10 Embarrassingly Shoddy Doctor Who Monsters
Mock if you will, the effects of Doctor Who. They range from the jaw dropping to the sadly embarrassing and I have compiled a best of the worst list you might say. I've put together a top or bottom 10, depending on how you prefer to look at it, of monsters that are remembered for the wrong reasons. You may notice a bias towards the classic series but consider the following, these creations were never intentionally bad. Admittedly on occasion the financial and practical shortcomings are visible but they were always made with conviction. So even though scrolling through the list you might not be able to help smirking, see them in context and it might take your mind off it. So get it out of your system now. Are you ready? Ok, lets go and dont laugh! 10. The Cybermen in 'The Tenth Planet'
If youve never seen the original incarnation of the Cybermen before then this might come as a shock to you. The original Cybermen are not the sleek, stylish figures you might be familiar with. Instead we have a man wearing silver wellingtons, a fetching striped jumpsuit wrapped in Clingfilm, a stocking over his head with a car headlight on top and an accordion strapped to his chest. They even have human hands and in one scene when the Cybermen are attacked, one of the Cybermens head handles pop off. Now the Cybermen were only intended to be one offs, when they proved to be a rather successful menace, they put a bit more money and thought into them to be used in future. One positive you can consider is that these Cybermen were prototypes. The Cybermen are humans who have had various limbs and organs replaced until there isnt all that much left. That journey is clear in the mismatched approach to their costumes. They genuinely look emaciated and their pieces all bolted on. Their hands seem to have worn well though, theyre originals. At least their first appearance left room for development, or rather improvement.
9. The Slitheen in 'World War III'
The Slitheen are by far one of the shoddiest monsters in not just modern Doctor Who. They were written as a race of 8 foot fart gags so things aren't off to a flying start and any credibility they might have had by realizing them as traditional rubber suits with baby faces. Unfortunately a little more action was required than the poor actors inside could achieve. So for this, when the Slitheen had to run, CGI Slitheen were added, which look considerably different. However some scenes of them running or rather shuffling in costume remained, which had the unfortunate effect of making the animatronics filled heads bob up and down on their long necks. That battering probably accounts for why in one scene of the Slitheen talking, one of their mouths doesn't move. Somewhere out there, there is a Slitheen ventriloquism school. Also, they cant seem to use their fingers. Goodness knows how they redressed and zipped up their skin suits. In the scene in World War Three, there is a crowd of them gathered around a telephone waiting for it to ring. If it had, theyd have face a considerable problem picking it up. Thank goodness for speakerphone.
8. The Daleks in 'Destiny of the Daleks'
The Daleks in Destiny of the Daleks are the most sorry looking Dalek props in history. Some of them have been patched up with odds and ends from the last two decades that dont particularly fit together, but nothing is done to hide that fact. For most of the story the main Dalek has a random strip of metal glued to its side. This was actually so that a bomb could be stuck on with magnets at the climax of the story. This glaringly obvious addition is visible on and off from the first episode of the story. The same Dalek also appears to readjust its top section midway through a scene. Another Dalek apparently was borrowed from an exhibition at Madame Tussauds, with a misshapen skirt making it look like it has a huge trailing back end, but whats more, the back end has had to be patched up with some vacuum formed replacement balls, eggs, hemispheres, whatever you want to call them. This is the one Dalek that the director should have avoided shooting from behind. What does he do? So explain to me why we have a low angle shot of this patchwork Dalek showing off its less than perfect derriere. The bit that takes the biscuit though is a scene where masses of Daleks go on a suicide mission. Now because the props run on wheels, the solution was to cut up one surviving Dalek props and make vacuum form moulds for lightweight Daleks,that an operator could lift from the inside and walk along with. So we have the threatening sight of Daleks toddling threateningly over the horizon wearing very trendy sandals.
7. The Garm in 'Terminus'
Now the Garm is a very unfortunate case, looking like zombie Winnie the Pooh. It speaks for itself really. Its odd in that it almost doesnt look as bad when its moving and in context, because of the role it actually plays. He actually turns out to be quite friendly and misunderstood. However, if you look at any still image of it, it looks absolutely dire. What am I saying, it's absolutely dire full stop. Its a great, big, woolly, dog, goat thing that looks a bit like Chewbacca with alopecia, wearing a battledress seemingly made out of the wrappers of spreadable cheese triangles. He plods around looking so sorry for himself. If anything the Garm seems just a little bit too sedate and cuddly, or at least as cuddly as a walking, talking, moth eaten, stuffed bear can be. But at the same time you kind of get the feeling that he my also be planning to steal your soul. If anything the Garm should get the award for most threatening moustache in Doctor Who. Sorry Brigadier.
6. The Mara in 'Kinda'
One of the most famous lackluster effects or as I like to call them effects they felt they had to hide for the DVD release is the Mara snake from Kinda. There are 3 stages in its manifestation and it gets progressively worse as it grows. At first we see a poor Kinda native wrestling with a normal size toy rubber snake, then a larger specially made snake which of course doesn't move at all. Same snake is then shot against green screen and zoomed in on in close up which looks shockingly bad, then finally, a giant piece of ducting painted pink, with a snake head at the end of it sways about as it hangs from the studio ceiling. In fairness, the head is pretty well made but everything else about it is utterly unconvincing. Aside from just looking like a snake, there is nothing snake like about it at all, it is about as animated as if it had hung itself in shame. The lower half of its body just lies in a vaguely coiled heap on the ground. Trying to realize a giant snake on an 80s budget was never going to go well though was it? Though they did a lot better the following year with 'Snakedance'.
5. The Krotons
The Krotons get a lot of unfair criticism I think. I watched the story on DVD recently and I dont think it was bad at all, I thought the Krotons themselves were quite innovative. They can apparently be reduced to a dormant state as crystals suspended in fluid, harvesting mental energy to be revived. Now explain to me how along the line when they take on their full form that firstly they are machines complete with vacuum cleaner attachments and secondly why they have little skirts. The top half of the Krotons, while not seeming true to their origins and looking a bit like a box of noodles actually looks pretty respectable, if vaguely like an attempt to replace the Daleks. However the waist down is beggars belief. No word of a lie, they are wearing little dresses under there. It is actually as if the designer did the top half, downed a bottle of wine and couldn't actually be bothered to do the rest. What is it even meant to be? Some sort of crystalline catheter? This absolutely ruins the Krotons credibility. Thankfully most shots only shoot them from the waist up it is possible to suspend disbelief for a while.
4. Everything in 'The Twin Dilemma'
This came after the Caves of Androzani! THIS! We have Colin Baker in an awful costume, Master Gibbs from Pirates of the Caribbean in an a rainbow karate outfit, a number of actors looking like Harry from Home Alone after being covered in feathers and to top it off, our main enemy, Mestor looks like a hairy pile of excrement. Whoever put this together was either under the age of 10 or was just having a very bad day. The Jacondans are actually passable, even if the actors appear to have been doused in glue and then had their heads shoved in a pillow. I m not entirely sure what they were aiming for with them, silver skin, horns and feathers, but Mestor is unbelievably worse. A big sack with deeply boppers is the best way I can describe it. No attempt is even made to disguise this fact as the whole thing is floodlit and the only movement the actor in there can achieve is waving his hands like the robot from Lost in Space. Why would anyone think this would be a good idea?
3. The Dinosaurs in 'Invasion of the Dinosaurs'
Regardless of how good or bad the Dinosaurs in this story were, they would never look as good as anything produced since then such as Jurassic Park obviously and of course Doctor Who itself. This is another famously poor effect that they couldn't even afford to change for the DVD. The Dinosaurs followed in the wake of the pretty successful Drashigs the previous year but oh my, did the Dinosaurs disappoint. Malcolm Hulke and Terrance Dicks were given full assurance that whatever they wrote, the effects team could deliver, and so they went ahead an wrote what is actually a pretty good script, only for the titular Dinosaurs to be absolutely awful. They may as well have had someone go to a toy shop and bought a load of stuffed dinosaurs. The Tyrannosaurus Rex isnt like any Tyrannosaurus Ive ever seen. The other dinosaurs cant even move, apart from a pterodactyl that appears to be a distant relative of Kermit the Frog that Jon Pertwee has to fight it off with a mop. The Dinosaurs let down what is actually a pretty good story. 'Dinosaurs on a Spaceship' it a glimpse into what could have been. Or you can always read the novelisation.
2. The Taran Wood Beast 'The Androids of Tara'
This one is inexcusable. This is where the money clearly ran out. As soon as this thing bursts out of the woods, the first thing you think is, you must be joking. But nope, theyre dead serious. Fortunately the creature only appears on screen for a couple of minutes. But you see it in its full glory. Consisting of a gorilla suit hurriedly hired from the nearest fancy dress for a tenner, with a paper mache mask that must have been made overnight. The Taran Wood Beast is actually laughable rather than terrifying. I hope it was just a native of Tara having a joke. That would have made much more sense. Thank goodness its sent packing by Count Grendel. Then we can get on with a decent story.
1. Erato in 'The Creature From the Pit'
Dont lie, you know exactly where Im going with this. If you were to X ray the Tythonian you would find several weather balloons, a stick and a man on a Tricycle wheeling it back and forth. But we all know it looks like a gentlemans region or Mr Nosey from the Mr Men books. To make it worse Tom Baker starts talking into its attachment, which then pins him to the wall while carving out a design as a clue for the Doctor. With a design brief of making the Tythonian look like a big green blob. Surely they could have done better than this. It looks like the personification of Syphilis. The most inadvertently hilarious thing is when at the end of the episode the Tythonian actually comes to say goodbye, sticking its proboscis through the front door of a throne room. It genuinely has to be seen to be believed.