10 Most Forgettable Leading Men On TV

Andy Bernard The Office As Abed Nadir famously said to Community's leading man, Jeff Winger:
"TV makes sense. it has logic, structure, rules, and likable leading men. In life we have this. We have you."
Every show needs a lead, whether they be a man or a woman. They don't have to be likable, but they do have to make an impression on us that keeps the show grounded and flowing smoothly. Unfortunately, plenty of shows have suffered from having leading men who bring almost nothing to the table. In some cases, it's not entirely their fault and may just be the result of bad writing and/or stellar secondary characters. Still, many shows on this list managed to maintain great ratings and storytelling, despite their lack of compelling, leading men. Let's start with...

10. Stefan Salvatore (The Vampire Diaries)

The Vampire Diaries Stefan Salvatore At first, this morally upright vampire was a solid leading man for the popular CW series. He was brooding, mysterious and great eye candy for this type of show. As his character started to unravel, however, everything interesting about this character began to fade away. All of the mystery and complex motivations we thought he had were quickly overshadowed by his more interesting brother, Damon. I don't blame the writers or Paul Wesley much for Stefan's failure to be a compelling lead (especially by season 4). They clearly didn't count on Ian Somerhalder's Damon becoming the reason to watch this show.

9. Eric Forman (That '70s Show)

George Foreman You can argue that Forman proved himself to be a necessary component when the series flatlined in season 8 after Topher Grace departed, but that still doesn't change how forgettable his character was compared to the rest of the cast. This is another case of how secondary characters can steal the show, and That 70s Show had a lot of great characters. Most of the laughs came from Fez and Kelso, the wit came from Hyde and we had both of these coming from Jackie and Donna. Even Forman's parents were more interesting than him. This is mostly because the character relied too heavily on the same characters for every episode. Most of his stories revolved around his relationship with Donna and his parents, and he rarely had significant moments with anyone else, besides Hyde early on. He was just a character that reacted to big moments, but he was never a character you remembered for doing anything. I have little doubt that his basement is the only reason these people bothered to hang out with him at all.

8. Andy Bernard (The Office)

Andy Bernard The Office The first red flag for Ed Helms' portrayal of a middle-class paper salesman was that they had to completely shift the character's personality after one season. Of course, that isn't a death sentence for everyone, since actors and writers naturally evolve characters over time. Still, that's not really the case with Andy. He went from being "the other Dwight," which was fine, to being "the less interesting Michael." When they replaced Michael with Andy as Regional Manager, things just got worse as this character began to appear even more confusing and difficult to root for. He was ultimately a forgettable presence because the writers had to rely on his romantic relationship with Erin (which was tired by this point) in order to keep viewers interested. I will grant that Andy became far more fun to watch when he left the branch as the series ended. They at least managed to give Andy a memorable ending that was still true to the character.

7. Mark Brendanawicz (Parks And Recreation)

Mark Parks Remember when Parks and Recreation had a leading man who wasn't Adam Scott or Rob Lowe? It's shocking, I know, but in the early days of this now veteran comedy, the "straight-man" was a city-planner who was allegedly a womanizer, despite his lack of charm or personality. I had to rewatch the first two seasons just to refresh my memory of Mark's character and what he was doing in the Parks and Recreation Department of good old Pawnee. It turns out he did have a story that had to do with his jaded outlook on a boring career he thought he would love in college. Really? City planning isn't exciting? Coupled with his odd romance with Leslie Knope and so-boring-they-broke-up-because-it-was-boring relationship with Anne Perkins, Mark was replaced with Ben and Chris in Season 3. Combined with the presence of Ron Swanson, Andy Dwyer, Tom Haverford and (of course) Jerry, Parks and Recreation easily found its groove without Mark.

6. Peter Petrelli (Heroes)

heroes easo It saddens me to put the once promising Milo Ventimiglia as Peter on this list. During the first season, Peter's potential as the leader of this group of unlikely heroes was in full swing. He began to collect incredible powers, displayed true heroism through his empathy (the source of his ability) and gave the series' unstoppable villain, Sylar, a worthy adversary. But then the world fell in love with Zachary Quinto as Sylar. He was a villain that we wanted to become a hero, and he was even teased as such. His incredible abilities and complicated motivations made us root for him without even feeling bad about it. Unfortunately for Milo, this put Peter in the backseat, and his character suffered. By later seasons, Peter was so stripped of his once enormous power that it hurt to watch him flail onscreen. It was quickly obvious that the meat of the character was pretty hollow if you took away his ability to actually be a force of change in the Heroes world. Looking back, it's almost impossible to find instances when he was a real asset after Season 1 (though it happened on occasion).

5. Will Schuester (Glee)

gleeWill It's odd to remember that Glee's Will Schuester used to be a central character to the show, which has drastically changed since season 2. Many of the A plot stories surrounded Will's relationship with his crazy wife (later ex-wife) and his pining after Jayma Mays, which no one can blame him for. Eventually, the writers stopped coming up with ways to make his stories interesting. With the exception of a few minor plots in Season 3 and a terrible love triangle with Finn in Season 4 (that he was mostly absent for), Will has become a secondary character with fewer lines than Sue Sylvester (probably). I'm not saying this was for the worst. Will's backing away from the spotlight was welcome, mostly because his character's odd rants and bizarrely close relationship with his students (that the show loves to poke fun at) made him a real stick in the mud. Many, like me, were pleased to see Finn, Kurt and Blaine step up as the show's central leading men.

4. Father Jack Landry (V)

V Jack Landry V had a lot of problems, especially when it came to leading men. We had Ryan, who was secretly a V who had been living on Earth for years, but his motivations were typically mixed with his own plot involving his pregnant (uh oh!) wife. So, we had Jack Landry, a priest who...did things...sometimes. It's been a few years since I've watched the show, of which I watched every episode, and I can't remember a single thing Jack Landry did or said. Most of his moments that should have left an impression were overshadowed by Elizabeth Mitchell, who was the real leading man in this case. What's sad about that is how by the second season, even Mitchell was pretty much bored with where the show was going. Sure, Kyle Hobbs came onto the scene a few episodes into the first season and was a welcome addition to the Fifth Column team, and we had some decent cast add-ons during the series' brief run. But no one can deny that V suffered from some of the dullest leading men on primetime television.

3. Everyone (Dads)

Dads There's really not much to say here. The four leads on Dads all fail to deliver either comedy or fun to an outright offensive script. It's sad because Seth Green has proven to be a strong asset for laughs through both Family Guy and Robot Chicken. For whatever reason, however, he brings nothing noteworthy to his role as Eli in this sitcom. Warner, played by Giovanni Ribisi, doesn't fare much better, and I actually preferred his dry character in Public Enemies over this. Worse, I was sad to see the writers make such poor use out of the older "dads," Martin Mull and Peter Reigert (I'm having Richie Rich flashbacks of tears). Instead of setting these characters up as layered individuals with interesting backstories and (dare I say it) heart, Dads positions great actors as caricatures, and you can tell that no one is having fun onscreen. After watching just a few episodes, it was difficult to even recall some of the major plot elements because I haven't touched on how poorly written their spouses are...

2. Jim Shannon (Terra Nova)

Jim Shannon Terra Nova When Terra Nova was first being marketed to us, no one really cared about who was in it. We just wanted dinosaurs and that guy from Avatar to stab things with knives and become a villain. Unfortunately, dinosaurs were a rarity, so we were left with nothing but the Shannon family to carry the show. We received Jim Shannon, a guy who should have been interesting, but just wasn't (much like the show itself). It was inexplicable how a man who has just been reunited with his family after being in prison for years shows almost no emotion, even with dinosaurs chasing him. Sure, he gave the heavy moments lip service, but we were so bored by every other character on this show, there's nothing he could have really done to salvage the role. I'll cut the Shannon family some slack, however, because they had to work off of a very dull script. The problem with setting your show in a fantastical setting is everything else taking place in that setting looks very plain in comparison. As a result, a decent actor who could have grown into a compelling lead fell flat.

10. Ferris Bueller (Ferris Bueller)

Ferris Bueller Did you know that a TV show about Ferris Bueller came out in the 90's? No? Well, that's probably because it is considered one of the worst TV shows of all time, abandoning a storyline about Ferris Bueller from the film and focusing on the "real" Ferris the movie is based on. Confused? One of the most pivotal scenes shows Ferris using a chainsaw to destroy a cardboard cutout of Matthew Broderick from the movie. Though Broderick's Ferris was a popular, outgoing guy, the TV version was nerdy and completely unlikable. A bright spot is that the show had Jennifer Aniston, yes, THE Jennifer Aniston. The problem? She played Ferris' sister, which means all of the sexual tension Aniston normally brings to a role woudn't be capitalized on until Friends debuted just a few years later. Another factor that plagued the show was its timeslot. Ferris had to compete against Will Smith's Fresh Prince, which would make anyone quickly realize the difference in quality between leading men. As a result, viewers abandoned the series and did their best to forget it ever happened.

Contributor
Contributor

Jon is the author of the Pixar Theory, the narrative that combines all of the Pixar movies in one timeline. You can read more about his random nonsense on jonnegroni.com