10 Most Cringe-Worthy TV Sibling Relationships

Incest, corruption, sociopaths and Monica & Ross doing "The Routine". It's all here...

Just because you€™re siblings doesn't mean that you have what a psychiatrist would call a healthy relationship. When brothers and sisters are featured on television, a medium that thrives on drama, the weirder the issues, the better. Sure, we've all got some irritants or awkward situations with our siblings, but they're usually of a relatively innocent variety. For example, "Oh no, my brother walked in on me in the shower!" or "My sister found my porn folder!" Embarrassing, but nothing that's going to put anyone in therapy for years to come. But if an alien race came to study humanity and only used our television programs, they would probably assume that we're all shagging our sisters. To be fair, though, not all awkward sibling relationships on TV have a sexual component. Sometimes you just see brothers or sisters on television, and something about their behavior makes you do a full body shudder. It's not a science, but you definitely know it when you see it.

10. Dexter/Deb - Dexter

So, we realize that Deb and Dexter aren't actually biologically related. But Dexter was taken in by Deb's family when he was three and she was just a baby, so they for all intents and purposes they are brother and sister. And we're pretty sure there's a thing where if you're raised in close proximity to someone up to the age of six, regardless of blood, you generally don't develop romantic feelings for one another. But hey, apparently rules are made to be broken. Because although they spend the first few seasons as a reasonably well-adjusted set of siblings (especially considering Dexter's little hobbies), the whole thing kind of goes off the rails during the later seasons. Deb becomes convinced that she is in love with Dexter, having dreams about them kissing, and she finally admits it to him. Understandably, Dexter is not on board with this whole situation, and we don't really hear anything else about it. You know you've gone down a dark path when you're starting to creep out your sociopathic, serial killer brother.

9. Sam/Dean - Supernatural

If there were ever two siblings that were entirely co-dependent, it would be these two. Neither is really all that jazzed about living without the other one, and they sort of don't know what to do if they don't have each other. A huge part of this has to do with the way they were raised. When Dean was four and Sam was a baby, their father put Sam in Dean's arms and told him to carry him out of a burning building, and that's really indicative of their entire relationship. Dean has been conditioned over the years to take care of his little brother at all costs, even if it means sacrificing himself, or if Sam doesn't want to be saved. Of course, teaching your kids to take care of one another isn't necessarily a bad thing -- except when your older child believes that it's their only reason for living, and that they are a useless failure if they can't protect their sibling from every evil in the world. (For more information, look in the Encyclopedia Brittanica under Wincester, Dean.) Also, not for nothing, but have you guys seen all the nods to "Wincest" that have been on the show?

8. Dennis/Dee - It's Always Sunny In Philadelphia

Although they're both terrible people in pretty much every way that counts, you have to admit that Dennis sort of edges Dee out in that regard. The sheer amount of cruel mind games that he has played on his twin sister boggle the mind. As it's been made clear from day one, Dennis is basically a relatively high functioning sociopath, who likes nothing better than to screw with his sister, degrading her and chipping away at her self esteem over a period of years. Dee isn't exactly blameless in their escapades, either, but Dennis definitely has sunk more battleships, so to speak. And then there was that whole episode where they got really drunk at a Halloween party, and Dennis couldn't really remember if he slept with Dee or not. You know, normal twin shenanigans. Oh wait...no. That just makes them the worst siblings ever.

7. Octavia/Octavian - Rome

Ancient Rome wasn't exactly known as a bastion of good taste, but we have to think that even they would be a little squicked out about what happens between Octavian and his older sister Octavia. First of all, giving your kids names that are almost exactly the same is a bad idea. That's just asking for siblings to get too close to one another. Really, their parents have no one to blame but themselves when Octavia gets the bright idea of trying to seduce her brother to get information out of him. Here's a little tip for you, Octavia: when you're trying to get your brother in the mood, don't lead with a story about how he used to come running to your bed every night when he was little. Because that's just creepy. Even Octavian, a guy with some decidedly non-vanilla kinks, knows that incest is wrong. To which Octavia replies, "you and I are above such petty social conventions". Uh...Octavia? Pretty sure that not sleeping with your brother is on a whole different level from wearing pants in public or asking someone how their day was even if you don't care.

6. Billy/Brenda - Six Feet Under

Brenda and Billy are unstable on their own. Put them together, and they're basically the nuclear bomb of destructive relationships. The show tries to pin some of their weird incestuous behavior on the fact that their parents were sexually liberated and maintained an open marriage that both children were aware of (and sometimes witnessed). That doesn't seem quite fair, though, because the parents aren't the ones harboring naughty feelings for their siblings. Billy is frequently depressed, and has attempted suicide in the past. He's obsessed with his sister and becomes outrageously jealous when he sees her with other men, especially Nate Fisher, the lead character on the show. He basically can't handle not having Brenda taking care of him. Back in the 80s, he burned down part of their house so that she would leave her fiancee and come back home. And later, he cut off his half of a tattoo that they both had, and then tried to do the same to her. So...there's that.

5. Cesare/Lucrezia - The Borgias

This is a television show (on Showtime, no less) about one of the most powerful religious families in all of Italy during the Renaissance, so on some level, you have to be expecting a certain amount of perverse sexual practice. But we can't ignore the fact that this sibling pair is entirely too comfortable with one another -- the longing looks, the caresses, the whole nine yards. It's just a little much for two people who are married to others and, you know, related. Whenever these two share the screen together, there's sexual tension so thick you could cut it with a knife. Their chemistry is magnetic, and they would probably be a really well-loved couple if it weren't for that pesky incest thing. And to be fair, they do seem to bring out goodness in one another. Cesare's devotion to Lucrezia is one of his best qualities. It's just a shame they have so much of the same DNA. Funny old thing, life.

4. Ross/Monica - Friends

There's just something a little bit off about the relationship between Ross and Monica. Their bond is almost too close to be entirely comfortable. Neither of them were exactly social butterflies when they were younger, and they didn't have a ton of friends (with Rachel as a notable exception), so it makes sense that they would be each other's closest friends. You kind of get the vibe that they were the type of siblings who would go to prom together, and not even think that it was weird. It's one thing to be close to your brother, it's quite another to ask him which dress will make you look hotter so that you can get laid. What kind of brother is like, "Oh, definitely the red one. You look hot in the red dress. I would totally bone you."? OK, so those aren't the exact lines, but that's what the implication is. Also, there was that whole situation where Ross's first kiss with Rachel was actually with Monica. Oops. It's super annoying when that happens.

3. All Of The Brady siblings - The Brady Bunch

To be totally fair, a huge part of why the Brady siblings are creepy is because of stuff that really has nothing to do with characters. But when you know that behind the scenes, every single one of them was hooking up with their opposite sex counterpart, it's hard to watch The Brady Bunch the same way. And it's not like there's even that huge of an issue when it comes to step-siblings becoming romantically involved -- after all, they're not really related. But with a show this squeaky clean and wholesome, it just feels wrong. Maureen McCormick (Marcia) and Barry Williams (Greg) dated briefly during the later years of the show (McCormick was only twelve when the show began), and could be seen making out on the beach. Christopher Knight (Peter) and Eve Plumb (Jan) have mentioned that their relationship would have gone a lot further, if a cuddle session in his pickup truck hadn't been broken up by the police. And even little Cindy (played by Susan Olsen) and Bobby (played by Mike Lookinland) got in on the action -- they reportedly used to sneak off to Tiger's doghouse and make out. Get it together, Bradys. This is the sort of stuff we expect from The Partridge Family.

2. Jaime/Cersei/Tyron - Game Of Thrones

Wow...this one's a trainwreck. Where do we start? Well, we might as well begin at the beginning. Cersei has always resented little Tyrion, because her mother died giving birth to him. She also has a very taboo relationship with her twin brother Jaime -- we learn in the very first episode that they've been sleeping together for quite some time, and that the three children Cersei has been passing off as her offspring with King Robert are actually Jaime's. So for those of you keeping score at home, that's adultery, incest, and a scandal involving illegitimate royal (sort of) children. Yikes. While Tyrion and Jaime have a reasonably healthy relationship with one another, both of their interactions with their sister are about as far from normal as it's possible to go. Most girls don't sleep with one of their brothers and try to get the other one executed for regicide. Cersei isn't most girls. But it's sort of unfair to give her all the blame. After all, it wasn't exactly her idea to have sex with her brother next to her son's dead body. That would be Jaime's, and it appears that we're all going to pretend that rape scene just didn't happen.

1. The Bluth Siblings - Arrested Development

Really, the entire Bluth family, but for the purpose of this article, we'll focus on the middle generation of Bluths (glossing over the alcoholism and terrible parenting from Lucille and George, as well as the awkward cousin incest thing going on between George Michael and Maeby). Because honestly, those four could keep a therapist rolling in Cuban cigars and caviar for decades. Gob, as the eldest sibling, is extremely resentful of his younger brother Michael, who is really the only Bluth sibling anyone takes seriously. Michael gets responsibility and their father's trust, which Gob's attempts to develop a career in magic are woefully derided. So he goes from being dependent on Michael to actively sabotaging his ventures...sometimes in the same episode. And let's talk about Lindsay. Most people, upon learning that they're adopted, don't immediately attempt to seduce the person that they grew up thinking was their twin brother. Maybe we're just old-fashioned, but that doesn't seem right. And Buster...well, Buster's just the classic example of the baby of the family.

Contributor
Contributor

Audrey Fox is an ex-film student, which means that she prefers to spend her days in the dark, watching movies and pondering the director's use of diegetic sound. She currently works as an entertainment writer, joyfully rambling about all things film and television related. Add her on Twitter at @audonamission and check out her film blog at 1001moviesandbeyond.com.