10 Best Buffy The Vampire Slayer Villains
Buffy's best adversaries.
Buffy the Vampire Slayer is the ultimate in good vs evil TV series. Buffy, destined to slay the demons and vampires that plague the world, has killed off a lot of evil in her time.
Though a lot of her adversaries stand as one-episode, Monster of the Week-type villains, each season of the show features a major adversary whose evil ways drives that season's main plot. The main villains, known as the Big Bad, are often vanquished in the final episode; the secondary villains, called Little Bads, serve as Buffy's big threat until the true Big Bad reveals themselves.
There have been plenty of great one-time bad guys on the show, all there, causing havoc, until they're finally cut down, but none of them will be seen on this list. Rather, the following villains are Buffy's best recurring monsters, ghouls and opponents - the Little and Big Bads who stuck around and made a solid effort of taking the Slayer and her friends down.
Whether a vengeful witch, a vicious vampire, a politician with a devastating secret or a god mad with power, here are the 10 best recurring villains Buffy ever faced.
10. Caleb
Caleb (Nathan Fillion) was introduced in season seven as an agent of that season's Big Bad, the unseen, manipulative First Evil. For a long time, the First Evil had been working its magic by way of manipulation, brainwashing and a group of sinister foot soldiers called the Bringers. But with Caleb, the First Evil finally had a powerful vessel - a committed follower and brutal warrior.
A priest who constantly quotes the Bible and makes obscure references to its teachings, Caleb is nothing short of awful. Though seemingly righteous and good-hearted, he quickly reveals himself to be a rampant misogynist and a murderer hoping to be filled with the First Evil's power.
He spends his tenure on the show hidden in a vineyard, protecting an ancient scythe and plotting with his master. When Buffy (Sarah Michelle Gellar), Spike (James Marsters), Xander (Nicholas Brendon) and the Potential Slayers attack the vineyard, Caleb is able to best them all in combat, killing Slayers left and right, knocking Buffy and Spike around like ragdolls, and taking Xander's eye in an act guaranteed to make you squirm.
Watching Buffy finally cut him in half was a welcome demise.
9. The Trio
The Trio are without question the most divisive and perplexing of Buffy's Big Bads. Three socially awkward, fast-talking and childish geeks, The Trio comes together in season six under the leadership of the deplorable and manipulative Warren Mears (Adam Busch). Their attempts to beat down the Slayer actually start off kind of comical - freeze rays, groundhog day spells and sloppy demon attacks - but it's not long before they go from funny to formidable.
During the later half of season six, Warren, Andrew (Tom Lenk) and Jonathan (Danny Strong) kidnap Warren's ex and brainwash her before killing her as she tries to escape. They convince Buffy she's taken a life. They threaten to break her with all their increasingly dangerous experiments.
In the end, Jonathan and Andrew prove to be nothing more than peer-pressured, weak wannabee supervillains, whilst Warren steps up as one of the show's most detestable and genuinely irredeemable villains. Killing Tara (Amber Benson), Warren finds himself flayed alive by Willow (Alyson Hannigan), ending his evil ways to zero sympathy.
Jonathan is killed before he can atone for his sins, but Andrew goes on to become a member of the Scooby Gang and fight the First Evil in the Battle of Sunnydale.
8. Spike
One of the greatest characters in the entire Buffyverse, Spike was a riot as the show's season two villain. With his punk-rock get-up, his bleach-blond hair and his arrogant demeanor, he arrived in the show's second season on a mission to kill the Slayer - a feat he'd already accomplished twice during his short tenure as a vampire.
He proved able to take on Buffy hand-to-hand, and gathered up an army to help him conquer her and her friends. As a villain, he wasn't around for very long in the grand scheme of things, sidelined by his slightly more unhinged accomplices, but the time fans do get to seem him is simply brilliant, menacing, and very entertaining.
Of course, he'd have another go at being the bad guy in seasons three and four, but neither efforts stuck, and in time he became one of the ultimate good guys, falling in love with Buffy and giving his life to save the world from the First Evil's armies. It's a hell of an arc, but doesn't take away from how great a bad guy he was.
7. Drusilla
Drusilla (Juliet Landau) beats out Spike for one simple reason: She's absolutely insane. Tortured before she was sired by Angel (David Boreanaz), as a vampire Drusilla is as fearsome, unhinged and blindingly evil as they come. Her madness makes her a menacing presence, and her nonsensical ramblings have undertones of threat and sinister intentions.
But there is a bit more to her than her madness. Toward the end of season two, when Spike is beaten down and confined to a wheelchair, Drusilla sets up a trap in order to capture Giles (Anthony Stewart Head). During the ambush, she comes face to face with Kendra (Bianca Lawson) and kills her, successfully kidnapping Giles in the process.
All told, Drusilla is the kind of bad guy who is as dangerous as they are insane, backing up her fearsome reputation and bizarre speeches with great strength and an imposing presence. She's not a vampire you'd want to cross, that much is for certain.
6. Dark Willow
Watching loveable, innocent Willow turn evil in season six was seriously hard to watch, but boy was it entertaining. With her magic addiction growing out of control throughout the majority of the season, culminating in her being left by girlfriend Tara, getting clean and getting back with Tara, everything comes crashing down when Warren kills the love of her life in cold blood.
Unable to bring her beloved back, Willow embraces the dark arts in order to kill Warren, Andrew and Jonathan. Her rage and power cause her to be become a completely different character - Dark Willow, intent on killing those who ruined her life and, eventually, sure that destroying the world is the only way to set things right.
Thanks to her immeasurable power, she is able to overpower Buffy, Anya and Giles (who comes equipped with his own magical knowledge) and lets her rage overcome her when she kills Warren and attempts to kill her own friends. Eventually stopped from continuing on her deadly path by Xander, Dark Willow was one of the show's most personal and heartbreaking villains - and one of the most powerful beings in the entire franchise.
5. Faith Lehane
Faith Lehane (Eliza Dushku) is easily one of the show's most compelling villains. A Slayer called to arms after the death of Kendra, she appears in season three and, despite enjoying the violent aspects of her duty and being a touch temperamental, she seems to be a solid ally for Buffy and the gang.
That slowly hits a snag, though, when she kills a man in cold blood and takes no responsibility for her actions. With a taste for murder and a deep dislike and distrust of Buffy and Giles, she goes on the run and joins forces with Mayor Wilkins (Harry Groener). She battles Buffy, tries to remove Angel's soul, and very nearly kills Angel with a poisoned arrow.
Eventually stopped in her tracks after a prolonged fight with Buffy, she returns in season four still intent on destroying her old friends. She played a major role in the spin-off Angel, and returned in Buffy's final season a new woman, committed to doing good and fulfilling her duty.
4. The First Evil
The joy of the First Evil is that you don't get long to see it in its true form. No, the First Evil isn't your typical Buffy villain - big, mean and strong - but the show's most manipulative and sinister ghoul. An evil as old as time, it feeds on fear and uses others to do its bidding.
Over the course of the final season, it manipulates Spike and Andrew and toys with Buffy, Willow, Dawn, and the rest of the larger-than-ever group. It imbues its power to Caleb, raises its army of uber-vamps from the Hellmouth, has Spike tortured and kills numerous Potential Slayers.
The most disturbing thing about the First Evil is that it can never die. Its armies may have been defeated in the final battle of the show, thanks to the sacrifice of Spike and the destruction of Sunnydale, but the First Evil itself will always be lurking in the dark, waiting for its moment to strike and beat its opponents down.
The representation of all the things Buffy has to face, it was a fitting final Big Bad for the Slayer and her friends.
3. Mayor Richard Wilkins
Mayor Wilkins was an absolute blast to watch. Played by Harry Groener with sinister charm and an air of both approachability and threat, he was nothing if not clearly a bad guy as soon as audiences got a look at him.
On the surface, the Mayor really isn't much. A normal-looking man, polite, obsessed with germs and being good, he is underneath it all an immortal psychopath who once sold his soul and is preparing to take part in the Ascension, a deadly ritual which will see him become a large, unstoppable, world-eating demon.
Though his demon form proves to be pretty formidable in the season's last episode, it's his human form that sees him at his most villainous. He manages to be both loving and cruel, harsh and kind. His manipulation of Faith and ability to worm his way out of trouble and gain supporters makes him the worst kind of adversary, and watching him finally bite the dust was great to see (if a little sad, given how entertaining he was).
2. Glory
Buffy has faced a lot of terrifying bad guys, from soulless vampires to debilitating fear demons, from demons that haunt dreams to animalistic goblins and an evil government corporation, but Glory (Clare Kramer) remains one of her most out-the-box opponents. Glory is a god, all-powerful and malevolent, hoping to open a demon hell dimension and rule over the world.
This might make her sound somewhat generic a bad guy, but thanks to Kramer's energetic performance and Glory's ability to beat the likes of Buffy and Willow in a fight, she is so much more than a "I'm going to end the world" villain. She's charismatic, narcissistic, and arrogant, and she's able to be at once hilarious and terrifying.
She beats Buffy in their first encounter, tortures Spike (a recurring theme for the vampire) and has little problem with killing Dawn (Michelle Trachtenberg) in order to fulfil her villainous quest. She spends her run almost unstoppable, too, until Buffy hits her in the face with a big hammer, and everything leading up to season five's finale was simply divine because of her.
1. Angelus
All things considered, there's no villain that Buffy has ever faced more devastating and effective as Angelus. Sure, his endgame wasn't as large scaled as Glory's or as transformative as the Mayor's, but Angelus's brilliance comes from how personal an opponent he is for Buffy.
Years ago, Angel was cursed with a soul, forced to live with his sins. Worse than that, if he ever had a true moment of happiness, he would lose his soul again and become the monster he once was. After a night with Buffy, the old vampire turns to his former self, calculating, cruel and torturous.
In killing Jenny Calendar (Robia LaMorte) and laying her in bed for a lovelorn Giles to find, in then kidnapping and torturing Giles and in joyously toying with Buffy and her friends, Angelus was not just a harsh and horrifying villain, but the most personal villain the Scoobies ever faced. Buffy can't bring herself to kill him; he makes her pay by killing those close to her.
No villain on the show has ever been as deplorable, menacing and emotionally devastating as Angelus, and given how many great villains the show has had, that's saying a lot.
Watch Next
Buffy The Vampire Slayer Quiz: Can You Finish These Quotes From Spike?