10 Changes Star Trek Hoped You Wouldn't Notice

There may never be a reason to explain away these changes in Star Trek.

star trek shield
CBS

When one is dealing with a franchise that has lasted as long as Star Trek has, one must remember that there will be so many, many different writers coming through the doors. Each of them will bring their own stamp to their script, even if they are handed a bible of material to work with. That doesn't mean that mistakes and changes won't get through. What matters in this situation is what exactly the show does to manage them.

From the different levels of Warp speed that a ship can achieve to the physical make-up of an entire species, sometimes it really is just easier to say nothing and accept that the audience will notice, whether you want them to or not. Trill spots and Ferengi reputations rise and fall with the advancement of the writing team, while sometimes characters can die and have their fates entirely wiped from the memories of those who love them most.

Such is television.

Which then are the changes that have occurred in Star Trek that the writers simply tried their hardest not to shine a light on?

10. Captain Kirk's Fate

Captain Kirk death Star Trek
Paramount Pictures

This is well-trodden soil of course, with the death of Captain Kirk and Scotty's apparently amnesia. This is actually one of the more egregious examples of writers simply ignoring what had gone before. While there have been continuity issues throughout the franchise, the deaths of main characters tend to be memorable events.

Star Trek Generations was written after The Next Generation came to a close. That means that the episode Relics, which featured Scotty guest-starring in the show, had been and gone. That episode featured Scotty's certainty that Jim Kirk himself had come to rescue him. Barely three years later, from the writers' point of view, Scotty was standing on the Enterprise-B, Deck 15, observing the hull breach, from which Kirk had been blown into the Nexus.

There have been attempts in the years since to explain this away, such as stating that Scotty had suffered a bit of memory loss while trapped in the transporter on the USS Jenolen. However, the truth is that it feeds into another entry on this list and that the writers were simply hoping the audience wouldn't pay too much attention.

Nice try, guys - this is literally our job!


9. Women Can't Be Captains

Star Trek Turnabout Intruder
Paramount Home Entertainment

There is plenty to hopefully forget about Turnabout Intruder, the final episode of the Original Series. Having said that, it's not an awful episode by any account. Rather, it suffers most from becoming, accidentally, the final episode of the show, due to the series' cancellation. The final words of the episode suggest that Kirk and Spock feel sympathy for Janice Lester on account of her gender - as women can't be starship captains.

In the sixties, the series had already made great strides in terms of equality and inclusiveness. While the network had pushed back on having a female first officer in the original pilot, The Cage, there was no issue with having Lt. Uhura on the bridge in every subsequent episode, marking a strong role model for both women and black people as well. To suggest then that Lester is driven mad by the limitations that Starfleet of the 23rd century places on gender is ludicrous.

Thankfully, this was washed quietly away by the time that Star Trek IV: The Voyage Home hit theatres in 1986. The film more or less opens with the USS Saratoga encountering the Whale Probe. The captain of this vessel is played by the great Madge Sinclaire, who would return to Star Trek as Sylvia LaForge in The Next Generation. There is never again any mention of a rank limit for women in the franchise, which indirectly led to the audience getting Captain Janeway down the line.


8. The Warp Scale

Star Trek Warp Speed
CBS

One of Star Trek's most famous episodes is Threshold, the second season entry from Voyager. In it, Tom Paris breaks the fabled Warp 10 barrier, allowing him to enter transwarp. Back in the late eighties, Gene Roddenberry himself suggested that Warp 10 would allow the traveller to exist in every part of the universe simultaneously, rendering all forms of space flight obsolete.

The Original Series used a different scale when it came to measuring Warp speed, with the Enterprise travelling well above Warp 10 from time to time. Further to this, in the Next Generation, the Enterprise-D is able to travel at Warp 13 in Q's version of the future. Far from existing in all corners of the universe at this point, it still takes the ship plenty of time to get from place to place.

The trials on the USS Excelsior were aimed at hitting transwarp, though they were deemed a failure and the ship was fitted with a conventional warp engine, shown in Star Trek VI. While a theory exists that they did, in fact, succeed, with all Warp speeds adjusting to accommodate the new capabilities, the truth is that for a long time in Star Trek, ships simply travelled at whatever speed the current writer imagined, failing to account for any limits imposed as time went on.


7. Doctor Pavel Chekov

Star Trek Chekov
CBS

Star Trek Generations was both the first cinematic outing for the Next Generation crew and the final one for several of the Original Series actors. The script was always going to feature William Shatner returning as Captain Kirk, which would end up with Kirk and Picard coming face to face. Two other faces from the earlier Enterprise were to join him, at least for a while - Spock and Doctor McCoy.

Leonard Nimoy was approached about returning, as was DeForest Kelley. The former refused after he discovered that Spock's role would only be a cameo. He had no interest in appearing or directing, in a film that treated Spock as a throwaway character. Kelley on the other hand was unable to secure insurance to return, due to his ailing health.

This left the writers with a script written for Spock and McCoy, with no chance of the actors returning. In a clumsy move, Scotty and Chekov were slotted into their places. Scotty's dialogue is slightly more stilted than it would normally have been, as he was given Spock's lines almost wholesale. Chekov, for his part, seems to have switched departments from Ops and Security to Medical. He takes over in sickbay, recruiting two reporters as nurses on the way. While it is a good scene for the character, there had never even been a mention of his Medical training before.

The truth is that the entirety of shots featuring Scotty and Chekov were simply (and poorly) veiled attempts to hide the fact the other two actors weren't returning for the film.


6. The Size Of The Galaxy

Star Trek The Final Frontier
CBS

Star Trek The Original Series and the movies that followed operated fast and loose with their rules of space travel. In the second pilot episode, Where No Man Has Gone Before, the Enterprise comes face to face with the Great Barrier that encircles the Milky Way Galaxy. The ship would return to it in By Any Other Name, when the Kelvans attempted to use the vessel to get back to their own galaxy.

Star Trek V: The Final Frontier sees the Enterprise-A travel in the opposite direction, heading directly to the centre of the galaxy this time. Here, they discover that a planet exists at the galactic core, whereupon a non-corporeal and malevolent entity dwells. Clearly, the greatest film of them all.

A much smaller example of the Original Series' ability to travel all over the galaxy comes in the following film, with the USS Excelsior warping from the Alpha Quadrant to the Beta Quadrant in mere minutes, though that's a bit more forgivable with Earth being located close enough to the border.

This all becomes much more of an issue when one thinks of Star Trek: Deep Space Nine and Star Trek: Voyager. The issues relating to the latter are obvious, while the former states that the station, located in the Denorious Belt, is on the outskirts of the Federation, far away from help in times of need. Added to this, the Bajoran Wormhole is the most fantastic discovery, linking the Alpha and Gamma Quadrants together.

However, back in Jim Kirk's day, none of these things were particularly far apart, making all of these discoveries far less impressive.


5. The Trill

Star Trek Trill Makeup Change
CBS

The Trill were introduced in The Next Generation, with Ambassador Odan being their first representative in the franchise. He failed to mention to Dr Crusher that the Trill were a joined species, one who was unable to use transporters for that reason. They are bore distinct forehead ridges in this appearance as well, shown on both the male and female hosts for the Odan Symbiont.

Then, along came Terry Farrell.

When Deep Space Nine was entering production, she was tested with this make-up and for several reasons, it was quickly abandoned. First, she has skin that is so sensitive that she can barely stay in direct sunlight for more than a few minutes, so heavy prosthetics were out of the question. Second, hiding her face behind these ridges was sacrilege of the highest order!

The Trill were then redesigned with the spots that ran from the forehead to toes, revealing far more of the actors' faces going forward. Naturally, this change was never addressed on-screen by the writers and the characters, so it is up to the audience to decide what exactly prompted this enormous change in Trill physiology in those few years.


4. Romii

Star Trek Balance Of Terror
CBS Media Ventures

Balance of Terror introduced the Romulans to Star Trek, also serving as Mark Lenard's first appearance in the franchise, though of course, he would return many times as Spock's father, Sarek. Also introduced are the two planets that form the heart of the Romulan Star Empire - Romulus and Romii.

This is the only appearance of this named planet in the entire franchise. Romii seems to have simply been added to offer another world for the Federation to know about, though it is never elaborated on. It would be many years in fact before this second world would be discussed at all. Star Trek: Nemesis featured a revolution of the Remans, the indigenous race that existed on the then-renamed planet of Remus.

While this brings the Empire more in line with their human inspirations, it does beg the question as to whether the writers consider Romii to be a blip in the history of the franchise, or whether it was meant to be an altogether different world. As shown on-screen, there is an argument to say that it could have been labelled RomII, as in Rom2, simply to highlight a second Romulan world. All of this is fine, but it does feel like something that the writers were simply hoping would fade into the history of the show.


3. The Effectiveness Of Shields

Star Trek Sacrifice Of Angels
CBS Media Ventures

Every ship in Star Trek is fitted with shields to protect them from attack. While there is a huge variety in the strength of these deflectors, they are almost universally present. Star Trek II: The Wrath of Khan features a plot point about conning the Reliant into lowering its shields to allow the Enterprise to even the playing field. Star Trek: Nemesis keeps a running tally of how long is left before the Scimitar gets through the Enterprise-E's defences.

Star Trek: Deep Space Nine features the most offences in this category. As the Dominion War began in earnest, the writers were faced with the challenge of accounting for each ship's shields gradually getting weaker and weaker as the enemy bombardments continued. They came up with a slightly disappointing answer to this, which is to say that Federation shields generally proved to be ineffective against Dominion weapons.

If that was a consistent rule, then it would be more forgivable. However, the Defiant seemed to generally do just fine against Jem'hadar weapons, while Deep Space Nine's shield grid was miraculously strong enough to withhold attack from an entire fleet in Call To Arms. Yet barely six episodes later in the infamous Operation Return, in Sacrifice of Angels, the Dominion are once again cutting through non-existent shield grids and destroying hundreds of Starfleet vessels. Were the sequence not so memorable, it would be slightly more forgivable - yet the visuals are so striking that they are impossible to ignore.


2. The Ferengi's Reputation

Picard and the Ferengi
Paramount Home Entertainment

In the first season of Star Trek: The Next Generation, the writers had hoped to introduce a new villain in the shape of the Ferengi. They would rise to become rivals of the Klingon and Romulan Empires, effectively serving as the new show's gift to the franchise as a whole. However, none of this happened. The writing for the Ferengi fell before they even got a chance to get out of the gate.

In a bizarre move, the writers decided that they would be most effective if they were depicted as hopped-up Gerbils with fangs. The Last Outpost was a misfire in terms of offering the audience a new empire to fear, with Armin Shimerman appearing as one of the first of this new species.

Though they weren't exactly redesigned, they were overhauled as a species. The Battle was one of the last times that they were shown doing anything that was driven by anything other than profit, though even this ends with Daimon Boc stripped of his title. Going forward, they became salesmen, concerned only with the drive for acquiring wealth. They went from an attempt at a frightening species to an endearingly greedy one. Armin Shimerman got to return as Quark, becoming one of the most loveable characters in the franchise, even if he was always trying to get a leg up on the competition!


1. Voyager's Fuel Levels

Star Trek Voyager Demon
CBS

One of the premises for Star Trek: Voyager was that the ship had been flung tens of thousands of miles away from the Federation, Starfleet or any allied powers. This automatically left them in a bind. Not only would they have to struggle to find friendly races to trade with, so as to replenish their supplies but they would also have to find a way to refuel the ship.

As Voyager went on into its second season and beyond, some of these aspects were quietly dropped from the show. It wasn't so much that they were wiped away altogether, as in the fourth season episode Demon saw the ship struggling with an almost empty gas tank. It was really more of a case that the restrictions that the show had placed on itself got in the way of the stories they began telling.

For example, when the Borg finally arrived at the end of the third season, there simply was no place for a storyline that would see Voyager on the run, suddenly out of weapons, fuel and supplies. Rather, these elements only returned when the episodes had room for them.

Ronald D. Moore, who only worked on a handful of episodes of Voyager due to a difference of opinion with Brannon Braga, went on to reinvent Battlestar Galactica, along with David Eick. In this series, these issues - particularly that of low fuel levels - were not only never far from the main plot but often guided the characters decisions along the way.


Watch Next


In this post: 
Star Trek
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Seán is the host and head writer/presenter for TrekCulture, as well as a writer/presenter on WhoCulture and WhatCulture Horror. He has authored two novels, dozens of short stories, and hundreds of articles for WhatCulture. He holds a Master of Arts in Creative Writing from University College Dublin. As part of his work with TrekCulture, Seán has been invited to participate in collaborations with Roddenberry Entertainment, as well as contributing to several Star Trek community projects. An avid fan of Star Trek, Doctor Who, and the horror genre at large, Seán's expertise has helped develop these channels to the successes they are today. As host of the Ups & Downs series on TrekCulture, Seán has become internationally recognised for his positive yet critically informed approach to reviewing every episode of modern Star Trek, ensuring he is one of the go-to voices in the Trek community. Favourite Quote to describe himself: "I'm serious about what I do, just not always about the way that I do it"