10 Failed TV Series Pilots You Need To Watch

Forget Breaking Bad and Game of Thrones, the Justice League of America TV pilot is a must-see.

Pilot season is the time when promising TV shows are given a chance to shine on the airwaves, and not so promising TV shows are sent to the scrap heap. It's a difficult thing to make sure that a TV show maintains good ratings whilst ensuring the creative process isn't hindered. No one goes in wanting to make a bad TV show but, unfortunately, not all TV pilots are as good as Breaking Bad or Game of Thrones and not all good TV pilots can get crazy ratings fresh off the boat like Empire. Sometimes a TV pilot can be good but isn't able to generate the buzz needed to sustain a full TV series, like the 2012 reboot of Mockingbird Lane. Sometimes a TV pilot simply does not click with audiences or studio executives despite the pedigree of the creative team or source material, like the terrible looking Wonder Woman pilot. And sometimes there are those TV pilots that are so fantastically absurd that there is no room in the television landscape for them to fit, like the time the British tried to make a Hitler-centric sitcom set in a Jewish neighbourhood. Yes that last one actually happened. So with that in mind, here are 10 failed TV pilots that were either brilliant but sadly cancelled too early, inferior but interesting adaptations of existing works, or canned for being completely left-field insane.

10. The IT Crowd (US Pilot)

When the US version of the Office became a big hit for NBC, the studio executives decided to try and catch the lightning in a bottle again in 2007 by creating a US adaptation of another UK cult-favorite sitcom, The IT Crowd. They cast a pre-Community Joel McHale as Roy, the conventionally more attractive Jessica St. Claire as Jen, and Rocky Carroll as Denholm. Just to make sure that audiences will love this adaptation, NBC even brought back Richard Ayoade to reprise the socially-awkward but funny Moss for this new version of the show. What could possibly go wrong? Well first, it's a little bit hard to believe that the tall, muscular, and handsome Joel McHale could realistically pull off being in IT support. Secondly, the US pilot used a script that was nearly identical to the original UK pilot, resulting in nothing more than a poor American imitation. People may point out that NBC's The Office also used the original UK pilot script, but people also forget that the first season of the Office was very nearly cancelled due to poor reviews and ratings until the writers decided to go their own way. Fortunately, this IT Crowd adaptation didn't progress beyond the pilot due to the 2007-2008 Writer's strike. Unfortunately, NBC have recently decided to take another crack at another IT Crowd pilot. http://dai.ly/xmjpk4

9. Justice League Of America

With the upcoming Batman vs Superman film in 2016 serving to start connecting the dots of a DC cinematic universe, people are already waiting eagerly for the first live-action debut of the Justice League. However, most people don't realise that the Justice League have already had their live-action debut back in 1997. Generally failed TV pilots fall into 2 categories: pilots that were great and interesting but unfortunately not picked up, and pilots that were so terrible that it was a blessing that the pilot was dropped. Unfortunately, the 1997 Justice League of America pilot by CBS falls into the category of 'so bad it's interesting'. There were numerous reasons why the Justice League pilot failed. The director and producers had no understanding of comic books or how to translate comic books to screen; Superman, Batman, and Wonder Woman were dropped in favor for the wrong Green Lantern, Ice, Atom, Fire, and The Flash; what superheroes they did have acted nothing like their comic-book counterparts; the plot had more holes than a block of Swiss cheese; and the costumes and special effects were laughably bad. Despite all the poor reception to the film, in which critics have described it as 'Friends with superpowers', that description alone is enough to warrant at least one view out of morbid curiosity if nothing else. http://dai.ly/x2fx183

8. Korgoth Of Barbaria

Adult Swim are known for producing a number of original animated TV series that are just 'out there' in terms of quirkiness and sheer weird hilarity. Korgoth of Barbaria is definitely up there in terms of encompassing Adult Swim's signature offbeat humor wrapped in an original and intriguing premise. Set in a comically anachronistic post-apocalyptic future where magic, sorcery, and medieval technology reign supreme, Korgoth of Barbaria is an affectionate parody of Conan the Barbarian and the whole sword and sorcery genre. The pilot sees Korgoth, a savage Conan-esque barbarian who looks like he picked a fight with a gang of ugly sticks and lost pretty badly, being extorted into stealing some McGuffin from a wizard whose powers are brought to life by chewing gum. Korgoth's adventure takes him through a world awash with excessive animated bloodshed, crude but funny jokes, excessive alcohol consumption, and just a touch of sex. Damn, that description alone makes Korgoth of Barbaria sound like the greatest thing ever. Unfortunately, despite managing to build up a dedicated fanbase and the pilot being very well received both critically and commercially upon airing, Korgoth of Barbaria was quietly dropped due to 'high production costs'. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yoxMiZxN-F0

7. Live-Action Aquaman Pilot

Before the existence of Arrow, The Flash, and the CW network, there was Smallville and the WB network. Seeing how successful Smallville was and how a specific Smallville episode which focused on an Aquaman-type character was well-received, the WB network decided to jump onboard the Aquaman TV show bandwagon. With a large budget (for a TV production) of $7 million, the pilot was shot in 2006. The show depicts Arthur Curry, a dive shop owner by day but a swimmer with superhuman speed, unlimited lung capacity, and super strength by, well, whenever he feels like showing off. A number of things made the Aquaman pilot stand out. Arthur was characterized as having absolutely no problem with flaunting his powers for his own personal gain, Atlantis and its inhabitants were to make regular appearances, the special effects were considered great (at the time), and crossovers with Smallville were in the works. Despite much promise and positive reception to the pilot, Aquaman hit a few unfortunate stumbling blocks. Upon completion of the pilot, the WB network merged with UPN, forming the CW network we know today. The new CW network proceeded to not order the Aquaman TV series, but the producers were passionate enough about the pilot to release it on iTunes for fans. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mdPNAQwnQh0

6. Zombieland TV Pilot

Before pop culture became over-saturated with zombies and soap operas featuring zombies somehow became amongst television's most watched programs, Zombieland was a quirky and enjoyable little romp that brought a new and fresh twist on the whole zombie thing. But what most people don't know is that the Zombieland concept went through quite a gestation period before and after the film was released. Zombieland was initially conceived as a TV pilot way back in 2005 but those plans did not come to fruition and the pilot was retooled into the movie everyone knows and loves. After becoming a surprising little sleeper hit in 2009, the obligatory plans for a sequel and franchise were underway. Here is where everything (unfortunately) comes around full circle. After years of trying and failing to get Zombieland 2 made, Amazon said 'screw it' and produced their own Zombieland TV pilot. A new version of Zombieland is all good and well, except that the producers decided to cast cheap little-known actors as the exact same characters as the movie. Rather than make the TV show its own thing, the producers basically ignored most of the movie's logic and character development, and gambled on the fans to watch the pilot anyway. Thankfully this backfired and the world was saved from what could've been another shoddy zombie TV show. http://dai.ly/xz6hxs

5. Lookwell

When Lookwell was pitched to NBC in 1991, it was one of those ideas that looked awesome on paper but terrible in execution. It was conceived and written by Robert Smigel (known for his SNL work) and Conan O'Brien (known for writing The Simpsons at the time) thus already giving the pilot a good comedy pedigree. The storyline involved a washed-up TV action hero who believes he can actually solve crime and the original Batman himself, Adam West, was cast in the titular role of Lookwell. What could possibly go wrong? As it turns out, audiences weren't particularly taken with Lookwell. Going against the multi-camera sitcom norm at the time, Lookwell was produced as a single-camera comedy with no laugh track. The pilot was a comedy but looked like a cop show and consisted of layer upon layer of meta jokes. Whilst this type of TV show would fit into today's TV landscape just fine, Lookwell did not fit in anywhere in 1991. This was reflected in the ratings as Lookwell finished last in its timeslot, despite positive critical reception, leading to the pilot being dropped. Whilst Lookwell was a sad failure in 1991, a cult following developed over time and the pilot is considered an underground gem for TV fanatics. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dBQ3HbB0c8Y

4. LA Confidential (2003 Pilot)

TV adaptations of hit movies seem to be the in-thing nowadays, despite being a bit hit (see Hannibal, Bates Motel, and Fargo) or miss (see the Zombieland TV pilot). Unfortunately, the 2003 LA Confidential pilot was firmly in miss category. The LA Confidential pilot was originally conceived as a 13 episode series for HBO and starred a pre-24 Keifer Sutherland and Melissa George as a second-rate Kevin Spacey and Kim Basinger respectively. A smattering of familiar faces that pop up on seemingly every TV show every now and again filled out all the other roles. Now to its credit, the pilot pays homage to the original novel and the film's noir tone but tries to be its own independent thing. Unfortunately, in trying to avoid copying the source material too much, the pilot alters the story in such a way that all the good stuff in the film and novel are cut out and what is leftover is just awful. The pilot was shot in 1999 but HBO lost interest and FOX took over. The pilot then sat on the shelf before finally being aired to little fanfare in 2003. By that stage, Sutherland had landed 24 and FOX had decided that ordering a TV series set in the 50's based on a terrible 4 year old pilot is probably not the best decision to make. http://dai.ly/xstbdb

3. Fargo (1997 Pilot)

The Coen Brother's 1996 film is considered a comedy-crime classic nowadays, so much so that a TV adaptation was produced in 2014 to some skepticism. Thankfully, FX's adaptation of Fargo was brilliant, had its own story independent of the movie, and was more akin to Breaking Bad squeezed into 10 episodes and minus the blue meth. But what most TV viewers may not know is that an earlier attempt at a Fargo TV adaptation happened in 1997. Rather than create its own independent story with recurring themes and motifs from the film, like the current Fargo TV series, the 1997 Fargo pilot was a sort-of-sequel to the film with the same cast of characters. The role of Marge Gunderson was recast and given to a pre-Sopranos Edie Falco. As for how the proposed TV series was going to unfold, the producers were going for a CSI case-of-the-week type structure rather than the serialised nature of the 2014 Fargo adaptation. However, after the pilot was shot in 1997, it was quietly dropped with no known reason before the pilot finally aired in 2003 as a TV movie special. It would've been interesting to see where this version of Fargo could've went, but then again if it had gone ahead, the Sopranos would've lost out on Edie Falco's memorable turn as Carmela Soprano. https://vimeo.com/11674952

2. The Orson Welles Show

During his time on Earth, Orson Welles was known for a lot of things. Citizen Kane, prolific filmmaker, a creative auteur, radio personality, and theatre actor are just some of the monikers he's been graced with. But one thing people didn't know was that Orson Welles once dipped his toes into the talk show pool. Filmed in front of a live audience in 1978 and 1979, the Orson Welles-directed talk show pilot was a weird and unique take on how a variety or talk show could look like. There was a very meta and Orson Welles-esque opening monologue before Burt Reynolds is introduced as the guest. Instead of a standard light-hearted interview from Welles, Reynolds was subjected to a scripted Q & A from the audience, resulting in something more akin to an awkward episode of Inside the Actors Studio. The rest of the pilot was filled with pre-taped appearances from the Muppets (for some reason), an actual interview with Jim Henson and Frank Oz, and a series of magic tricks from a magician (again for some odd reason), all accentuated by Welles' eccentric baritone drawl. Whilst the pilot was never officially broadcast or released, this little piece TV oddity is available on Youtube thanks to some anonymous person with deep connections. Understandably, Welles later said that the reason he only did the talk show was for money. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WlpAE2Sf3QU

1. Heat Vision And Jack

Back before Dan Harmon made Community, before Jack Black was in High Fidelity, before Ben Stiller made Meet the Parents, and before Owen Wilson became, well, Owen Wilson, all four had collaborated on an acid-trip of a TV pilot called Heat Vision and Jack. Channelling an excessive amount of marijuana and affectionately riffing on Knight Rider, the Six Million Dollar Man, and Buck Rogers in the 25th Century, the pilot involves Jack Black playing Jack, an astronaut who was exposed to too much solar energy thus granting him super-intelligence. Owen Wilson voiced Jack's talking motorcycle, which is really Jack's roommate who was hit with some weird ray and was subsequently merged into a motorbike. Together, Jack and his talking motorbike sidekick must stop Ron Silver (the actual actor) because he's the bad guy who has an acting passion for some reason. Yeah, all this absurdity was actually put to film and directed by none other than Ben Stiller. Despite the hefty comedy pedigree of its cast and crew, FOX weren't sold on the pilot nor its awesome concept and the pilot was sadly canned. Out of all the failed TV pilots on this list, Heat Vison and Jack had the potential to become something that was mind-boggling and awesome, so it is shame that only 1 episode worth of Heat Vision and Jack was made. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WHvjcsELcjA

In this post: 
Jack-Black
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

My life story is nothing special. I haven't cured ebola, I'm nowhere near stopping terrorism, and I'm still working on that climate change problem. Instead, all I've done so far is put a few hundred words together in an attempt to make people laugh. You can follow me at @Fry_ying_pan but don't be offended if I don't tweet back. It's usually because I've spent too long trying to think up a witty response that the reply window has closed.