10 Craziest Fan Theories About The Simpsons

But who really, really shot Mr. Burns?

You can't make 550 episodes without inadvertently inspiring a few fan theories. Over the last 25 years fans have fallen in love with Americas favorite yellow family (and out of love in recent years!) and with episodes replayed on a daily basis in just about every country in the world, it's hard not to truly immerse ones self in the multi-layered world of Springfield. As a result, many of the shows most diehard fans have began to notice things upon repeat viewings that may have gone over our heads. Out there on the internet there's countless musings and links made by diehard fans. These fans have used... oh lets call them "clues" found in episodes, as well as their own imaginations to put together answers to several of the shows unanswered questions. For example why are the Simpsons really yellow? Where is Springfield actually located? Who really, really, really shot Mr Burns? And did somebody say 9/11 conspiracy? In the interest of fairness we intend to present these theories with complete objectivity, and to be honest some of them are actually pretty compelling. But please don't feel like you're being forced to believe anything. After all, that's probably what THEY want you to think!

10. The Simpsons Predicted The Ebola Outbreak

The Simpsons Sandwich Starting with the most current conspiracy theory, you've probably heard about the recent outbreak of the deadly Ebola virus. Ebola first manifested in the 1970s and has now reemerged in North America causing understandable fear and concern. However with fear, there often comes demand for answers and reassurance. So it came to be that many Simpsons fans are convinced that Fox and Matt Groening were apparently in on this pandemic... a full seventeen years before it occurred. Let that marinade. The episode "Lisa's Sax" which first aired in 1997 features a flashback to a five year old Bart, miserable after a rough start at school. Marge offers him a book entitled "Curious George and the Ebola Virus". Bart turns down the book and when asked if he wants to color something he points out a drawing of himself dead and surrounded by corpses. Fans believe this drawing was Bart's vision of a future society destroyed by the Ebola virus. Though it can hardly be called a premonition (Ebola already existed and was sure to come back eventually), it does give the episode an odd sense of significance upon current viewings.

9. The Simpsons Predicted The Syrian War

The Simpsons Simpson Tide Earlier this year Egyptian TV channel al-Tahir aired a segment about the 2001 Simpsons episode "New Kids on the Blecch". The episode, which saw Bart and his friends form a boy band (which turned out to be a front to recruit children into the US Navy), featured a controversial music video. Entitled "Drop Da Bomb" the video showed the boys flying fighter jets and attacking hostile Middle Eastern soldiers. One shot showed a group of soldiers standing by a jeep adorned with a flag that bares a striking resemblance to the current flag of the Syrian Opposition. This has led to the conclusion that The Simpsons not only predicted the current Syrian Civil War, but that the West may actually have planted the seeds for it. Heading right to the source, Simpsons executive producer Al Jean had this to say: "Yes, we had the amazing foresight to predict conflict in the Middle East." We'll let you decide if he was being serious.

8. The Simpsons Predicted 9/11

Our final "Simpsons Predicted It" theory, this one is debatable, but then conspiracy theorists thrive on debates. The opening episode of Season 9 "The City Of New York Vs Homer Simpson" sees the Simpsons head to New York City to track down Homer's lost car. Throughout the episode Homer makes it clear on numerous occasions that he hates New York and everyone in it, and the Twin Towers are featured prominently (Homer's car is parked between them). And the above image is the most curious scene of all. The episode first aired in 1997 (there's that year again! It's all connected we tells ya!) a full four years before the terrorist attacks on New York and was actually pulled off the air for over five years out of respect. And even when it returned to our TV screens, it was heavily edited. Still we have to admit $9 is a suspiciously low price for a bus to New York!

7. Springfield Exists Outside Of Time And Space

Springfield Ever wondered what state Springfield is in? Or why nobody ever seems to age? Well this idea known as the "Tesseract Theory" suggest that Springfield is actually an isolated town existing outside of the space time continuum. That is to say that the town and all of it's residents are permanently trapped in a floating timeline where everyone stays the same age and the world ages around it. While the Simpsons and their many supporting characters have stayed the same age for twenty five years, we have seen glimpses of the world outside of Springfield mirroring our own at the time. George Bush Sr, Bill Clinton, George W. Bush and Barack Obama have all occupied the Oval Office on the show, indicating the passage of time. Celebrities ranging from movie stars to singers have all made their way to Springfield, where they are recognized for their real world achievements. In Season One, Bart tried smuggling a Walkman into church. Now every child in Springfield has a Smartphone. The Simpsons have evolved with the times, but they have not aged. This theory explains why everyone is apparently immortal (except for Maude Flanders and a few others) and why Springfield is impossible to locate on a map. The Simpsons are actually living in some form of supernatural purgatory where the laws of time and space do not apply.

6. OJ Simpson Is Related To The Simpsons

There are a lot of rumors surrounding Orenthal James Simpson but this one is our personal favorite. There are indeed people out there who believe OJ Simpson is related (however distantly) to our four fingered friends. We'll give you a minute to read that a few more hundred times. The Simpsons have already confirmed to have famous relatives in the real world. Jessica Simpson is apparently the cousin of Bart, Lisa and Maggie. So it's not entirely out of the question that they could also be related to OJ. The only other piece of evidence fans can provide is that OJ has a middle name beginning with J, a trait that Abraham, Homer and Bart all share. As for the other obvious problem with this theory, we did learn that the Simpsons have African American roots from the Civil War, so maybe, just maybe, OJ is a descendant of Virgil Simpson. Maybe.

5. Barney Is Nelson's Father

We're big fans of this one, though since we have already met two different incarnations of Nelson's father, this does not hold much weight. But then given the nature of some of the previously mentioned theories on this list, we're prepared to believe anything. The two were briefly seen together in "Bart's Comet" and since then fans have been convinced that the two are related. There's certainly some evidence. Aside from the obvious physical similarities and choice of wardrobe, Nelson pretty much grew up without a father, so there's no guarantee he would actually recognize him if they met. Who's to say that the men we met in "Brother from the Same Planet" and "Sleeping with the Enemy" were not just Mrs Muntz's gentleman callers of the week. After all, we know Nelson's mother is promiscuous. His real father could be anyone in Springfield. Even someone as physically unappealing as Barney would stand a chance. Then there's Barney's years of alcohol abuse and inability to remember events while drunk, and it's more than feasible that he could have unwittingly fathered a child. Or Nelson could be the result of one of Barney's many, many donations to the Springfield Sperm Bank.

4. The Real Reason Why Everyone Is Yellow

Mr Burns Pig1 Warning: This one is a little grim. One theory behind why the Simpsons are yellow is because everyone in Springfield is dying of radiation poisoning due to prolonged exposure to the nuclear power plant. It goes on to suggest that the Simpsons is not a cartoon at all, but a documentary about a real life city of people whose lives have been ruined by this monstrous plant. It is believed that evil, rich,capitalist tyrant Montgomery Burns is working with the Republican Party to cover up this disaster because America needs nuclear power. Therefore the notoriously right wing Fox Network broadcasts footage of this dying town and it's doomed citizens, under the guise of an animated cartoon about funny yellow people. It's certainly a more interesting theory than Matt Groening simply wanting to annoy his viewers by forcing them to change the color tones on their TV settings, but we honestly prefer Peter Griffin's theory that everyone in Springfield has Hepatitis.

3. Every Simpson Is Apparently A Genius

This theory isn't as far out there as others, as it actually makes some sort of philosophical sense. The theory goes that everyone in the Simpson family is inherently born with genius level intellect. No, seriously! Lisa is the most obvious example so we won't bother explaining her intelligence, but it turns out that her most defining character trait is not just unique to her. Homer turned out to be a genius when he had a crayon removed from his brain. The fact that he had shoved said crayon up his nose as a child probably disputes this theory, but then all Simpson males are doomed to fall victim to the the dreaded "Simpson Gene". According to Grampa Simpson, who himself was once an accomplished sergeant, pilot, jazz pianist, Olympic athlete and professional wrestler, the Simpson Gene causes all Simpson males to lose their intelligence during childhood. This would explain why Homer may have been a genius all along and how even Bart was a good speller during his early years at Springfield elementary. Speaking of Bart, many fans have pointed out that despite his lack of academic intelligence, many of his pranks would require intricately detailed planning. Could he really have constructed that "Big Butt Skinner" weather balloon without some kind of mathematics and scientific prowess? Marge may not be a Simpson, but she too was shown to be extremely intelligent in high school, before falling in love with Homer. So if all the Simpsons are geniuses, we are forced to ask. What happened? Fans point out that Homer, Marge and Bart willingly chose happiness over intelligence (which in itself could be viewed as an act of intelligence). Homer had the crayon reinserted in his brain because he was unhappy being smart. Marge chose love over academic achievement and chose to settle down and be a devoted wife and mother. Bart embraced his Simpson Gene and chose the path of underachievement and is clearly proud of it. Only Lisa has chosen to embrace her intelligence and as a result is clearly the least happy member of the family. Finally Maggie has shown signs of intelligence far beyond her years, or year as it were. We can't say what life she'll choose in the future, although the signs don't exactly point in a positive direction ...

2. Maggie Will Grow Up To Be A Homicidal Sociopath

stewiemaggie Like Stewie Griffin, Maggie has displayed supreme intelligence such as being able to write her name on an Etch a Sketch, spell equations with her blocks and occasionally rescue family members in peril. She has also displayed violent and homicidal tendencies that have many fans convinced that the youngest Simpson may grow up to become a fiendishly intelligent serial killer. Though she doesn't share Stewie's passion for matricide it seems Homer may be Maggie's target. Over the course of the series she has knocked him out with a mallet, attempted to stab him with a pencil, shot him with a nail gun and electrocuted him along with the rest of the family during a therapy session. She has also made it clear that she doesn't get along with other babies (Gerald with the one eyebrow could be right after Homer on her list), and doesn't like to see Marge lavish attention on anyone but herself. Though she has saved Homer's life many times such as saving him from drowning and catching a beer bottle flying towards his head, some of her methods have been as deadly as they have been heroic. Such as shooting at Fat Tony's gang with a rifle, and dropping a freaking boulder on Russ Cargill's head at the climax of the Simpsons Movie. Could she be constantly saving Homer's life just so she can kill him herself? And we didn't even mention her shooting Mr Burns - well actually that's because it may not have been her ...

1. Marge Actually Shot Mr Burns

Simpsons Mont Burns Points To Maggie1 Yes, yes we know. It was Maggie. Or Smithers. Or maybe Homer. At least that's what he claimed in "Revenge is a Dish Best Served Three Times." Yet many fans insist that Marge actually shot Mr Burns. Why? Because he dared to take Maggie's candy. And one surefire way to make Marge angry is to threaten Maggie. So we have our Why?, but what of the How? Well Burns was shot by a Smith & Wesson, the same pistol owned by Grampa Simpson. In "Who Shot Mr Burns Part 1" we see Marge bury Grampa's gun in the backyard, although the gun has been dug up by the episodes end, just in time for it to be used against Burns. Marge would at least have known where the gun was. Secondly the bullet had Simpson DNA on it which would make Marge a suspect (she took everything when she married Homer, including DNA). She was already trained to use a firearm during her career as a cop in "The Springfield Connection" and she looked a little too comfortable with Homer's gun at the end of "The Cartridge Family". Finally Marge pinned the shooting on Maggie, knowing that no jury would convict a baby (except maybe in Texas as Chief Wiggum pointed out). But wait! If that were true, then why would Burns go along with it? Why did he name Maggie as the assailant, instead of Marge? Well fans argue that Burns still had feelings for Marge after the episode "Marge Gets a Job". He was so in love with her that he fired her for being married to Homer. This too could be argued as a possible motive for Marge to shoot him. Of course for this theory to be correct, we would have to ignore the fact that Marge was seen alone outside Town Hall when the gun went off, and as Troy McClure would say "That would be downright nutty!" So there you go! Ten of the craziest, yet oddly compelling Simpsons fan theories. Got anything to add? We'd love to hear it!

In this post: 
The Simpsons
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

As a wrestling fan I've flown across the Atlantic for the last five years specifically to attend WrestleMania (28 and 30) as well as TNA, ROH, Evolve, Chikara and most recently PWG. I may have a problem! But if you're reading my work then you probably love wrestling too, so lets focus on that!