10 Biggest TV Disappointments Of 2016

Not even dancing Mulder could save X-Files 2016.

Negan The Walking Dead
AMC

2016 was a bit of a rollercoaster for many reasons. There was the eventful – to say the very least – U.S. presidential elections, the Brexit vote and the deaths of icons like David Bowie, Prince and Alan Rickman. It’s a year a good few people will probably be glad to see the back of, though it also produced some cracking movies, video games and television.

Of course, there were plenty of letdowns too, like great TV shows being cancelled before their time, or a formerly great show turning to utter crap. It’s getting harder and harder to entertain audiences, who’ve grown tired of gimmicks and hollow storytelling, and sadly a lot of shows in 2016 had too much of both. Let's hope TV sheds a few of these bad habits next year.

Let's take a look at some of the big disappointments on television this year, and examine the reasons why they kind of sucked.

10. The Cancellation Of Agent Carter

Agent Carter
ABC

2016 was a bad year overall for Agent Peggy Carter. She passed away off-screen in Captain America: Civil War at the ripe age of 95, and then her former love Steve Rogers immediately hooked up with her niece! Adding fresh insult is the fact her show was canned after two seasons on ABC, and looks very unlikely to be continued elsewhere.

Despite the character being a fan favourite and the show giving fans a unique look at the early day of S.H.I.E.L.D, the show’s ratings were always an issue. It may have had great characters and solid storylines, but the low viewership essentially doomed it.

This is pretty heartbreaking for fans of the series or the character in general, since it’s hard to see how she could fit into another MCU movie, outside of the odd flashback appearance.


9. The Sloppiness Of The New X-Files

X-Files Home Again Mulder Scully ashes beach
Fox

They say time heals all wounds, so when season ten of The X-Files was announced people couldn’t help being excited, forgetting that the final seasons of the show were a bit crap. Still, it was good to see Mulder and Scully back, with both Anderson and Duchovny still having the chemistry needed to make it work.

Unfortunately, they didn’t have the best material to work from; the opening and closing episodes were a horrible mess of convoluted conspiracy theories and stilted drama. The monster of the week episodes didn’t work either, given that the show had done similar stories back in the day, and executed them much better. Poor Skinner barely got any scenes either.

Surprisingly the Were-Monster episode was the only one that worked, despite the insane premise and over the top execution. Even with only six episodes this season outstayed its welcome, and despite a cliffhanger ending it’s hard to get jazzed about more.


8. Limitless Failed To Reach Its Limitless Potential

Limitless Series
CBS

Limitless is the movie that cemented Bradley Cooper as a leading man outside The Hangover movies, thanks to the dopey but intriguing premise. It’s easy to see how the concept of a pill that makes you super duper smart could make for a fun show, but Limitless aimed low by turning it into a bog standard procedural.

While Cooper is obviously too busy making that mad blockbuster money, he did produce the show and make several guest appearances as his character from the film, which was a neat tie-in. The downside there is he’s easily the most interesting thing about the story, and it should be following him each week instead of the bland hero who takes the lead.

In the show’s defence, it did have some inventive ideas and it was real easy to watch, but ultimately it wasn’t unique enough to survive past one season, and didn’t gain much of a fanbase to mourn it.


7. The Lame Humour Of Red Dwarf XI

red dwarf poster
Dave

Red Dwarf fans have had a hard time the last two decades. When co-creator Rob Grant left the show after season six the quality took a noticeable dip and subsequent seasons struggled to maintain a baseline of quality.

The seasons since then have a couple of good episodes and lots of iffy ones. Alas, season eleven continued this trend. Officer Rimmer is the only one that felt consistent, thanks to the cast’s commitment and a steady stream of zingers. The other episodes were insanely hit and miss, filled with lame gags and storylines recycled from past seasons. A couple of random jokes might land, but it felt half-hearted.

Despite the advancing years, the cast is still great, but if the show is to continue beyond this point it seriously needs fresh blood in the writing department.


6. The Hellish Boredom Of Damien

Damien The Omen
A&E

The Omen franchise hasn’t had a great time in the last twenty-five years or so. The Omen IV: The Awakening and the remake of the original are so poor Hell itself wouldn’t screen them, and despite being made to celebrate the 40th anniversary of the franchise, the TV series Damian isn’t much better.

The show ignores everything but the 1976 movie, with Damian only becoming aware of his apocalyptic destiny when he’s grown-up. It’s easy to see how such an intriguing concept could make for a gripping horror series, but Damien is so ham-fisted and poorly conceived it squanders that potential.

The lead actor has the charisma of a peeled orange, and it lacks the shocking gore or b-movie charm of the original movies. A show about a good man learning he’s literally The Devil should have been awesome; instead, it was canned after one season.


5. The Blackfish Subplot On Game Of Thrones

Game Of Thrones Blackfish
HBO

Game Of Thrones has so many subplots and characters you sometimes need a graph to connect everything, and the show isn’t above tabling characters for a few years until they’re needed again. Season six was unusually efficient with wrapping up loose ends and reintroducing old characters; Arya finally gained revenge for The Red Wedding, The Hound was confirmed alive and we even caught up with Beric Dondarrion.

One character fans were eager to see was Brynden Tully, aka The Blackfish. Catelyn’s uncle disappearing following The Red Wedding, and after the Frey’s took Riverrun he quickly seized it back from them. It was assumed his reintroduction would play a big part in Jon and Sansa’s quest to take back Winterfell, but nope. He appears for one episode where he refuses to give up Riverrun, and when his spineless nephew gives it up to the Frey’s he decides to fight to the death before running.

Season six was a bit rushed with resolving plot points, but the sheer anti-climatic of The Blackfish's return was unforgivable. He doesn’t even get an onscreen death.


4. The Buddy Cop Flop That Is Lethal Weapon

Lethal Weapon TV show
Fox

It feels like TV show remakes of classic movies are the new thing, but where Hannibal or Westworld took the initial premise and spun them off in exciting new directions, the TV version of Lethal Weapon is content to be bland as possible.

It’s clear the network sank a lot of money into it, but the glossy look can't hide the lack of decent gags. McG – the McGenius behind Terminator Salvation and This Means War – directed the pilot, showing off his typical flair for making something look slick but utterly devoid of soul. The two lead actors are fine and have decent chemistry, but Mel Gibson or Danny Glover they most certainly are not.

The show is doing alright in the ratings, but this modest level of success means it will probably run for a couple of seasons before being canned without fanfare.


3. The Tedium Of The Walking Dead's New Season

The Walking Dead Negan
Gene Page/AMC

Big bad Negan was supposed to energise The Walking Dead, which had devolved into a joyless slog of death and boredom. In the end, all he brought was more death and boredom, with the seventh season scaling new heights in tedium and stall tactics.

Since the already infamous opening episode remarkably little has happened to progress the story, and the show has padded itself out by splitting episodes between characters. This has only served to underline how little plot the show has left, and the only weapons left in its arsenal are gore and shock deaths.

That’s not enough to power it through, which has already affected the ratings. The show has lost around six million viewers since the season began, and unless it figures out a creative direction soon, that spiral looks set to continue.


2. The Failure Of Vinyl

Vinyl Bobby Cannavale
HBO

So confident were HBO in Vinyl they’re said to have blown around $30 million on the pilot alone, and they renewed it before the first episode even aired. That’s the kind of confidence you get from re-teaming Boardwalk Empire creator Terrence Winter with Martin Scorsese, but this time that confidence was tragically misplaced.

Despite the expensive sets and use of classic rock music, Vinyl fell flat. The story was never gripping and none of the characters was especially likeable. Everything on the show was surface gloss, and when it failed to hook viewers within the first few episodes it became clear a second season wasn’t going to happen after all.

It’s a real shame too because there’s no reason this much talent shouldn’t have been able to make a great show.


1. The Delay Of Twin Peaks

Twin Peaks revival poster
Showtime

The fact there’s new Twin Peaks at all is something of a minor miracle; David Lynch sort of retired after Inland Empire, and always stated he’d never, ever return to Twin Peaks. God was merciful, however, and it was announced in 2014 a new limited series would air in 2016, which would also mark the 25th anniversary of the show going off the air.

There have been scares along the way since then; Lynch announced he was stepping away from the project after budget disputes, but thankfully he came back, and the number of planned episodes doubled to 18. The real heartbreak was learning at the start of 2016 the show wouldn’t air until at least 2017 since Showtime were giving Lynch all the time he needed.

Fans the world over let out a collective sigh of disappointment, especially after a casting announcement revealed most of the old cast were returning, in addition to newcomers like Tim Roth, Jennifer Jason Leigh and Naomi Watts. Still, at least we'll have something to look forward to next year.

What were your biggest TV disappointments of 2016? Let us know down in the comments.


Contributor
Contributor

Handsome. Charismatic. Intelligent. Noble. Witty. I'm none of these things, but I'm a half decent writer, I guess.