10 Comic Book TV Shows Cancelled Before Their Time
Why did Netflix have to go and cancel all those Marvel shows?
These days, it seems you can't turn on the television, check out a streaming site, or visit a movie theater without stumbling into something inspired by comic books.
With so much content out there, it's not surprising a series or two has met an unnatural end at the hands of television executives. Over the years, this has happened to more than a few comic book-based television series, but some were cancelled way before their time.
Whether it was due to low ratings or the network's dislike of the property, some comic book shows failed to reach their natural conclusion in a satisfying way, only to get the cancellation hammer slammed down upon them to add further insult to injury.
There have been many prematurely cancelled comic book TV shows over the years, but these 10 are the ones that hurt the most. Just when they were building an audience and gaining traction, the networks swooped in and cut them - never to be seen or heard from ever again.
10. Birds Of Prey (2002)
Birds of Prey was a television series developed for The WB in 2002. The series only aired for one season consisting of 13 episodes and never achieved a wide enough audience for the network to latch onto it.
This was during a time-period when The WB (Now The CW) was still building up its audience and unlike the DC series on the network today, this one failed to launch.
The series' premiere episode pulled in a whopping 7.6 million viewers in the targeted 18-34-year-old demographic, but those numbers dropped significantly within only a few weeks. Birds of Prey was only loosely based on the comics that inspired it, but it featured most of who you would expect: Barbara Gordon (Oracle), Helena Kyle (Huntress), and Dinah Redmond, a telepath who was the daughter of Dinah Lance, the Black Canary.
The series starred Ashely Scott, Dina Meyer, and Rachel Skarsten and featured characters prominent in the Batman Universe, but never made its mark. It has since become a cult favorite, but the characters may again see the light of a movie screen. DC is set to release Birds of Prey as a film in 2020, though that property will be based more on the comics than this series.
9. The Cape (2011)
NBC got into the superhero game with Heroes in 2006 and while that series was cancelled early, it found a new life years later. When Heroes came to an end, NBC developed another new series which was inspired by comics but created entirely for the network, as a new property called The Cape in 2011.
The Cape was a huge success when it first aired, but almost immediately saw declining ratings which pushed the network to reduce the number of episodes ordered for the first season from 13 down to 10. Shortly after that announcement, the network cancelled the series and moved the remaining episodes to its website as the only place it could be seen.
The series followed the adventures of Vincent "Vince" Faraday, a former soldier and police officer who learns the ways of circuscraft and illusion so he can use a special cape made entirely of spider-silk to his advantage.
Elements of Batman and other similar crimefighting superheroes without powers clearly inspired development of The Cape and while it retains a large cult following, only 10 episodes were ever made, leaving many wanting more. Fortunately, a webcomic was released to supplement the series, but few fans were satisfied.
8. Witchblade (2001)
Witchblade was a series created for the TNT network, which aired from 2001 to 2002 with only two seasons and 23 episodes. The show was developed from the comic of the same name published by Image Comics/Top Cow Productions and featured the characters from those books.
Oddly enough, Witchblade was a mega-hit with critics and fans, which made its cancellation one of the strangest in television history. It holds the distinction of being the highest-rated TV series to be cancelled, but there may have been a practical reason for its cancellation.
Yancy Butler, the actress who played Detective Sara "Pez" Pezzini and the main star of the series, entered rehab for alcoholism in September 2002. The show was cancelled the same month, which led to widespread speculation her treatment was the reason for cancellation. This was pretty much confirmed by Top Cow editor Matt Hawkins who spoke on the cancellation when it occurred.
While the original series is long gone and it doesn't look like anyone involved will be returning, NBC announced in January 2017 that it was developing a new Witchblade series for the network. The new series will be a reboot with entirely new players and could air in 2019 or beyond.
7. The Tick (2001)
Fans of The Tick comic and animated series from the nineties were ecstatic when Fox announced the production of a new live-action series for the network's 2001 fall lineup. The show hit the network with a strong pilot starring Patrick Warburton as the big blue guy, but died in the ratings almost immediately.
Various changes were made to the characters and situations in the show, but that only added to its appeal among fans. The series was well-received, but suffered due to Fox's choice for its time slot. It was aired opposite ratings juggernauts including Survivor: Africa and NBS's "Must See TV" lineup of shows.
The competition and Fox's refusal to promote the show led to the series' downfall and only nine episodes were ever produced. In the early 2000s, Fox had a nasty habit of placing shows it didn't outright own into poor timeslots without promotion, which led to the cancellation of Firefly, Family Guy, Futurama, The Tick, and many others.
Fortunately, The Tick didn't remain dead for too long. Amazon picked up the property and created a rebooted live-action series. That series premiered in 2018 with 12 episodes and will drop another 10 episodes for its second season in 2019.
6. The Flash (1990)
Comic book television series have found a home thanks to the success of series like Smallville and Arrow, but back in the nineties, those series were hit or miss. One show that was well done for its time and appreciated by fans was The Flash, which aired on CBS in 1990.
The show only aired for one season consisting of 22 episodes, but helped to establish the Scarlet Speedster as a real commodity for television. Anyone who knows of the so-called Flarrowverse is aware of The CW's successful Flash series starring Grant Gustin, but the nineties was not the right time for a live-action Flash.
The series suffered from a time-slot shuffle, which ended up forcing it to compete with The Cosby Show and The Simpsons. This ended up causing movements, which didn't help retain an audience and moving a series several times to different days in its first season almost always spells its cancellation.
Fortunately, The Flash has been reborn on The CW, and that series has several connections to this one. John Wesley Shipp, who played the Flash in the nineties series has played Dr. Henry Allen, Jay Garrick, and Barry Allen in different versions of the character on the new show. Additionally, Mark Hamill reprised his role as The Trickster on the new series in much the same way he portrayed him on the nineties show.
5. Avengers: Earth's Mightiest Heroes! (2010)
For the most part, comic book animated television series do remarkably well and rarely see an early cancellation, but that can't be said for The Avengers: Earth's Mightiest Heroes!.
The series first premiered in 2010 on both Disney XD and Toonami online with a 20-part micro-series and it did rather well. Fans appreciated the new take on familiar characters including Iron Man, Giant Man, Hulk, Thor, Wasp, Captain America, Black Panther, and Hawkeye. Eventually, Ms. Marvel and Vision joined the roster.
Most of the stories were based on the original books by Stan Lee and Jack Kirby, which gave the series a classic tone fans of old appreciated as much as newer viewers, which primarily consisted of children. Unfortunately, the show only lasted for two seasons of 52 episodes and saw an untimely cancellation in 2013.
The show wasn't picked up for a third season and was instead replaced by a new series, Avengers Assemble in 2013. While it was suggested that the series would seen an "epic conclusion" via the new show, few voice actors were carried over and the original production seems to remain dead in the water with little to no hope of a return.
4. Constantine (2014)
The excitement was palpable when NBC teamed up with DC Comics to create a live-action Constantine television series in 2014. The show was based on the Hellblazer comics and had little to nothing in common with the live-action film, which took a great deal of creative license with the characters. This show was all about John Constantine and fans loved it.
Unfortunately, that adoration for the series failed to keep it on the air and Constantine only produced a single season consisting of 13 episodes. Even with fan support, the show failed to achieve enough ratings to justify keeping it on the air, but all hope wasn't lost with the series cancellation.
When the show died, the character continued to live on in other series. Matt Ryan continued to voice the character on the CW Seen animated web series, Constantine: City of Demons and he even showed up in live-action form in an episode of Arrow.
Constantine popped up in the third season of Legends of Tomorrow, which worked so well, he was upgraded to a series regular for the fourth season. The world may have lost a Constantine television series, but at least the character continues with the same actor on another.
3. Agent Carter (2015)
When Captain America: The First Avenger hit theatres in 2011, fans loved Agent Peggy Carter, who was played by Hayley Atwell. She was so well received by fans, in fact, that an entirely new series called Marvel's Agent Carter was greenlit by ABC for the network's 2015 season.
Agent Carter premiered to amazing ratings in its first season and helped to flesh out the character's origin, the creation of S.H.I.E.L.D., and other characters from the film and associated series, Marvel's Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D.
Like every other show on this list, the series failed to maintain the ratings it pulled in when it was originally aired. It pushed out an opening season consisting of only eight episodes and was followed by a second season of ten, but that was it. The series was cancelled before it could come to a reasonable conclusion.
The series maintained a favorable rating among critics throughout its airing, but despite that and a positive fan following, ABC gave the series the axe. The character, as played by Atwell, continued to appear in other films within the MCU and was regularly referenced in Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D. and other shows, but mostly disappeared from our television sets when the show met its untimely end.
2. Luke Cage
Shows like Iron Fist and The Defenders were wrought with criticism when they aired so it wasn't surprising when Netflix cancelled them, but the world was shocked when the streaming service pulled Marvel's Luke Cage from production after the series' second season concluded.
Luke Cage was one of the most critically acclaimed series Marvel and Netflix created, which is why few understood why it was given the axe. When it was cancelled, few details were provided as to the reason, but some rumors about creative differences between Netflix and the series' creators brought the third season discussion to an abrupt halt.
According to Deadline Hollywood, the writers crammed into their spaces to work hard on the third season without an official greenlight from Netflix. Everyone seemed to believe the series would receive a third season order, but work was put on hold after the episode order was cut from 13 to 10.
The turmoil that went on behind the scenes ultimately resulted in the cancellation of the series. Fans who hoped Luke Cage might appear in the third season of Iron Fist lost that dream when that series was cancelled a few weeks later. It appears Luke Cage, alongside other Marvel/Netflix characters, will no longer have a series of any kind on the streaming service either.
1. Daredevil
While fans were still recovering from the loss of Luke Cage, Iron Fist, and other series on Netflix, the show that nobody thought could be cancelled was dropped after its third season was released too.
Marvel's Daredevil launched Netflix's MCU contingent and the show was incredibly successful and popular. Because of Daredevil, shows like The Punisher, Jessica Jones, and the other previously mentioned series all saw light on the streaming service, so its cancellation came as a shock to fans across the world.
Before the third season premiered, it was already reported that a fourth season was sure to follow due to it being "widely watched and critically acclaimed," but that wasn't the case. When Netflix cancelled the series, they gave no explanation other than to suggest the character would "live on in future projects for Marvel."
Rumors and discussions on the Internet suggest Marvel and Disney may be planning to recreate Daredevil and some of their other properties on Disney+, the House of Mouse's own streaming service set to launch in 2019, but there have been no confirmations about that so far.
With the cancellation of Daredevil, hopes for continued Marvel/Netflix live-action shows are bleak, and though this cancellation was only recent, fans won't forget it anytime soon.