10 Biggest Doctor Who Leaks Ever

If Doctor Who was a boat, it would have sunk during the Moffat era...

Doctor Who The Name of the Doctor Clara Eleventh Doctor
BBC Studios

It's a universally acknowledged truth that Doctor Who guarantees headlines, and in the constant search for some attention-grabbing material, publications sometimes ignore press embargoes, or even cultivate relationships with on-set "insiders" to get scoops on the future of the show.

These leaks aren't always deliberate, however, and some of Doctor Who's biggest leaks have been purely accidental.

An upload to the wrong server here, an unchecked box there, and all hell might just break loose. The BBC itself can even reveal information early, such as when it released the 1996 Paul McGann movie on VHS before it even aired in the UK. And who can forget when John Simm was shown off to the UK's press during the launch of Series 10? Umm, spoilers, you guys.

With so many leaks over the years, Doctor Who wouldn't make it from one side of a narrow canal to another if it was a boat. Which, thankfully, it isn't. From whole episodes releasing early to some major 50th anniversary spoilers, here are ten of the biggest leaks in the show's long history...

10. Series 11 Scenes Leak MONTHS Before Broadcast

Doctor Who The Woman Who Fell To Earth
BBC Studios

The Chris Chibnall era of Doctor Who has been notoriously tight-lipped about what fans can expect from series to series. When that approach worked, it gave us the exciting reveal of Sacha Dhawan as the Master, and Jo Martin as the Fugitive Doctor. When it didn't work, fans had to make do with an underwhelming trailer that rattled off the names of guest actors.

At the same time though, the Chibnall era hasn't been free of the leaks and spoilers that have troubled its predecessors.

Early scenes from Jodie Whittaker's debut story The Woman Who Fell To Earth leaked online in June 2018, four months before its October broadcast. The BBC even went to court over the leak, issuing a subpoena to one of the websites responsible.

The leaked footage didn't do anything to lessen interest in the first female Doctor though, as The Woman Who Fell To Earth became the most-watched new Doctor debut ever, with ratings of 10.96 million viewers in the UK alone.


9. Peter Davison Accidentally Discovers His Replacement

Doctor Who Colin Baker the Sixth Doctor
BBC Studios

The casting of a new Doctor is something that's always shrouded in secrecy until the moment's right (or until the bookmakers mysteriously slash the odds on bets for Jodie Whittaker or Peter Capaldi). The departing Doctor is usually among the first people to find out, with Jodie Whittaker learning about Ncuti Gatwa just before his casting announcement was made public in May.

This is also true in the classic era, albeit by accident. Producer John Nathan-Turner was preparing for the departure of Peter Davison as the Fifth Doctor, and he was taken with Colin Baker following his previous appearance in Arc of Infinity, and had met the actor on several occasions since.

So, the two men had a series of meetings about the direction Colin Baker wanted to take the Doctor. After one such meeting, Baker and JNT stopped at the Bush Hotel for a drink, and it was here that they bumped into none other than Peter Davison. Naturally, this made the next day's filming on Warriors of the Deep pretty darn awkward.

Davison told JNT that he'd guessed Colin Baker would be replacing him, because Nathan-Turner hated the Bush Hotel, so why else would he be there? And also because of Colin's departing words when he left the set of Arc of Infinity: "Remember - the name's Baker!"


8. The Witchfinders Leaks Early

Doctor Who The Witchfinders
BBC

One of the highlights of Jodie Whittaker's era is The Witchfinders by Joy Wilkinson. It's a classic Doctor Who historical that is one of the few stories to touch on the fact that the Doctor is now a woman. Oh, and it was also released early.

Due to an error in updating Doctor Who Series 11 on Amazon Prime, users could watch The Witchfinders a few days early, but there was a price to pay. That price being that the week's actual episode - Kerblam! - wasn't available to watch. However, the subtitles still existed and ran alongside The Witchfinders when users selected close captioning, leading to a confusing situation for all concerned.

The error was swiftly rectified after fans bragged about watching The Witchfinders three days early on Twitter. The BBC quickly removed the episode and launched an investigation, which presumably led to a poor staff member receiving a slapped wrist.


7. The 60th Anniversary's Surprising Monsters Revealed By On-Set Photos

Beep The Meep
Doctor Who Weekly/Marvel Comics

If there's one thing that Russell T Davies should've remembered from his previous era, it's that filming on location inevitably leads to plot details, returning actors, or returning monsters being leaked.

It's presumably for that reason that the casting of David Tennant, Catherine Tate, and Yasmin Finney in the 60th anniversary specials was announced to the world the day before they arrived on location.

The first day of filming for Tennant and Tate predictably caught the attention of fans with smartphones, who flocked to the set. Photos were snapped of the much-missed Bernard Cribbins in character as Wilf, as well as Donna's mother Sylvia, and her husband Shaun. It's now a foregone conclusion that Finney is playing Donna and Shaun's daughter, Rose.

However, RTD clearly underestimated the appeal of Doctor Who Magazine's classic comic-strip villain Beep the Meep. The photos of Beep, and the insectoid aliens that are hunting him down, predictably lit up social media, with fans speculating about Davies potentially remaking the classic Doctor Who comic The Star Beast. Time will tell!


6. The Name Of The Doctor Is Sent Out Early

Doctor Who The Name Of The Doctor John Hurt the War Doctor
BBC Studios

We all know how exciting it is when you pre-order one of the Doctor Who Collection Blu-Ray sets and it arrives on the Saturday morning before release. That's a whole weekend of watching Doctor Who!

However, imagine if the Doctor Who box-set that dropped on your doormat wasn't a classic you'd already seen multiple times, and was a series finale that introduced a previously unknown Doctor?

That's exactly what happened in 2013, when a production error meant that fans who had pre-ordered the second half of Series 7 received it before The Name of the Doctor aired. This meant that they knew what the Doctor's name actually was. Was it Keith? Or something completely unpronounceable?

The BBC leaped into action, pleading with those few lucky fans to not spoil the surprises of the episode for the majority. Steven Moffat even offered to release a video of Matt Smith and David Tennant after the episode if fans kept quiet. Thankfully, they did, and news of John Hurt's new incarnation (and the true meaning of the episode's title) largely remained unspoiled in wider fandom.


5. Tom Baker Spoils His 50th Anniversary Cameo

Doctor Who The Day of the Doctor Tom Baker the Curator
BBC Studios

Tom Baker is a great storyteller, and if you've been a Doctor Who fan for long enough, you've probably heard a lot of them multiple times. Stories of grandmother's tingling bosoms, pretending to cry at Catholic funerals for monetary gain as a child, and his hilarious impression of painter Francis Bacon.

So it was something of a surprise when Tom broke the habit of a lifetime by giving The Huffington Post an exclusive in the run-up to his Doctor Who return in 2013:

"I am in the special. I'm not supposed to tell you that, but I tell you that very willingly and specifically; the BBC told me not to tell anybody but I'm telling you straight away."

Though this was revealed four days prior to The Day of the Doctor, it still managed to remain a secret to most Doctor Who fans, who were probably too busy finalising their anniversary plans. Or perhaps they'd become so familiar with Tom's tall tales that they chalked it up to his mischievous nature.

Thankfully, despite Tom Baker's indiscreet interview, his reveal as the Curator retained its power, becoming one of the most spine-tinglingly brilliant moments in modern Doctor Who.


4. Christopher Eccleston's Debut Hits The Internet Three Weeks In Advance

Rose Ninth Doctor Doctor Who
BBC Studios

After a 16-year break, Doctor Who returned as a continuing series on 26 March 2005, and despite the unwanted intrusion of Graham Norton, it became a runaway success that audiences are still enjoying 17 years later.

In 2022, Doctor Who has been back on our screens for longer than it was ever away. However, in the wasteland of the 1990s and the early 2000s, fans could be forgiven for being impatient to see Christopher Eccleston's first episode as the Doctor.

On 8 March 2005, it was reported that Eccleston's Doctor Who debut had been leaked online. The source of the leak originated in Canada, whose Canadian Broadcasting Corporation was a production partner on the revived Doctor Who. Eccleston even recorded links for each of the episodes in Series 1.

It wasn't a completely finished version of Rose, as Murray Gold's arrangement of the iconic theme tune hadn't been added to the title sequence. Instead, it included a classic version of the iconic Delia Derbyshire arrangement of Ron Grainer's theme. In the years that followed, it's been speculated that the leaking of Rose was an attempt at guerilla marketing, to gauge the opinions of hardcore Doctor Who fans ahead of broadcast.

It's probably an overly-romanticised view of what was likely an excited fan working at CBC who was keen to share RTD's bold new vision for Doctor Who.


3. Series 8 Scripts And Episodes Leaked In Error

Doctor Who Deep Breath
BBC

Where on Earth is Marcelo Camargo? That name became legendary among Doctor Who fans in 2014, when it was emblazoned across the incomplete, black-and-white footage of Peter Capaldi's first two episodes.

According to the BBC, the episodes - along with the first five scripts of Series 8 - were sent to BBC Worldwide's Latin American headquarters in Miami to be translated ahead of broadcast. Marcelo Camargo was believed to be the subtitler tasked with performing that job.

The footage leaked was the workprint version, lacking fully-rendered special effects and all in black-in-white. Essentially, it was a bit like watching a reconstruction of a missing episode from the 1960s.

Camargo was innocent of any wrongdoing, and it was believed that BBC Worldwide's Miami server was hacked. While it soured Peter Capaldi's highly-anticipated debut as the Doctor a little, the leaks were swiftly reported to the BBC by concerned fans, who clearly wanted to wait to see the finished episodes as intended.

In a statement at the time, the BBC said:

“We’d like to thank the amazing Doctor Who fans who are continuing to keep fan sites and social media spoiler-free.”

Not sure what fan sites they've been visiting.


2. Jodie Whittaker's Regeneration Appears Online

Doctor Who The Power of the Doctor Thirteenth Doctor regeneration
BBC Studios

Jodie Whittaker's regeneration was the subject of great speculation. Who would she regenerate into? David Tennant or Ncuti Gatwa?

The answer to that question thankfully remained a secret until the closing moments of The Power of the Doctor, when the Fourteenth Doctor found himself in the body of the Tenth. However, a low-res image of the regeneration itself accidentally went up on iTunes, presumably due to an accidental early upload, or a pesky automated screengrab.

The image showed the Thirteenth Doctor atop a cliff, regenerating. While it wasn't a massive spoiler, it did give an indication of the different direction the team went in for Jodie Whittaker's final moments. Firstly, the Doctor has finally remembered to regenerate while the TARDIS isn't in flight, which vastly reduces the risk of the Doctor's ship crash-landing in 2023.

And secondly, it's quite a dramatic and poetic image that a low-res screengrab doesn't do justice to. The Thirteenth Doctor, stood by her TARDIS, regenerating as the sun sets, is a poignant and beautiful moment. It was a small leak - and it could've been so much worse - but it risked ruining an amazing climax to the Whittaker/Chibnall era.


1. Christopher Eccleston's Departure Leaked Days After Rose

Doctor Who the Ninth Doctor
BBC Studios

Given that the BBC's response to the leak has often been cited as Eccleston's reason for not returning to the role of the Doctor, it's fair to call this moment one of the biggest leaks in the history of Doctor Who.

After the overnight success of Rose and the overwhelming positivity about Doctor Who's future, the party screeched to a halt a short while later, when news of Eccleston's departure was leaked by the BBC.

In a false statement that was released without his consent, the BBC claimed that Eccleston feared typecasting. They later apologised to Eccleston for this, and the actor has since blamed the working environment on his first and only series.

Eccleston had legitimised the show again, which meant it was no longer a punching bag for the tabloids. However, his departure began an ongoing obsession with behind-the-scenes dramas on the BBC's flagship show.

Doctor Who does guarantee headlines, but those headlines don't always have the best of intentions.


Watch Next


Doctor Who Quiz: How Well Do You Remember The 9th Doctor?

Doctor Who Rose
BBC

1. Where Did The Ninth Doctor First Meet Rose?

In this post: 
Doctor Who
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Citizen of the Universe, Film Programmer, Writer, Podcaster, Doctor Who fan and a gentleman to boot. As passionate about Chinese social-realist epics as I am about dumb popcorn movies.