10 Biggest Doctor Who Missed Opportunities
For a show with limitless potential, Doctor Who does tend to let many things slip by…
It's safe to say that, as a collective, Doctor Who fans are more vocal than most about the direction of their favourite show.
Every Whovian has their own wildly different view on what Doctor Who should and shouldn't be - some prefer the quirky, runabout charm of the classic series, some prefer RTD's space opera soap, and others prefer to plot Moffat's convoluted stories on a flow chart.
The point is, the one thing we love to do more than flame the show we claim to love, is to politely disagree with each other about almost every aspect of it. But sometimes, very rarely, impossible things just happen, and we call them miracles. When our hearts are in the right place, and the stars are too, Doctor Who fans agree.
There have been tons of missed opportunities in the show's history, and no doubt, we can all shake hands on the fact that the following ten - from wasted characters to storylines ripe with potential - represent some of the biggest of the lot.
10. River Not Meeting Captain Jack
Let's start off with a fun one: how did River Song never cross paths with Captain Jack Harkness?
It's obvious from their cheeky personalities and disregard for rules that they'd make a brilliant pair for a standalone adventure, but that opportunity is pretty much deader than Gallifrey at this point.
It wasn't for a lack of trying though. Efforts were made to bring Jack into the Doctor's team in A Good Man Goes To War, and you can only imagine the fireworks that would've ensued if Barrowman and Kingston had got into a quippy back-and-forth.
Or how about River in Torchwood? She would've fit perfectly with the more adult tone of that show, and the fact that this was never considered as an option (or maybe it was, who knows) is disappointing.
The similarities between the characters - right down to both owning a vortex manipulator and the same squareness gun - certainly suggest that they have met, and meet they did... in a Big Finish audio drama.
It's better than nothing, but one of the most-requested team-ups in Doctor Who history deserved an onscreen adventure.
9. Not Curing Twelve’s Blindness
For a few episodes in Series 10, it looked as if Doctor Who had thrown us a very intriguing curveball.
In Oxygen, Twelve is exposed to the raw vacuum of space in order to save Bill, with this traumatic experience resulting in him going blind. This plot thread continues through the rest of Oxygen as well as Extremis, until the monks restore the Doctor's sight in The Pyramid at the End of the World.
Granted, the moment in which Twelve's blindness is finally revealed to Bill, with him trapped on the other side of a door he can't open (because he hasn't installed FaceTime), is a crushing conclusion, but we have to wonder if we would've got something more special had the Doctor remained blind until his regeneration half a series later.
Not only would this have provided a fresh angle for the show, but having our protagonist learning to live with a disability, and not letting this stop him from saving the world, would've been some fantastic representation for a disability that is often treated as a gimmick in movies and TV.
It would've also provided an interesting challenge for the writers, who would've had to find more creative resolutions - and to be honest, Empress of Mars and The Eaters of Light could've done with that extra spark.
Just imagine, as his regeneration kicks in, Twelve regains his sight, and is able to lay eyes on Bill, Nardole, and Clara one last time... you just know Peter Capaldi would've had us all weeping into our Christmas puddings.
8. Not Getting Peter Jackson
Cast your mind back: the year is 2015, and the geeky side of the internet has just melted.
Peter Jackson, the legendary director behind the greatest trilogy ever put to screen (and also that other slightly less great trilogy), has just posted a video skit in which he is bombarded by emails by one Steven Moffat, asking him to travel to Cardiff to direct an episode of Doctor Who.
Unmoved by the proposal, Jackson then receives a delivery (by hand) from a white-haired Scottish postman who claims to be the Doctor, who forces him to sign a contract.
The appearance of Jackson and Capaldi together, along with the not-so-subtle hint at a collaboration, left fans ecstatic.
The known fact that Jackson was a lifelong Whovian (who owns two Dalek props, as well as his appearance alongside Sylvester McCoy in The Fiveish Doctors), only added fuel to the fire, and we collectively assumed the deal was set in stone.
The disappointment was therefore immeasurable when the guy who directed The Lord of the Rings never directed an episode of Doctor Who.
Jackson has gone on record in the years since, stating that he is still interested. But for reasons unknown, it's never come to fruition.
7. Not Giving Seven And Ace Another Year (Or Having Them Both In The TV Movie)
The 1996 TV movie hamstrung itself before it had even begun.
The idea of having a freshly-regenerated Doctor was an understandable decision to put casual and hardcore fans on an even footing, but the absence of any returning cast members whatsoever (minus Sylvester McCoy, who literally arrives, gets shot, and dies), meant that existing fans of the show - who were always going to make up the bulk of the audience for the film - had absolutely nothing tethering it to the show they knew and loved.
There was a case for including Anthony Ainley’s Master instead of Eric Roberts’ weird Dracula-cosplay version, but the far better inclusion would've been Sophie Aldred’s Ace.
Ace is basically a NuWho companion from the classic era. She would've been the perfect character to bridge the two eras of the show, and would've brought some spirit, humour, and Britishness to a movie that feels just a little too Americanised. This would've also given the character a proper onscreen resolution, something we had to wait until 2022 to finally get.
In general, it's a shame that Seven and Ace didn't get at least another year before the classic series was cancelled. Some of those final stories - The Curse of Fenric, Ghost Light - are really damn good, and with this pairing, it felt like the show was on a roll again, after a tumultuous period in the mid-80s.
6. Not Doing Much With The Time Lords
The Time War is one of the greatest additions to Doctor Who lore since it began, providing the show’s title character with an extra layer of depth, and a sharper edge to appeal to a modern audience.
That being said, with seven series of exploring the ‘Last of the Time Lords’ arc, Moffat’s decision to save Gallifrey came at the right time, allowing the wider story to move on and explore new avenues.
Or so we thought.
While the Time Lords have never been the most thrilling characters in Doctor Who - and it’s important to ration them to preserve their mysticism - we only got one episode set on Gallifrey before it was destroyed again: Hell Bent. This is a better episode than it gets credit for, but what it isn't is an episode about the Time Lords - it’s the finale of Twelve and Clara’s arc.
Nobody wants a return of the dull, bureaucratic Time Lord politics, but there have been plenty of opportunities to introduce some new Time Lord friends (or foes) over the years, or actually do something interesting with the Doctor's people.
On the plus side, maybe Neil Patrick Harris and Jinkx Monsoon will provide just that in the near future.
5. Letting The Spinoffs Die
One of the strengths of RTD’s Doctor Who is its world-building.
Despite the weekly planetary invasions, Earth feels very grounded in Russell’s series, in a way that it doesn't in other eras. The characters feel more real, the world feels more lived in, and there’s a sense of interconnectivity that ties everything together. It’s the closest we’ve ever got to Doctor Who being a true ‘franchise’.
A huge factor in that were spinoffs Torchwood and The Sarah Jane Adventures. These shows had followings in their own right, and would occasionally cross over into the main show - much to fans' delight.
Sadly, both spinoffs were eventually retired for wildly different reasons, and nothing rose to take their place (well, except Class, which is solid, but didn't come anywhere close to filling the void). As a result, the world of Doctor Who has felt a little bit emptier for the last decade or so.
Thankfully, with a UNIT spinoff heavily suspected to be on the way (about which we are very excited), it looks like a course-correction is imminent. About damn time!
4. Not Bringing Jenny Back
Way back in 2008, Stephen Greenhorn penned The Doctor’s Daughter, which introduced us to… well, you know who. The episode isn't top-tier Doctor Who by any means, but that has more to do with the astounding quality of Series 4.
Jenny brought an interesting, temporary dynamic to the show that hadn't been seen since Hartnell’s era, and there are so many avenues you could explore with that parent/child relationship. Just maybe not with David Tennant - would probably feel a bit weird now that Georgia Moffett is his wife.
Jenny's survival at the end of the episode leaves things frustratingly wide open, and seems to suggest there was at least an interest in bringing her back at some point.
We imagine her as an occasional companion, akin to River Song, wheeled out for an adventure every few years. Hell, even bring her back in a multi-Doctor special alongside the Fifth Doctor (her real-life dad), and watch the magic happen!
3. No Master For Eleven
Every main incarnation of the Doctor has faced off against their arch-nemesis since the Master's creation during the Third Doctor's era - except for two of them.
Eccleston gets a pass on account of his departure after just one series, as we can assume that this might've happened if he'd stayed longer. That leaves just one Doctor who never got to go toe-to-toe with the Master: Matt Smith. You know, the incarnation with the most individual stories of any NuWho Doctor. It wasn't like the Moff was short on time!
Could we not have squeezed in at least one appearance in place of Series 6 and Series 7's lacklustre finales? If we swapped out The Great Intelligence with the Master, would Series 7's plot have even changed that much? Jumping into the Doctor's timestream seems like the sort of spiteful and ludicrous thing the Master would do, and we could've even kept Richard E. Grant in the role and let the man actually be his oddball self, instead of a charisma vacuum.
This will be a void that will forever be empty, like an interpretation of Sherlock Holmes without a Moriarty. It's just wrong.
2. Wasting Paul McGann
This man was in the right place at the wrong time. Paul McGann had the potential to play a 10/10 Doctor, but was stuck in a 5/10 movie.
If his extensive Big Finish archive and his NuWho cameos are anything to go by, we were robbed of a potential golden era. In many ways, McGann is a quintessential Doctor, and would've served as the perfect bridge between classic and modern Who: an Edwardian gentleman, a dashing hero, or a broken man trying not to lose his way, depending on whereabouts in his timeline you’re dropping in.
That mooted American series would've hopefully been great despite the TV movie's shortcomings, but are you seriously telling us that we couldn't have had one special, a three-part miniseries, or a proper multi-Doctor story in the decades since?
We’re still holding out hope that there’s room for an Eighth Doctor spinoff in RTD’s Whoniverse. Paul McGann may be the man who never ages, but every year that passes is a year where that cruel mistress known as time might finally catch up with him.
1. Lack Of Companion Variety
This is, in our humble opinion, the most egregious sin of the modern era.
Even though the majority were still humanoids, the classic years found a way to implement plenty of different companions, and that’s something that NuWho has been sorely lacking.
We’re not asking for full-on prosthetic-clad aliens or prop robots here. As Kamelion and K9 have taught us, they have a tendency to be a production nightmare. But would it be such a terrible thing to give us someone from a different planet, or dare we say a different time period, slightly more often?
Aside from the likes of Jack and Nardole, we’ve not had a single companion that isn’t from present-day earth, and over half of them have been women in their twenties. We understand the need for an audience surrogate in a show like this, but there’s no reason why that role can’t be filled by just about anybody.
We got so close to more companion variety with Victorian Clara, only for her to fall to her death not 30 seconds after officially accepting the companion job. And unfortunately, with present-day teen Ruby Sunday due to join the TARDIS alongside the Fifteenth Doctor, it looks like we’ll have to wait even longer still.
Watch Next
Doctor Who Quiz: Which Villains Do You Know?