10 Insane Doctor Who Rumours That Never Happened
What on Earth links Doctor Who with Robert Mugabe, Pamela Anderson and North Korea?
Doctor Who has been a British institution for nearly six decades now, and like all such institutions the show has had it's fair share of scurrilous rumours, half-truths and outright lies. A lot of this is due to the show's popularity, a Doctor Who news story guarantees clicks from fans eager for more information in the fallow period between episodes.
During the 1990s, whilst the show was off the air, there appeared to be a rumour of a new film or series going into production every other week, with increasingly wild casting. The unfounded rumours and out-of-control fan theories didn't stop when the show came back in 2005 either!
On the day Christopher Eccleston was announced as the new Doctor, the Daily Mail tried to get ahead of the competition and published a story reporting that Bill Nighy had been cast.
As social media has exploded over the past decade, these rumours and half-truths spread like wildfire amongst fan communities and even find their way into the papers.
So let's take a look at some of the most ridiculous items of Fake Whos from the history of the show and see if we can detect any truth to them.
10. Robert Mugabe Had Missing Doctor Who Episodes
Due to a shocking lack of commercial foresight and cultural appreciation, much of the early years of Doctor Who are no longer available. Thanks to the efforts of self-styled Indiana Jones impersonator-cum-internet troll Philip Morris and record producer/overly thorough genealogist Ian Levine, many of these lost works have now been rediscovered.
Missing Doctor Who episodes have been dug up in all manner of places from church basements to Hong Kong and Nigerian broadcasting stations. Since 2013, rumours have persisted that someone holds a copy of every missing episode of Doctor Who and has a list of insane demands they want fulfilled before they even consider returning them to the BBC.
That man? Deceased Zimbabwean Prime Minister Robert Mugabe. No, not really, but back in 2009 The Sun ran an article which claimed that Zimbabwe had bought the first series of Doctor Who back in the early 60s for broadcast in the country.
Due to the poor diplomatic relations between the UK and Zimbabwe following their dismissal from the Commonwealth, it was proving difficult for UK researchers to get in and root through the archive. Mugabe has been dead for almost three years now, and, as far as we're aware, hadn't listed all seven episodes of Marco Polo in his will.
9. Johnny Depp IS The Doctor
Back in 2010, following his departure from the series, Russell T Davies was already rumoured to be considering a return to Doctor Who. Reports suggested that a feature film was in development, scripted by Davies and with Johnny Depp as preferred casting for the role of the Doctor.
As a newspaper report, it smacks of something an office junior in the entertainment section would knock together during a bank holiday. After all, Johnny Depp is the sort of "quirky" actor who is often suggested as a big screen Doctor by people who've never watched Doctor Who before.
More interesting is what has happened since. Depp's reputation has taken a bit of a battering and it's likely he'd be allowed nowhere near the role nowadays. Back in 2014 however, during the North Korean hack of Sony, emails were leaked that spoke of an interest in making a Doctor Who feature film. Steven Moffat vetoed the idea, but a few months later, Russell T Davies stated an interest in writing a screenplay.
With Russell returning to the show and production company Bad Wolf being acquired by Sony, we may get that Doctor Who feature film after all...
8. Peter Jackson To Direct Doctor Who
Peter Jackson is a bit of a Doctor Who fan. It wasn't just Sylvester McCoy's performance in King Lear that convinced the director to cast him in The Hobbit trilogy!
Back in 2013, there were persistent rumours that Jackson was to direct an upcoming episode of Doctor Who. It's unclear how true this was, Jackson was certainly interested and said as much in interviews. Indeed, Peter Capaldi, Jackson and his daughter recorded a daft video together when the Doctor Who team visited New Zealand. But surely the logistics of getting an Oscar winning Hollywood director from New Zealand to a studio in Cardiff were too much of a headache for the BBC?
What may have happened is that this rumour was a mish-mash of Jackson's own desire to do a Doctor Who and the fact that the opening episodes of Series 8 were to be directed by Ben Wheatley, another bearded director who started out in low-budget horror.
As a side note, the director of Drive and Neon Demon, Nicholas Winding Refn has also previously lobbied to direct an episode of Doctor Who. The mind boggles.
7. Peter Capaldi and Steven Moffat to Remake On the Buses
In what was surely a wilful misreading of some top-notch, deadpan Scottish sarcasm, it was reported that Peter Capaldi and Steven Moffat wanted to reboot the old UK sitcom On the Buses for a modern audience. The source of this nonsense was a panel during the pair's final Doctor Who appearance at the San Diego Comic Con. Peter Capaldi joked that he wanted to bring the of-its-time sitcom back to screens and bore a passing resemblance to the actor Stephen Lewis. Steven Moffat joined in on the joke by quipping "We are working our way through the classics, so it is bound to come up."
It's hardly surprising that the joke fell on deaf ears amongst the audience in San Diego. In the history of British sitcoms, On the Buses was hardly a global cult hit like Fawlty Towers or Mr Bean, despite an ill-fated US remake back in 1973.
Capaldi and Moffat were clearly just being mischievous and the very fact that the joke was being po-facedly reported as a possible next project for the pair show just how keen audiences were to see more from them.
6. Pamela Anderson as a New Companion
There was as many Doctor Who comeback rumours in the 1990s as there were unlicensed spin-off videos and audio plays. One of the strangest rumours came in 1995, a year prior to the Paul McGann TV Movie. It's strange because there is actually a lot of truth to it, none of which is the potential casting.
The Daily Mail reported that Eric Idle was to play the Doctor in a new co-production between the BBC, Universal and Steven Spielberg's Amblin Television. That co-production turned out to be the McGann movie of course, and the original pitch document featured a plotline that would see the Doctor trying to find his long-lost father, Ulysses. The newspaper article cites that Peter O'Toole was to play the part of the Doctor's Dad.
It also suggested that the Doctor would, as ever, be joined on his travels by a female companion to be played by Pamela Anderson, then riding high on her popularity from Baywatch.
As we would find out a year later, all of this came to nothing and it's incredibly likely that the report was pulled from some names thrown around the production office rather than any concrete casting. Something that Eric Idle noted on Twitter recently when he retweeted an old press cutting stating: "This is so made up."
5. Plastic David Beckham
In the run up to Doctor Who's return to our screens in 2005, there was a tabloid report that claimed to know the plot of the opening episode. It correctly claimed that the Doctor would once again face off against the Autons, last seen in the 1970s.
From there, the story's accuracy promptly fell off a cliff. The plot, claimed the article, would involve the Autons replacing prominent celebrities with plastic duplicates in what would essentially be a remake of Spearhead from Space for the Heat magazine generation. One of the unfortunate duplicated celebrities would be David Beckham, in a bit of casting that was sure to draw the crowds for the show's return.
It's not quite clear where this rumour came from, whether it was a joke by Russell T Davies in a production meeting that leaked and was taken out of context or some mischievous fan over on Outpost Gallifrey. Either way, it's probably just as well such a potentially cheesy Children in Need sketch of an idea didn't actually see the light of day.
4. TARDIS No More
You don't mess with the TARDIS. Look at the outrage back in 2004 when the production team had the audacity to make the new police box prop "too fat" and "got the windows all wrong". 1980s producer John Nathan-Turner knew just how integral the blue box was to the show, and also knew what a good bit of publicity it would be to threaten to do away with the TARDIS' police box shell.
Perhaps buoyed by the response to the shocking cliffhanger at the end of Frontios Part One, where the TARDIS is blown to smithereens, he decided to promote the opening of Season 22 by telling the press that the shape of the TARDIS was about to change.
Which it does, albeit briefly, in a bit of disposable padding in the opening minutes of 1985's Attack of the Cybermen. Deciding to finally fix the chameleon circuit, the newly regenerated Sixth Doctor lands on Earth inside a fabulously painted French dresser. As the ship continues to change shape to the chagrin of the Doctor, it eventually resettles on the police box shape. Thank goodness.
3. Adam is Davros
Alas, poor Adam, we hardly knew you. Earning the dubious pleasure of being the only Doctor Who companion to be properly evicted from the TARDIS for selfishly trying to profit from visiting the future. But what happened after he was dumped on Earth with a great big hole in his head?
Many Doctor Who fans clearly wanted Adam to take some revenge against his treatment by the Doctor and got their wish in the 2013 IDW twelve issue anniversary series Prisoners of Time, in which he joined forces with the Master.
Before that however, a rumour was doing the rounds on the forums that Adam would return in the closing episode of Series 1. Most fans had guessed that the Daleks would be back in force, and this rumour posited that they would be led by Adam, or as he would now be known...Davros!
The only basis for this appeared to be his previous link to the Daleks and the fact he had a great big hole in his head where you could fit a blue eye. Some fans held firm when the Emperor Dalek was revealed and believed that he would instead be back as the creator of the Cybermen in Series 2...
2. Paul Daniels IS The Doctor
If anything was indicative of how Doctor Who was viewed by the UK tabloids before 2005's barnstorming return, it's this insane rumour. By the time of the article's publication in 2004, Paul Daniels had largely been out of the spotlight. His most recent TV appearance of note had been in a Louis Theroux documentary three years previously, which had interrogated whether Paul was ready to retire.
Clearly not, if the Sunday People was to be believed! It feels like something that was completely made up to fill space during a slow news week. "He may even be able to use his magic to defeat Daleks and Cybermen!" the article quips, and it would be interesting to see how a cup and ball trick could take out Skaro's finest.
It concludes by suggesting that Shane Richie, Eddie Izzard and Stephen Fry are also in the frame for RTD's new series, all of which seem equally unlikely, albeit for very different reasons!
Anyway, Paul Daniels never did play the Ninth Doctor, but could you imagine that iconic Series 1 trailer with Christopher Eccleston running from an explosion? "Do you wanna come with me? Because I warn you, you'll like it, not a lot, but you'll like it!"
1. Woody Allen As Albert Einstein
2007's Christmas special, Voyage of the Damned, featuring Kylie Minogue is the highest rated episode of the modern series, a record not likely to be bested any time soon. It's well-known that this festive disaster movie could also have featured Dennis Hopper, who was keen to appear in the series. RTD eventually nixed the idea, worrying that the inclusion of Hopper would draw attention from their star casting of Kylie as Astrid.
However, another Hollywood figure was also being linked to Doctor Who in the press. Comedian, writer, director and clarinet player Woody Allen was tipped to be playing Albert Einstein in the upcoming Christmas special. As a casting suggestion, you can certainly see it. However, quite how the rumour came about is unclear. A combination of the discussions with Dennis Hopper and the historian character Mr Copper, perhaps?
Given everything that's come out in recent years, it's almost certainly for the best that Woody Allen in Doctor Who was just an unfounded rumour.
Fans on Twitter are still fighting over whether or not to erase Talons of Weng-Chiang and the work of Gareth Roberts from the canon, we don't need another pitched battle!