10 Confusing TV Shows That Nobody Understands

Who needs plot when you can can have secret robots, alternate universes, and Vince Vaughn's koans?

Westworld HBO
HBO

Whether they're dark and gritty cop procedurals or warm fuzzy family sitcoms, one thing most TV shows have in common is a pretty easy to understand structure.

You don't need to be a script writer to know that most shows follow a clear three act structure, feature one or two primary protagonists, and usually have a main plot for the week's story to follow along with a less important subplot as its B-story. This predictability makes most shows easier to follow and saves viewers who may have missed an instalment here or there from being hopelessly lost.

Then there are the shows on this list.

Disregarding structure either as an audacious decision by the creators or simply because they couldn't be bothered learning the rules, these shows are nigh on impossible to fully comprehend.

Some are bogged down by byzantine backstory, some are mystery which hide missing pieces from the viewer in order to limit what it's possible to work out. Some are beloved for their complexity and the enigmas hidden in their depths, whereas some are adored more for their characters and the impossible-to-follow plotting is an element fans resent or try to ignore.

Whatever the case, these ten shows have one thing in common: like so many moody teens, no one gets them.

10. Stranger Things

Stranger Things 3 Billy
Netflix

At first glance, Netflix hit Stranger Things may seem like an odd inclusion on this list.

After all, compared to the byzantine plots of Westworld or the trippy free association madness of Twin Peaks, the Duffer Brothers' mega successful coming of age sci fi mystery may seem fairly easy to follow.

But for anyone actually looking to make sense of its knotty, convoluted backstory, the show is surprisingly hard to make sense of.

Where the slow burn debut season followed a fairly genre standard government cover up of an alternate dimension, the second series started to loop in elements of possession (sort of), government programs to control those with telekinetic abilities, and demon dogs coming from said alternate dimension.

Meanwhile the divisive third instalment saw the Russian government involved in experiments almost identical to those of the shadowy American organisations, complicating things further. Are the two nations working together? Is it a coincidence? Is the Upside Down hell? Are demagorgons demons, or aliens, or...


9. The Wire

Omar, The Wire
HBO

A sprawling five season epic set in Baltimore, Maryland, Treme creator David Simon's iconic HBO series The Wire may not have received much attention upon release but in the years since its last episode aired the crime drama has become a phenomenon.

And deservedly so, as the show which introduced viewers to the likes of Idris Elba and Michael K Williams managed the extraordinary feat of illustrating the intersections between criminals, cops, corrupt politicians, and the press with grace and finesse.

Portraying its entire massive cast as complex, multi-faceted characters, the show's ever-wavering moral compass could not have been further from the "good cops vs bad criminals" simplicity of Law and Order and its ilk.

As a result of this huge scope however, as well as the accurate portrayal of complicated in-group lingo from both criminals and cops alike, the show required a veritable glossary for the uninitiated and even viewers who understand the constant slang are likely to have trouble keeping up with the huge cast's diverging storylines.


8. True Detective

True detective season 2
HBO

The sparse and intense first season of HBO's deeply disturbing, almost Lovecraftian crime thriller True Detective is undeniably complex at times.

But the story of Matthew McConnaughey and Woody Harrelson's mismatched cops trailing a psychotic child murderer and uncovering a vast underworld conspiracy in the process actually turns out to be surprisingly (and for some fans, disappointingly) simple by its denouement.

The viewer never learns the secrets of the cult the villain is involved with, but the pair nonetheless uncover the culprit and save the day in relatively straightforward if somewhat trippy fashion.

Not so with season two.

Centring on Colin Farrell's loose cannon detective, Rachel McAdams' troubled recruit, and Vince Vaughn's pseudo philosophical mob boss, the second season of the hit is an impossible to decipher disaster.

With intersecting hints of cults, satanism, and land ordinance violations, the show spun a web no one could hope to untangle, then left viewers with no key to this enigma beyond Vaughn's unintentionally hilarious koans.

It was Lynchian alright, but more in the vein of his appearances on The Cleveland Show than Mulholland Drive...


7. Riverdale

Riverdale Cheryl Blossom Poisons
The CW

Taking a leaf from True Detective's book, the CW's gritty Archie comics reboot makes about as much sense as... Well, as the idea of a gritty Archie reboot.

The show's relatively straightforward debut season centred around a simple enough plot concerning a murder mystery, with the cast of teens trying to solve who slew poor Jason Blossom.

By the time this question was answered the show had set up a nice little love triangle and some subplots (Archie wants to quit football for music!) to follow in future instalments.

So what came next?

Well, a slasher-style season wherein characters were offed one-by-one by a mysterious Black Hood, soon followed by the reveal of some secret siblings, the formation of a vigilante gang by our teen hero, some drug manufacturing, some prison time for our hero, bear attacks, an illegal in-prison boxing ring, a life-or-death game of knock-off Dungeons and Dragons, a turf war between two teenage criminal gangs (unrelated to the aforementioned vigilante gang)...

Oh, and speaking of a taking a leaf from True Detective's book, the show soon started investigating a series of grisly sacrifices, all the while continuing its ever-unravelling love triangles.

Did you get all that?


6. Fringe

Fringe TV Show
Fox

With Lost mastermind JJ Abrams at the helm, 2009 debut Fringe was always bound to become more complicated than its initially simple premise implied.

The show followed Anna Torv and Joshua Jackson as a stoic government agent and the son of a mad scientist who are thrown together in a race against time to solve some sort of maybe-supernatural, definitely complicated conspiracy.

But before long, this apparent X-Files rip-off was moving into crazier and more complex territory than Chris Carter's series ever dared to touch upon.

Whether it was the intersecting timelines, the multiple versions of events, or the eventual bombshell revelation that the show had thus far taken place in an alternate universe (there's something viewers could have done with knowing earlier), this series was trippier, odder, and more ambitiously weird than almost any sci fi series had endeavoured to be before it.


5. Game Of Thrones

Game of Thrones Emilia Clarke
HBO

Like The Wire earlier in this list, HBO's big budget gritty fantasy mega hit Game of Thrones didn't need an unexplained conspiracy or multiple universes to complicate its set up.

Instead, the show's set up was complicated from the get-go, with a massive cast of characters ensuring that the series always had at least a dozen storylines on the go at any given time.

Yes, you read that right: A show which managed to win over mainstream acclaim often switched between over ten different settings, sometimes going an episode or two without even revisiting characters.

Plot lines and their characters were dropped for seasons at a time only to be picked up again without any exposition to remind the viewer where they were, and countless seemingly central characters were introduced only to be offed moments later.

The show's controlled chaos allowed the creators to weave between backstory, in-universe ancient history, and complex political machinations with ease, and the show deserves credit for its ability to condense such a massive sprawling story into something vaguely comprehensible.


4. Twin Peaks

Twin peaks ending
Showtime

Did someone say "something vaguely comprehensible"?

Hope not, because this entry is about Twin Peaks.

When network television allowed Blue Velvet director/ infamous oddball David Lynch create a prime time series, they really should have seen this show coming.

A surreal headf*** from start to finish, the first two seasons of Mark Frost and Lynch's co-created small screen masterpiece used the murder mystery "who killed Laura Palmer" as an excuse to unveil the strange secrets of the eponymous American everytown, wherein everyone had something to hide and nothing was as it seemed.

A bizarre and impossible-to-categorise mash up of soap opera, murder mystery, police procedural, drama, comedy, surreal horror, and concentrated nightmare juice, Twin Peaks defied genre even before Lynch returned with 2017's triumphantly weird, answer-free disturbing third season The Return.

Difficult, dense, and nigh on impossible to parse, this unparalleled achievement is a testament to the medium of TV's ability to confuse, obsess, and mesmerise its audience.


3. Westworld

Westworld Dolores Evan Rachel Wood
HBO

From the jump, it should have been obvious that 2016 debut Westworld was going to be a complicated and hard-to-untangle series.

After all, the show was adapted from Jurassic Park author Michael Crichton's 1973 film of the same name, a Yul Brynner vehicle wherein androids go haywire and wreak havoc in a wild west theme park.

As such, at any point in this dark, big budget HBO hit, the audience was always aware that any given character could turn out to be a robot, often without them even knowing it. However thanks to some clever timeline cross-cutting, the show manages to confuse and confound even the canniest viewer as epitomised by the shocking cliffhanger twists featured in every second episode.

There are so many that WhatCulture devoted an entire list to the show's best reveals and, even though the recent third season frustrated many faithful fans, it seems that the show is set to keep viewers hooked and utterly lost for some time yet.


2. Lost

Lost Sayid Naveen Andrews
ABC

You knew it was coming: controversial sci fi director JJ Abrams divisive 2004 debut Lost is infamous amongst TV fans for being almost impossible to follow, but so addictive that no one could resist an attempt to unlock its secrets.

Yes, the eventual finale transpired to be both too over-complicated and too predictable in its general conceit (it's the twist you guessed in the second episode, give or take a few convoluted details).

But during its original run this cult series combined techniques like flashbacks, flash forwards, and the infamous flash sideways to alternate timelines in order to complicate the story of its large, ever-changing cast and obscure the mystery of what this island they crash landed on was and why they were sent there.

It may not have stuck the landing (sorry), but at its most shamelessly complicated and ambitious, this enigmatic sci fi series really did soar.


1. The Prisoner

The Prisoner
ITV

The original indecipherable TV show and still the greatest to ever do it, Patrick McGoohan's cult sci fi mystery The Prisoner debuted in 1967 and had viewers hooked throughout its brief seventeen episode run.

What's it about?

A government agent quits his job, then awakens to find himself held captive in a small seaside town he can't escape.

That's it.

As our hero, played by McGoohan himself, attempts to discern who his captors are and why they've taken him hostage, the show offers tantalising glimpses of a massive, sprawling conspiracy which runs much of the outside world... And that's it.

The conspiracy is never explained, the captors are never revealed, and the trippy, surreal closing scenes of the final episode are a hilarious, disturbing slice of sixties psychedelia which raise many more questions than they answer.

McGoohan was forced into hiding when the series finished, unable to escape the demands of enraged fans who wanted an explanation. None was ever provided, and so this cult gem remains as mysterious as ever all these years on.

Far out, man.


Watch Next


In this post: 
Westworld
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

Cathal Gunning hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.