10 Most Disturbing Twin Peaks Moments
A terrifying return to the most famous murder investigation in television history...
Twin Peaks isn’t merely cherry pie and ‘damn fine’ coffee – it can be profoundly disturbing, with its dark secrets, prophecy, vice and a town under the influence of supernatural entities, intent on murder and mayhem.
To the uninitiated, Twin Peaks is maddeningly non-linear, narratively backwards (literally) and frustratingly metaphorical. Lynch’s own vocalisation is amusingly declarative, and at complete odds with his unique style of filmmaking, in a way that has made something of a cottage industry of Lynch explanation and explication alike.
Twin Peaks’ cultural impact cannot be underestimated; the red curtains and chevron floor have become part of our televisual heritage - without Twin Peaks there’s no X Files, no True Detective and definitely no Lost.
A mixture of the macabre and the everyday, Lynch’s work is not for those of transient attention. All the clues are painfully obvious if you understand Lynch’s presentation of dramatic events; “I mean it like it is… like it sounds,” explains the spirit of Mike, speaking for Lynch himself.
Lynch is as comfortable with horror as he is with surrealist cinema – here are the definitive, most disturbing moments featuring Special Agent Cooper, killer BOB and Laura Palmer’s heart stopping scream, in a town where nothing is what it seems…
10. Sarah Palmer Removes Her Face
Sarah Palmer has a more integral and sinister part to play in The Return and episode eight introduces Sarah as a teenager in 1956. As she sleeps, Sarah is blissfully unaware as a ‘frog-moth,’ the seed of events yet to pass, enters her mouth – events that become increasingly more disturbing.
Grace Zabriskie plays Laura’s grieving mother - a broken, abused woman - and The Return finds her alone, deserted by the world with no role left to play in the drama of her own life, or so she thinks.
In the fourteenth episode, as she sips a Bloody Mary, alone at a bar, a trucker decides to assail her with misogynistic, homophobic insults as she warns him to mind his own business. Some guys just can’t take a hint – Sarah calmly asks him “Do you really wanna f*ck with this?” and literally removes her face. Underneath, a sharp, spiked tongue and rows of shiny teeth remove half of the man’s neck, leaving him dying on the bar floor in a pool of his own blood.
Unusually gory and loaded with mystery, this is one of the most interesting sequences of The Return. Through ending the investigation prematurely in season two, the creature behind the face represents closure; Lynch, in his own abstract way, is telling us to be careful what we wish for - it might just come true.
9. Laura Discovers The Truth About Her Father
Twin Peaks: Fire Walk With Me, the story of the last seven days in the life of Laura Palmer, was not well received on release, yet it holds all of the clues to the mystery and a particular scene so scary that it demonstrates how comfortably Lynch can switch from surrealist cinema to unfiltered horror.
As Laura makes her way home, after a particularly odd encounter with Mrs. Tremond (in which she receives a painting which could grant her access to The Red Room), she enters her home and makes her way up the stairs to her bedroom. Note the overhead fan revolving above her, generating wind, a sure sign that something terrible is about to happen and a reoccurring motif throughout Twin Peaks. As she slowly opens the door to her bedroom, Laura moves with such trepidation that the tension is palpable.
Lynch takes the rare opportunity to give us a jump-scare.
Suddenly and without warning, there he is; BOB is wedged in between her dresser and the wall. Sheryl Lee lets rip with one of her signature screams and flees the house, only to see her father, Leyland Palmer leaving immediately after. She arrives at the same conclusion as us – BOB and her father are "one and the same". It’s a chilling moment, despite the audience already knowing the identity of the killer, brought to life by a committed and unnerving performance from Lee.
8. BOB Murders Maddy Ferguson
Regrettably, network pressure forced Lynch and Frost to reveal the identity of Laura’s killer midway through season two, effectively destroying any hopes of the show’s longevity and highlighting the profound lack of understanding placed upon Twin Peaks by executives, only interested in mainstay soap-opera style entertainment. Luckily this does not diminish the impact of this sequence, now considered one of TV's most infamous murder scenes.
Madeleine Ferguson, the spitting image of her murdered cousin Laura (a doppelganger theme runs throughout the story), came to Twin Peaks to aid in the investigation and is ultimately doomed to suffer the same fate, totally unaware that the killer is closer than she realises.
As Sarah Palmer lies drugged, unconscious on the floor, the horror of the scene plays out, sound tracked by a stuck record left revolving on its turntable, clicking with a rhythm of inevitability. BOB, now in control of Leyland, Maddy's uncle, takes the stage, illuminated with a spotlight (metafiction) and holds Maddy’s bloody body in an embrace. Leyland weeps, unable to stop himself from killing her, slamming her face into a picture frame on the wall. "It's happening again," says the giant.
It’s an intense and visceral scene, as touching as it is painful to watch. The murder is taking place in our own living rooms - Lynch is showing us the violence we have allowed to penetrate our lives, his final message to us before departing the second season.
7. The Glass Box
In 2017 Twin Peaks returned, but in what form?
Would we simply slip back to damn fine coffee and cherry pie, served in reverse by someone of unusually small or tall stature, while Cooper returns to defeat BOB and save the world? David Lynch and co-writer Mark Frost were never going to make things that easy; audiences just had no idea how right they really were.
The first episode of The Return gives us Sam Colby – a man hired for the sole purpose of watching a glass box housed in an empty warehouse. Watching an empty glass box with a tube at the back where nothing ever happens? It all sounds a little familiar – if Lynch is making a comment about television, his metaphor becomes clearer as the episode slides into straight out horror.
When Tracy persuades Sam to let her into the warehouse, it’s not long before the amorous couple have their heads violently torn to pieces in a fountain of blood by what is believed to be Judy, the 'mother of all evil in the world.' Lynch is showing us what bad TV does to our brains – it literally tears them to pieces. Judy takes the form of a faceless being with zenomorph qualities, referenced by Phillip Jeffries (David Bowie) in Fire Walk With Me, the 1992 prequel film and who is now a giant talking kettle in The Return.
6. What Year Is This?
After eighteen agonisingly cryptic episodes, Cooper, now fully recovered and on a mission to change past events, tracks down a woman he believes to be Laura, now going by the name Carrie Page. Without much persuasion (there is after all a dead body on her sofa and a conspicuous white horse on the mantle piece), they depart for Twin Peaks, arriving at night to the house of Sarah Palmer, ‘Laura’s’ mother.
Answering the door is a woman claiming to be Mrs. Tremond (played by the real homeowner and using the same name used by the mysterious old woman featured in the original series) who tells Coop that she has no recollection of a Sarah Palmer. Cooper then asks the big question, “What year is it?”
The sound of Sarah Palmer's voice calling Laura's name is heard and Lynch gives us the most fitting end possible - Laura/Carrie lets out one of the most blood curdling screams in television history.
Twin Peaks is finished, and the mystery still lingers like stale smoke in the air. What year is this? Are they the real Cooper and Laura? Do we even know what dimension they are in? Did Twin Peaks even exist? Disturbing, thought provoking rhetoric on the modern obsession with consumable TV darkness and the desire for answers. Explanation killed the investigation and by extension, Twin Peaks itself and this is what we were left with - Lynch, as usual, had the last laugh.
5. BOB Crawls Over The Sofa
BOB, Bob, or killer BOB is a TV villain of the highest calibre, terrifying, sinister and thankfully rarely seen. He inhabits the body of Leland Palmer from a young age, forcing him to abuse his own daughter and wreak terror in Twin Peaks. After Laura Palmer's murder, the anonymous killer is still on the loose, “He is BOB, eager for fun, he wears a smile, everybody run…” says Mike, one time ally of killer BOB. The denim clad demon is played by Frank Silva, originally a set decorator on location, spotted by Lynch when he was accidentally caught on camera.
In the second episode of the second series, as Maddy is left alone in the Heywood’s living room, a figure dressed in a blue denim jacket with long, scruffy grey hair appears from the right of the screen - BOB is with us. As he climbs over the sofa, staring with a murderous intent at Maddy, BOB is really staring at us. Practically shattering the fourth wall, he comes straight towards the camera, as if he will crawl straight from the screen, like Sadako from Ring, into our very own homes.
No riddles, no clues, no abstraction: BOB is the evil within us, he inhabits our minds and bodies and forces us to commit unwilling acts of extreme violence for the purposes of entertainment. Lynch is holding up the mirror to the audience, we let him in, we pay the price.
4. How’s Annie?
For 25 years, eleven months and eleven days, fans of Twin Peaks were caught between two worlds, wondering whether the past is the future and the future really is the past. One question (maybe a few more) hung in the zeitgeist: “How’s Annie?”
The final moments of the second and last series, at least in the 20th century, are considered to be one of the greatest cliffhangers in television history. Windom Earle, former FBI agent and Cooper’s ex partner, kidnaps Annie, Cooper’s new love interest (sorry Audrey). Driven by revenge, Earle brings Annie to The Black Lodge where he intends to give her to BOB and lure Cooper into his trap. BOB, however, has other plans, creating a doppelgänger of Cooper and setting Earle’s head on fire. Cooper, or so we think, returns to Twin Peaks with Annie and all is right with the world again… almost.
Returning to direct the final episode, Lynch took back control of the second season, choosing to show us what had become of Twin Peaks. You want answers? Well tough, said Lynch – Cooper, inhabited by evil BOB, and was now free to spread the evil throughout the world. How’s Annie? Who cared anymore? The investigation was over, Cooper had failed and by association, so had we. The final shot of Twin Peaks, at least until 2017, saw Cooper laughing maniacally, his face dripping with blood as he repeats, “How’s Annie?” over and over again.
How’s that for an ending?
3. Gotta Light?
Part eight: possibly the most Lynchian piece of filmmaking by Lynch himself.
What initially appears to be more of an experimental art film than an episode of Twin Peaks, 'Gotta Light?' takes a drastic shift from not only the main plot but also the visual style of previous episodes in this and the preceding two seasons.
‘Gotta Light?’ gives us the creation of evil (Judy and BOB), the birth of light and the forces of good (Laura Palmer), the purpose of the Woodsmen (purveyors of smoke, electricity and oil, the conduit of evil) and perhaps the most compelling evidence yet for theories behind the entire Twin Peaks universe – is the show actually self aware? Are the forces of evil using mainstream entertainment to corrupt our minds?
After revealing the The Fireman’s plan to use Laura’s murder investigation to defeat BOB, the Woodsmen descend upon a remote radio station in New Mexico, crushing the skulls of the technicians and implanting a new message to broadcast, “This is the water and this is the well. Drink full, and descend. The horse is the white of eyes and dark within.” In the process of transmitting the message to the world via radio waves and TV broadcasts, Lynch is citing this as the very moment our collective obsession with television began to rot our souls.
The entire episode is an anthology of disturbing moments and one of the most surreal experiences amongst an already abstract universe.
2. The Murder Of Laura Palmer
Twin Peaks: Fire Walk With Me was, at the time of release, a failure. Audiences hoped the movie would pick up the cliffhanger ending of the series and reveal Cooper’s fate. Instead, Lynch made a prequel, focusing on the last seven days of Laura Palmer, leading to the horrific murder of Twin Peaks beloved but troubled beauty queen. The film featured a more recognisable cast, with David Bowie as Phillip Jeffries, Chris Isaac as Special Agent Chester Desmond and a young Kiefer Sutherland. The final ten minutes of the film are deeply moving, showing the audience the abject horror that Laura Palmer suffered.
Dragged to an abandoned train carriage, Laura and Ronette Pulaski are bound by Leland Palmer, possessed by the spirit of killer BOB. While a guardian angel mysteriously appears and frees Ronette, Laura’s fate is sealed when Mike, BOB’s former ally and spirit now possessing the body of Phillip Gerard, throws a ring with a symbol of an owl upon it into the carriage to Laura, allowing her access to the White Lodge after her death.
Sheryl Lee gives a chilling performance, her eyes wide with terror, as her father brutally ends her life. Lynch wants the audience to witness the suffering of Laura, in an almost quasi-religious sacrifice for the sake of the story. The scene makes for very uncomfortable watching; Lee is spellbinding as the doomed Palmer, her expressive eyes and ear-piercing scream are hard to watch yet harder to forget.
1. Laura Palmer’s Screaming Doppelgänger
No Twin Peaks discussion would be complete without The Red Room, the place ‘in between worlds’ and the setting of some of the series most culturally iconic imagery; the red curtains, the chevron floor design, The Arm, The Fireman, Mike, BOB and Laura Palmer herself, all set to the beat of Angelo Badalamenti.
In the climactic episode of the second series, Lynch returned to take back control of his work and show the audience the result of revealing the killer too soon - BOB has won and was free to kill again. Fiction had become metafiction - the audience had literally affected the actions of the characters and Twin Peaks would, in 25 years time, be unrecognisable.
The final visit to The Red/Waiting Room gives us definitive Lynch and pure, unfiltered Twin Peaks as Cooper frantically searches behind a maze of red curtains for Annie. As The Arm explains the existence of doppelgängers, Cooper is faced with Laura’s double, pursuing him, white eyed and open mouthed, screaming as only Sheryl Lee knows how. With the release of The Return in 2017, it’s only now we can step back and appreciate the stunning achievement of David Lynch and co-writer Mark Frost. Twin Peaks will be remembered as not only one of the most unique pieces of surrealist television but also for what it truly is – a dream captured on film.
Or perhaps a nightmare, either way, it’s still just as disturbing.