10 Best Actors On American Horror Story

Gore, sex and disturbing scenes, and these actors make it look good.

A year ago, American Horror Story fans were rolling their eyes at the prospect of Lady Gaga "replacing" Jessica Lange in the current season of the show - and I use the word "replacing" loosely as she was hardly replacing the queen of AHS - only to find that the queen of pop managed to pull off her role as The Countess quite well, after all. With 5 seasons of shock and horror, the series has been one of the most successful FX shows to date and there's no guessing why either. The actors are all brilliant and bring their own flavour to an already-spicy show, and they all know exactly how to make each role their own, and with so many different characters to portray on one show, that's a rather difficult task for an actor to do. Fans can gladly admit that the show's producers definitely chose well when they cast the first few faces for season 1's Murder House and every other recurring actor that they cast down the line.

10. Denis O'Hare

You might be mistaken in thinking that O'Hare starred in all of the American Horror Story seasons, but he was notably missing in season 2's Asylum. The actor, who is best known for his role in True Blood as as Russell Edgington, the vampire king of Mississippi, has pulled off a range of characters both on AHS and various films and TV shows. In AHS season 1 he played Larry, a crazy and burnt psycho, in season 3, he was Spalding, the mute butler to the witch coven and in season 4 he played the dodgy Stanley, who was a horrible con-artist - and he portrayed them all brilliantly. However, it was his role as Hotel's Liz Taylor that really opened our eyes to what a brilliant actor the star really is. Denis portrays the cross-dressing bartender with pure class, bringing fans to tears with Liz's back story and making us all wish we had a little Liz in our lives.

9. Lady Gaga

The biggest surprise on this list is television newcomer Lady Gaga. Known for her edgy dress sense and can't-get-them-out-of-your-head radio hits, nobody (except maybe die-hard fans and those that have seen her over-the-top stage performances) really believed that the Pokerface singer could actually act, did they? Well, it's safe to say that she proved them wrong. In her role as The Countess, Gaga makes making a meal out of her lovers look uber-sophisticated. The Countess is mysterious and sexy, but also creepy as hell as she kidnaps little platinum blonde kids for her growing collection. While other fans are still hung up on Lange being able to play the role better, you can't argue that Lady Gaga is doing a superb job.

8. Angela Bassett

Feisty, fierce and downright bad-ass are just a few ways to describe actress Angela Bassett, and the characters she portrays on American Horror Story (or any other role for that matter) are no different. She joined the cast for the 3rd season's Coven as voodoo queen Marie Laveau and it earned her a nomination for a Primetime Emmy Award for Outstanding Supporting Actress in 2013. In Hotel, she plays Ramona Royale, an actress and former lover of The Countess. As usual, she delivers a real alpha-female performance as she murders and turns every second person in her path, only to wreak havoc in her former lover's life. She is the fire to Gaga's ice and she is amazing at it, wouldn't you say?

7. Kathy Bates

Kathy Bates crawled into fans hearts back in the 90's when she played the lovable Molly Brown in Titanic, and she's been residing there ever since. Her characters on American Horror Story are no exception either. She tends to play lovable and strong mother types that make you root for her no matter the circumstances - who could forget ol' Ethel Darling in Freak Show? In American Horror Story: Coven, Kathy did something we never thought she could make us do, however. She made us loathe her as the racist and despicable Madame Marie Delphine LaLaurie, a character based on the notorious New Orleans socialite, who tortured her slaves in the most inhumane ways (well, torture in itself is rather inhumane, but hey). Bates delivered an awesome performance, just like we knew she would.

6. Finn Wittrock

So, who do you love more? Your friendly neighbourhood psycho Dandy or Hotel's model junkie-slash-vampire Tristan? Finn Wittrock is a pretty boy, but aside from that, he delivered great performances as both characters, and it doesn't look like he's slowing down any time soon. While it's quite obvious that serial killer Dandy would have quite a few fans hate him for being a crazy rich brat in Freak Show, he actually turned out to be one of the best characters the show has ever produced, and thus has quite a fan base. Finn himself has quite the following, and despite looking like a youngster, he's already 31 years old and has a string of roles behind his name, like the soap opera All My Children and the feature film Twelve. His acting career only has one way to go from here, and with those looks and an amazing on-screen presence, you can only assume that it's up.

5. Lily Rabe

Lily Rabe has played everything from a hippy witch, a grieving mommy ghost and a serial murderer in the latest season of American Horror Story, but it was her performance as Sister Mary Eunice in season 2's Asylum that really put her at number 4 of this list. Do you remember her role as the creepy (and naughty) nun? An insecure, sweet little thing, Mary Eunice gets possessed by the devil and begins her unorthodox rule over the asylum, delighting in having free reign over the establishment. She wrecks havoc in the most devilish ways, all while pretending to be her old, butter-won't-melt-in-her-mouth self. Rabe pulls this performance off so stylishly that you'd almost swear that the personality is all her own.. and you can't deny that she was your favourite nun, like, ever.

4. Frances Conroy

Frances Conroy's been missing from the latest season of American Horror Story, and fans have been furious about it, but I suppose everyone needs a break every now and then. She's left a mark on fans with her stunning performances in previous seasons of American Horror Story, and the most incredible performance she has given us to date was that of the sexy maid in the first season. Or was it that of Myrtle Snow in Coven...? Hmm, it could have been playing Dandy's mother in Freak Show. Well, whatever your preference, there's no denying that she is one amazing actress and can literally convince you that she is the character that you see on television. Also, did you know that she also played Ruth Fisher in the series Six Feet Under? Of course you did, because you're a big fan of hers, aren't you? Now, if that's not an impressive resume, I don't know what is.

3. Sarah Paulson

"Say 'I love you Sally'..." Yes, that scene had quite an impact on you, and that's just what Sarah Paulson seems to do to American Horror Story viewers. She's like a presence that sticks with you long after you watched the show, no matter who she plays. Murder House didn't do Paulson's acting abilities justice when she played the medium Billie Dean Howard, but the producers of American Horror Story seemed to learn that they had a gem on their hands, and have since given her some hardcore characters to portray. Who could forget Lana Winters in Asylum, a role that had fans comparing her looks to that of Lana Del Rey's or even Bette and Dot Tattler in Freakshow, two very different Siamese sisters who have no choice but to live with one another. She's incredible, and personally a favourite of mine... but there are two other talents that I just have to give the top spots of this list to.

2. Jessica Lange

WHAT?! Jessica Lange isn't the top spot of this list?! Well, no. She is amazing, yes and there's no denying that she was the best actress of the entire series at all. She made a name for herself long before American Horror Story hit our screens and she will, no doubt, be dominating whatever projects she has in the future (and one of those might just be American Horror Story season 6), because she is one feisty, crazy and downright amazing performer. Narrowing down her American Horror Story performances to just one would be downright sinful, because she was basically the star of every single season thus far, so you'll just have to pick your favourite and argue it out with other fans of the show. So, if you could pick her best performance, would you say it was Constance Langdon in Murder House, Sister Jude in Asylum, Fiona Goode in "Coven", and Elsa Mars in "Freak Show"? Personally, I loved me some Sister Jude.

1. Evan Peters

He's been there since the start and he's played some of the most likeable characters on the show - who knew you could love a school shooter so much? - and in the latest season, Hotel, he is just to die for. In Hotel, he plays Mr. James Patrick March, a character who is heavily based on serial killer H.H. Holmes, a man known for building a hotel solely for the purpose of killing his guests. Evan portrays him with as much class and ignorance as you would expect a serial killer of the 1920's to have, but what really makes Evan a great actor is his ability to morph from a teenage heartthrob to a full-blown Oscar-worthy performer in pretty much anything he plays in. A chameleon of an actor, Evan has played murderous teenager, a man who is framed as a serial killer (and then gets abducted by aliens), a university student whose romantic involvement with a witch turns him into a Frankenstein project and a rebellious human oddity who makes a living by "pleasuring" wealthy women all in American Horror Story alone, and then he still did a fantastic job as Quicksilver in one of the X-Men films, a role that he will reprise in X-Men: Apocalypse.

Contributor
Contributor

"Don't take life too seriously. No one gets out alive anyway." Twitter: @GrungyUnicorn Instagram: https://instagram.com/mlgabriel22/ Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/mlgabrielwriting