, the whole first series) is shockingly poor. The show plays more like a historical drama with a few funny bits, instead of the other way around. The writers made the mistake of trying to be too historically accurate to the time period, and as a result we get a very boring series with very little humour. The show was shot on location with laughter added later, and it shows €“ the film quality is awful and just dates the show completely. The casting of Brian Blessed as the King is an inspired touch, but he's completely out of place in what is supposed to be a farcical comedy how. Edmund is a complete sniveling idiot in it, nothing like the devious, saracastic anti-hero his ancestors would become. How Did They Fix It? Ironically, with a budget cut. The BBC cut their budget hugely and forced the creators to shoot in a studio, which means more focus was put on the humour and comedy, instead of the historical accuracy. Rowan Atkinson was also kicked off the writing team and replaced with Ben Elton, who turned Edmund into the scheming, sarcastic manipulator we know and love. The format never got stale because each series was set in a different historical era and as a result different humour could be extrapolated from the various new situations we found the characters in. Also, by being shot in a studio with an audience actually there, there's a different energy with the cast, akin to live theatre and the episodes really hurtle along with jokes and gags being thrown at you so fast you don't have time to breathe. Also - no Fry, no Laurie and Baldrick isn't a complete idiot. Did we miss any TV shows that managed to survive an awful pilot and went on to great success and acclaim? Share your own picks below in the comments thread.

Contributor
Contributor

3rd Year Film and Television Production student at Edge Hill University. Writer of "Stockton's Last Stand" and screenwriter/director of "Hunted" and "Spyfail 2: The Search for Spyfail 1". I also do stand-up comedy sometimes... I'm told I'm marginally funny.