10 Awesome TV Shows Whose Hype Totally Backfired!
These shows may be awesome, but too much hype can backfire hard.
If there is any important lesson to be gleaned from our modern media landscape, it's this: corporate monopolies on media enterprises is a bad idea that drowns out creativity and healthy competition in pursuit of the bottom line. But only SLIGHTLY less important a lesson is this: nothing turns potential new viewers off from your product more effectively than too much hype.
You would think that the best way to get someone to watch something would be to tell them what makes it so damn great. But there comes a point, whether it's near constant word of mouth or advertising being crammed full of the thing 24/7 or both, when hype can in fact scare people off.
And sometimes if they do watch it, their expectations become so high that nothing could match it, and the little problems with the show that you didn't notice become IMMEDIATELY noticeable to them. After all, if this show is so awesome, why did it do this thing, or that thing, or this other thing?
But that doesn't detract from the quality of the shows themselves, it just proves that maybe we should all dial it back a notch. From advertising campaigns to constant public presence, the hype may be real, but it can definitely be too much.
10. Buffy The Vampire Slayer
Joss Whedon has had an... interesting career, hasn't he? Starting out as a TV show-runner before moving on to big budget Hollywood movies like Serenity and The Avengers, Whedon has cemented his place in geek culture. But as geeks are one to do, his work can be built up just a bit too much.
Case in point, Buffy The Vampire Slayer, by far Whedon's most lasting work on television. Besides kicking off Sarah Michelle Gellar's career, it's also gained notoriety for its fun monster action, its progressive politics about sexual orientation and gender roles, while also being one of the best character dramas on the air in its day.
However, if you want people to see all that, then you might wanna start them off later in the show's life. For the first one and a half seasons, Buffy is a straightforward monster of the week show taking place in a high school. Granted, a really good monster of the week show, but a lot of it hasn't aged well, even in later seasons.
You can't really blame Buffy for not ageing great in this regard, but in this age of Rebecca Sugar, G Willow Wilson, Noelle Stevenson, and the Wachowski sisters, the feminist and sexual politics of Buffy that made it so acclaimed seem quaint at best, toothless at worst when viewed today. Not helped by Joss turning out to be nowhere near as enlightened as he portrayed himself.
Still a great show overall, but definitely one we've been selling too hard.
9. Stranger Things
Now that we're on the third season, the fandom around Stranger Things has thankfully simmered down immensely, especially compared to when it started.
Being one of the first Netflix original shows to gain genuine popularity, Netflix and viewers alike were dogged in their attempt to make sure as many people as possible watched it. And if you were to watch it during the time of all that hype, there's a decent chance that you might have thought it was overblown.
Now granted, we're talking about a time when only one season of Stranger Things was out. Seasons 2 and 3 are undoubtedly an improvement on what came before. But one flaw that does tend to exist throughout - which might turn off some people - is the near constant fellatio of 80's pop culture. Considering that you can't go 5 minutes without some new show or movie shoving something that happened in the 80's in your face, those who never lived through the 80's might not be keen to add more of that to their lives.
Add onto that some other hiccups that season 1 had (which to be fair, most season 1's have because they're still new at this) and it's no wonder that there's a decently sized amount of folks who - while they don't hate it - just aren't all that interested.
8. Game Of Thrones
Look, you probably don't need to be told this, but this show didn't exactly leave people satisfied.
But when it was good, Game Of Thrones really was one of the absolute best shows on television, and definitely one of HBO's masterworks. Its characters were complex, its content shocking, but never to a point where it became exploitative (something its copycats definitely failed to learn), and the political intrigued kept you as glued to the screen about as effectively as it kept readers glued to the novels.
However, Game Of Thrones is DEFINITELY not for everyone, not by a long shot. After all, one can hardly blame someone for not wanting to watch a show where every female character is brutally raped at least twice. So when you build up a show as the greatest thing to happen since tummy rubs, and then display such... controversial content, it's no wonder why for every person obsessed with Game Of Thrones, there were some who just couldn't get into it.
7. Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood
Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood is considered one of those shows you absolutely have to see before you die. And while certainly excellent once it gets going, the show definitely leaves a lackluster first impression, especially compared to its 2003 predecessor. Indeed, while FMAB may have a superior - well - everything else, FMA 2003 has the superior beginning.
And it's easy to see why, Bones worked on both shows, so they skimmed over everything they did in the first half of 03's first season when they got to Brotherhood. Then 15 episodes later someone must have finally whacked the director upside the head and explained the problem with that approach. The first 15 episodes of Brotherhood are the prime definition of rushed. And while most people can withstand two or three lackluster first episodes, 15 is asking a bit much. And unlike Buffy, you can't skip them because they have too many important plot beats.
Still a fantastic show at the end of the day, and definitely superior to 03 where it counts. But first impressions are everything, and with the hype surrounding this show, that first season is a rough as hell sell.
6. Firefly
With only one season, 14 episodes in total to its name, the hype surrounding this show is interesting, since it's born purely out of frustration. The mishandling of this show by Fox is legendary at this point, from infamously poor advertising, to a near constantly changing time slot, Fox was determined to kill this show right out of the gate.
We'll never know what this show's true potential was, but the episodes we got were good enough that to this day, people are still talking about it. However, because of its limited amount of episodes, there's a ton of setup, with inevitably no payoff. Character arcs are seriously incomplete, plot elements that look interesting go nowhere, and generally the show is great, but feels as unfinished as it was.
Of course, bringing this up to someone might end up deterring them from actually watching it. After all, why get invested in a story that will never payoff what it sets up? It probably wouldn't be on this list if it got so much as one more season, since those 14 episodes really do live up to the hype for the most part.
But as it stands, you're better off tracking down a copy of Outlaw Star.
5. Batman: The Animated Series
Batman: The Animated Series has garnered some well earned praise since its debut. From kicking off the entire DC animated universe that lasted throughout the 90's and into the mid-2000's, to finally getting Paul Dini that Emmy, and of course, we have this show to thank for cementing Kevin Conroy as the one true Batman and Mark Hamill as the one true Joker.
So this show is absolutely perfect, right? Well, no show is, but Batman TAS' is an interesting case, because it was made in a very different era from today. Someone watching needs to be fully aware of how shows back then worked in order to completely gel with it.
For one, this was before the time of cartoon seasons having a set amount of episodes, so each season can feel like it's going on for a while. While the show holds up shockingly well under HD scrutiny (likely partly due to every frame being drawn on black paper) the character movements can at times feel a bit sluggish.
And finally, like a lot of shows back then, it is not a streaming show, and binging it all at once will likely exhaust you. The episodes everyone talks about still hold up, but when watched in constant succession, it can wear down.
The hype, like the other entries on this list, is well earned. But selling it to someone who's grown up with today's method of watching television will require a few caveats.
4. My Hero Academia
No one hypes like the anime community, period. The fact that we have two animes on this list should be proof enough of that. And nothing embodies the anime hype machine better than a good shonen anime. And My Hero Academia isn't just a good shonen anime, but rather one of the best that we've had in over a decade.
That is, if you LIKE shonen and all its conventions and trappings. If you don't, MHA isn't all that interested in changing your mind. Indeed, while this show (and especially the manga) have long since tipped their hand by now to reveal that they have more going on under the hood, it takes a bit to get there.
So if you've been hearing about My Hero Academia, and how it's the best thing since a humorous example of something positive, and you sit down to watch it from the beginning, you're going to find a checklist of popular shonen cliches and tropes, and MHA ticking boxes. All setup for bigger and smarter things, we know now, but that's 50 or so episodes from the beginning, and you can't ask someone to hold out that long if they aren't okay with these tropes.
3. Gravity Falls
Unlike the other ones we've seen, the kneecapping by hype rests squarely on the fandom surrounding it. Sure, you could argue that Gravity Falls helped create the obsessive hype machine that surrounds it by indulging the internet's need to theorize and connect dots and decode puzzles, but that was meant to be in good fun.
If you took away an impression of Gravity Falls from how the fandom chooses to remember it, you'd probably get the kid's version of Sherlock, a complex, detail-obsessed, puzzle within a puzzle within another puzzle with gripping drama and 4-dimensional characters.
if you watched the show, you know it's a complex, detail obsessed comedy for kids with only one - admittedly big - puzzle throughout with enough drama to get it by and a pig. Everyone forgets the pig.
The fandom just doesn't remember the same show it watched anymore.
2. Steven Universe
If there is anything to take away from this list, it's that nothing ruins hype more than a lackluster first impression. Not even a bad first impression, but if the first several episodes don't hook you, why should you devote your time to watching more with the hope of it getting better?
To an extent, the Steven Universe fandom is aware of this, which is why when they talk about the best episodes, across the board, you'll notice that most of the episodes from season 1 are conspicuously absent. Steven Universe takes 24 episodes - 12 episodes comprised of two ten minute long episodes - to actually start getting interesting, or really any good to be honest. Before then it's just a weird story about a kinda annoying kid who raps about ice cream cats and occasionally they'll fight a monster.
The minute Lapis Lazuli shows up, it's like the show has suddenly woken up from a stupor and remembered "oh yeah I'm supposed to be awesome" and then proceeds to be just that.
The 3 episode rule is flawed but it's there for a reason. It's not even that the episodes preceding that point are terrible, they just feel like they have no reason to exist. Only one or two are ever brought up again, so there's no reason the episodes couldn't have been structured better.
1. Rick And Morty
There is no question what awesome show has been irreparably crippled by its own hype and fandom than Rick And Morty. Shock of all shocks, a show that drove people to harass McDonald's employees has a bit of a hype problem.
Fandom shouldn't play a part in our enjoyment of a show, nor should the hype that surrounds said show, but the fact is that it does, because humans are influenced by the world that surrounds them. Anyone watching the show for the first time nowadays is going to know Rick And Morty going in as that show where all the memes come from and where all the people who think they're smarter than everyone else gather together in worship.
Watching folks willingly miss the point en masse of the Pickle Rick episode, and the character of Rick Sanchez in particular, can also turn people off from the show. Doesn't help that the show isn't as good at demonizing Rick's actions as it thinks it is. All the parts of the show that are meant to be "the point" aren't analyzed properly enough for some people, and all they see is an excuse for bad writing. Because the bad first impression was made before they even watched it.
This show is at the top not just because people were built up so much that it could only disappoint them. It's also here because that hype - and the form of behavior that it took - has begun to circle back around and turn into the cause of its own backlash.