10 Highly Questionable Actions Committed By Doctor Who

7th and Ace

For fans of the long-running British SF institution Doctor Who, it's difficult to imagine a dark side to their favorite Time Lord. For fifty years now, The Doctor, in his various incarnations, has saved the Earth from alien invasion countless times, toppled repressive governments and tyrants in time for tea, and generally been the best friend that humanity could possibly have. But this pleasant, sunny side is not all that constitutes the complex psyche of the Doctor. Here are 10 instances from the history of the series where his moral and ethical judgement could be called into question, and his darker and more disagreeable side has come to the fore....

10. He Kidnaps Ian & Barbara

doctorwhohartnell1

The fact escapes a lot of New Who fans used to swooning over the dreamy David Tennant and Matt Smith, that in the very beginning of the series, the Doctor was more of a rude and crusty old grandfather type than anyone that your average Twilight fan would want to have tacked to their bedroom wall. Schoolteachers Ian and Barbara were intended to be the figures for audiences to identify with, and through their tenure on the series they are shown as intelligent, courageous, resourceful figures. By contrast, The Doctor was an unabashed anti-hero, a truculent, devious fellow who spends a large chunk of the first episode "An Unearthly Child" first cruelly insulting Ian and Barbara and calling their intelligence into doubt, then, over the desperate objections of his granddaughter Susan, kidnaps them with the TARDIS, when they threaten to report him to the police. To add insult to injury, they even get knocked unconscious when the ship takes off, as the Doctor has not quite mastered the takeoff at this point. Apparently, the seat belt hadn't been invented yet.

9. Lying To & Endangering His Companions To The Daleks

Doctor Who In the very next story, the Doctor recklessly endangers the lives of his companions by demanding that they enter the Dalek city in search of replacement mercury for the TARDIS fluid links which supply power to the ship. This exposes them to massive levels of radiation and later capture by the hostile Daleks. The Doctor then grudgingly is forced to admit that the fluid link excuse was a lie he concocted like a petulant child, purely because he wanted to explore the city. This story is the beginning of the attempt to soften the sharp edges of the Doctor character as he expresses regret at his reckless behavior, telling his companions he's "desperately sorry" for getting them into this mess, but for the first half he's still an unpleasant, grouchy old jerk. It's not too hard to imagine him yelling at Ian and Barbara to get off his lawn.

8. The Third Doctor's Uneasy Alliance With UNIT

Doctor Whos The working arrangement of the exiled Doctor providing assistance to a military group like UNIT (United Nations Intelligence Taskforce) was an uneasy alliance from the start, so it's more than somewhat surprising that the 3rd Doctor continues to work with them after the events of "The Silurians," where Brigadier Lethbridge-Stewart commits genocide against the entire Silurian race, mercilessly bombing them into oblivion, shown in the above picture. The disgust Pertwee shows in this final scene as he learns that an previously undiscovered intelligent alien race with whom he has been conducting peace negotiations has been slaughtered is palpable. But this is conveniently forgotten by the time of the next UNIT adventure, "Inferno" (which features an alternate reality version of the Brigadier who is even more of a dick.) Perhaps the Doctor is merely masking his contempt for the Brigadier (which changes to admiration as the series progresses) in order to have continued access to the scientific resources at UNIT's disposal, but it's worth considering that when faced with a very similar choice to commit genocide in "Genesis Of The Daleks", the Doctor flatly refuses to do so.

7. Attempted Assassination In "The Deadly Assassin"

Doctor Who 3 Yes, I realize that the Doctor doesn't actually fire the shot that kills the President, and Chancellor Goth and the Master are really behind the whole thing, but the first episode is misleadingly directed in such a way to make the viewer to think that the 4th Doctor is a stone-cold killer with a sniper rifle, traumatising generations of children in the process. However, what I see as worse behavior from the Doctor is that in order to travel to Gallifrey alone, in the previous episode "The Hand Of Fear" he unceremoniously and brusquely dumps perhaps the most beloved series companion of all time, the utterly charming Sarah Jane Smith, in some anonymous suburban cul-de-sac nowhere near her actual home ("This isn't Hillview Road! I bet it isn't even South Croydon!"), with only a stuffed owl, some sad plastic flowers and a rather pathetic looking suitcase to keep her company. That plays like a jerk move in my book, seeming more like how Don Draper of Mad Men would treat an ex than what we expect from the Doc. The series later attempted to fix this by bringing Sarah back for a few episodes during Tennant's run, and giving her a spin-off series "The Sarah Jane Adventures", which took some of the sting of her less than ideal departure away.

6. Gasses The Silurians In "Warriors of the Deep"

Doctor Who 4 In this so-so base under siege story from Peter Davison's final season, The Doctor is forced into a corner by the Silurian's plan to launch a nuclear war, rendering the Earth uninhabitable (wait, don't they want to take over the Earth in "The Silurians"?) and uses some conveniently placed hexachromite gas to poison them, reducing them all to steaming piles of bubbling green goo. As with most stories of this era, the body count is exceedingly high here, leaving only four characters left alive by the end (The Doctor, Tegan, Turlough and senior base officer Bulic). Here, the Doc makes basically the same decision as the Brigadier in "The Silurians", showing his earlier offense at his actions to be somewhat hypocritical. Unlike the Brigadier's decision to slaughter a whole race for reasons of simple expediency, The Doctor is lead to this point by his own hesitation and indecision, trademark traits of the rather naive 5th doctor. It's also somewhat hypocritical that in this story, the Security Chief for the base insists he use the gas to stop the Silurian plot, which the Doctor initially refuses to do, accusing the Chief of advocating genocide. Even though he ultimately saves the planet (again), he realizes the ultimate emptiness of his victory as he ruefully mutters, "There should have been another way."

5. The Sixth Doctor's Attempted Murder of Peri

Peri Doctor Who "Disagreeable" is a perfect term to describe the 6th Doctor's short tenure. A conscious rebellion against the rather placid and agreeable 5th Doctor, one of the first things the 6th Doctor utters is an insult aimed at his companion ("That's 3 I's in one breath, makes you a rather egotistical young lady.") From there, things get much, much worse. Unhinged by his regeneration, the Doctor becomes fixed on the irrational notion that Peri is actually an ancient, evil creature and physically assaults her, attempting to strangle her to death in the TARDIS control room, a scene that is still rather shocking to this day. I mean, can you imagine David Tennant stabbing Billie Piper? This is a scene that couldn't be done in the snug and comfy domestic atmosphere of the new series. Just to throw a little salt into the open wound, The Doctor then threatens to bring Peri with him to some desolate, solitary asteroid for a few decades while he gets his head straight. Lucky for Peri, the story kicks in at that point, saving her from that unimaginable fate. Unfortunately for the audience, that story is "The Twin Dilemma."

4. The 6th Doctor's Unbearable Costume

6th Docs Coat

While on the topic of the 6th Doctor, it's hard to ignore the retina-searing awfulness of his peacock-vomit costume, certainly the poorest sartorial choice for a Doctor ever. Yes, it does perfectly reflect the oversized brashness of his personality, only too well. The costume magnifies the arrogance and vanity Baker's Doctor emanates in waves, being so off-putting to the casual observer that it's hard, if not impossible, to identify with him. (And as a sidebar, what's the deal with the cat pin on the lapel? At least Davison's celery served a purpose.) The original plan was that the Sixth Doctor's character and outfit would mellow as time progressed in the series (and a toned-down version of his costume can be seen on the covers of various Sixth Doctor audio adventures), but Baker getting canned by the BBC put this plan on ice, thus ensuring that this wretched ensemble would forever be identified with the Sixth Doctor.

3. Manipulation Of Ace By The 7th Doctor

7th and Ace

The 7th Doctor's seemingly befuddled demeanor and appearance was, like the 2nd Doctor, merely a mask to disguise a devious mind with an unknown agenda. His manipulation of his companion Ace begins almost as soon as they meet, and comes to a head in "The Curse of Fenric", where he finally admits that Ace has been used as a pawn in the ancient battle between him and Fenric, in order to shake her faith in him. Their unconventional teacher/student relationship was originally meant to culminate with Ace going to the Prydonian Academy on Gallifrey to train to become a Time Lord, however, the series cancellation in 1989 left this intriguing development unfulfilled. Without this goal being mentioned, the 7th Doctor's treatment of Ace seems needlessly cruel: whenever he's not badgering her with endless questions about their surroundings, he constantly lies and withholds information from her to keep her in the dark about his true intentions. He certainly wasn't this controlling with his previous companion Mel, perhaps the shrillest and most annoying cast member of the classic series.

2. The John Hurt Doctor's Actions In The Time War

john-hurt-doctor-who

It's not yet been firmly established what exactly the Doctor's role in the horrifyingly brutal Time War was (well, Clara finds out when she reads the book of Time Lord history in "Journey To The Center of the TARDIS", but she isn't telling), but the John Hurt character revealed in "Name of the Doctor" seems to be responsible for the majority of the atrocities.

The most likely explanation for the presence of John Hurt's Doctor (and the only one that doesn't completely make a hash of the established continuity) is that he is a future incarnation of the Doctor that contains all his hate, rage, and negative emotions... in other words, the Valeyard, or his 13th incarnation, brought back in time by the Time Lords to do their dirty work.

This theory is backed by the fact that it's already been shown in "The End Of Time" that the Time Lords had no compunction about using the Master to accomplish something similar, and they even gave him a full set of new regenerations for the trouble. Whatever destruction he was responsible for, the 11th Doctor can hardly contain his disgust for the man, and why not? His mere existence proves that the Doctor's goody-goody image is merely a facade that contains some truly dreadful things.


1. The Whole "Time Lord Victorious" Thing In "Waters of Mars"

Waters-of-Mars-doctor-who-9104903-1248-704

In "The Waters Of Mars", undoubtedly the single darkest outing from the Tennant Era, The Tenth Doctor's hubris gets the better of him, and he attempts to change a fixed point in history because as the only survivor of the Time War he can do whatever the hell he wants, and anyway, who's going to stop him? The Doctor decides he wants Captain Adelaide to escape the slaughter on Bowie Base One, so he rescues Adelaide and two of her crew, returning them to Earth in time to avoid the nuclear explosion that destroys the base. These actions, however merely shift the method of Adelaide's demise from explosion to suicide (which is mercifully not shown on screen.) This is an instance where the Doctor recognizes and admits to his error in judgement, ruefully admitting "I've gone too far." Clearly the Doctor has forgotten the invaluable advice given to him in "Voyage of The Damned": "You don't get to decide who lives and who dies. If you could, that would make you a monster." Agree or disagree with these actions? Let us know in the comments section below.

In this post: 
Doctor Who
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

Hi there, What Culture-ers! I'm William Graff, a 40-year old freelance writer from the wilds of Capitol Hill in beautiful Denver, Colorado. I enjoy many things such as beer, Doctor Who, The Simpsons, record collecting, stand-up comedy, long aimless walks, and of course the Broncos, which is required by law if you live here. I appreciate all feedback for my writing, but I prefer cash and/or deleted Smiths singles in lieu of praise. Rock on!