10 Biggest Missed Opportunities In TV History

Ash vs. Evil Dead's cancelled fourth season looked INSANE.

The Walking Dead
AMC

The sheer number of moving parts that comprise even the simplest TV show are absolutely mind-boggling, and so it's little surprise that so many series end up falling short of their huge potential.

The creative push-and-pull between a showrunner, the network, and passionate fans can make or break a series. But even many good or great shows end up throwing some easy wins away by simply not giving the audience what they want.

Inspired by this recent Reddit thread, these 10 TV shows - among some of the most popular and acclaimed of all time - stumbled hard by failing to do justice to a golden opportunity staring them in the face.

Perhaps the showrunners fumbled a crucial character arc, skipped over something fans desperately wanted to see, or otherwise failed to exploit their blatantly obvious storytelling capital.

It's not always strictly the creatives' fault, of course: often they've got network executives breathing down their neck or are trying to desperately ward off overzealous fans.

But all the same, this ripe storytelling potential was promptly thrown out for no good reason, and the show was all the worse for it...

10. Daenerys' Botched Heel Turn - Game Of Thrones

Game of Thrones Daenerys Iron Throne
HBO

Game of Thrones' eighth and final season is basically a comedy of errors - an avalanche of storytelling mistakes as showrunners David Benioff and D. B. Weiss attempted to speed-run a full season's worth of story and character work in just six episodes.

There were many, many missed opportunities in the show's final stretch, but nothing more egregious than the botched presentation of Daenerys Targaryen's (Emilia Clarke) transition into the Mad Queen.

On paper, the idea of Dany's heel turn was perfectly fine, but it also needed to be built up and finessed over at least the course of a season, rather than feeling so suddenly thrown into the mix at the end as it did.

When Dany burned down King's Landing in the show's penultimate episode, it simply didn't feel earned - rather it came off as rushed, with Benioff and Weiss racing to tie up her arc in record time.

As character development it felt inauthentic to Dany up to that point, a fact made even worse by her abrupt death in the series finale.

Daenerys becoming a full-blown villain could've been incredible if given sufficient time to marinate, but it was painfully clear that those in charge just wanted to get it done as fast as possible and move onto other projects.


9. The Scrapped Friends/Seinfeld Crossover

Friends Seinfeld
NBC

There's no denying that Friends and Seinfeld were the sitcoms of the 1990s, and as such, a crossover event which saw each series' characters appear in the other show would've been absolutely huge.

And get this, with both shows airing on NBC, it actually almost happened.

When both sitcoms were at the peak of their popularity in the mid-to-late '90s, the network seriously considered a crossover night where Friends characters would appear in Seinfeld and vice versa, effectively confirming them to exist within the same continuity.

But according to former Seinfeld writer Peter Mehlman, the ambitious and appealing idea was ultimately given the kibosh by Seinfeld creator Larry David himself.

David had no interest in a crossover, though Melhman apparently almost persuaded him by suggesting they agree to it, only to kill off Ross on their episode - something NBC presumably would've vetoed anyway.

All the same, this would've been one of the most legendary TV crossovers of all time - seeing Seinfeld's signature cynicism injected into the broader, more upbeat world of Friends would've been one hell of a sight.


8.  Not Being Quicksilver - WandaVision

Wandavision Ralph Bohner
Disney+

Jaws were collectively dropped around the world when, at the end of WandaVision's fifth episode, Wanda (Elizabeth Olsen) was greeted by none other than her apparently dead brother, Pietro.

The big twist, however, is that he wasn't played by Aaron Taylor-Johnson as in Avengers: Age of Ultron, but rather Evan Peters, who played Pietro/Quicksilver in Fox's canonically unrelated run of X-Men movies.

The reveal seemed to suggest that Fox's X-Men universe was going to be integrated into the MCU somehow, only for the series finale to throw this all away by revealing that "Pietro" was actually a regular Westview resident called Ralph Bohner, who was forced to impersonate Pietro by the villainous Agatha Harkness (Kathryn Hahn).

Basically, it was a bait-and-switch which got fans hugely excited only to leave them massively deflated by season's end. Considering how great Peters was in the role of Pietro, teasing him joining the MCU only to throw it away a few episodes later was a colossal miscalculation.


7. Killing Shane Too Early - The Walking Dead

walking dead shane
AMC

The Walking Dead truly didn't know what it had with its early antagonist Shane Walsh, played with gruff delight by the ever-brilliant Jon Bernthal.

Shane was a terrific foil for protagonist Rick (Andrew Lincoln), and so his death in season two's penultimate episode left many fans hugely disappointed, leaving a giant void of personality and overall screen presence in his wake.

While it's fair to say that Shane died much earlier than this in the comics, given that the show has deviated significantly from the source material on numerous occasions, would it have killed the showrunners to keep Shane around for a little longer at least?

The show could've slow-bled the increasing tension between Shane and Rick for at least another season before bringing it to the boil. If nothing else, seeing Shane's descent into madness continue for another batch of episodes would've made for compulsive viewing.

Given how long-tenured some of the series' more notable villains have been - namely Negan (Jeffrey Dean Morgan) - it's a crying shame that Shane got taken off the chess board so soon.


6. Not Recasting Kevin Spacey - House Of Cards

House of Cards Kevin Spacey
Netflix

The production of House of Cards' sixth and final season faced a massive challenge following the firing of Kevin Spacey after sexual misconduct allegations were levelled against him.

Netflix ultimately decided to kill off Spacey's protagonist Frank Underwood and shift the perspective towards his wife, Claire (Robin Wright), for the final batch of episodes.

But as great as Robin Wright was in the role, the creative just wasn't there, and the final season was massively harmed by the fact that Frank's death clearly wasn't part of the original plan. It was a huge creative pivot, and not one the show handled gracefully at all.

Yet there was perhaps a more elegant solution hiding in plain sight - just recasting Frank.

House of Cards' big narrative gimmick is that Frank regularly breaks the fourth wall to address the audience, so why not simply replace Spacey and have the new actor tell the audience to deal with it?

It certainly would've been a bold move in of itself, but with an A-lister like Bryan Cranston or James Spader filling Spacey's shoes, it just might've worked.

In the very least, it would've made for a more coherent final season than the abject mess we ended up with.


5. The Second Series Finale Disappoints Fans AGAIN - Dexter: New Blood

Dexter New Blood Dexter Death
Showtime

Dexter's original series finale remains one of the most disappointing of all time - Dex (Michael C. Hall) ends up faking his own death and working as a lumberjack under a fake name in Oregon. OK?

When Showtime announced that a sequel series was in development, and that it was committed to giving fans a superior second ending to Dexter's story, fans were cautiously optimistic. After all, it couldn't be any worse, right?

And while Dexter: New Blood certainly didn't plumb the awful depths of the original series finale, its ending nevertheless rubbed a lot of fans the wrong way.

Even beyond the fact that Dexter died at the end - a divisive choice if there ever was one - many fans felt that the final episode was a rushed, convoluted mess which simply tried to do much inside of a single hour.

Basically, New Blood had returned to the roughshod quality of writing that sunk the original show in its final season.

Again, New Blood certainly had more positives than the original ending, but given how much Showtime and showrunner Clyde Phillips hyped it up as delivering a "proper" ending worthy of the show's better, earlier seasons, it ultimately felt like a bit of a damp squib.


4. The BTK Killer - Mindhunter

Mindhunter BTK
Netflix

Netflix's Mindhunter is one of the greatest TV series of the last decade - a stunningly moody crime thriller overseen by David Fincher, focused on the FBI's Behavioral Science Unit studying serial killers in the 1970s and early 1980s.

Throughout both seasons, the main story periodically cuts away to show brief vignettes of an unnamed ADT serviceman (Sonny Valicenti) who is initially implied to be Dennis Rader aka the BTK Killer, before his identity is formally confirmed in season two.

These segments have virtually no interaction with Mindhunter's main story, though by the end of season two, the show seemed to be setting up a third season which would focus on his crimes more explicitly.

Yet because Mindhunter was ultimately cancelled after two seasons, we never got to see the long game play out with BTK.

Given that Rader wasn't caught until 2005, decades after the show is set, it would've been interesting to see how his arc unfolded in season three. Would he have remained an enigma to the FBI, or would the show have jumped forward in time to show his capture?

Either way, that we didn't get to see whatever the show had planned with BTK is an all-time shame.


3. Not Killing Brody In Season One - Homeland

Homeland Brody
Showtime

Homeland's first season was absolutely terrific, but the creatives ultimately chickened out on a pivotal moment which could've cemented the show as one of the all-time greats.

In the season one finale, Marine-turned-terrorist Nicholas Brody (Damian Lewis) makes the decision to carry out a suicide bombing at a State Department policy summit, with the intent of killing Vice President Walden (Jamey Sheridan) and denouncing a U.S. drone strike in Pakistan.

It's a deliriously tense sequence as Brody readies himself to detonate the vest, but he's eventually stopped in his tracks by a phone call from his daughter, Dana (Morgan Saylor), who unknowingly persuades him not to blow himself up.

Killing Brody so early in the show would've given Homeland's first season one hell of an unforgettable ending, akin to Ned Stark's (Sean Bean) unexpected demise in Game of Thrones' first season.

Instead, Brody was given a stay of execution and it became increasingly clear over the seasons that followed that those in charge just didn't know what to do with him, leading to his belated demise at the end of season three, long after many had stopped caring.


2. The Post-Apocalyptic Fourth Season We Never Got - Ash Vs. Evil Dead

Ash Vs Evil Dead Bruce Campbell
Starz

As belated TV sequels to hit movies go, Ash vs. Evil Dead must surely be one of the greatest ever - a show that both pays homage to Sam Raimi's legendary horror-comedy trilogy while feeling like a legit sequel in its own right.

The show was sadly cancelled after three seasons due to dwindling ratings, ending on a tantalising cliffhanger where Ash (Bruce Campbell) wakes up in a post-apocalyptic future, and is gifted a supped-up version of The Oldsmobile by his sexy robot companion Lexx (Jessica Green).

It was one hell of an insane way to end the season, and had Starz not cancelled Ash vs. Evil Dead barely a week before the episode aired, it would've left fans hugely hype for season four.

According to Bloody Disgusting, the fourth season was set to have a vibe similar to both Mad Max and Fallout, the incredible potential of which speaks for itself.

Sadly with the series' cancellation and Campbell's subsequent retirement from the role of Ash, it'll forever be one of TV's great what-ifs.


1. The Three-Day Time Skip - Twin Peaks

Twin Peaks Leland Palmer
ABC

Twin Peaks' controversial second season eventually revealed that Laura Palmer's (Sheryl Lee) killer was her own father, Leland (Ray Wise), albeit while possessed by the interdimensional entity Bob (Frank Silva).

Shortly after Leland is arrested mid-way through the season, Bob leaves his body and he dies, only for the next episode to abruptly take place three days later at his funeral.

Yet David Lynch missed a ripe opportunity by glossing over those three days - an entire episode centered around the town reacting to Leland's capture and death could've been absolutely fascinating.

Given that Laura's murder captivated the local community, it's bizarre how tossed-off and rushed-over its resolution feels. In reality, it would've sent shockwaves throughout the town and surely resulted in some compelling character drama.

This misstep could perhaps be attributed to the fact that Lynch wasn't originally planning to reveal the identity of Laura's killer at all, but was ultimately pressured to do so by network ABC.

And so, it's little surprise that so much of Twin Peaks' second season is a pure mess.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.