10 Best Christmas TV Episodes Ever

Tis the season, and all that.

Christmas episodes of our favourite TV shows can be one of two things; they can be lazy excuses for showrunners to put their feet up and give their actors a week off by basically running a clip-show instead, or they can allow the writers to go for broke, compelled by the festive mood to weave a very different story that's quite unlike the ones we're used to. Even shows that aren't primarily centred around comedy have, with surprising success, managed to deliver an impressive Christmas episode, and though the majority of the shows on this list are shooting for laughs, they all share one thing: they've managed to take a potentially rote idea - the cloying Christmas special - and turn it into a great excuse to throw caution to the wind and make viewers feel sufficiently filled with festive cheer. Here are the 10 best Christmas TV episode of all time.

10. Community - "Abed's Uncontrollable Christmas"

It was clear from the minute we heard that Community was going to attempt a Christmas special that it would be anything but normal, though we didn't quite expect Dan Harmon and his intrepid writing team to do this. Abed's Uncontrollable Christmas is a stop-motion episode of the show, an absurd meshing of a child-like fascination with Christmas with Community's singular, very smart sense of humour. The results proved fruitful, as the episode earned the show the Emmy award for Individual Achievement in Animation. Parodying classic Christmas specials like Rudolph the Red Nosed Reindeer and Santa Claus is Coming to Town while basically following the narrative of Robert Zemeckis' The Polar Express, this is a gorgeously animated episode with highlights including Chevy Chase as a teddy bear, and an abominable snowman who is in fact pretty terrifying, likely beyond what the animators intended. With its honest examination of what Christmas means, this is arguably the best episode of the show, and definitely one of the best Christmas specials in TV history.

9. The X-Files - "How The Ghosts Stole Christmas"

Given how rooted in its mystery premise The X-Files was, it wasn't exactly a show we expected to serve up a Christmas episode to provide a nice break in the suspense, but it happened anyway, and against the odds, is actually a pretty great, surprisingly clever mixture of Yuletide cheer and the series' pulpy tone. A lot of the episode's success is down to the casting; Lily Tomlin and Edward Asner are absolutely superb as two ghosts trapped inside their house as a result of their suicide pact, with Mulder and Skully showing up on Christmas Eve to investigate. It's neither a conventionally syrupy Christmas episode nor a conventional X-Files episode, but something weird, wonderful and totally different to what we could have imagined; it's an unexpectedly touching fable, but one that also juggles its other aspirations - namely towards horror - exceptionally well, making for a tonally accomplished piece of work. Still, the real reason it succeeds is the excellent performances from the two guest stars, at once knowing, devilishly funny, and genuinely quite emotive as well.

8. Friends - "The One With The Holiday Armadillo"

This classic episode of Friends begins as we learn that Ross' seldom-seen son Ben is to visit for the holidays, and Ross is keen to teach him about his Jewish lineage, while also not wanting to disappoint him by downplaying the Santa myth. When it turns out that Ross can't get a hold of a Santa outfit, he decides to dress as the only thing he can find, a "Holiday Armadillo" uniform, an absurd get-up with which he presents Ben his Christmas gifts while trying to shoehorn in the message of Hanukkah, with hilariously inept results. It gets worse for Ross when Santa (Chandler) and Superman (Joey) show up, completely diverting Ben's attention and ruining Ross' attempts to educate his young son. Ross has always been a hit and miss character as far as the show goes - he's either too over the top or too subdued - but this is one episode that totally got him right, the suit being a superb gimmick to hang on his character. It also allowed David Schwimmer to enact some ripe physical comedy, again, something that has always been one of his comic strengths.

7. 30 Rock - "Ludachristmas"

Too many Christmas episodes just recycle the same sentiments and ideas that we've seen dozens of times before, so it's nice to see Tina Fey change it up a bit with this classic episode of 30 Rock, in which the show's crew is gearing up for their annual so-called "Ludachristmas" celebration, which pesky upstart Kenneth is trying to put a stop to. Kenneth wants to promote the "real" meaning of Christmas, and spends most of the episode riling up Tracy, who has been prohibited from drinking alcohol and therefore can't stand Kenneth's wholesome sentiments. Meanwhile, Liz has to deal with her family (Anita Gillette, Buck Henry, and Andy Richter) showing up for the holidays, while Jack has a surprise visit from his mother Colleen (Elaine Stritch) after initially being relieved that she wouldn't be able to make it. Buck Henry and Andy Richter as Lemon's father and brother respectively are the stand-outs here; it's a feat of casting so perfect it's difficult to imagine anyone else in the role. Meanwhile, Tracy Morgan gets to give some of his best mugging in the entire series, and the characters of Liz and Jack are given some impressive character development. A great episode.

6. South Park - "Mr. Hankey, The Christmas Poo"

Mr Hankey might be one of the more puerile creations in Matt Stone and Trey Parker's brilliant South Park, but he's also one of the best, a talking piece of fecal matter who attempts to console Kyle who, as a Jew, feels excluded during the Christmas period. Mr Hankey, the apparently living lump of poo, tries to give him advice during this period, while the rest of South Park simply think that Mr Hankey is imaginary, given that he "goes prone" as a dried out piece of crap when Kyle tries to show him off around other people. Adding to the hilarity is that any...mess...that Mr Hankey leaves behind is attributed to Kyle, his parents assuming that he is pooing everywhere as a form of anti-social protest, only getting him into further trouble. Easily one of the best episodes of South Park ever, the show not only introduced this delightfully mischievious little fella, but it also made an iconic song out of Cartman's belter of a tune, "Kyle's Mom is a Big Fat B****". This is an early episode that makes it clear Stone and Parker aren't just fielding out lewd potty humour for the sake of it; the manner with which they take to task the overtly political correctness around Christmas is borderline genius.

5. Arrested Development - "Afternoon Delight"

This brilliant episode begins by broaching a common source of confusion for many people, that Starland Vocal Band's classic song "Afternoon Delight" was, in fact, not about ice cream. We all know what it's about now, but during this episode, Michael Bluth is under the same childlike assumption that it's all innocent, and when he finds out the truth, there are hilarious consequences. Another highlight is Gob trying to be a company man, but resolutely failing because he keeps going on about how amazingly expensive his suits are, even doing so when he gets a cab dressed as a banana. It gets even better when Buster lies to his mother about things going well at the Army, when in fact, Buster has essentially become addicted to a mechanical crane arcade game, and has been spending most of his time there. It might not be an episode that's the most focused on Christmas, but it provides more laughs and brilliance than the vast majority of those that stringently put mistletoe, Santa suits and ugly jumpers all over the screen. For that, it has to be commended.

4. The Office (US) - "Christmas Party"

Even if it's pipped to the post by the superior Christmas special of the UK version of The Office, the US version isn't far behind, with its first Christmas episode easily being the best of its entire 9-season run so far. Arguably the highlight is how Secret Santa unfolds; Michael buys Ryan an iPod, but when Michael himself get stuck with a crappy oven mit, he initiates "Yankee Swap" rules, whereby people can elect to take someone else's gifts, causing everyone to essentially start fighting over the iPod. Compounding this is Jim's frustration that the present he put a lot of thought into for his love interest, Pam, could end up in the wrong hands. Even when Pam finally gets it - it's a teapot with a note in from him - he decides to sneak the note into the pocket, so she doesn't learn how he feels. Another great moment occurs when Michael realises that he's killing the vibe of the party, so he buys an absurd amount of alcohol to make sure that everyone still has fun. This results in Meredith trying to get naked, and it's vile, but absolutely hilarious. No other Office episode has evoked the Christmas spirit so well.

3. The Simpsons - "Simpsons Roasting On An Open Fire"

How could we forget this classic Christmas episode, which was also the very first episode of The Simpsons ever? Everything begins in fairly bleak, depressing style, with Homer despondent that he didn't get a Christmas bonus from work this year, while Marge has to use their Christmas fund to pay for Bart to get his tattoo - yes, you read that right - removed. It gets worse when Homer decides to take a small gig working as a mall Santa, only to go and blow the earnings with Bart at a race-track, betting on a dog called Santa's Little Helper, and yeah, you can see where it's going. Homer and Bart lose all their money, but take Santa's Little Helper home, much to the pleasure of Marge, Maggie and Lisa, giving the episode a joyful happy-ever-after ending, while also kick-starting one of the greatest TV shows of all time (even if it's not so great these days). Here's proof that you can make a heart-warming Christmas episode that isn't ridiculously saccharine and condescending.

2. Seinfeld - "The Strike"

Here's a Christmas episode so brilliant and influential that it helped popularise its own holiday, Festivus. In the show, it's a holiday devised by George's father as a substitute for the overtly commercial pressures of Christmas, whereby there is an aluminium "Festivus pole", meatloaf dinner, and guests can do things such as air grievances with their family and also try to best them in tests of strength. Best of all? The show's customary banter results in characters declaring regular events to be "Festivus miracles", a hilarious thumb-in-the-nose at the overt preciousness with which people can regard the holiday period. It's an episode so well-regarded that Festivus is actually celebrated by many families the world over, a great way to be cheap (c'mon, it's George!) while also snubbing the stress-inducing importance that some place on the day. On December 23rd, you can kick back, relax, air some grievances and maybe even have a swing on the Festivus pole; get ready.

1. The Office (UK) - Christmas Specials

When it was announced that The Office was to return for a two-part Christmas special, expectations were insanely high, especially given that Stephen Merchant and Ricky Gervais left that desperate thread dangling, as to whether Tim would ever manage to snatch Dawn away from her boring, careless boyfriend Lee. The episode begins brilliantly, with David Brent, now a minor celebrity as a result of the previous series' success, travelling the country as a novelty act, while also trying to get a date for the Office Christmas party that he has been invited to. While Brent has always been a pretty irksome individual, we actually get to see some sweeter moments here, as he tries to find a woman who he can settle down with (he does), and most memorbly, he tells Finchy to f**k off. But the real attraction is the resolution of the Tim/Dawn storyline; Dawn returns from the US for the party, and though sparks soon fly again between her and Tim, we're still not sure what's going to happen. Just as it seems like all hope is lost, Dawn is getting a cab home when she opens Tim's Christmas present, and makes the cab turn back around. She shows up, plants a lip-lock on Tim, and the rest, as they say, is history. Easily the most crowd-pleasing and affecting Christmas episode ever, Gervais and Merchant crafted a genuine piece of TV magic. What's your favourite Christmas-themed TV episode? Let us know in the comments below.

Contributor
Contributor

Articles published under the WhatCulture name denote collective efforts of a number of our writers, both past and present.