10 Doctor Who Episodes That Should Have Been Two-Parters
If only they'd had twice the runtime, these episodes could've been masterpieces.
Some of the best stories in all of Doctor Who's revival era are the two-parters: stories which span across two episodes with a nail-biting cliffhanger in the middle. Two-parters allow stories plenty of room to breathe, giving them a chance to properly set up the plot, setting, and characters, as well as do those elements justice later on. There's enough time in a two-parter to really explore the story in a way that makes them feel grander and more fulfilling than regular episodes.
With that said, there are a number of single episodes of Doctor Who that would have really benefitted from being two-parters instead. Perhaps they were overstuffed and needed their events to be more spread out, or maybe their ideas merited more time for exploration, or perhaps they were rushed and needed extra time to improve the pacing. Either way, these 45-minute adventures would have been far stronger stories had they been extended into feature-length two-parters instead.
10. Sleep No More
Sleep No More is one of Doctor Who's most unique and polarising episodes. It's filmed entirely in a found-footage style, like one of those cheesy horror movies from last decade. But surprisingly it's actually executed quite well, and the found-footage isn't just a gimmick: it plays a key role in the episode. Essentially, villain-of-the-week Professor Gagan Rassmussen's evil plan is to spread the infection responsible for the Sandmen via glitches in a video feed. That video feed is the episode you're watching, and you are the target for the infection. Basically, Rasmussen fabricated a Doctor Who episode and then used that episode for his nefarious schemes.
It's an ingeniously meta concept and it's genuinely unnerving, but what makes this episode feel somewhat unfinished is that the Doctor and Clara fail to save the day at the end of the story. They don't stop Rasmussen, they don't figure out what was really going on, and they allow lots of victims -- including you, the viewer -- to be turned into Sandmen. This episode ends on a great cliffhanger, but there's no resolution: there really should have been a Part 2 where the Doctor and Clara figured out what was happening and resolved the plot. Maybe then this unique and ambitious episode would've been remembered as a standout story.
9. The Doctor's Daughter
The Doctor's Daughter is one of the slightly weaker episodes in the brilliant Series 4, but it does have a really intriguing character at its core that, given more time, could have been way more memorable. That character is Jenny, the Doctor's biological daughter who was artificially created by a Progenation Machine, which used a sample of the Doctor's DNA to create a brand new lifeform. Amusingly, Jenny's actress is the real-life daughter of Fifth Doctor actor Peter Davison, and went on to marry Tenth Doctor actor David Tennant.
She does a great job in the role and she's instantly charming, but to be honest she doesn't have much of a character. She's friendly, upbeat, inquisitive -- everything you'd expect a descendant of The Doctor to be -- but she doesn't exhibit any interesting flaws or motivations. If this story had been a two-parter, Jenny's character could've been a lot more fleshed out and complex, which would have made her far more impactful. Perhaps that would have been enough for us to see her return to our screens, rather than disappearing at the end of the story and never being seen again. The rest of the episode could've done with more time too: there's some fascinating worldbuilding around the planet Messaline, and it would've been great to see more time dedicated to it.
8. The Ghost Monument
After a promising start with The Woman who Fell to Earth, Jodie Whittaker's second episode as the Doctor unfortunately fell rather flat. It's a frustrating case of an episode that sounds brilliant on paper, but is completely flawed in its execution. There's tons of great ideas here: a hostile planet full of varied threats! An intergalactic space race! A quest to find the TARDIS! But sadly, none of those concepts are properly capitalised on, and there are a number of other ideas that are introduced but go absolutely knowhere, such as the deadly microbes in the planet's ocean. The Ghost Monument also features some of the most useless villains in Doctor Who history: the SniperBots (robot marksmen with worse aim than Stormtroopers) and the Remnants (dirty old rags that can talk) which make this episode feel even more underwhelming.
But with some fixes, it could make for a cracking two-parter. If there was more focus on the space race, with more participants than just Angstrom and Epzo, you could have the Doctor and her companions caught up in the chaos of the race while desperately avoiding the planet's array of threats. Finding out that the end goal of the race is the TARDIS would make for a cracking cliffhanger, and would really amp up the tension. The Ghost Monument has all the ingredients for a rip-roaring adventure, but sadly they used the wrong recipe: they should've cooked up a two-parter instead.
7. Kill The Moon
Ah, Kill the Moon. The infamous episode where it's revealed that Earth's moon is actually an egg. Seriously. The Moon exhibits unusual behaviour throughout the episode, and at the climax we're told that that's because a giant baby dragon trying to hatch out of it. A lot of fans despise this twist because it's unrealistic and nonsensical and, well, it is! But when has that ever been a problem for Doctor Who? The egg reveal is silly and it stretches believability, but that's the fun of it.
But putting the omelette surprise to one side, this is a fantastically tense and atmospheric episode with a classic feel to it, and it really deserved more time to develop all of its ideas, particularly the moral dilemma at the core of the story which pushes Clara to her limits and demonstrates the Doctor's ambiguity. Said moral dilemma culminates in a fiery finale between the Doctor and Clara, and it would've been fantastic to have seen more of this. The giant moon spiders are really creepy too, and putting a little more focus on the horror aspects of this story alongside the moral dilemma would have made a two-part version of this story truly egg-cellent viewing.
6. The Battle Of Ranskoor Av Kolos
As Series 11's finale approached, fans wondered what kind of shock twist or surprise reveal showrunner Chris Chibnall would pull on us. And it was soon revealed that... well, there was no reveal. The Battle of Ranskoor Av Kolos turned out to be one of the most underwhelming finales in the show's history, with a dull plot, baffling character decisions, and a general low-stakes atmosphere that made it all feel like a bit of a waste of time.
However, if expanded into a two-parter, this story could have had much more of an impact. Despite the title, there actually isn't a battle in The Battle of Ranskoor Av Kolos: it takes place off-screen before the events of the episode. But if the story were a two-parter, there would be enough time and scope to actually show the battle, which would nicely raise the stakes of the episode and make it feel more climactic. We'd also have more time to get to know the Ux; an interesting concept that weren't explored to their full potential. We could've seen how people on Earth reacted when Tim Shaw tried to miniaturise the planet, plus Graham's vendetta against Tim Shaw could've been fleshed out. Particularly for a series finale, this episode feels lacklustre and disappointing. But turning it into a two-parter could've fixed that, and brought Jodie Whittaker's first series to a properly exciting finish.
5. The Wedding Of River Song
The Wedding of River Song is an absolute mess of a finale. It's crammed with way too many concepts and characters, making it feel rushed and bloated. After the admittedly very entertaining opening sequence where all of history is happening at once, giving us such delights as Charles Dickens being interviewed on the news and Winston Churchill as the Holy Roman Emperor, the episode sadly devolves into a meandering story that doesn't seem to know what it wants to be.
There are just too many loose ends to wrap up: the Silence, River Song, Madame Kovarian, The Doctor's Death at lake Silencio, Amy and Rory's trauma over the loss of their baby Melody... with all these hugely important plot threads needing to be resolved, it's no surprise the episode buckles under the weight of its own ambition. The sweeping story arc of Series 6 really deserved a two-part finale to properly wrap things up, to give both the viewers and the characters enough time to process and reflect on all the twists and turns.
4. Nightmare In Silver
When fans were told they were getting another episode written by Neil Gaiman for Series 7, they were overjoyed. After all, his previous offering The Doctor's Wife was one of the best episodes of Series 6. Sadly however, Nightmare in Silver was a classic case of overambition, with lots of bold ideas crammed too tightly into a rushed episode that felt hastily written and sadly didn't do a great job of introducing the new Cybermen design.
But if the episode had been expanded into a two-part story, it would have thrived on the extra runtime. The setting of space theme park Hedgewick's World could have been elaborated upon, the new Cybermen could've had a more intimidating introduction and the battle against them been much more ambitious, and the Doctor's unique stint as the Cyber-Planner could have been examined in more depth. The Cybermen rank among the Doctor's most iconic foes, but it can be hard to do them justice on-screen, especially within the confines of a single episode. A two-part Nightmare in Silver could have gone down as one of the best Cyberman stories ever. A fan can dream...
3. Fugitive Of The Judoon
Fugitive of the Judoon was a treat for Whovians, since it saw the long-awaited return of fan-favourite character Captain Jack Harkness, a proper appearance from everyone's favourite space rhino police (the Judoon), and even the surprise reveal of a new, as-yet-unseen incarnation of the Doctor, played with style and swagger by Jo Martin. This episode seemed like it would be a standard mid-series monster-of-the-week runaround, but it soon expanded into a twisty plot-focused episode that contributed to the wider story arc.
While that was a nice surprise, it also sadly robbed us of something we were all looking forward to: a good old-fashioned alien invasion story focused on the Judoon. If the episode was turned into a two-parter, you could have the first part focus mainly on the Judoon and the mystery surrounding Ruth, with the shock reveal that she's the Doctor working as a cliffhanger. Then, part two would focus on the fallout of this reveal and tie things up with the Judoon, while also featuring the return of Captain Jack, hopefully expanded into a meatier role rather than the extended cameo we got. If the writers could have tied Jack's role into the episode's plot and given us more time with the Judoon, this story could have been an all-time great, and turning it into a two-parter would have been the perfect solution.
2. The Power Of Three
The Ponds' penultimate adventure, The Power of Three is an ambitious episode where the premise of Earth being invaded by very small cubes gives us a lovely examination of the Doctor's relationship with his companions, as Amy and Rory are torn between their life on Earth and their life with the Doctor. This allows for some beautifully touching scenes, particularly the Doctor and Amy's conversation on the riverbank.
And the main plot is intriguing as well, right up until the infamously rushed ending. After all the build-up around the mystery of the cubes, it turned out that all they did was give people heart attacks. Was that really the most creative thing the writers could think of? Worse still, the episode is resolved, no joke, by the Doctor simply waving his sonic screwdriver at a screen, putting everything back to normal.
Furthermore, there are loads of questions left unanswered: Who were those cube-mouthed surgeons? And that creepy little girl in the hospital? And why were the Shakri abducting humans onto their ship? It all adds up to make this potentially phenomenal episode leave us with the bitter taste of disappointment. The Power of Three certainly has a sense of scale befitting a two-parter, and if it had been one, there would have been more time to do the main plot justice, as well as giving us more of Kate Stewart and UNIT, and a deeper examination of the Ponds' dilemma.
1. The Time Of The Doctor
The Eleventh Doctor's final story gives Matt Smith a heartfelt send-off with a memorably melancholy regeneration scene, but sadly fails to satisfyingly wrap up Steven Moffat's ambitious story arcs that had followed the Doctor throughout his tenure. It's a lovely episode, but ultimately not a satisfactory resolution to years of build-up, and that's mostly due to the fact that the pacing feels rushed and the script feels overstuffed with ideas. What should have been big reveals come at you so quickly and without fanfare that you're left wondering if you've accidentally pressed fast-forward, and the sense of impact from the plot therefore doesn't quite match up to the epic scale of the visuals.
If this Christmas special had been extended into a two-parter like The End of Time, it would have been perfect. We could have had more time with the Doctor taking care of the people of Trenzalore, more screen-time from the Daleks, Cybermen, Silence, and Weeping Angels, more of everyone's favourite one-off companion Handles, and properly satisfying explanations for the Eleventh Doctor's story arcs to give fans the resolution they deserved. A popular fan rumour says that, had Matt Smith stayed for Series 8, the Siege of Trenzalore would have formed the basis for that entire season. But that might have been a little excessive: a solid two-parter would have been more than enough to wrap up the Eleventh Doctor's reign with a neat little bow-tie.