10 Biggest Doctor Who Criticisms (And Why They're Wrong)
We look at fan issues with Doctor Who that aren't quite the end of the universe...
Time Lords and Ladies, rejoice. The wait for new Doctor Who is almost over. Okay, so it’s not as bad as it was back in the nineties, but it’s still been a full year between episodes. New spin-off Class is filling the gap between now and Christmas, and the Christmas special will be flying onto our screens pretty soon.
But with new material emerging, new (and some old) complaints have started to crop up. Particularly with this year’s Christmas Special featuring the return of Matt Lucas as Nardole and including a superhero as a guest character. Though sadly it’s not the Karkus from The Mind Robber (and that fills your daily quota of obscure 60s Doctor Who references).
But this has become pretty common in Doctor Who fandom. In fact, you could go as far as saying that it’s an intrinsic part of part of watching Doctor Who: Picking over every little thing from the incidental music to the size of the Tardis windows (and yes, that last one did happen).
But even though complaining is something of a hobby for Doctor Who fans, there are some criticisms that just don’t hold water no matter how often they are brought up. So today and here is the time and space to lay them to rest.
10. The Programme Is In Trouble
Along with intrusive paparazzi shots of celebrities and pun-filled headlines, part of the lifeblood of UK tabloids is prophesising doom for Doctor Who. Even if it’s as utterly ridiculous as claiming that Emma Watson could be the Thirteenth Doctor. No, seriously.
Most recently were the Daily Mirror’s claims after the start of Series 9 that Doctor Who was going through a ‘crisis period’ that would lead to Series 10 being scrapped in favour of Sherlock-style specials, and that Peter Capaldi was being replaced with Game Of Thrones star Richard Madden. Something that does seem just a tiny bit less likely at the moment.
But making out that the ratings are through the floor and that everything Doctor Who-related is falling apart is the old standby for both tabloids and fans. For the record, consolidated viewing figures and Appreciation Index scores are as consistent as ever. Anything that claims Doctor Who’s viewer base is collapsing based on a single overnight viewing figure is just yellow journalism with absolutely no substance to it.
But most of all: Doctor Who’s future is secure until 2020 when it is next up for renewal. It’s in such a stable position that it’s only being re-commissioned once every five years. But also, Doctor Who is one of the BBC’s sacred cows. This isn’t the 1980s when they drifted between not caring and actively trying to kill it. If something had happened that was threatening Doctor Who’s future, the BBC would have jumped on it immediately to keep the money and critical acclaim flowing.
9. It's Not Like It Used To Be
If Doctor Who is being discussed and somebody mentions that it’s not like it used to be, then good. That means whoever is in charge is doing their job. Because, in the words of the Second Doctor: “Life depends on change and renewal." And so does Doctor Who.
It’s been that way since William Hartnell left. The Troughton era shifted its focus to base-under-siege plots and recurring monsters. After that we’ve had an Avengers-esque era, a Gothic period, and multiple other takes on Doctor Who’s premise all leading up to the present. Doctor Who is rooted in change and has been for decades. Because if a showrunner is handed the reins and proceeds to change absolutely nothing, then what’s the point of hiring them?
Without Russell T. Davies, Julie Gardner, and Phil Collinson making drastic changes to practically everything in 2005, Doctor Who would never have survived its relaunch. It was by leaving the serial format, cardboard monsters, and no hugging no kissing policy in the past that they managed to reinvigorate the show. Five years later, Steven Moffat refreshed it again by switching things round. And Chris Chibnall is almost definitely planning to do the same thing.
Doctor Who will always be changing. That’s how it carries on. That change isn’t necessarily better or worse (that’s entirely down to opinion) but it is necessary. In that sense, Regeneration is the perfect metaphor for Doctor Who itself.
8. The Doctor's Characterisation Is Wrong
Here’s a little thought experiment: Try to picture the First Doctor listening to Ian Dury and talking about how much he loves The Muppet Movie. Or the Sixth Doctor disguising himself as a Welsh milkman. They don’t quite fit together, do they?
This is because even though the Doctor is one person, each incarnation has a different personality. Different attitudes, different preferences, and different opinions. Each Doctor’s personality can’t be compared to another’s because their personality changes after Regenerating. That was established fifty years ago in The Power Of The Daleks.
Which means that the Doctor isn’t being mischaracterised if he does something that another Doctor wouldn’t do. There are some aspects of his character that stay the same but he is prone to change as much as the next man. Even more, really. He’s never cruel or cowardly but beyond that he could be compassionate, light-hearted, brooding, arrogant, condescending. The list is almost endless.
And that’s not even considering the character development for each Doctor. The Eighth Doctor is a very different man immediately before his Regeneration than he was to begin with. Essentially, you can’t expect one Doctor to completely hold to the ethics and personality of another or to stay exactly the same.
7. Old Characters Aren't Returning
In a perfect world, any character could be brought into Doctor Who for a great big blast of nostalgia. And if Doctor Who was a cartoon, things would be much easier. But when it comes to live-action television, things are never so simple. At the risk of generalising, bringing back an old character requires three criteria to be fulfilled:
1. Does it work within the story? 2. Is the character owned by the BBC, and if not, can they be licensed from their creator? 3. Is the actor willing and able to reprise their role?
You can fudge the first one a bit with the only comeback being a few bad reviews and some angry Tweets, but the other two have no real wiggle room. Jack Harkness was written out of Series 6’s A Good Man Goes To War because of scheduling conflicts, and the reason K-9 was trapped in another dimension for the first two years of The Sarah Jane Adventures was licensing issues with his creator Bob Baker.
Old characters not returning can all too often feel like a missed opportunity but there’s usually a very good reason behind it. That's either because the story is stronger without them, or because things don’t come together to let it happen.
6. [Insert Writer Here] Is Ruining Doctor Who
Some advice to offer Chris Chibnall ahead of him taking over from Steven Moffat is this: “You will get blamed for everything you do, everything you don’t do, and everything that other people do.” It’s been that way since at least the days of John Nathan-Turner and almost certainly before that.
Part of the job description is being a professional scapegoat and a lightning rod for criticism. If something happens that fans don’t approve of, it’s automatically the showrunner’s fault. And with that come the cries of “They’re ruining Doctor Who”. But while actual criticisms like poor plotting and characterisation can be brought to the table with valid points to back it up, the idea of “ruining Doctor Who” is entirely subjective. What someone really means when they say this is “Doctor Who does not currently match what I think it should be”.
Which is a criticism that can never be accurate because it’s rooted in opinion. And one person’s opinion doesn’t represent the whole fan-base. Especially with a programme that has gone through so many transformations over five decades. Unless a Doctor Who showrunner is at the helm when everything crashes and burns, they can’t be said to have ruined it. And as the 1980s showed us; even when that happens, you can’t pin the blame on a single person.
5. There Should Be More Episodes
It would appear that, for a lot people, the “too much of a good thing” motto doesn’t apply to Doctor Who. Because something that’s often at the top of the list of fan desires is an increased episode count every year. Which would be pretty nifty apart from one problem: It’s not physically possible.
A full series of Doctor Who and the Christmas Special shoots for just under eight months. That’s two thirds of every year just for principal photography. Each series is probably closer to being a full year’s work, with a lot of crossover between different areas of production just to get everything done in time. When Series 4 was in progress, FX house The Mill were designing the Adipose while the script for Partners In Crime was still being written.
Apart from breaking every labour law going and seriously rushing production, the only real way to cram more Doctor Who into each year would be to make enormous changes to the format to allow for the production of multiple episodes alongside each other. In particular, a larger permanent cast to stop the programme being reliant on two actors (which would mean a reduced focus on the Doctor), and more standing sets that would be used for every episode to trim the budget. And while that decision worked to an extent during the Jon Pertwee years, doing it again probably wouldn’t have positive results.
4. The Companion Gets Too Much Focus
A criticism most commonly levelled at Clara, this is the opinion that Doctor Who’s writing is weighted too much towards the Doctor’s Companions. Which is kind of understandable since all of the major Companions since 2005 have ended saving the universe and rescuing the Doctor at least once. Bonus points if they get special powers and/or a title like the Doctor-Donna or the Impossible Girl. But this is one of those changes from Classic Who that was definitely needed.
The real birth of all of this was the Seventh Doctor’s Companion Ace. While previous Companions were well characterised for the most part; Ace had entire stories built around her past and personal demons, and was a part of the story arc in the Seventh Doctor’s last two seasons. Had Season 27 gone into production in 1990, she would have even left the Doctor to become a Time Lord. In fact, you could make the argument that Ace was the first really fleshed out Companion and set the template for Nu-Who.
Because modern Doctor Who is mostly a double act character-wise, the Companion is a lead character and needs a certain degree of focus. That’s part and parcel of having a well-written show. But most importantly, it’s what elevates them to properly engaging characters rather than a tagalong sidekick who’s there to scream and run down corridors until they’re hastily written out when the actor leaves.
3. Fan Aren't Getting The Spin-Offs They Want
Despite Class’s first series being fairly well received, before its premiere it still gained a reputation amongst some fans on social media as 'The spin-off no one asked for', while others have called for a return of Torchwood, or new spin-offs with pre-existing characters. But television can’t work purely from what fans want.
While the Paternoster Gang are workable as occasional characters, a full spin-off with them would be a logistical nightmare. Not only would the Victorian setting chew through quite a bit of the budget; but two of the three lead characters need heavy prosthetics that take hours to apply and have to be replaced for every day of shooting.
Elsewhere, some spin-offs have either run their course or just don’t have enough going for them to go to a full series. Torchwood racked up a respectable four series but by Miracle Day, many thought it had run out of steam. Meanwhile, a Clara and Ashildr spin-off would be little more than Doctor Who with a different name and an incredibly impractical Tardis prop.
Fans just have to accept that what they think would be a good spin-off might not make for the best ongoing series, or be possible to produce. But failing that, there’s always the Big Finish audios. Where the only real stumbling blocks are licensing, and signing on the actors they need.
2. The Budget Should Be Higher
Even though it’s at the height of its powers, Doctor Who often struggles with its budget. It’s an expensive programme and the money only goes so far. So, some fans say, “Why can’t they just increase the budget?” Well, that’s where it gets a bit complicated.
For the uninitiated, the BBC is funded by a legally mandated license fee of £145.50 every year. And because of that; all BBC programmes cannot carry any adverts or product placement, and the License fee must fund a wide variety of programming without bias. A BBC4 documentary about the history of biscuits get as much of a fair shake as something like Doctor Who.
And there’s the rub. The BBC is held accountable by the government and the license fee payer so it can’t do an HBO and start firing money at one show with a pneumatic cash gun. And if that doesn’t already exist, I’m patenting it. There are already significant austerity measures in place and the renewal of the BBC’s charter is imminent. They’ve even had to let go of one of their highest rated shows for financial reasons. So suddenly deciding to jack up Doctor Who’s budget for no real reason isn’t an option.
And anyway, all the extra money would do is just make things a tiny bit glossier. On its current budget, Doctor Who is producing thirteen episodes a year with multiple settings, monsters, and (depending on the series in question) a cast of close to one hundred credited actors. Which is one hell of a feat.
1. It Ignores Continuity
Continuity. It’s a tricky thing. Especially for something that’s been around for decades, frequently contradicts itself, and once produced The Two Doctors. A story so out of whack with established canon that it took a fan theory the BBC took a shine to for it to make any kind of sense.
After a new episode of Doctor Who airs, fans are almost certain to start picking apart how it matches up to the lore established by other episodes. It’s traditional. It’s also why the Reapers from Series 1 are still constantly being discussed eleven years after a single appearance. But for Doctor Who, continuity can’t really be a priority.
Usually when a TV or movie series keeps a tight grasp on its continuity, it’s one that ends up lasting maybe a decade at most and stays broadly the same the whole way through. For Doctor Who, that’s never going to happen. We’re fifty-three years and more than eight hundred episodes in so following continuity to the letter would be massively restrictive on Doctor Who’s storytelling. Not to mention you’d need an enormous dossier of Who trivia and a small army of fact checkers to keep track of it all.
So with Doctor Who continuity, it’s best not to overthink it. There’s usually an explanation of sorts if you’ve got the interest to look further into it. And if not; just put it down to certain aspects of time being prone to change, stick the kettle on, and try to relax. Which isn’t bad advice for life in general as well.
What do you think of these criticisms of Doctor Who? Any others to share? Let us know down in the comments.