10 Game Of Thrones Characters We Never Saw Die
Are they still alive? Did they say to the many-faced god: "Not today"?
It's one of the bloodiest shows on TV. Virtually every episode comes with a death scene or two, many of them shocking, unexpected, and often quite graphic. All of which of course means that, with the final season of Game Of Thrones just days away, there is inevitably a whole heap of speculation about who will still be alive come the 19 May finale. But what if some of those that will turn out to live in the final season are characters that we've been assuming are already dead?
By now fans are savvy enough to know that if the series - which glories in shockingly violent on-screen deaths like the iconic Red Wedding - doesn't actually show us the moment of a character's death, then perhaps they never really died at all.
Arya, for example, left the Hound to die, battered and bleeding after his fight with Brienne, on a cliff at the end of Season 4. By midway through Season 6, though, there he was alive and well and building a church with Ian McShane. Stark uncle Benjen, the First Ranger of the Night's Watch in early episodes, had an even longer gap between being presumed dead in the first season and riding to the rescue of Bran and Meera beyond the wall in the sixth.
But who else might pull a Benjen and surprise us all by showing up alive and well in the final season?
10. Xaro Xhoan Daxos
Last Seen:
In Season 2, Episode 10, being left to die, locked inside his own impenetrable (and empty) treasure vault by Daenerys, who has taken the only key.
Could He Still Be Alive?
The self-proclaimed King of Qarth was all about plotting and deception. The whole point of the vault and what it represents was about show rather than substance: a grand and supposedly unbreakable door which served to convince people that what was stored behind it must be the untold wealth that Xaro was rumoured to possess. Instead, of course, the vault was empty.
Which does beg the question of what else he was lying about. The idea that he would have died from being locked in an impenetrable vault does rather rely on the notion that he was telling the truth about breaking into the vault being impossible and the only key being the one in Daenerys's possession. Given his track record with the truth, though, that may not be the case. He could easily have secreted a key elsewhere or built in an escape route as part of his various schemes.
Daenerys' escape from the warlocks of the House of the Undying leaves them still pursuing her in the following season, which means that Xaro's allies still exist and both retain a grudge against the Mother of Dragons. If Daenerys's plot was still Essos-based this would mean that Xaro's return was definitely a possibility. As it is, though, he's just too far on the other side of the world still to be relevant to the story.
9. Orell
Last Seen:
In Season 3, Episode 9 (the episode better known for containing the Red Wedding), being stabbed through the chest by Jon Snow. In his dying moments, Orell used his warging powers to transfer his mind into an eagle and attack Jon again.
Could He Still Be Alive?
In a manner of speaking, yes. His body was obviously killed on screen, but warging allowed his mind to escape. Orell could still be living quite happily in the North as an eagle, albeit that's a life which can't be easy in and of itself as a long winter arrives.
In practical terms, Orell's possible survival and continuing status as an actual character kind of depends on how warging works. We know from conversations taking place between Bran and Jojen Reed that spending too much time warged into the mind of an animal results in your human mind slipping away and you becoming completely bestial. The likelihood, then, is that this is just what has happened to the Orell-eagle, and it is now indistinguishable from any other eagle.
Unless, that is, Orell could warg from the eagle's mind into another human body and take possession of that. We've seen Bran do something similar with Hodor, although this is used as a sign of quite how powerful Bran is rather than a normal warging power. So, unless Orell is miraculously as magically gifted as Bran, he's probably a goner.
8. Tyene Sand
Last Seen:
In Season 7, Episode 3, chained in a dungeon in King's Landing. Tyene is kissed by Cersei with the same poison that Ellaria, her mother, used to kill Cersei's daughter, and left to die while Ellaria watches helplessly on.
Could They Still Be Alive?
This episode (which also ended the Tyrell plot and family line by poisoning Queen of Thorns Olenna at Highgarden) seems designed in part to wrap up the storylines of Westerosi houses who won't have a role to play in the battles of the final season. In that sense, then, tying up the loose ends of the Dornish thread, always the show's least popular plotline, seems a pretty conclusive end for Tyene, whose sisters were already killed by this point.
Nevertheless, it really feels like Cersei is failing Villainy 101 by pulling the classic move of delivering a lengthy monologue about how she's going to kill someone slowly and elaborately and then just shutting them away behind closed doors and hoping the rest of it goes without a hitch while she's not looking.
She even admits that she has no idea how long the knock-off toxin recreated by Qyburn will take to work, which doesn't inspire confidence in its effectiveness against someone who has a developed knowledge of poisons and maybe even some level of immunity. Even so, there's only the slimmest chance of Tyene still living. Her mother, on the other hand...
7. Ellaria Sand
Last Seen:
In exactly the same scene as the last entry, chained up on the other side of the dungeon, watching her daughter be poisoned.
Could She Still Be Alive?
Technically, she probably still is. Cersei's plan for Ellaria was a particularly long and drawn-out slow revenge. While Tyene was poisoned, Ellaria was just left there in the dungeon, forced to watch her daughter die and be helpless to prevent it. Cersei even promised to have Ellaria force fed to make her live long enough to see her daughter's corpse rot away. That could take months or years. So, yeah, Tyene probably is dead by now, but her mother not so much.
What that means is that, should Cersei lose in the coming war and an army of living people seize control of King's Landing at any point, Ellaria's erstwhile allies may well find her still alive in her cell, glaring angrily at her dead daughter's remains and plotting what she might do should somebody ever let her out.
The whole thrust of the Oberyn/Ellaria/Dorne storyline has been a story of how vengeance begets vengeance and ends in a brutal, violent end for everyone. What if there's still one more twist to come in that arc between the two surviving vengeance-hungry grieving mothers?
6. Brynden Tully
Last Seen:
In Season 6, Episode 8, refusing to flee the besieged Riverrun to travel north with Brienne and help his niece and nephew recapture Winterfell and instead choosing to fight the Lannister army, self-deprecatingly suggesting that he'll "probably make a fool of myself". Cutting to after the battle, an anonymous Lannister soldier tells Jaime that Brynden has been found dead.
Could He Still Be Alive?
The recapture of Riverrun by the Lannister and Frey armies feels partly like a plot to tie up why the Tullys and the Blackfish are unable to help with the fighting in the North, something to ensure that the odds are stacked heavily against Jon during the Battle of the Bastards.
Now that the fight in the North has switched to one between the living and the dead, the living side are always going to have the odds stacked against them, though, and could use all of the help that they can get, or at least a few more characters to play cannon fodder when the deaths start stacking up in the final season.
The show made a point of reminding audiences that the Blackfish had been present at its greatest bloodbath, the Red Wedding, and managed to make it out intact. Could this be prompting us to imagine that he might have done the same here? We never see his body and it's only through second- and third-hand observation that we know he's dead.
In the books, meanwhile, Jaime captures the castle and the Blackfish escapes by swimming under a portcullis and into the river, so there's every possibility that this happened here too.
5. Lady
Last Seen:
All the way back in Season 1, Episode 2. Sentenced to execution in place of Arya's wolf Nymeria, Lady is taken away to be killed by Ned Stark himself, rather than the king's executioner. We see Ned raise his sword and bring it down on something that whimpers off-screen.
Could She Still Be Alive?
It feels like the idea of the fate of the direwolves as tied to the fate of the Stark family does kind of require some of both to make it to the final episodes. Only Jon's albino runt of the litter Ghost has been a regular player on the whole run of the show, though.
Arya's Nymeria, however, disappeared in the same episode as Lady before finally returning as a giant wolf at the head of her own pack in the last season. So, Game of Thrones is perfectly capable of bringing something back after all that time.
With the other direwolves, like Robb's Grey Wind and Rickon's Shaggydog, the show did not stint on its usual graphic gore (showing off both their severed heads), and the wolves' deaths were closely tied to that of their masters. So, the death of Sansa's Lady feels quite different.
Could the decision to show Ned taking on the duty himself and then not actually depict the beheading suggest that the Warden of the North spared his daughter's faithful companion and executed a substitute? Probably not, but the return of Nymeria does suggest that there's more to come from the direwolf-Stark connection.
4. Stannis Baratheon
Last Seen:
In Season 5, Episode 10, leaning against a tree with a bleeding leg after losing the Battle of Winterfell, telling Brienne to "do her duty" after she passed a sentence of death on him for his blood magic murder of his own brother.
Could He Still Be Alive?
The answer to that largely rests on the honourable Brienne's interpretation of "doing her duty". We saw her accuse Stannis of crimes that he most definitely did, and him confess to them. We saw her pass her own death sentence on him and raise her sword to strike the fatal blow and saw Stannis remind her of her duty.
But was appointing herself judge, jury and executioner actually the dutiful thing for Brienne to do? Might we never have seen the death blow because Brienne thought better of it? Might she perhaps have realised that her place was never to take revenge for Renly but to fulfill her promise to Catelyn to protect her still living daughters? The framing of this episode's story and direction certainly calls her out for putting personal vengeance first and thus missing Sansa's signal for help. Maybe Brienne came to realise this before striking Stannis down.
On the other hand, the original script for these scenes did spell out pretty clearly that Stannis dies in this scene. So, even if we didn't actually see it happen, there's a pretty strong chance that the writers intend this to be his death scene.
3. The Waif
Last Seen:
In Season 6, Episode 8, chasing down Arya before being lured into a darkened room by the once-blind sword-wielding Stark girl. In the next scene her bloody face has been removed and placed in the Hall of Faces of the House of Black and White.
Could She Still Be Alive?
Given that she's a nameless assassin with an ability to change her face, her former face being on show in the House of Black and White isn't really sufficient evidence that The Waif is definitely dead. We really have no way of knowing whether Faye Marsay's face was her original self anyway (and, therefore, its removal being any different from any of her other face changes).
In practical terms, the final confrontation between the Waif, in complete health and fitness and with a lust for murder, and Arya, badly injured, is by no means a foregone conclusion just because Arya blew a candle out. Even with the advantage of having previously learnt to fight blind, there's no guarantee that Arya would have won that.
Which leads us to the alternative theory that she didn't, that Arya never left that darkened room alive, that the girl now going around wearing Arya's face in Westeros (most of the time, anyway) and acting as an expert killer is actually the Waif instead, on her own mission from the Faceless Men to sway the tide of the war. After all, the Faceless Men suddenly seem very blasé about Arya learning all their secrets, refusing to become no-one and then returning to wreak havoc in Westeros, having only just tried to have her killed for less.
It's unlikely, but it certainly would be a shocking last act twist.
2. Syrio Forel
Last Seen:
In Season 1, Episode 8, fighting off Lannister guards with just a wooden sword. As King's Guard Meryn Trant slices through Syrio's wooden sword, Syrio tells Arya to flee, leaving her and the audience to assume the ending of the fight.
Could He Still Be Alive?
Many fans have long suspected as much. Syrio was the first time that Game Of Thrones did the thing of leaving a character to a presumable death and then never following up on it, and that has resulted in many people speculating that there could have been a different outcome. After all, for all that he's armed with just a broken wooden sword, Syrio (former first sword to the Sea Lord of Braavos) is established as an expert fighter and Meryn later referred to as a pretty useless one, so Syrio's defeat and death doesn't seem a certainty.
And then there's that Braavosi connection. Given Syrio's home in the same city as the Faceless Men, coupled with his insistence that "there is only one god and his name is Death", many have speculated a connection between the two. Indeed, given that Jaqen H'gar shows up immediately after Syrio's "death" and takes a great shine to Arya personally, it's often thought that they could turn out to be the same person.
Maisie Williams herself has been known to voice her support for this theory, so at least somebody within the Game Of Thrones team is on board with it. Could we be yet to discover that Syrio told the many-faced god "not today" one more time?
1. Rhaegar Targaryen
Last Seen:
By all accounts dead before the start of the series, Rhaegar has only actually appeared on screen once, in one of Bran's visions in the last episode to air: Season 7, Episode 7. However, his death - his chest and ruby-studded breastplate caved in by Robert Baratheon's warhammer at the Battle of the Trident - has been mentioned frequently by other characters.
Could He Still Be Alive?
Of all the characters whose death is reported rather than depicted, Rhaegar's is the one with the most witnesses. It seems fairly set in stone that this, one of the most important events of the Game Of Thrones backstory, happened just as is commonly described. So, how could the Mad King's eldest son and heir (Daenerys's brother and Jon's father) still be alive?
A lot of attention is placed on Rhaegar's armour in descriptions of the battle. Could that be because someone else was really the person wearing it? (It's happened before with Loras charging into battle in Renly's armour). Or maybe all those rubies had perception-shifting powers. We know that Melisandre's ruby necklace makes her look decades younger, after all. Could they also help to cheat death?
There is even a fan theory that Rhaegar escaped to become a Faceless Man and that in fact it is he, not Syrio, who is behind Jaqen H'gar's face.
Honestly, that last idea feels a bit of a stretch. But Rhaegar actor Wilf Scolding has been seen on set for the final season, so even assuming that Rhaegar is dead there are definitely more revelations surrounding him to come in one way or another.