10 Grimmest TV Storylines Ever
Just how far is too far?
Life is pain sometimes and don’t TV writers know it. From the heartbreaking to the just plain offensive, some plot lines can ramp things up to the extreme and then some.
Tensions soar as we the viewer watch the kinds of struggles we spend our whole lives trying to avoid unfold on the small screen. From deaths to wounds to curses and rituals, there’s all manner of darkness out there in the land of TV.
Often bleak, often depressing, some of these storylines pushed shows to new creative heights where others had viewers hastily changing the channel for some relief.
10. The Infection Of Fred Burkle - Angel
Fred Burkle was a fan favourite with her life in full swing by season 5. Her and Wesley had finally made good on their oft teased romance and her work at Wolfram & Hart was going well. All it took was inhaling some sarcophagus dust for that to all come tumbling down.
Suddenly under attack from an ancient demonic force, we have to watch the amiable Fred be consumed by the parasite within as the main cast unite to try and save her.
At first it appears Angel and Spike have done just that, locating the cure for her in England only to discover it would cause thousands to die instead. Caught between a rock and a hard place, they choose to let Fred succumb to her long, drawn out, agonising death.
And to add some injury to injury, we’re informed that the damage done to her will also prevent her soul from an afterlife or a resurrection. Talk about having a hard run of things.
“Why can’t I stay?” remains some of the saddest last words in TV history and one the of most devastating and memorable moments the Buffy spin-off put out.
9. The Death Of Jane Margolis - Breaking Bad
Don’t do drugs kids, they might ruin your drug dealing.
For Walter White, watching partner in crime Jesse Pinkman slip into heroin addiction with his girlfriend, Jane is a step to far. It nearly ruins their business and it’s clear Jane has to go, at least if you asked old Heisenberg about it.
Staging an incredibly shabby intervention, Walter tries to awaken Jesse from his opioid induced stupor and instead knocks Jane onto her back. From here we get the horrifying sight of her violently choking to death on her own vomit. At no point does our favourite meth baron intervene, her death is a promising development for hsi work after all.
One of the bleaker moments in the series, it sets up what had been foreshadowed all season: catastrophe.
Jane’s grief stricken father causes 2 planes to crash head on, resulting in the deaths of hundreds.
Don’t do drugs kids, it might ruin someone else’s holiday plans.
One of the biggest and darkest far reaching consequences of Walter’s nefarious adventures, Jane’s death winds up permanently scarring Jesse and the city they live in as a whole.
8. The Mutilation Of Theon Greyjoy - Game Of Thrones
After a brief and ludicrous stint as the self appointed Prince of Winterfell, Theon Greyjoy is betrayed by his own men and winds up a prisoner in the Dreadfort, the last place in Westeros one would ever want to be.
The squeamish viewers might want to leave the room as Theon is hobbled, beaten, manipulated, has a fingernail dug out, starved, dehydrated, has appendages flayed and is finally castrated and for what you ask?
Nothing. Absolutely nothing beyond the fact his captor Ramsay Bolton finds it utterly hilarious. Physically and mentally shattered, Theon lives as Reek, Ramsay’s trusty servant and punching bag for years. He stands by as Ramsay savagely rapes Sansa Stark, refuses salvation from his sister due to paranoia that Ramsay some how orchestrated it and deliriously accompanies Ramsay on his ‘hunts’.
The nastiest material George R.R. Martin has given the world yet was actually toned down for the show. Indeed, at least Theon still looks like Theon in the show. The nature of his transformation in the novels was among the most horrific plotlines in the history the fantasy genre.
7. Tracee And Ralph - The Sopranos
Dancing at Tony’s Bada Bing strip bar, Tracee’s got an ill son at home and a volatile boyfriend in the form of Tony’s least favourite colleague, Ralph Cifaretto, played to detestable perfection by Joe Pantoliano.
Pregnant with Ralph’s child, Tracee incurs the wrath of his fellow mobsters when she starts calling in sick to spend more time with the father of her unborn child. Beaten by Silvio Dante with a laughing Ralph in the background, we follow Tracee back to work where an argument with Ralph gets vastly out of hand.
Watching Ralph violently beat and ultimately kill Tracee and their child is among the most disquieting moments in the notoriously violent series. Unflinchingly shot and acted, the abuse and ultimately murderous end to Tracee’s story is so messily done that even the other hard-hearted mobsters are visibly appalled.
Sitting in his therapist’s chair, visibly shaken by the actions of one of his men, Tony Soprano comments “Sad when they go so young”.
Sad indeed and a watershed moment in the Tony/Ralph dynamic that would dominate the mid seasons of the series.
6. The Burning Of Shireen Baratheon - Game Of Thrones
You know it’s bad when the broadcaster tells you in advance to be ready for distressing scenes in a show already known for all manner of brutality.
Stannis the Mannis is having a hard go of things in the harsh winters of the north, so his advisor Melisandre suggests using his daughter for firewood will warm the place right up.
Hellbent on kingship no matter the cost, Stannis agrees to sacrifice his young daughter to the Lord of Light and stands idly by as his only child burns to death.
A disgustingly cruel act of desperation, Stannis’ kinslaying gamble does not pay off whatsoever. Quite the opposite in fact as by the morning he has lost his sellswords, his horses and his wife. Shortly thereafter he and what’s left of his army are handily crushed by the Boltons and Stannis dies by Brienne’s hand over the death of his brother Renly years earlier.
No one is more cursed than the kinslayer.
A particularly harsh ending in a show full to the brim with them, the destruction of House Baratheon here was a harrowing thing to watch. Any sympathy Stannis once had from audiences had safely gone up in smoke by the time his head left his shoulders.
5. Wallace’s Demise - The Wire
Sometimes, crime just does not pay.
At just 16 years of age, Michael B. Jordan’s Wallace learns that the hard way. Working with the police to bring down Avon Barksdale’s criminal enterprise, Wallace falls foul of Avon’s right hand man Stringer Belle.
Already traumatised by his involvement in Stringer’s violent crimes, Wallace dies by Stringer’s order. At the mercy of his former friend Bodie, Wallace’s death is a long and painful process, requiring several gunshots to put an end to it.
Despite his often criminal actions in life, Wallace’s death reminds us that he was youngster with his whole life ahead of him. The fear and devastation that washes over him as he dies by the hands of someone he was once so close to is among the bleakest moments in David Chase’s classic series.
Wallace’s story throughout season 1 is a thematic centre to the show. His decline into crime, drug abuse and ultimately death proved how far the series was willing to go in examining the harshest aspects of city life.
4. The Red Wedding - Game Of Thrones
Where does one even start?
Is it Robb watching his pregnant wife get stabbed to death?
Or Catelyn watching her eldest son take a knife to the heart?
Or us watching Catelyn’s throat get slit?
One of the definitive moments in Game of Thrones, The Red Wedding proved how little the series cared for fantasy convention. After Ned’s unceremonious death in season 1, many viewers probably figured his son Robb would triumphantly avenge his old man.
Of course, if you thought anything in Westeros was going to have a happy ending, you clearly weren’t paying attention. 2 seasons in the making, Robb inadvertently sealed his doom the moment he spurned his agreement with the reviled Walder Frey to take one of his daughters in marriage.
Despite winning every battle, Robb soundly loses his war against the Lannister family by underestimating the depths of dishonour his rivals will stoop to. The Westerosi custom of guest safety is thrown to the wind as were many of the storyline expectations and fan theories for those who had not read the novels prior.
3. The Retribution Of Damon Pope - Sons Of Anarchy
When Damon Pope’s daughter falls victim to a misdirected attempt at revenge by the brutal Tig Trager, Pope ramps the revenge up to 11.
Pope ensures Tig is chained up and close enough to watch what transpires without being able to intervene in any way. Gasoline is then poured all over Tig’s daughter Dawn as he begs in vain for Pope to kill him instead.
“Know my pain, Mr. Trager,” says Pope as he tosses in the cigar he’d been smoking, burning Dawn alive in the process. The sight of Dawn consumed by the flames is horrific in itself but the sound of her screaming ”Daddy!” one final time is the icing on the cake.
Pope’s eye for an eye mentality leaves Tig suffering a fate here far worse than the death he desperately begged Pope for in exchange for his daughter’s life.
Capped off with the sight of Tig sobbing at the sight of his daughter’s body, it was safe to say he and Pope had destroyed one another’s lives.
Hard to watch for its unforgettable brutality, this was among the most traumatic moments in the history of Sons of Anarchy and indeed of television as a whole.
2. The Peacock Family - The X-Files
When an episode’s opening scene is a baby getting buried alive, you know it’s going to be a pretty bad one. When that proves to be the lightest scene in the entire episode however, all bets are off...
The notoriously nasty season 4 episode Home introduces Mulder and Scully to the Peacocks, a band of severely inbred brothers living in a dilapidated home dating back to the US Civil War. Between home invasion murders, booby traps and dead babies, this episode was harsh enough before the dreaded mother reveal.
Determined to figure out how the brothers are producing children without any known female member of the household being present, Mulder and Scully break in.
What came next unsettled viewers at the time so greatly that Fox vowed to never air the episode again. Hidden under the bed is the quadruple amputee Mrs Peacock who has been breeding with her sons for goodness knows how long.
Often regarded as one of the scariest episodes in the show’s history, Home’s meditations on themes such as incest and child murder make it one not suitable for the weak of stomach.
1. The Behanding Of Gary Beecher - Oz
Boy, that Vern Schillinger was a piece of work, wasn’t he?
When his long-running nemesis Tobias Beecher (who had already been beaten, raped, broken-limbed and stabbed by Vern at this point) tries to make good between them, Vern sees only a new threat.
Paying Vern’s last living son to come and visit his old man in the big house, Tobias will forever rue the day he tried to be nice. Vern sees this all as a dastardly ploy and takes the offensive, getting his son to kidnap Beecher’s infant son and daughter. From there they cut the hand off Beecher’s young son Gary and mail it to him in prison before killing the poor kid completely.
Sometimes, it does not pay to be nice.
Having already killed one of his sons by tricking him into overdosing, Vern’s preferred son is executed by hitmen on Beecher’s orders leaving him childless and guilty of one of the worst things to happen in possibly the most unpleasant TV drama of all time.
Seriously, did TV ever get nastier than this?