10 Most Hated Doctor Who Characters

Over fifty years, and over eight hundred episodes... who have you hated the most?

Reactions to the new Doctor €“ the 12th, not including John Hurt€™s War Doctor and the 10th Doctor€™s petulant refusal to regenerate €“ have been pleasingly positive since the first episode of the eighth series aired on August 23rd, after some fears that younger fans of the rebooted Doctor Who would hate their new, older-looking hero. In fact, for a show that€™s been running for fifty years, Doctor Who hasn€™t attracted a vast amount of negativity €“ it€™s a deeply loved family-oriented programme that even survived cancellation, a sixteen years hiatus and a failed reboot for an American audience. When the reboot finally succeeded, it was under the stewardship of Russell T. Davies and the BBC, thank goodness. Coming in 2005, it was also under the auspice of the Internet, and the Internet is never exactly coy about making its feelings known about television shows that it loves or television shows that it hates (often, like the stalker it so often resembles, online fandom can€™t make its mind up which is which). However, the goodwill for the show is generally so intense that in researching this article, even nine years and four Doctors after Christopher Eccleston first strode in to rescue Rose Tyler from the Autons, we genuinely thought we might be on to a hiding to nothing. How wrong we were. There are some very strong feelings out there, about old school Who as well as the rebooted show. Surprisingly, there are almost no issues surrounding any of the series€™ many, many monsters and villains, no matter how despicable their deeds or how terrifying they were. The most bile seems reserved for the companions, with even Amy Pond and Rose Tyler, the two most popular companions in the revamped show€™s brief history, having their online detractors. However€

Dishonourable Mention:

€if he was ever to write himself a cameo on the show, we€™d have to rewrite this article to place current showrunner Steven Moffat at the very top of the list. The amount of loathing that Moffat inspires in the audience that loves the show that he produces is jawdropping. Going back a few years, fandom had issues with Russell T. Davies and some of his favourite themes and tropes €“ but nothing compared to this. Steven Moffat is pretty much blamed for everything that anyone ever dislikes about the rebooted show since taking over: the dense storylines, the sexual politics, the Doctor€™s characterisation, the dialogue, the companions, the lot. The writer who also gave by far the best episodes of the first four series of the rebooted show €“ The Empty Child, The Girl In The Fireplace, The amazing Blink €“ has been roundly eviscerated by online fandom for the last four years. We€™re amazed that the poor man doesn€™t feel the need to leave the house in a flak jacket.

10. Jackie Tyler

Russell T. Davies, in rebooting the show, elected to show us the Doctor and his many adventures through the eyes of his companion, placing nineteen-year-old Rose Tyler squarely at the forefront of the narrative, allowing her to soak up some much needed (and thankfully creatively delivered) exposition. Unfortunately, that also meant that we, like a nervous prom date, had to meet her mother. An overbearing single mother of one, Jackie Tyler was written to be as obnoxious as possible in series one. We needed to see that Rose wasn€™t entirely satisfied with her life €“ so much so that she might, on the spur of the moment, jump into a police telephone box with a gurning stranger and go on adventures. In reality, the 9th Doctor was a mysterious older man appearing out of nowhere to take her out for the day. Rose had probably been daydreaming about her father coming back to do that very thing since she was old enough to know that he had passed on. And if we see all the wonders of the universe through Rose€™s eyes, we also see her life, and her mother through her eyes as well. Permanently dressed to lounge on the sofa, ear-splittingly shrill and shallow, working class Jackie is portrayed as being lazy and vain, nattering away into her mobile phone while watching daytime television, as her teenaged daughter went out to work. Would you want this woman to be your mother? If you went off on madcap adventures throughout time and space, how often would you call her? And that€™s exactly the point€ we see her through a dissatisfied Rose€™s eyes. In her later appearances, we see a different side of Jackie Tyler: the tough, compassionate, no-nonsense woman who raised her daughter to echo those traits, on her own, with very little in the way of support. Long after audiences had fallen in love with Rose a little bit, they realised who made her that way €“ and by the time we said goodbye to Rose and the 10th Doctor, the additional room for characterisation had given us a fully rounded and nuanced Jackie Tyler that, yes, we€™d have been delighted to have as our mum.

9. The Absorbaloff

The showcase alien villain from the series two episode €˜Love & Monsters€™, there€™s no love for the Absorbaloff, one of the most tragic missteps in Doctor Who history. It€™s not the fault of the production design. Created as the result of a Blue Peter competition, nine-year-old William Grantham originally intended the creature to be huge €“ about the size of a bus, in fact, which would have precluded casting middle-aged comedian Peter Kay to run about in terrible make-up and what appears to be a loincloth. No, it€™s the writing €“ €˜Love & Monsters€™ was one of the episodes that was written around the absence of the Doctor, like the far superior €˜Blink€™ and €˜Turn Left€™. Without the main character anchoring the show, the story has to be clever and engaging, and this wasn€™t that. Left bored by the story, the bodysnatching Absorbaloff, with his ridiculous name and, yes, Peter Kay dancing around in his pants, was the thing everyone remembered: the howling mistake everyone pointed at. Loathed by everyone who€™s ever watched the episode, the Absorbaloff would only ever appear once, and once was more than enough.

8. Mickey Smith

Suffering from much the same issues as Jackie Tyler when he first appeared, Rose€™s innocent and none-too-bright boyfriend also got it in the neck from the writers and therefore the audiences: after all, (the reasoning goes) if Rose had had a boyfriend worthy of her, she€™d never have left with the Doctor in the first place. That€™s obviously faulty logic, and a little disappointing€ why should her hopes for a more interesting life revolve around who she was seeing? This is the 21st century. It€™s okay for young women to want a little more than that these days, you know? But Davies wasn€™t above pandering a little, and just as he gave us a shortcut to dislike Rose€™s mother, he gave us the comedy cowardice of Mickey Smith to roll our eyes at, too. Future BAFTA award winner Noel Clarke was forced to portray some of the most sniveling cringing any promising young actor, screenwriter and director has ever had to deliver. He literally wraps himself around Rose at one point in fear, utterly failing to impress her, the Doctor or television audiences, who couldn€™t really see what Rose saw in the boy in the first place and couldn€™t wait for her to leave him. It wasn€™t until later episodes recast him as a man adrift who finds his purpose (after breaking up with Rose) as the leader of a Cyberman resistance movement in a parallel world that Mickey finally got a chance to shine and to step out of Rose€™s shadow. The coda to his story, the fact that he ended up with former companion Martha, someone else who needed to become her own person and step away from the complicated Doctor-Rose dynamic, was really rather perfect.

7. Dr. Grace Holloway

Proper Doctor Who fans were always going to be on the back foot with the TV film that attempted to kickstart the franchise back in 1996. A co-production with the USA and Canada, set in America and made for an American audience, with a generic US-TV plot, ropey CGI and a half-human Doctor (thank god they junked that development), it just wasn€™t what the loyal fanbase wanted. And nowhere were fans more vociferous about their disappointment than with the new Doctor€™s companion, Dr. Grace Holloway. It wasn€™t really actress Daphne Ashbrook€™s fault €“ her first scenes have her accidentally killing the 7th Doctor during a botched surgery, causing his regeneration into the 8th Doctor. That€™s no way to introduce the main supporting character for the film. The TV film was also vilified for giving the Doctor a love interest rather than a companion. The kiss between the two resulted in a major fanstorm, a word we€™ve just coined to describe what happens when fandom roundly and unanimously defecates on a character, scene or episode from a great height. Of course, it didn€™t help that Ashbrook and Paul McGann had less chemistry than a high school English lesson. Sadly, Grace was also found to be very, very annoying. After the horrors of Peri, no long term Who fan was ready for another American companion, even a real one. When she delivered the line €œI finally meet the right guy and he€™s from another planet€, the collective groan and clunk as TV remotes were thrown at the screen could probably have been heard from the moon.

6. River Song

More than a little controversial, River Song is either absolutely, violently loved by fandom, or hated with a passion. There seems no middle ground for the Doctor€™s wife. Many choose to take out their frustrations with Steven Moffat€™s direction for the show upon River, who seems to represent for them everything they dislike about Doctor Who after Russell T. Davies left. Her appearances inevitably involve jiggering around with complex stories that lack complete explanations, something that Moffat is routinely berated for. More than that, there€™s the extrapolation of her character following Moffat€™s taking over the series in 2010, and the development of her backstory. Too many elements of her character seemed to be a variation upon the €˜Mary Sue€™ trope in fandom: she€™s an idealised but far from fully-realised character, inserted into the narrative as having an instant, important connection with the protagonist, with powers and skills that in many ways rival his own, and who usually (if not always) comes out on top in verbal exchanges between the two. River is also the subject of mystery and speculation throughout the majority of the narrative of Moffat€™s run with the 11th Doctor, and has elements of tragedy to her in her asynchronous relationship with him. Finally, she€™s revealed to be even more central to the plot than had previously been hinted at. At times, it feels as though the character has been created by an adolescent fan for use in their own amateur Doctor Who fan fiction, not by a professional writer and producer for use in their hit television show. That€™s not all, of course €“ many seem to feel that River is annoying, and that her frequent reappearances in the story are irritating rather than something to look forward to. Of course, these are the same people that find irritating any strong, capable woman who doesn€™t fall immediately in line with the hero, so we€™ll take that with a pinch of salt.

5. Vislor Turlough

On paper, Turlough was a thrilling new concept for Doctor Who in 1983 €“ a companion who had conned his way on board the TARDIS, having been charged by a malevolent universal personification of chaos and disorder to murder the Doctor. The Black Guardian had appeared as an antagonist in the show before, as the bad guy in 1978/1979€™s sixteenth season. Facing the 4th Doctor in the year-long quest to reunite the parts of the cosmic MacGuffin €˜the Key To Time€™, the Black Guardian had been thwarted, and the Doctor had been so worried about retribution that for a long time afterwards, he€™d attempted to hide the TARDIS€™ travels through time and space to prevent being tracked down for revenge. Dressed as a school prefect, and with a sinister, vulpine face, Turlough wasn€™t trusted in the slightest by the 5th Doctor€™s companions, Nyssa and Tegan, but as accepted with open arms by the Doctor himself. Fans didn€™t react well to the €˜snake in our midst€™ storyline, which seemed to spoil the cosy atmosphere on board the TARDIS, and really didn€™t like the cowardly, sharp-tongued and ruthless Turlough €“ all of which would have boded well for a villain. However, when Turlough chose to deny his master and remain with the Doctor, fans were left with a quandary€ they still really, really didn€™t like Turlough, and now they were stuck with him. To make matters worse, Nyssa had left the TARDIS (and the show) only a few weeks after he arrived, and the following year€™s Resurrection Of The Daleks serial saw Tegan leave in the end. Were they really going to have to live with the snide, creepy Turlough as the Doctor€™s only companion? Fortunately, actor Mark Strickson had decided to leave as well, feeling that the character wasn€™t gaining enough development due to the format of the show, and departed with the very next serial, Planet Of Fire. Unfortunately, this wouldn€™t make matters any better€

4. Perpugilliam €œPeri€ Brown

€because Planet Of Fire introduced us to the Doctor€™s next companion, Peri. A spoiled and reasonably dumb rich kid and college student, Peri spent most of her time asking very silly questions, screaming and being kidnapped, and wearing revealing clothing, the producers having brought her on board to add sex appeal to the show. What made the character even more annoying was that the decision had been made to make Peri American. Now, not as many people as you€™d think actually suspected at the time that actress Nicola Bryant was in fact English€ in the mid-eighties, not as much American television was broadcast on the United Kingdom€™s four television channels, and you could get away with a lot more. Bryant was also asked to retain her fake accent throughout filming and at all public appearances to maintain verisimilitude with the audience. No, the reason for the objections wasn€™t because viewers thought that Peri was fake, but rather that they thought she was real. The very English Doctor Who didn€™t need an American coming into it, messing things up. Introduced a month before the end of Peter Davison€™s run as the Doctor, the despised Peri also had the misfortune to be the cause of the 5th Doctor€™s regeneration, as the two were poisoned during the events of The Caves Of Androzani and there remained only enough antidote for one. The very popular young 5th Doctor would then transform into the most-disliked Doctor in the show€™s history, while Peri herself would bow out in peculiar fashion a year or so later, with a very significant death scene that was later revealed to be faked, her actual departure occurring off-screen. And all without ever revealing to an uninterested audience where in all the universe a girl gets given a name like €˜Perpugilliam€™. Speaking of the 6th Doctor€

3. The 6th Doctor

For Nu Who fans €“ imagine if David Tennant€™s 10th Doctor had been killed and had regenerated into Piers Morgan. That€™s the extent of the culture shock that pervaded upon Peter Davison handing over the role to the much-maligned Colin Baker (no relation to Tom). Victim of a traumatic regeneration that messes with his brain, the 6th Doctor begins his short run on the show by trying to strangle Peri, an act completely out of character for the show€™s protagonist, but which elicited cheers from a lot of the viewers watching at the time. However, even when his personality finally properly settled, the 6th Doctor proved to be irritable, grumpy, sour-tempered and arrogant€ and wore what appeared to be a clown costume. The stories Baker was given weren€™t the greatest, either. Universally loathed showrunner John Nathan-Turner, a man fandom has since charged with ruining Doctor Who throughout the 1980s, had been instructed to lighten the show€™s dark atmosphere by BBC1 boss Michael Grade. Nathan-Turner, not being the world€™s most creative force, chose to interpret this as €˜make it very, very silly indeed€™. Colin Baker wasn€™t €“ and isn€™t €“ a bad actor, just unfortunately saddled with making a silk purse out of a sow€™s ear. He€™d asked to wear black, in keeping with his Doctor€™s supposedly darker persona, only to be presented with an ensemble that wouldn€™t look out of place in a circus. He was supposed to be scarier, more mysterious, yet scripts repeatedly called for him to deliver petulant, crotchety dialogue that made him sound like a sour old uncle at a wedding. All of this was in direct opposition to what Grade wanted the show to be, causing further behind the scenes political manoeuvering. Finally, Grade gave Nathan-Turner the ultimatum: change the Doctor or lose the show. Baker was fired by courier, Nathan-Turner not even having the grace to speak to him personally, and as the 7th Doctor, Sylvester McCoy would shepherd the show gently, whimsically, but with the occasional sinister touch, to its conclusion in 1989.

2. Melanie Bush

The absolute nadir of the show's ongoing issues with awful companions occurred after Peri€™s alleged demise, the next companion proving to be actually worse in every conceivable way. Bonnie Langford, a former child star of seventies British television and dancer, joined the show in 1986 as Mel during the Trial Of A Timelord serial. A computer programmer from the tail end of the 20th century, Mel was everything that audiences had come to loathe about Doctor Who companions, that had begun with Peri. Squeaky-voiced, with a blinding, cutesy smile, Mel constantly attempts to shoehorn her vegetarian, gym bunny lifestyle upon the Doctor: like a bad pro wrestling gimmick, that was all there was to her personality so it cropped up time and time again. Without even Peri€™s alleged saving grace of adding glamour to the programme, this human chipmunk was sickly sweet and almost always did exactly as she was told, a trait that never works for a good companion. Langford was not a natural actress, feeling the need to over-emphasise her performance as if she was working on the pantomime stage. Admittedly, a pantomime was sometimes what Doctor Who resembled most by this point, but the addition of Mel as the Doctor€™s regular foil didn€™t help matters. Mel would finally leave the show in the episode Dragonfire, going off to have further adventures with a space pirate. The episode would, thankfully, introduce audiences to Sophie Aldred as new companion Dorothy Gale McShane €“ aka €˜Ace€™. The troubled teen with a fondness for homemade plastic explosive and hitting Daleks with baseball bats would prove to be one of the best companions any Doctor ever had.

1. Adric

Astonishingly, one companion stands head and shoulders above all the rest with Doctor Who fandom. Not as the favourite, but as the most despised in history - even more so than Mel. That€™s mathematical prodigy from world in the parallel universe of E-Space, Adric stows away on board the TARDIS in the 4th Doctor€™s serial, Full Circle, becoming a companion for a gratingly-long two years. Adric is a teenage know-it-all, a boy with a pathological need to know everything about everything. Always badgering the Doctor or his fellow companions, Adric€™s abrasive personality and arrogant mannerisms would set teeth on edge the entire time that he appeared on the show. He suffered in comparison with those companions, too €“ Romana and K9 were two of the most interesting and popular in the show€™s history, and when they left, Nyssa and Tegan would join the crew. Tegan in particular would prove to be the longest running companion in the show€™s history, a loudmouthed Australian with an assertive personality and a heart of gold, and she and Adric did not see eye to eye for quite some time. Adric would prove so unpopular that the decision to actually kill the character, the first time a companion had ever died on the show, was met with street parties and the declaration of a public holiday.* He wasn€™t the first companion to die €“ that€™s Katarina, the Trojan slave who didn€™t even know what a key was, and died after only a few episodes, still not understanding that the Doctor wasn€™t a god and the TARDIS not a temple. Killed failing to prevent a spacecraft crashlanding on Earth while battling the Cybermen, Adric€™s death was supposed to be lent poignancy by the fact that it was predestined: the crash was the extinction event that wiped out the dinosaurs. Unfortunately, the character was so universally disliked that the majority of viewers couldn€™t have cared less. * This may or may not be literally true, but it should have been. Who€™s the character you€™ve hated most, watching Doctor Who? Do you think they belong on this list instead of one of our selections? Tell us all about it in the comments!

Contributor
Contributor

Professional writer, punk werewolf and nesting place for starfish. Obsessed with squid, spirals and story. I publish short weird fiction online at desincarne.com, and tweet nonsense under the name Jack The Bodiless. You can follow me all you like, just don't touch my stuff.