10 Characters The Walking Dead Killed Off At The Wrong Time
The Walking Dead is understandably a show all about death, but sometimes the timing is a bit off!
The Walking Dead is known for its gory deaths sprinkled throughout the show. While they are used for shock value and to keep viewers hooked, many deaths serve the narrative in impactful ways. After all it would be unreasonable for all the characters to survive through a zombie apocalypse.
In fact some of the best and most memorable moments in the show all revolve around death and murder, be it Shane forcing Rick to kill him or Hershel having his head lopped off by The Governor in front of the other survivors. A good, well-timed death can be the perfect bittersweet ending to a character and stops them from losing their appeal or growing stale.
However there are some deaths in the show which could've been placed a bit better. Some people died way too early, many just as their story was starting to get interesting, while other characters could've exited the show with a well executed death but instead ended up sticking around for too long. There really is nothing worse than getting excited for where a story might take someone, then having all your hopes stomped out as they're killed off.
10. Axel
One of the prisoners rescued by Rick and the group, simply put, Axel was a cool dude. He was the funniest of the prisoners and immediately tried to assimilate with the group, quickly accepting the apocalypse for what it was. He also had a very unique attitude towards the fact he had been incarcerated, admitting that his time inside made him a better man. He also had a cool moustache.
Unfortunately for the reformed prisoner he didn't get to stick around long as he was shot through the eye by The Governor in the first prison attack. While the scene is fantastic as The Governor's theme comes pulsating in as Axel dies, it just seemed a little early to be saying goodbye to him already. His presence in the prison wasn't wholly welcomed yet he was able to get friendly with Carol.
Had Axel stuck around for a little longer we could've seen him become a core part of the group and perhaps even develop a relationship with Carol. Having him around for longer also meant he could've been killed in the fourth season's mid finale, adding to the kill count of the large prison battle, which unfortunately failed to reach the same insanity seen in the comics.
9. Abraham
Daryl doesn't feature in the comics, therefore Rick has a range of different right-hand men throughout the apocalypse. After losing the prison, Rick and Abraham co-lead the group to Washington while butting heads until they eventually learn to respect each other as leaders. This was always really interesting to read as both characters made fair decisions while also taking things too far, but we only see glimpses of this in the show.
It's a shame, because Michael Cudlitz is absolutely fantastic in the role. His survivability seemed to improve though, as Abraham's comic death was given to Denise and Robert Kirkman started to admit he regretted killing of the character before the rebellion against Negan began. It seemed likely that the TV show would give Abraham a chance in the spotlight in the soon-to-arrive conflict. This would've been really fantastic to see, seeing as Abraham actually has military experience and could've turned the tide.
This didn't come to fruition though, as he was killed by Negan to subvert the expectation that it would be Glenn that dies in the infamous baseball bat scene. But then Glenn did receive the Lucille treatment anyway. While having Negan killing two of Rick's group was a good way to add an extra punch, having it be Abraham just seems like such a missed opportunity. Being good friends with Glenn, Abraham would've likely butted heads with Rick once more when Rick first refused to fight and it would've been really interesting to see how Abe would've stepped up.
8. Dale
While Dale's death in the show was influenced by external conflict between AMC and Jeffrey DeMunn, it really is a shame that he had to exit the show so early. The appointed moral compass of the group, Dale would always say what he believed had to be said even if it made him unpopular with other members of the group. After his exit from the show, the writers seemed to pass his role onto Hershel.
While Hershel made for a great moral compass to the group, there was something about how riled up and angry Dale could with anyone. He also had great relationships with everyone in the group, but most importantly Glenn, Rick and Andrea. These relationships would've made the third season even more interesting, especially with the situation with Woodbury.
Would Dale attempt to get Andrea to come back to the prison, or would he actually rather move to Woodbury as well? Who knows what Dale would think of the group after a winter on the road, or of Rick after he killed Tomas. His beliefs would've been pushed to that absolute extreme as he gets caught up in the war between the two groups and his inner conflict could've helped drive the message home that both groups have their faults.
We'd also get to see a lot more of the iconic stare, which is always a bonus.
7. Tara
When Tara was introduced many expected her to be killed off in the prison battle, but instead she stuck around and actually helped Glenn find Maggie. It was really quite interesting to see a member of The Governor's militia actually go on to become a member of the group. Although it was a shame that there was no real conflict about Tara changing sides, having the group accept someone who helped destroyed their home demonstrated that they weren't too far gone.
Tara stuck around until the ninth season where she was unfortunate enough to become one of the heads on the whisperer border. The problem is her character doesn't do a huge amount throughout the show. She seems to always be the secondary character to several storylines and she was also written out of a small part of season five and a small portion of season six.
The constant stepping back and lack of central stories revolving around Tara just made her character a little bit forgettable. Truly believing in Eugene's ability to find a cure, having her die on the road to Washington protecting him could've been used to finally make the lying school teacher crack and spill the truth. Or perhaps she could've received the death that Noah got, seeing as that would've traumatised Glenn just as much or possibly more.
Speaking of Noah...
6. Noah
Only appearing in ten episodes of the show, Noah made quite an impact in a short time. Perhaps it was due to the fact he had great chemistry with characters such as Beth, Tyreese, Glenn, Aaron and Reg, and only shared a few scenes with all of them. It just seemed such a waste of an interesting character and a talented actor to kill him so swiftly.
Had Noah stuck around we could've seen him step up after Reg was killed and the large horde of walkers from season six decimated the Alexandria defences, putting whatever architecture lessons he got to good use. Having him lead the reconstruction of Alexandria would allow him to step up to a more prominent role in the show while also allowing for Tyler Williams to show off his acting skills, something he was able to demonstrate superbly in episode nine.
One thing is for sure, it certainly would've been cooler to see Noah grow as a character rather than watching him get torn apart by walkers.
5. Andrea
Andrea was a divisive character amongst fans due to the fact that she was wildly different than her comic-book counterpart and also because she chose to stay with The Governor in Woodbury over returning to The Prison. But it was this, her headstrong attitude and commitment to seeking peace that made her entertaining to watch.
Andrea was never originally meant to die in the season three finale and supposedly actress Laurie Holden was told she would be required for around eight seasons. It wouldn't be the last time an actor was lied to regarding their character's life span on the show. It's no understatement to say that the show would be radically different if she stuck around.
It's interesting to speculate but it's also possible that keeping Andrea around could've meant that Michonne and Rick would've never ended up together, as in the comics it is actually Rick and Andrea who enter a relationship. However you can't be sure, as Andrea had already diverged from her comic counter-part massively. Even still, it seems unfair rob fans of her reunion with the group after building up to it for an entire season.
4. Beth
Beth Greene is an interesting entry on this list because she could've been killed before or after her actual death and it would've made for a better story. The reasoning behind this is that the second story arc of the fifth season of The Walking Dead revolves around where she is, who has kidnapped her and how she is going to escape. On the cusp of a reunion with Daryl and her sister Maggie, she is killed in a rather contrived way.
This was frustrating for fans as it just made the entire hospital arc feel a bit pointless. Had Beth survived beyond this event it would've been interesting to see how the group reacted to how she had changed since they had last seen her at the prison. There were plenty of different avenues that could've been explored between Beth and Maggie, seeing as they both never got a chance to mourn their father together. Sadly for the sisters, the reunion was never to be.
On the other side of things, having her actually die in the prison battle would've benefited the story in several ways. It would've boosted the death count, it would've meant that there was no need for the arguably pointless hospital arc and it would mean people couldn't critique Maggie for choosing Glenn over her own sister. It was always strange and out of character how Maggie barely even mentioned her younger sister until season five began.
3. Denise
Many fans often forget about just how important Denise was for the group despite only appearing in nine episodes of season six. In that time she began dating Tara, assists Morgan in caring for Owen in secret and also saves Carl's life during the No Way Out arc. In just over half a season Denise was able to impact the story in several different ways and was shaping up to be a key asset to the group moving forward.
Sadly for the medic she would be receiving the death originally given to Abraham in the comics. This just feels like a waste of a character who was just getting started. While Denise didn't have any loose ends left after being killed off, it's a shame that she couldn't have slowly been built up to be a mainstay of the show. For the show to stay fresh, new characters have to be introduced and not just killed off later for shock value, something the later seasons of the show seriously struggle with.
It's not like she would be useless in the rebellion against Negan either. Being a medic she likely would've caught the attention of Negan himself and perhaps could've eventually seen herself being held captive by the Saviours. Or perhaps she would save several characters lives through her work as Alexandria's medic.
2. Carl
Does it even need to be explained? Carl should not of been killed during season eight and really shouldn't have been killed off full stop. For a start, Carl represents the future of the world. A kid who is forced to grow up in the apocalypse, it's a miracle and testament to his own character that he didn't turn evil or lose his mind. He was also Rick's main motivation, alongside Judith, to build a better world.
Furthermore he had a key role to play in the future of the story, arguably more so than ever. After the time-skip in the comics, Carl has developed a sort-of friendship with an imprisoned Negan, he begins dating Lydia which is a major part of the Whisperer conflict and he eventually joins his father in The Commonwealth.
Rather than Carl being the character used for these stories, his role has been divided up and given to characters such as Judith, Henry and Daryl. While there is nothing wrong with remixing things, it makes no sense to kill Carl if the writers were still planning to explore the same stories. A key part of the relationship between Lydia and Carl in the comics is the fact that Lydia doesn't care about his eye-wound due to her upbringing, and this just couldn't be explored with Henry. Furthermore, Negan and Carl have an established history, which Judith is lacking.
He just deserved so much better.
1. Merle
Perhaps the greatest addition to the show not seen in the comics is the Dixon brothers. While Daryl has stuck around for the entire show, Merle was not so lucky. Missing since season one, Merle was one of the most interesting characters in season three and his death was extremely emotional. But killing him off? Not only was it a waste of a fantastic actor, but it also meant missing out on some really interesting stories.
For one, Merle would've been the group member willing to get his hands dirty for the prison. His presence would be sure to cause tension with characters such as Glenn and Maggie, but also he had interesting relationships with Rick and Michonne, not to mention his brother. Post prison, it would've been amazing to see him choose to protect a weak Glenn and help him find Maggie as atonement for his actions with The Governor.
Past this, can you imagine him in any one of the situations Rick and the group face? He'd have the perfect dark joke for the situation with Terminus, the people of Alexandria would be in awe of the man with a blade instead of a hand and Merle meeting Negan would likely of lead to some of the greatest moments in the show's entire run.
Of everyone on this list, Merle was absolutely the one with the most potential.
Watch Next
The Walking Dead Quiz: You'll Never Be Able To Name All These Characters!