10 Horror TV Shows That Ended On A Cliffhanger

A list of horror TV shows - some long-forgotten - that ended on titillating cliffhangers.

The Terror
BBC

The humble cliffhanger is a story trope almost as old as the art of storytelling itself. Often employed to hook in viewers and leave them frothing at the mouth for more, the act can fall flat on its face when the show itself is cancelled or remains unrenewed.

Horror TV shows have this particular problem in spades. Outside of the more standard anthology format adopted by shows like Channel Zero, American Horror Story and the Twilight Zone, long-form narrative horror shows have a hard time drumming up enough sustained interest to keep them going.

Ironically this leads to the more prevalent use of the Cliffhanger trope in an attempt to guarantee more episodes but as we’ll find out in this list, it doesn’t always work. Without further ado and with many a spoiler ahead, here are 10 Horror TV Shows That Ended On A Cliffhanger.

10. The Terror

The Terror
BBC

BBC’s The Terror is a horror-infused fictionalised account of the very real lost expedition of ships Terror and Erebus. Both ships were sent to seek out the Arctic’s fabled Northwest Passage in 1845 and never returned. Based on the Dan Simmons novel of the same name, the show follows an excellent cast including Ciaran Hinds, Nive Nielson, Adam Nagaitis and Jared Harris as they contend with poisonous cold, spoiled rations, cannibalistic mutiny and a giant bear/wolf/man-monster.

Throughout its 10 episode run the deaths ramp up exponentially, with crew members going missing or dying in increasingly gruesome ways. By the show’s conclusion only the flawed but courageous Captain Crozier - played by the inimitable Jared Harris - has survived. Throughout the show, we’ve seen him contend with sickness, alcoholism, mutiny and some very serious injuries.

With his crew dead, the monster killed and now safely in the company of the Inuit people, Captain Crozier decides to go missing - choosing to stay with his adoptive tribe and letting them relay a message to the British Empire to ‘never come here’. Ominous. His ultimate fate is left deliberately up in the air, making this very much a ‘soft cliffhanger’. Nonetheless, the lack of closure on this man’s incredible journey was enough to turn the balls blue; and not with cold.


9. The River

The River
ABC

Airing on ABC back in 2012 (Ten years ago? No, you’re definitely lying), The River was touted as a found footage supernatural adventure horror; a mid-season replacement sandwiched between the network’s bigger shows. Following the story of a famous explorer - a Steve Irwin-like figure called Dr Emmet - who went missing in the Amazon rainforest, the plot follows said explorer’s son as he and a team of similarly related people venture off to the dangerous jungle to find him. What they don’t know is that they’re actually venturing to an area where magic comes alive with forest demons, mystical curses and other paranormal phenomena.

At the conclusion of the show, the rag-tag crew has successfully rescued Dr Emmet and narrowly escaped the clutches of some zombie-like cannibals only to discover the river they were on, and the terrain around it, is constantly changing to prevent them from ever leaving. And that’s where the story ends.

Season 2 would have undoubtedly seen the troubled crew try and escape their predicament Dungeons & Dragons-style, running into all sorts of supernatural hindrances along the way. Alas, despite warm critical reception, the show never showed up in the ratings department and was thus cancelled; the crew's ultimate fate left forever unknown.


8. Wolf Lake

Wolf Lake
CBS

Airing all the way back in 2001, Wolf Lake followed the story of a pack of Werewolves living in a rural Seattle suburb. Largely directionless, the plot follows detective John Kanin as he attempts to unravel the mystery of his fiancee’s disappearance in the titular town.

At the time the show was marketed as Twin Peaks but with werewolves and, as tantalising a concept as that sounds, the poor writing, uneven direction, and questionable acting all scuppered the show’s chances before it even got properly started. Its original nine-episode run on CBS was cut short at only five episodes, the remaining four airing much later on UPN.

It’s actually something of a shame as, despite its overall poor quality, Wolf Lake was way ahead of its time. The cheesy, supernatural young adult genre would carve up the market in giant properties like Twilight, True Blood and The Vampire Diaries only a few years later and Wolf Lake does feel like a natural extension of that niche.

Nevertheless, viewers were left unsatisfied as, at the plot’s culmination, sweet innocent character Sophia (here played by a pre-fame Mary Elizabeth Winstead) is revealed to have been turned into a werewolf herself. What this would have meant for the plot going forward is anyone’s guess but it’s disappointing that we’ll never know.


7. Spooksville

Spooksville cast
Hub Network

A horror adventure comedy mashup aimed at younger audiences, Spooksville is yet another forgotten gem. With a ‘mystery of the week’ format channelling some serious Goonies energy, the plot follows Adam and his friends Sally and Watch as they solve various spooky goings-on around their bizarre hometown. An overarching mystery of the plot involves Adam’s supposedly deceased mother and there’s plenty of time-travelling, alien robots and vengeful ghosts along the way. In the final episode ‘Stone’, we find out that Adam’s mother is alive and well - however by the episode’s conclusion, a witch’s curse renders Spooksville unrecognisable to him and he himself is forgotten by his friends. Bummer.

First broadcast by The Hub Network in 2013, the show appeared to be a critical and commercial hit for the network. What's more, the show didn’t appear to ever be officially cancelled, instead just left unrenewed. To add to the intrigue, series lead Keehan Johnson revealed in a 2014 interview with Sweety High that stories had been completed for a supposed season 2, including a demon dentist and other crazy new monsters.

This bizarre apathy to the property left fans rightly frustrated given the cliffhanger ending and has since seen petitions pop up to save the show as recently as 2015 (What do you mean that’s not recent? Stop lying). Currently, Netflix US has the rights to the show so there’s some minuscule hope the streaming giant could resurrect the property and finally give us some much-needed closure.


6. Wayward Pines

Wayward Pines
Fox

Based on the successful book series of the same name, partially helmed by horror master M. Night Shyamalan and flexing some series Twin Peaks-esque muscles, Wayward Pines looked set to soar. And initially, it did! Seeing FBI agent Ethan Blake (played by an excellent Matt Dillon) travel to the titular town to seek out two fellow agents who went missing in the area, Blake finds himself unable to leave and lacking the means to seek answers about his idyllic prison; itself revealed to be surrounded by a post-apocalyptic earth inhabited by bloodthirsty mutants known as ‘Abbies’.

The show kept piling on plot-twist after plot-twist, reveals and revelations throughout its run. Just when you thought you had a handle on what was going on, the rug would be pulled once again. It was, frankly, awesome.

Intended to be a one-and-done affair, the show’s success saw it renewed for a second season. This is where its reach exceeded its grasp, however. As we’ve seen with comparable sophomore efforts like True Detective’s troubled second season, sometimes lightning only strikes once. Wayward Pines season 2 was marred by a plodding story, a lack of inherent mystery and a painful leading-man gap left from Ethan Blake’s heroic death at the end of season one.

A combination of these elements led to its official cancellation in 2018 but not before we were teased with what might have been: the town once again in ruins, humanity’s last sealed away in cryo-pods hoping to wake to a better future and a wild group of Abbies seemingly caring for a fully human baby. A bold revelation for sure, and one we’ll never have the answer for.


5. Truth Seekers

Truth Seekers
Amazon Prime

Marketed more as a comedy in the vein of Shaun of the Dead - a deliberate theme that highlighted Nick Frost’s involvement in the project - Truth Seekers actually brought some serious scares to the table when it debuted on Amazon Prime back in late 2020. Following a pair of broadband installers moonlighting as paranormal investigators, the show, unfortunately, didn’t stick the landing.

Despite lukewarm critical reception, the show’s cast and their performances were widely praised, alongside the show's commitment to be, y’know, actually creepy. These positives failed to maintain interest long enough for many audiences to finish it, however.

Those that did make it to the end of the enjoyable, if uneven, project were treated to a cliffhanger involving the group’s 3rd musketeer Astrid. Revealed in the penultimate episode to have been a living ghost the whole time, Sixth Sense Style, Astrid travels to the metaphysical plane to do battle with villain Elara while Gus and Elton fight antagonist Toynbee in the real world to stop a world-ending ritual involving 8G signals. Just a normal one, then.

Astrid tragically ends up ‘crossing over’ permanently and the show ends with Gus and Elton lamenting the loss of their ectoplasmic chum. But wait! In a final twist of the knife, Astrid is shown once again trying to break through to the mortal plain via a painting, her new corporeal friends none the wiser. Nick Frost then announced the show’s cancellation through Instagram shortly after, obviously. Poor Astrid.


4. American Gods

American Gods
Starz

The small screen adaption of Neil Gaiman’s horror-fantasy epic had a turbulent run, to say the least. A falling out between the author and showrunner Brian Fuller marred the transition from the first season to the second and accusations of racism and shady business practices aimed at the studio from recurring star Orlando Jones cast long shadows over the show’s viability. The story follows Shadow Moon, a man released early from prison on account of his wife’s death, who’s employed as a driver/bodyguard for the mysterious Mr Wednesday, literally Odin himself, as they journey across America meeting deities from various other cultures.

As premises go, it’s a doozy, and with big names like Ian McShane, Emily Browning, Crispin Glover and Gillian Anderson the show gained a few awards alongside excellent critical reception, despite all the trouble behind the scenes. Alas, the third and final season spent most of its time trying to right the ship from the disastrous second season and, what began as an exploration of the immigrant experience and the modern world’s relationship with faith, ended as a less inspiring story than the one it had begun.

Season 3 closes with Shadow hanging himself from the world tree Yggdrasil in sacrifice, a homage to Odin’s own legend, and appearing to be consumed and killed. However, Shadow still pops up with Mr Wednesday afterwards in a plane “somewhere between life and death”, strongly hinting that this was far from the end of Shadow’s story. For context, his dead wife was following him around as a horny zombie for most of the show so we do know death isn’t the end in this universe. Nevertheless, barring another studio stepping in to save it, it might be the last we see from this flawed masterpiece of a show.


3. Angel

Angel TV Show
20th Television

Buffy the Vampire Slayer fans rejoiced when it was revealed fan favourite character Angel would be getting his own spin-off series. Following the "vampire with a soul’s" escapades in Los Angeles, the show utilised a police-procedural format alongside returning and recurring Buffy characters to move the story along. Angel started as a modest success that grew in both fan and critical enjoyment over time.

The fifth and final season in particular, which saw another fan favourite Spike being brought into the fold, was the show's biggest success to date and ended at the precipice of an epic battle between Angel and his cohorts with a literal army of ghouls, giants and a motherloving dragon! Angel exclaims “let’s go to work” and we cut to black. Forever.

Commonly lamented even twenty years later as one of TV’s most frustrating cliffhangers, it’s not known why the show was cancelled at such an apex. As pointed out ratings for the show were up, not down, and the epic battle we were teased at the end of season 5 would have surely cemented viewers continued interest in the property. Some suggest it was Joss “Where’s My Hug At” Whedon pushing Warner Brothers too hard for an early renewal that saw them eventually pull the plug, but given how much time has passed, it seems we’re unlikely to ever find out for certain.


2. Lovecraft Country

Lovecraft Country
HBO

HBO maintained their reputation as the kings of so-called ‘prestige television’ with this wonderfully weird and socially conscious remix of the works of H.P. Lovecraft. Following an always excellent Jonathon Majors as Atticus Freeman, the show tracks our hero’s journey across America with friend Letitia, witnessing the horrors of the Jim Crow era alongside various eldritch monstrosities ripped straight from the Necronomicon. The show received near-universal acclaim from critics and audiences, who praised the creativity, performances and deftly handled themes of social injustice.

The climax of this show won’t be spoiled here as you should absolutely check it out for yourself; it ends on a decisive conclusion, as well. So what gives with this entry? The real cliffhanger was actually in what was promised to be coming in the cancelled second season. Showrunner Misha Green confirmed that Lovecraft Country would be pseudo-anthology series, similar to Fargo, that would cover similar themes in different eras with different characters.

Season 2, tentatively titled Lovecraft Country: Supremacy would show an alt-history USA in which slavery never ended in certain districts and had ended up being absorbed into a form of modern white-supremacist society. There were also hints at a zombie epidemic that a new cast of protagonists would have likely had to contend with alongside the Hunger Games-like setting. As thoroughly tough viewing as this premise sounds, it’s a complete travesty we’ll likely never see it given the quality of the show’s first outing.


1. Hannibal

Hannibal TV Show
NBC

Oh Hanni we hardly knew ye. The cliffhanger of cliffhangers in a figurative and literal sense, Brian Fuller’s immaculate horror adaptation left fans screaming, crying, shaking and starting petitions the world over. Three seasons of visceral artsy build-up and plenty of homoerotic subtext led to Will Graham and Hannibal Lecter uniting against the Great Red Dragon Francis Dollarhyde, stabbing each other in an act of loving victory and then falling off a cliff, out of audiences’ view.

In a classic case of Habeas Corpus we never actually see Will and Hannibal’s dead bodies. Furthermore, a mysterious post credits stinger shows the pair’s psychiatric frenemy Dr Bedelia Du Maurier sat at a table set for three, sans one whole leg. This is the second Brian Fuller effort on this list and actually three-for-three if you count the Pushing Daisies cancellation.

Fuller himself is united with fellow cast members and longtime fans to resurrect the utterly unique show for one final go-around (this time covering elements of The Silence of the Lambs story). Did Will and Hannibal make it? How did they do it? What would an intense ‘Fuller-ized’ adaption of Silence of the Lambs look like? Will they finally just make out already? Hopefully one day, we’ll find out.


Watch Next


In this post: 
Horror
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

Total goblin. Quit the food and beverage industry after ten years to try my hand at writing nonsense online. I have a huge passion for film, television, cats, art, tattoos, food, anarchy and classic literature (mainly Dune). Currently based at my mum's house, I can be best reached on Instagram (@charlie_marx) where I attempt to soothe my mental health with memes.