10 Most Heartbreaking Doctor Who Moments

The Doctor, the man who keeps running, runs from a lot of heartbreak.

Doctor Who David Tennant
BBC

Doctor Who is one of the longest running shows on television. It encourages a lot of incredibly dedicated fans of all ages. Each fan has fond memories of their favourite Doctor and companions, with endless debates about who is the best. What everyone can agree on, however, is that this show will pull on your heartstrings.

Due to the changing nature of the show, and the constant change of not only the main character, but those around them there, are a never ending number of goodbyes. When it returned to our screens in 2005 with Christopher Eccleston as the enigmatic Doctor and Billie Piper as his companion, Doctor Who embraced its wild sci-fi plots but kept its human aspects. Since then there have been four more regenerations and twelve companions (not including many recurring characters and trusted allies).

There are so many moments in Doctor Who that are action packed and funny. The aliens and monsters range from laughably bad to downright scary, and even border on traumatising. However, the real reason fans follow this so avidly is the moments of humanity and heart that give the show its core.

These are the moments that made us not dive behind the sofa, but dive for the tissues.

10. Graham's Wife

Graham Grace Doctor Who
BBC

We meet Thirteen's companion Graham O'Brien, portrayed by Bradley Walsh, as he is diagnosed with cancer and falls for his chemo nurse Grace. The two married after his cancer went into remission and lived with her grandson Ryan.

In Thirteen's first episode, an electric tentacled monster attacks a train which the family is on, but they are saved by the Doctor. After this, they take the Doctor to recover at their house where Grace discovers the Doctor has two heartbeats.

In a heroic act later in the episode, Grace faces the monster one last time, electrocuting it and saving everyone. However, the kickback throws her from the crane she climbed down to the ground. She dies in Graham's arms, telling him not to be afraid.

The episode moves to Grace's funeral where Graham gives a moving speech about her life, and revealing Ryan's video we saw at the opening of the episode has been about her, not The Doctor, all along.


9. Eleven's Regeneration

Doctor Who Matt Smith regeneration
BBC Studios

This is a long build up to an incredibly quick regeneration. In but a flash of light we meet Peter Capaldi's 12th Doctor. However, before this we see a Doctor who is aged and dying, but gets a final blast of regeneration energy from a rip in time.

This boost of energy allows him to recover and revert to his younger self, still in the guise of Matt Smith. Clara walks into the TARDIS to find a bowl of fish fingers and custard, the first food Eleven ate and liked. She finds him monologuing and hallucinating a young Amelia Pond. Amy comes to him and gives a final goodbye to her "Raggedy Man".

The Doctor begins the final stage of the regeneration welling up much like David Tennant's Doctor before him, he gives a speech about how we must always move on but remember those before. It's an incredibly poignant moment for one of the more energetic iterations of the Doctor.


8. Bill Potts Cries

Doctor Who Cyber Bill The Doctor Falls
BBC

After the loss of Clara, we are introduced to Bill Potts. She becomes the Twelfth Doctor's companion until, whilst attempting to reform Missy, she was mortally wounded.

Knowing he cannot save her, the Doctor lets her be taken away in an attempt to save her life. During an attempt to rescue her, Twelve comes face to face with a fresh Cyberman who recognises him as the Doctor. He asks where Bill Potts is and the Cyberman tells him it is Bill Potts. Tragically saying "I waited for you", and letting loose one single tear.

In the next episode, we see Cyberman-Bill appearing from a spaceship carrying an unconscious Doctor in her arms. We jump forward two weeks and Bill is in a barn, a woman brings her blankets but is fearful of Bill, who believes she is still human and cannot see her cyber self.

Bill and the Doctor stand against the Cybermen so everyone can escape, she finds his body and weeps over him. She connects to Heather, a sentient oil creature, Bill becomes like her and goes with her on another adventure, leaving the Doctor to regenerate.


7. River In The Library

Doctor Who River Song Library
BBC

Time is a funny thing, we meet River and watch her die before we even know who she is. One of the few people who knows more than the Doctor, she reveals she is from his future.

In a heartbreaking speech she explains he must have always known how she died. She flirts with him, alluding to their future with a knowing wink in a style that becomes very familiar as we learn more and more about her. The Doctor asks how she knows his name to which she replies, "Spoilers" - her catchphrase, and also tragically the last word she ever utters to him.

She sacrifices herself for the entire library, saving the lives of thousands of people, including the Doctor's. River's true power comes from her identity and as we discover more and more about her, this scene becomes even more heartbreaking. But who is she? Spoilers...


6. Van Gogh's Museum Visit

Van Gogh
BBC

Not all scenes are heartbreaking due to a tragic death or the exit of a companion, sometimes Doctor Who is just simply breathtakingly beautiful. One such scene comes in the form of Vincent Van Gogh visiting the Musée d'Orsay and seeing his own work displayed.

It is an understated moment in which Bill Nighy's Art Curator talks about how Van Gogh touched everyone's lives with his art, whilst Vincent listens. Van Gogh is moved to tears and we as an audience feel such empathy for this tortured soul. Having got to know him over the episode and already warmed to him, this moment is held by fans as one of the most moving moments in Doctor Who history.

The scene is made even more heartbreaking when we, alongside Amy Pond, discover that he still died weeks later despite this. It is a moment that uses history and fantasy and paints them together flawlessly.


5. Clara's Last Moments

Doctor Who Clara diner Peter Capaldi Jenna Coleman
BBC Studios

Clara's fate, like many other companions, was not a happy one. Although her timeline is complex, sprawling, and sometimes slightly confusing, she appears throughout the Doctor's life after she is scattered into his time-stream.

In the Twelfth Doctor's final episode, he returns to Nevada and tells a waitress, who looks and sounds exactly like Clara, a story about his escape from Gallifrey. Driven mad by over 4 billion years of torture, he saves Clara from her death and runs from the Time Lords once more. Clara is neither alive nor dead, existing in a state between her last heartbeats, whilst the Doctor tries desperately to save her.

We learn in the episode that the Doctor has erased his memories of her in order to save them both. Whilst the Doctor is forgetting he says he will remember her smile and passes out. He wakes up in Nevada having forgotten Clara's identity.

He tells the waitress (Clara) how he can remember their adventures but not who she is. Clara suggests it could be her but the Doctor says he would recognise her, causing her to cry. The Doctor plays guitar as Clara walks away into a TARDIS control room and the diner disappears around him, revealing his blue box.


4. Donna's Memory Erasure

Doctor Who Donna Noble Journey's End
Tumblr

A comedic duo who stole the hearts of Doctor Who fans across the globe. The friendship between ordinary Donna Noble, played beautifully by Catherine Tate, and David Tennant's 10th Doctor is palpable.

From the start she is loud, opinionated, and wonderfully human. As the series progresses, Donna grows and learns a lot about her own self worth, becoming stronger and stronger from each experience. However, this humanity is her tragic downfall when she absorbs some of the Doctor's regeneration energy, giving her knowledge that her brain cannot contain.

She tries to hide her pain from the Doctor, but he understands what is happening immediately. She begins speaking rapidly as her mind tries to focus with all the knowledge of a Time Lord inside. To save her life, the Doctor wipes her memory as she cries and begs him not to.

When Donna wakes up she doesn't recognise the Doctor and introduces herself. The Doctor gives her a final goodbye as she brushes him off whilst on the phone. This is not only the loss of a friendship but the loss of everything Donna became, and had learnt from her experiences.


3. Bad Wolf Bay

Doctor Who Doomsday Tenth Doctor Rose Tyler Bad Wolf Bay
BBC Studios

Rose Tyler, the first companion of the Ninth Doctor, and the woman who brought the humanity back to this Time Lord. Her history with the Doctor is extensive, with parallel timelines complicating matters more than the usual time travel complications.

After visiting a parallel universe, the Tenth Doctor meets Pete, Rose's dad, alive and well. They realise the planets could be falling into the Void, and must defeat an alliance between the Daleks and the Cybermen in order to save themselves. The Doctor reunites Jackie, Pete, and Rose, and sends them to the parallel universe. However, Rose jumps back to help the Doctor.

In a heartbreaking goodbye, Rose hears something calling her to a bay. She goes there, and the Doctor appears through the breach. Rose finally tells him she loves him. Before he can respond, the breach closes, and their goodbye is cut painfully short. A moment of pure emotion between two characters follows, that is often cited by fans as one of their all time favourites.


2. Amy Pond's Death

Doctor Who The Angels Take Manhattan
BBC Studios

A running joke during their time with The Doctor was the frequency at which Rory, Amy's boyfriend, would die and come back to life. This made it all the more gut-wrenching when it was clear his final death would be the last, a fact made even worse by the death of companion Amy Pond.

In The Angels Take Manhattan, we see the pair with the Doctor and River Song fighting long-time villains, the Weeping Angels. Often agreed to be one of the scariest monsters in the show's long history, they have taken over a large amount of Manhattan, trapping people in an apartment building to repeatedly send them back in time.

Rory becomes trapped too, and it becomes clear that this time they cannot save him. After seeing his gravestone, Amy takes the risk of falling victim to the last surviving Weeping Angel in order to live out her life with Rory. The Doctor begs her not to, as there is no guarantee she will end up with him, but she turns to say goodbye, allowing the Angel to take her.


1. Wilfred Knocks Four Times

Doctor Who David Tennant
BBC

The Tenth Doctor has been haunted by a prophecy that he will die when someone knocks four times. After saving the world in a tense, and supposedly his final battle, the Doctor discovers himself alive, much to his surprise.

His relief is shattered when he hears a knocking sound. He turns to see Donna's granddad Wilfred, trapped in a containment unit about to be flooded with radiation. Selflessly, Wilf tells the Doctor to leave him, but he cannot bring himself to do that, telling Wilf that it's his honour to take his place. They swap over, and the Doctor is hit by devastating radiation as Wilfred watches on helplessly. The Doctor realises his regeneration has started, leading to a farewell tour of his companions.

The Doctor visits everyone who's lives he has touched. We see where our favourite companions are now, and finally he sees Rose before she's met him, and tells her she would have a great year.

An Ood appears to sing to him, giving him the strength to fight through the pain. He walks into the TARDIS, where he says the now iconic, "I dont want to go." He regenerates, shooting energy all about the TARDIS control room, destroying his surroundings before morphing into Matt Smith.


Doctor Who Quiz: How Well Do You REALLY Know David Tennant's 10th Doctor?

Doctor Who The Christmas Invasion
BBC Studios

1. The Tenth Doctor Defeated The Sycorax Leader With What Fruit?

In this post: 
Doctor Who
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Danni Scott hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.