10 Hidden Gem Horror TV Shows You Need To Watch
The scares you haven't felt yet.
For many years, it seemed like horror as a genre would forever be relegated to the big screen, with television efforts at delivering the same scale of gore and fear present in theatres falling flat.
Thankfully, this is no longer the case - everyone and their mother has heard of shows like American Horror Story, and many popular horrors are actually considered prestige television, rather than your regular old slasher flick.
Despite this, there are many excellent horror shows out there that all but the most invested of horror aficionados likely missed, whether thanks to lack of promotion, niche subject matter, or relegation to genre-specific cable and streaming networks.
This needs to change, because horror is producing some of the best quality programs around, and who doesn't like a little jump scare to spice up your weekend?
No matter if you’re a tentative fan dipping your toe in the bloody waters, or a long-time fear-seeker branching away from movies, these shows deserve to be added to your to watch list, stat!
10. The Strain
Ironically for a show about vampires, FX’s The Strain has admittedly seen a little more time in the sun than some of the other shows on this list, earning itself an impressive four seasons with the American Horror Story network. However, for a show created by (and based on the novel trilogy of the same name) eerie mastermind Guillermo del Toro himself, it remains pitifully under-recognised.
The Strain merges science with the supernatural, following the head of a CDC project who is called to investigate a plane landing wherein all the passengers are found mysteriously dead, and later discovers a sudden viral outbreak that mimics an ancient strain of vampirism.
Bloodsucking as a pandemic is an innovative spin on the genre itself, but over the seasons, the narrative, along with the outbreak, expands far beyond this initial premise and cements itself with a compelling cast of characters.
Better yet, the show never got cancelled, but rather was able to tie up the plot laid out in its source material as intended, so the entire, completed story is ready and waiting in full for you to get your fangs into.
9. Hemlock Grove
One of Netflix’s earliest original offerings, 2013’s Hemlock Grove is undeniably polarising.
As to be expected from one of the streaming services first forays into in-house production, the show exhibits some now-unfortunate choices, whether that be around its dubious portrayal and somewhat inaccurate casting of Romani people, or simply Famke Janssen’s horrific British accent in season one.
However, hiding underneath these errors is the meat and bones of an intriguing and overall decent supernatural horror show, if you like spectacular gore paired with a languid, dreamlike, and often absolutely batshit insane narrative.
Starring Landon Liboiron and a pre-Steven King Bill Skarsgard, the show focuses on the friendship of the two teenagers from startlingly different economic backgrounds - oh, and also, that fact that one is a werewolf and the other a kind of vampire.
If this sounds like teeny-bopper Vampire Diaries-esque fare a serious horror fan wouldn’t be interested in, think again. While it’s necessary to recognise the show’s missteps, looking beyond will provide you with an undeniably adult show, whose most violent scenes might even leave you feeling a little ill.
At the very least, it features maybe the most gruesome werewolf transformation ever put to screen, so catch it for that if nothing else.
8. Archive 81
Adapted from the podcast of the same name, Archive 81 features a mysterious horror premise, where conservator Dan is hired to restore a series of fire-damaged video tapes, housed at a spooky facility from which they cannot be removed.
While the creep-factor is inherent from the beginning thanks to the dubious men in suits and unnerving atmosphere, as Dan begins to watch the tapes - made in 1994 by grad student Melody for a project about a now-burned down apartment building - the element of the supernatural quickly reveals itself.
From here, the narrative follows the two characters in their respective timelines as it becomes clear that something evil resides not only in the apartment building, but perhaps within the tapes themselves.
To elaborate much further would be a spoiler, and Archive 81 is a story you deserve to unravel firsthand. While Netflix did unfortunately cancel the series after only the first season, what was released is still a more-than worthwhile watch that incorporates found footage in a new and interesting way.
If you like time travel, cults, and a who-(or what)-dunnit element to your horror, this one is definitely for you.
7. Slasher
Originally broadcast on now-defunct horror network Chiller, ongoing anthology series Slasher was later picked up by Netflix, and then genre-dedicated streaming service Shudder. However, despite the high quality and positive reviews, the niche nature of both the show’s original and current broadcasting homes has meant it has as yet not reached the wider audience it sorely deserves.
As implied by the name, Slasher calls back to classic movie tropes by featuring a different masked serial killer and new group of core characters each season, with the first following Katie McGrath’s Sarah as her return to the own where her parents were killed sparks a spate of copycat murders.
Fans of gory horror will appreciate the dedication the show has to its titular violence, however this is supported by excellent writing, fast pacing, and killer performances. The series is also unafraid to innovate, with the upcoming fifth season ‘Ripper’ taking on a new, historical setting in the 19th century.
As of 2022, Slasher is still going strong, and we can only hope that it will be renewed for a further sixth season, allowing it to gain the same public renown as fellow horror anthology American Horror Story.
6. Castle Rock
Somewhat overshadowed by 2017’s It, Bill Skarsgard’s second Steven King outing (and second appearance on this list) Castle Rock nevertheless deserves equal commendation.
Set in the eponymous Castle Rock, Maine, the show sets out to adapt many of the stories set within King’s often-used fictional town by taking a character-driven approach and featuring elements of the various different narratives within the same place.
When results is an anthology-esque horror mystery that is sure to please the most hardcore of Steven King fans, with the first season surrounding the appearance of a secretly long-held inmate at Shawshank Prison, and the attorney called to return to the town to represent him.
Full of references and easter eggs hiding around every corner, the series however was missed out on by many potential casual viewers, thanks to obtuse marketing and its broadcast on US-only streaming service Hulu.
Though the show was sadly cancelled after only two seasons, it is undeniably still worth the watch, as intense performances and a masterfully-crafted atmosphere deliver a Once Upon A Time-esque delight for horror fans everywhere.
5. Requiem
A Netflix and BBC collaboration that unfortunately flew under the collective radar, ghostly thriller Requiem comes well-equipped with psychological spooks to seriously unsettle your day.
Starring Lydia Wilson as famous cellist Matilda, the narrative starts out as something of a crime mystery, as witnessing her mother’s sudden suicide leads her to investigate the previous small-town disappearance of a young Welsh girl, and causes her to question her own identity.
However, the more Matilda digs into the case, the more supernatural elements reveal themselves, opening up into a frightening tale of cults, angels, and ghosts that will have you on the edge of your seat.
While the show features less outright bloody violence than your typical horror, the creeping dread, eerie atmosphere, and trauma dealt by show’s multiple suicides serve to make it an unnerving watch all the same.
Be mindful of the subject matter, as the mental health themes in this one really do get dark, but Requiem stands as a rare example of a show that blends and handles its psychological and supernatural horror equally well.
4. Channel Zero
A somewhat overlooked Syfy gem, anthology horror Channel Zero sought to break the typical horror trope mould by choosing a distinctly new and modern source material for its narrative:
Creepypastas.
For the uninitiated, these are established urban online legends, often created by undetermined authors, which tell tales of horrors commonly influenced by current internet culture that blend the lines of fiction and reality.
With each season based on a different creepypasta, the show delivered some seriously sinister concepts during its four season run, capitalising wholly on the beauty of the anthology format. It also boasted an esteemed cast, with the likes of Fiona Shaw leading the first installment, and saw positive reviews from critics and viewers alike.
Despite this, it seems many dismissed the show when it aired, perhaps with the impression that it would be Slender Man-esque fare unappealing to the serious horror crowd.
Thankfully, this is undoubtedly not the case, and while Channel Zero was cancelled after its fourth season, horror streamer Shudder quickly scooped up every season for those of us who missed it.
3. Ares
The first of two foreign language horrors on this list, little-known Dutch Netflix original Ares takes on themes of cults, colonial racism, and the fanatically violent lengths some will go to and then keep secret for power with confidence and beautiful art direction.
Set within a top-flight medical school in Amsterdam, the series sees mixed-race first year student Rosa become further and further involved with an exclusive and increasingly frightening student society, the titular Ares.
Despite the historically white society’s discomfort with her involvement, racism proves to be only one of many of this show’s horrors, as Rosa’s descent into Ares’ dark depths is trailed by a series of mysterious suicides at the school.
While this show is certainly not for the fainthearted, and the extremely prominent themes of mental health, suicide, and self harm mean that those who find these subjects distressing should tread lightly, Ares handles them well.
Combining the true horror of the misdeeds of those in control with a supernatural manifestation of that same evil, Ares leaves you thinking about it days after the credits roll.
2. Marianne
French horror Marianne takes something of a meta approach to its narrative, showcasing a fiction within a fiction.
Focusing on popular horror novelist Emma, the show quickly becomes a terrifying Inkheart-esque tale, as she steadily discovers that the titular witch and villain of her books, Marianne, is also appearing in the real world, and that the words Emma writes influence future events.
Thought it takes the fairly common trope of an ‘imaginary’ childhood demon continuing to haunt the protagonist in adulthood, the show successfully elevates the concept through metaphors of addiction and its continual preying on the characters’ emotions - with the writing Emma began as a way to fight Marianne ending up holding her hostage.
Something of a sleeper hit, Marianne realises its evil so frighteningly that the show immediately captured the imagination of all horror fans who discovered it.
Despite this, the series deserves far more exposure, and if you can look beyond the subtitles contextlessly goofy prosthetics, you will find some of the best supernatural horror to grace the small screen in recent years.
1. Brand New Cherry Flavor
It’s not often that a show comes along with the ability to both meaningfully criticise the manipulative, exploitative nature of modern Hollywood and see its main character literally vomit up kittens in every episode, but Brand New Cherry Flavor really has it all. Starring Rosa Salazar as an up-and-coming director who comes to LA to pitch a horror feature, she ends up turning to witches and curses for revenge after a sleazy producer uses her and steals her film.
Chock full of metaphors about the price of art and power, Brand New Cherry Flavor is steeped in the occult, something which has garnered it some reviews on the bad side thanks to its complicated and obscure nature. Don’t let these dissuade you: the magic in the show feels earned, and, honestly, absolutely disgusting. Seriously, this show is really, really gross, but in a way that visually emphasises the emotional and physical toll the narrative takes on the characters. This thing gets wild.
You’ll need a stronger stomach than the main character to have a chance at taking this show on, but the Cronenberg-style body horror and examination of the dark side of Hollywood in the wake of the Me Too movement crafts a horror that feels all too real in its unreality, and is seriously worth watching.