10 Huge Unexplained TV Mysteries (That Were Totally Solved)
Want to know what happened to the "unkillable" Russian from The Sopranos?
Writing a television show is a fluid, unpredictable process. The writers might carefully set up a storyline, only to realise it doesn’t work and they have to find something new to fill its place. An important character might suddenly disappear without being mentioned again, or a season may end on a cliffhanger that’s not addressed when the show returns.
There’s are plenty of famous examples of this, from the disappearance of Chuck Cunningham in Happy Days to Lost dropping Walt’s subplot like a hot brick. These mysteries are good fodder for fans to debate on forum boards, but a little bit of digging reveals some of these famous questions actually have an answer.
It might be the showrunner letting it slip during an interview years later, or the answer is given as part of spin-off media. Some of the answers are shocking, while other are a letdown after such a long build up. Here are ten famous “unsolved” TV mysteries that have totally been solved, and how the answer impacts the show.
10. What Happened Between Seasons Two And Three? - 24
The Mystery
24 had a habit of breezing past certain cliffhangers and storylines from season to season, with the switch from season two to three being the most awkward. Season two ended with an assassination attempt on David Palmer – where his fate was left ambiguous – and the real villains of Day Two remaining free.
Season three opens a few years later and doesn’t bother explaining what happened in-between; Palmer is fine and no mention is made of the people behind Day Two.
The Answer
It wasn’t until the 24 game for PlayStation 2 that we got some answers, though they weren’t terribly interesting ones. We learn how Jack first met Chloe and Chase and that Palmer was still recovering from his attack months later.
We also learn the mysterious Max from Day Two was an arms dealer who wanted revenge on America for the death of his family. He causes more trouble during the game – including causing an earthquake – before Jack gives him a well-deserved bullet sandwich at the end.
9. What Was Shepherd Book's Backstory? - Firefly
The Mystery
Firefly’s cancellation is a pain that refuses to go away, and it left many, many questions unanswered. Movie spin-off Serenity answered a few of them, but one thing we never learned was the past of Reverend Book. Despite being a man of peace he clearly had some kind of violent past, but he never revealed what it was.
The Answer
This was ultimately revealed in graphic novel Serenity: The Shepherd’s Tale. It turns out he used to be a petty criminal, and that when he needed a new identity to become a mole he killed a man and stole his name. He worked for the Alliance for a time doing their dirty work, but when he fails a mission he’s forced to retire.
He soon becomes homeless and discovers his faith, deciding to redeem himself by becoming a preacher.
The show hinted at these aspects so it’s nice to rewatch the show, and know just how far the character has come.
8. What Happened To Greatjon Umber? - Game Of Thrones
The Mystery
With so many characters – especially bearded ones – it’s little wonder audiences occasionally forget a couple. This fate befell Greatjon Umber, a big bear of a man who backs Robb Stark’s claim to become King In The North.
He takes some convincing, and it’s only after Robb’s direwolf bites off two of his fingers that he sees the light. He’s a big player throughout Robb’s campaign, but he disappears after season two - thanks to the actor being unavailable - and subsequently went unmentioned for years. Some fans thought he might have been killed in The Red Wedding, but his fate was left vague.
The Answer
That’s until season six, where his son joins Ramsey Bolton’s side. He quickly explains his father died at some point, and that he captured Rickon Stark as a gift. It’s a rather blunt explanation, but at least it tied up the loose end.
7. Did Frank Black Stop The Apocalyspe? - Millennium
The Mystery
Millennium was X-Files creator Chris Carter’s other creepy paranormal show, about a psychic investigator named Frank Black working for a secret society. He helps track down serial killers and cults, and the show could be incredibly downbeat and disturbing at times.
The show also turned the secret society into the villains for the final season, with the group planning to spark the end of the world around the turn of the Millennium. Ironically the show was cancelled before it actually reached the new century...
The Answer
But luckily, Carter wanted to bring some closure to the story and to achieve this he did a crossover with The X-Files in its seventh season, where Black teams with Mulder and Scully to stop a plot to trigger the end of the world. Sadly this finale is rather silly; Black is a subplot and the use of zombies as the main threat goes against the tone of Millennium. Still, at least Black’s story got something of a happy ending.
6. Did Anyone Survive? - Blake's 7
The Mystery
Blake’s 7 was cult sci-fi back in the days when such a thing barely existed, and despite suffering from a low-budget it featured great characters and gripping storylines. The show was regularly on the brink of being cancelled throughout its four-season run, especially after the actor playing Blake quit after season two.
The show kept going, though, and when cancellation was threatened again at the end of season four the showrunner decided to end on an almighty cliffhanger to entice viewers back. The final episode ends with Blake’s reappearance, but he’s soon shot dead by crew member Avon who mistakes him for a traitor. Then the rest of the gang are seemingly killed one by one by troops until Avon is surrounded. He smiles and the show cuts to credits as shots ring out.
This scene was shot in such a way the characters could be resurrected if the show came back, but the BBC pulled the plug. They duly did so, but fans were still left clamouring for an answer.
The Answer
An official sequel novel called Afterlife would later explain that Avon and Vila survived the shootout – without explaining how – and wind up on another adventure.
5. Did Earl Finish His List? - My Name Is Earl
The Mystery
My Name Is Earl was a cult sitcom about a low life criminal who realises that whenever anything good happens in his life, something terrible is right around the corner. He decides to correct his karma by making a list of all the bad things he’s done, and working through it one by one until his karma is clear.
The show ran for a healthy 96 episodes before the plug was pulled, but the showrunner wasn’t able to give it a proper ending. Fans were thus left in limbo, wondering if the luckless Earl ever managed to complete his impossible task.
The Answer
The creator actually threw them a bone in his next series Raising Hope, where a radio broadcast reveals Earl’s fate.
It turns out he managed to complete the whole list, and that the ending was truly spectacular. It’s not much to go on, but at least Earl got a happy ending.
4. What Happened To Mr Turner? - Boy Meets World
The Mystery
Boy Meets World is weapons grade nostalgia for those who grew up in the nineties, and followed a teenager named Cory as he tried to make sense of this crazy thing called life. He had some sage mentors along the way, including school principal Mr Feeny and super cool teacher Mr Turner.
Mr Turner is one of those awesome teachers that can only exist on television, and despite his unconventional style, the students all respected him. Despite being a popular supporting character he suffers a motorcycle accident and winds up in a coma in season four, and then subsequently disappeared from the show.
The Answer
Many just assumed he died offscreen, but nearly twenty years later the mystery was solved on sequel series Girl Meets World. He reappears alive and well, having recovered from his injuries, marrying his nurse and moving to a new city. He remained friends with Cory in the aftermath, however, and was even responsible for him becoming a teacher in later years.
3. Did The Team Survive? - Angel
The Mystery
Angel season five ended with Los Angeles being sent to literal Hell because of Angel’s actions, and the final scene has the gang about to clash with demons. Despite the cliffhanger set up it’s kind of a perfect ending to the show; after all, Angel has to keep fighting to earn his redemption.
The Answer
Still, fans weren’t pleased with the notion Angel might have died in this battle, so Joss Whedon decided to recycle some of his ideas for the scrapped sixth season and make a comic out of it. Titled After The Fall, this comic deals with the aftermath of the finale, with Angel and his team trying to save the city from hell. Turns out everyone survived, but they're having a miserable time of it.
The comic was a huge hit with fans, and unlike other spin-offs is considered canon thanks to Whedon involvement. A real season six is unlikely to happen in this lifetime, so After The Fall is as close as we’ll ever get.
2. What Happened To The Unkillable Russian? - The Sopranos
The Mystery
While the ending of The Sopranos will be debated to the end of time, the show left plenty of other questions for viewers to mull over. One of the top mysteries is what happened to Valery, the seemingly unkillable Russian mobster from the Pine Barrens episode?
Valery is taken out to the woods by Paulie and Christopher to be killed, but he escapes – after taking a bullet to the head – and is never seen again. Paulie’s car is later found missing, which implies he escaped, but no mention is made in later episodes. This was intentional on David Chase’s part, who felt it was stronger if Valery just vanished without explanation.
The Answer
Eventually Chase went crazy being asked about it all the time, and finally revealed what happened. It turns out Valery soon collapsed from his wound, only to be found by Boy Scouts in the woods. He was taken to the hospital, but since he suffered massive brain trauma he couldn’t explain what happened to him.
His boss later shipped him back to Russia to be with his family. The mystery was cooler, no?
1. What Happened To President Wayne Palmer? - 24
The Mystery
24 dropped plotlines like crazy throughout its run, with the showrunners using the real-time formula as an excuse for occasional sloppy storytelling. We still don’t know what happened to Behrooz from Season 4, and the fate of other major characters has been left in the air.
A major one from the sixth season is Wayne Palmer, the serving U.S. President. David Palmer’s brother survived an assassination attempt midway through, and despite bravely trying to push through his injuries he eventually suffered a brain haemorrhage. He’s then rushed to the hospital and his fate was never revealed.
The Answer
Expect it was, in a sneaky way.
In the TV movie 24: Redemption a newspaper clipping about his successor revealed Wayne died of his injuries shortly after season six. This wasn’t revealed on the show since the network was nervous about killing off a serving president character, so they implanted the outcome as an easter egg instead.
Can you think of any other TV show mysteries that were actually resolved? Share them in the comments below.