10 More Underhyped Shows That Blew Everyone Away

Who needs marketing, anyway?

It S Always Sunny
FX

It's no secret that a lot of work goes into making a TV show. And once the casting is complete, the sets are built, the script is written and the episodes are shot, the most important aspect of bringing a series to life comes from actually getting people to watch it.

Marketing is a massive part of making sure a show doesn't crash and burn, and that all the hard work that's gone into producing the series ends up being worth it.

Unfortunately, not every studio is open to pushing their product onto the public, whether it's because they aren't sure it'll be a success, they think it's been miscast, or they're happy to let it fend for itself as nothing more than filler in-between much more popular shows.

Here at WhatCulture we've already touched on several such shows that were left high and dry by uncertain networks but managed to find a loving audience anyway, and so for this list we're going to have a look at 10 more shows that became madly popular through word of mouth and fanfare alone.

10. Charmed

Charmed Cast
The WB

In 1998, following the recent success of female-led supernatural movies The Craft and Practical Magic, The WB decided to give the greenlight to Constance M. Burge's idea for a show about witches called House of Sisters.

Unfortunately, there were some issues, with producer Duke Vincent proclaiming no one would be interested in watching a series about a group of witches who live together, aren't evil, and look like normal people.

In the end, the show was renamed Charmed, the script was rewritten, and the witches became sisters rather than unrelated roommates. According to The WB, the "family values" aspect of the story would keep more people hooked than the supernatural side of things.

The studio then tossed the show out with little marketing, put off by the messy pilot and virtually unknown cast. To their surprise, though, people at home instantly gravitated toward it, and it quickly became The WB's biggest property, consistently breaking viewership records and running for an unprecedented eight seasons.


9. Sesame Street

The Count Sesame Street
PBS

Considering it's been running for nearly sixty years and is one of the most famous children's programmes in the world, it might be hard to believe that Sesame Street got off to a shaky start and was initially undervalued by PBS studios.

Masterminded in 1966 by writers Joan Ganz Cooney and Lloyd Morrisett, the series was conceived as an educational kids show which would prepare children for school and the complexities of life.

They spent years planning and researching in order to make the show appeal to as many kids as possible, but even with their hard work struggled to get funding from any major networks. It wasn't until Jim Henson came along and got The Muppets involved that Cooney and Morrisett were given funding and a timeslot from PBS.

The show was expected to be a flop when it was finally released in 1969, but to everyone's surprise the years of hard work paid off, and Sesame Street became a massive hit and a cultural landmark, educating kids the world-over and changing the way in which children's TV would be produced for years to come.


8. Broad City

Broad City
Comedy Central

Created by stars Ilana Glazer and Abbi Jacobson, Broad City started life not as the critically acclaimed sitcom it would become, but a short web series on YouTube made during their time in a New York improv comedy group.

The series proved a big online success, especially when TV royalty Amy Poehler mentioned she was a fan and even turned up in the finale, boosting its popularity.

With their run on YouTube over, Glazer and Jacobson got to work on a pitch to make the series into a network sitcom, and with the help of Poehler they seemed destined for success. Things took a hit, though, when FX turned it down - get this - for being "too girly."

Comedy Central eventually picked it up, but did so tentatively and without ordering a full first season. It was released with minimal advertising, but managed to catch the eye of critics and various social media groups. Broad City ended up running for five seasons, and Ilana and Abbi's relatable mishaps proved to be a massive hit with audiences throughout. Not bad for a YouTube original...


7. Doctor Who

Doctor Who Second Doctor Jamie
BBC Studios

In 1963, a timeslot opened for the BBC, and the channel got to work looking for a piece of children's entertainment that would fill the gap between the popular sports programme Grandstand and the panel show Juke Box Jury.

Producers Sydney Newman, C. E. Webber and Donald Wilson banded together to bring a filler show to life, and they ended up creating Doctor Who - a fun slice of family entertainment about a time-travelling alien, originally intended to be an educational series about history and science.

Since it was designed as passable filler, the BBC weren't too concerned about ratings or fan reception, and not only did they not market it, they actually cancelled it before the first episode even aired.

Releasing episodes until the thirteenth instalment made the BBC realise they could keep it going a little longer, which proved a genius move in hindsight, because the show had become an overnight sleeper hit. And save for a brief hiatus, the show has been running consistently for over fifty years, and stands tall as one of the most famous TV series ever made.


6. Banshee

Anthony Starr Banshee
Cinemax

Banshee spent its entire run underrated, but by the end of its fifth and final season it had become something of a cult classic, and the ratings had been increasing every season at an unprecedented pace.

With little advertisement and limited audience awareness, the gritty crime-drama was brought to life by Cinemax studios, who were attempting to make more original content for their channel. Though they hoped Banshee would capitalise on Strike Back's success back in 2010, they struggled to get the marketing side of things right.

This issue was quickly solved, though, when the first season aired and set new viewership records for the network; records that would be broken with every subsequent season.

Thanks in equal part to the power of social media and the show's controversial violence, sex and shock value, Banshee proved it didn't need a big marketing campaign to get itself off the ground, just the right audience to spread its name and get others invested in things to come.


5. Seinfeld

Seinfeld The Contest
NBC

Seinfeld has always been described as "a show about nothing", and that's exactly why it seemed doom to fail.

Focussing on the mundanity of everyday life from the perspective of four narcissistic, socially incapable New Yorkers, the sitcom was created by star Jerry Seinfeld and writer Larry David, who used the series as an attempt to mix Seinfeld's stand-up with brief side stories about innocuous day-to-day happenings.

One of the show's producers over at NBC described the show as "too New York", and test audiences of the pilot loathed it so much that the network almost cancelled the show entirely.

But thanks in equal measure to the show's small gaggle of fans and NBC's inability to find another series to replace it, Seinfeld was able to finish its first season in one piece, and received a high enough rating from audiences to justify a second instalment, which featured some slight creative changes that made it one of the most-watched and critically lauded sitcoms of all time.


4. The X-Files

X Files
FOX

Taking inspiration from the likes of The Twilight Zone, Twin Peaks, and Night Gallery, The X-Files is one of those shows everyone can recognise from one still image, but it wasn't always seen as the sure-fire success story it would become.

Series creator Chris Carter had an uphill battle with Fox Studios to get the show greenlit, since the executives were unsure about the paranormal themes, but he eventually won them over. Only when he did, he hit another snag, with the studio complaining about the casting of the almost-unknown David Duchovny and theatre actress Gillian Anderson.

Both the actors eventually won Fox over, too, but even so the studio was unsure how the series would appeal to a wide audience.

When the first season aired, it broke numerous records and became an instant fan favourite thanks to relatively new use of Internet chatrooms and social networking sites. It remains one of the most enduring sci-fi series of its time, and Duchovny and Anderson secured countless awards for the work in the iconic lead roles.


3. It's Always Sunny In Philadelphia

Its always sunny season eight
FX

It's Always Sunny In Philadelphia might be the most unlikely success story on this list. Created by stars Rob McElhenney, Glenn Howerton and Charlie Day, the series was originally titled It's Always Sunny On TV, and was shot for nothing on some digital cameras in the trio's own apartments.

After some gruelling pitches and major rewrites (the original premise was centred on three out-of-work actors, but this was too similar to other shows of the time), the trio got FX onboard for one properly financed season of the retitled It's Always Sunny In Philadelphia.

The budget was still crazy low, mind, and FX was worried the dark tone, controversial jokes and low production design would ruin things right out the gate.

Come the second season, though, when the studio introduced Danny DeVito to the main roster and McElhenney, Howerton and Day had some time to refine their characters, the show's dark humour, sociopathic characters and urgent pace proved a hit with audiences, so much so that it's been renewed up to its eighteenth season.


2. Breaking Bad

Breaking Bad Walter White
AMC

It might be hard to believe now, considering it's often listed as one of the greatest TV shows of all time, but Breaking Bad was initially seen as a major gamble for AMC.

Vince Gilligan, a long-time writer for fellow shock hit The X-Files, wanted to write a show about a protagonist who became the antagonist of his own story. In his own words, he wanted to "turn Mr. Chips into Scarface."

Once he'd figured out the finer details of the plot - the story, the meth lab concept, the supporting characters - he pitched it and secured a deal with AMC, who were initially very reluctant to cast renowned sitcom actor Bryan Cranston in the lead role before being convinced by Gilligan to give him a shot.

Despite the cast gamble, a disruptive writers' strike and the unplanned future of the series, Breaking Bad chugged along to huge critical acclaim but few viewers, only becoming a ratings smash hit in its final, final episodes. Still, at least it got there in the end. You love to see it.


1. Buffy The Vampire Slayer

Buffy The Vampire Slayer
Mutant Enemy

To say that everyone was pessimistic about Buffy The Vampire Slayer would be an understatement. Following on from the 1992 movie, which flopped both critically and commercially, a series was surprisingly greenlit with director Joss Whedon as the showrunner.

With an all-new cast of characters, a change in setting and a much darker tone than the film, the series was originally produced by The WB and seemed to have very little going for it. The cast were all unknown, Whedon was young and inexperienced, and the budget was meagre.

But within just one season, Buffy The Vampire Slayer acquired a legion of fans and a positive critical reception, so much so that it would run for another six years and inspire an also-great spin-off about the vampire with a soul Angel.

These days, Buffy is consistently listed as one of the best shows of all time, and is also considered one of the most academically studied shows ever made. Not bad for a series inspired by such an awful movie.


Contributor

I get to write about what I love, which is cool. You'll typically find me in front of a TV, or hunkered down behind a book, or dreaming of things far away. Be good to each other. Find my other writings here: https://allthethingsineversaid.substack.com/