10 Best Character Arcs In Buffy The Vampire Slayer & Angel

Buffy & Angel: Which character had the biggest growth?

willow buffy the vampire slayer
Mutant Enemy

Over the course of 12 seasons, Buffy the Vampire Slayer and its spin-off Angel introduced audiences to a wide variety of complex and ever-changing characters. Each major player in Joss Whedon's supernatural universe went through the wringer, and nearly all came out the other side stronger and more developed than they were before.

The following 10 characters were subject to the most impressive arcs in the franchise, whether they were evil vampires who learned how to be a good man, a shy overachiever who grew into an all-powerful witch, a former demon who attempted to integrate herself into society, or a high school mean girl who found a purpose in life beyond her need for acceptance.

There have been dozens of characters to grace Buffy and Angel, and so some of the other fan favourites who didn't make the top ten will have to be relegated to honourable mentions: There was Darla, the vampire who was resurrected as a human and gave her life for her child; Rupert Giles, the watcher and father figure who learned to let his Slayer go off on her own; and Xander Harris, the funny sidekick who kept the gang together through thick and thin.

With that out a way, here are the 10 best character arcs in Buffy the Vampire Slayer and its spin-off.

10. Dawn Summers

Buffy The Vampire Slayer Dawn Summers
Mutant Enemy

It's fair to say that Dawn Summers, introduced in season five as Buffy's younger sister, is the most divisive character in the franchise. Of course, much of the hate she receives is barely justified. Sure, she was loud, whiny, and a kleptomaniac, but she was also a ball of energy known as The Key, created to open a demon dimension that would bring about the end of the world.

All I'm saying is, maybe it's time to cut her some slack.

Dawn spends season five coming to terms with the fact that she's not technically real, and by the end of the season is willing to give up her life to save everyone. She also learns to think of Buffy as her real sister, and over the next two seasons grapples with her new life, her emotionally distant sibling, and her lack of parental figures.

By the end of the show, the vast majority of her annoying habits had disappeared, and she proved to be a selfless hero in her own right. Hers was not a overly complex arc, looking at it as a whole, but it was low-key one of Buffy's most subtle and effective.


9. Fred Burkle

Angel Winifred
Fox

Fred Burkle remains one of the Buffyverse's most sympathetic and endearing characters. She first turned up in Angel's second season, having been trapped in a demon dimension for five years and presumed dead back in the real world. She was saved by Angel, Cordelia and the gang, and brought back to L.A, where she struggled to adapt to her life back on earth.

Though at first she seemed out-of-place, and felt sidelined by the rest of the group, she soon learned how to help the team out with their heroic adventures. Intelligent, intuitive and wise, she quickly proved to be an invaluable member of the gang, and briefly dated Charles Gunn before falling in love with Wesley Wyndam-Pryce.

In the final season, Fred was put in charge of Wolfram & Hart's science division, and continued to prove her worth as a leader and hero. She formed a bond with Spike, and began dating Wesley, only to have her time cut short when her body was taken over by the ancient demon Illyria. Fred grew from shy and unsure to confident and heroic, and though she didn't make it to the show's end, she had one hell of a great journey.


8. Angel

Angel David Boreanaz
Fox

Angel appears in more episodes and seasons than any other character in either show, and his quest for redemption and atonement covers his entire arc. In season one, he was nothing more than the cryptic handsome stranger, occasionally helping Buffy and attempting to prove his worth.

By season two, things really began to heat up. Not only did he and Buffy fall madly in love, but after a night of passion with her, Angel lost his soul and spent the rest of the season tormenting Buffy and her friends. After being killed, the vampire returned in season three, his soul intact and his conscience scarred.

Realising he couldn't be with Buffy, he moved to L.A and, with the help of a former high school mean girl and a charismatic demon, began helping people in hopes that he could regain his humanity and make up for his evil doings. He has a son, takes control of an evil law firm, and loses nearly all of his friends along the way. In the end, he signs away his chance for living a normal life, and gears up for battle, knowing he'll always be needed to fight the big fights.


7. Anya Jenkins

Anya Buffy Emma Caulfield
WB

Further proof that both Buffy and Angel are big fans of redemption arcs, Anya Jenkins first appeared in Buffy's third season as a vicious vengeance demon, where she was defeated by Rupert Giles and rendered both mortal and human. Shunned from the demon fold, Anya started attending high school and by season four had formed a romance with Xander Harris.

During her stint on the show, Anya struggled to come to terms with her newfound humanity, and often insulted people with her blunt, careless observations. Still, she was a great addition to the gang, and proved to be quite the asset throughout the show.

After being left at the altar by Xander, Anya became a vengeance demon once more and attempted to fall back into her evil ways. But she couldn't. Even with her powers, she decided to give up on her demonic ways and submitted to her mortal life. Eventually, she reconciled with Xander, found her true purpose, and died at the Battle of the Hellmouth.


6. Buffy Summers

Buffy The Vampire Slayer
Mutant Enemy

Buffy's arc throughout the main show (and briefly its spin-off) was phenomenal and complex. She started out the show aged sixteen, a Slayer who wanted a normal life but deep down knew exactly what she had to do in times of trouble. She formed a bond with Willow Rosenberg, Xander and Giles, and at the end of the show's first season briefly died facing The Master.

Throughout the next few seasons, Buffy fell in love, saw loved ones die, killed her own boyfriend, and learned her sister wasn't who everyone thought she was. She gave her life again in season five, saving Dawn and the world and fulfilling her duties as Slayer in the process. Resurrected in season six, he tried to rebuild her life but struggled to admit her inner turmoil to her friends.

Buffy began a strained (at best) relationship with Spike around this time, lost her best friend to a dangerous magic addiction, and later began training an army of Potential Slayers for the fight against the First Evil. Buffy was everything from friend, leader, superhero, sister and more, and by the end of the show had become the very best version of herself.


5. Faith Lehane

Buffy Faith
The WB

Though Darla's arc was more than exceptional enough to gain a place on this list, no recurring character on either show had a more impressive arc than the rogue Slayer, Faith Lehane. Introduced in season three after the death of Kendra, Faith proved to be charismatic, likeable, and a bit of an adrenaline junkie. Unlike Buffy, she got enjoyment out of killing vampires and demons.

After accidentally killing Sunnydale's deputy mayor, Faith became distant and even tried to blame Buffy for the murder. With her lust for power growing, she nearly killed Xander before joining forces with big bad Mayor Wilkins. Under his influence, Faith manipulated the Scooby Gang and Buffy was forced to put her into a coma after a vicious fight.

When she woke up, Wilkins was dead, and Buffy and the gang had moved on. Faith tried to get revenge, but upon failing ran off to L.A, where she went after Angel, who talked some sense into her and forced her to pay for her crimes. Then, after a stint in jail, she fought alongside Buffy at the Battle of the Hellmouth, finally becoming one of the heroes and atoning for her sins.


4. Cordelia Chase

Angel Cordelia
20th Century Fox

Cordelia Chase's arc was mostly non-existent in the first three seasons of Buffy, but upon moving on to the spin-off and befriending Angel, she proved to be one of the most compelling characters in the franchise. At first shallow, a casual bully who lived for popularity and acceptance, her move to L.A saw her grow up and realise there was more to life than the material things.

Forming Angel Investigations with Angel and new friend Doyle, Cordelia began an arc that centred around helping people. After the death of Doyle, she was able to see people in danger, giving Angel the chance to save people throughout the city. She grew selfless and brave, and though she never lost that sassy edge, she did become more mature and fully-formed as the show went on.

Angel's fourth season betrayed her character slightly, effectively making her the bad guy and killing her off, but one last stop in season five allowed Cordelia to prove her heroism and set on Angel on the path needed to stop the coming apocalypse. Cordelia was fierce, loyal and complex, and despite the blip, she had one of the best arcs in the series.


3. Willow Rosenberg

willow buffy the vampire slayer
Mutant Enemy

The ever-dependable Willow went through hell and back during her seven-season stay on Buffy. At first, she was the loud-and-proud nerd who knew how to hack computers, kept the gang together, and became Buffy's best friend. She was goofy and fun, and despite being easily freaked by the world around her, never deterred from helping Buffy fight the forces of darkness.

Through seasons two and three, Willow began getting comfortable with using magic, restoring Angel's soul and dating laidback musician Oz. Later, she formed an attachment with fellow wicca Tara, and came out after realising her love for her, in one of the show's sweetest and most beloved developments.

Unfortunately, all was not well, as Willow's magic use began to grow out of control and cost her her relationship with Tara. After getting clean, she got back with Tara, only for Tara to be killed, causing Willow to embrace the dark arts to get her revenge on Warren Mears. She eventually tried to end the world, but was stopped by Xander and began a long journey to rehabilitation that ended with her giving Buffy's power to every Potential Slayer in the world.

Shy bookworm to big bad to all-powerful witch - it doesn't get much better than that.


2. Wesley Wyndam-Pryce

Wesley Wyndham-Price
Mutant Enemy

Watching Wesley during his third season stint on Buffy, it's almost impossible to comprehend where he ended up. Brought to Sunnydale as a replacement watcher for the recently-fired Giles, Wesley was pretentious, annoying, inexperienced and, on more than one occasion, dangerously ignorant and unprepared.

After Buffy, he ended up with Angel and Cordelia in L.A, where he joined Angel Investigations following the untimely death of Doyle. Though he still carried with him many of his usual irritating traits and hilarious ineptitude, it wasn't long before Angel's exploits began to rub off on him, and he became a strong, experienced and daring demon hunter.

In later seasons, he betrayed Angel after learning the vampire might kill his son, Connor, and had his throat cut after siding with the bad guys. His relationship with Angel remained strained for the rest of the show, and Wesley's injuries - paired with the fact all his friends abandoned him - caused him to toughen up more than ever before. After the death of Fred, he died trying to prevent the apocalypse.

His was not a happy arc by any stretch, but it was brilliantly realised and so deep it's impossible not to love.


1. Spike

spike buffy
Mutant Enemy

Spike's arc remains the best from either show. Initially introduced as Buffy's new big bad before the return of Angelus, Spike managed to escape Sunnydale unscathed with his love, Drusilla, in tow. But, following Dru leaving him, he became bitter and kept returning to town to wreak havoc in the lives of Buffy and her friends.

But then came the twist. In season four, the Initiative fit him with a chip that prevented him from harming any humans, and through reluctance, convenience and misunderstanding, he became an ally of the Scooby Gang. During season five, he realised he'd fallen in love with Buffy, despite not having a soul, and the two formed a twisted relationship in season six.

After assaulting Buffy, Spike went out to get his soul back, so he be a good man, and with his soul intact he became a full-fledged member of the team, training the Potential Slayers, having his chip removed, and reconciling with Buffy. In the final fight, he gave his life to destroy the First's armies, and was resurrected in L.A, where he started working with his old nemesis Angel.

Spike was everything from big bad to comic relief, love interest to hero, monster to champion, and there's no development better than his in the entire series.


Contributor

I get to write about what I love, which is cool. You'll typically find me in front of a TV, or hunkered down behind a book, or dreaming of things far away. Be good to each other. Find my other writings here: https://allthethingsineversaid.substack.com/