10 Most Messed Up Deaths In Star Trek: The Next Generation
'D' is for 'deadly' in TNG's disturbing Enterprise alphabet of doom.
All that "new life and new civilisations" has to find its cosmic and storytelling balance somehow. When you can't seek it out, snuff it out. Continuing on from the Kirk-era's most messed-up demises, The Next Generation found new and equally creative, equally unhinged ways to dispatch its characters, main, middle, or just there for the day. If you did want to avoid the worst of fates, it was probably best to stay away from the Enterprise-D (and elsewhere) entirely. If not, then at least watch where you were walking!
Of course, one of the most infamous of awful exits in TNG, which won't be featuring on this list, because, well, we've already covered it to death on the channel — was that of Tasha Yar, sent off to the wide blue-green yonder both with and without so much as a handshake. Besides, there's still plenty to choose from if we leave Armus out… for once. Killed by a terrible toy, killed by time travel, and killed by a single thought, Star Trek: The Next Generation had it all.
Personally, I feel sorry for all those poor functionaries who have to process the 24th century death certificates. 'The cause of death was what now?!' If you say so, Doctor Crusher! Moreover, this is also Star Trek, where even the most terrible death can be just another way to live. Eat, drink, and be not a merry man…!
10. Called Me Mother — Commander Remmick And Parasite
Guess who's back in the house, and with our (mostly) sincere apologies for bringing the bluegills/butt bugs back up again! It's not an 'obsession' — that's an episode of The Original Series we covered in the previous incarnation of this list. Plus, if you can stomach the body horror of it all, the final fate of Lieutenant Commander Dexter Remmick in Conspiracy was without a doubt one of the worst in Star Trek, although his fictional serial killer first-namesake would have probably just called that breakfast.
Just how long Remmick had been walking around with mother butt bug inside him was never made clear, but given the size of the thing, it's no wonder he needed a good sit-down near the end there! "You don't understand," Mother Remmick says to Picard and Riker. No, not completely, and I'd prefer we keep it that way! Well, much like a good meal at Starfleet Headquarters, it seems, we can't always get what we want.
Everyone ends up learning a lot more than they bargained for about Remmick's innards and butt bug biology when Riker and Picard aim both their phasers and fire. Their combined power causes the Lieutenant Commander's head to explode, followed unceremoniously by 'melting-chest effect,' exposing 'mother,' who emerges snarling like she's been disturbed mid-xenomorph reunion. Picard then gives a look of most mild disgust, as though someone had scuffed the bridge carpet rather than just eviscerated a fellow Starfleet officer. And, of course, the crew of the Horatio was still very dead!
9. Death To The Dekyon Field — Crew Of The Enterprise-D…
… Crew of the Enterprise-D, crew of the Enterprise-D, crew of the Enterprise-D… and won't somebody PLEASE think of the children! Round and round they go, where the temporal causality loop stops, nobody knows… until Data figures out why three is the magic number.
A glitch in time saves no one. The cold-opener to Cause And Effect is one of the most dramatic put to screen. What a way to announce a reboot with a whole new cast! Of course not! This was just one of those weirdly beautiful Star Trek technicalities in the Typhon Expanse. They were all back to playing poker soon enough. A Riker in time saves everyone. Decompress the shuttlebay already!
Death, deal, repeat; death, deal, repeat. If having your molecules ripped apart by a warp core breach several times over weren't bad enough, the most messed-up thing was that, even though each loop was a reset, the crew became more and more aware that they'd done it all before. This wasn't déjà vu (nIb'poH in the Klingon), this was 'déjà vécu' — quite literally 'already lived'… and lived and lived.
More than that, when Doctor Crusher realised she was not just hearing voices, but actually hearing voices, Geordi and Data figured out that they were, in fact, listening to themselves — the crew on a path to disaster, echoes of the dekyon field. Now they had the .mp3 of their own doom! All that's not to mention the social death for the crew of the Bozeman of being 90 years behind the times.
8. Nightmare, Unhelmed Street — Crew Of The Brattain
What went down on the Brattain — and not the Brittain, as that was a misspelling on the filming model of the ship — was a waking nightmare. Not heard from after sending out a distress call 29 days prior, by the time the Enterprise-D showed up, all of the crew of the Brattain were dead, having murdered each other in several manners, one more brutal than the last. Full points for creativity though!
The 'rescue' in 'rescue party' is moot in this instance, as the team from the D beamed over. The Captain of the Brattain had been stabbed through the chest by a rather hefty looking dagger, one crewmember had had half of their flesh melted away by a phaser on "a setting of six or seven," and two other bridge officers were cause unknown, save for a horrible head wound and a dab of dried blood. And those are just the ones we saw without the body bags! Aboard the Brattain, the Night Terrors were made manifest — 34 dead by their own (often bare) hands.
It turned out that the Brattain had become trapped adrift in a Tyken's Rift — an energy-absorbing rupture in space — and now the Enterprise-D was stuck there too. Whilst rare and tough to escape from, Tyken's Rifts don't usually cause people to kill. There were telepathic aliens in this one too, however, and their mental distress call was preventing REM sleep in everyone but the Betazoids. If you've ever felt a little homicidal without that coffee in the morning, that's but a fraction of how messed-up it was for the crew of the Brattain!
7. Miller-Urey(-Q), Who? — All Life On Earth
When doctoral candidate Stanley Miller and supervisor Harold Urey were running their famous experiment that set out to reproduce the atmospheric conditions thought to have existed on Earth between 4 and 3.5 billion years ago (the 'primordial soup'), in order to demonstrate that organic molecules (such as amino acids) could indeed be produced from inorganic compounds in such an environment, they weren't counting on an anti-time eruption as a factor for the chemistry.
When Q transported Picard back to his "[extremely] old stomping grounds" in All Good Things… however, whilst there were already amino acids present on that prebiotic Earth, they had been stopped short of forming the first protein by the anomaly. There's the 'everyone dies and then comes back to life' messed-up, and then there's the All Good Things… 'every animal, plant, fungus, protist, archaeon, bacterium, and virus will never have existed on Earth in the first place' kind of messed-up!
It is estimated that, as of 2022, the number of humans to ever have lived was in the order of 117 billion, and who knows how many more by the 24th century (and beyond)! Plus, in the far-far-far-distant-past, the anti-time anomaly, which Picard had technically created with the convergence of three inverse tachyon pulses, filled the entire Alpha Quadrant. That's a whole lot of extra effed-up non-existence before Jean-Luc was able to figure it all out!
6. Rocky Rebellion — Crew Of The Pegasus
No good deed, or mutiny with the best of motivations, goes unpunished. Captain (at the time) Erik Pressman's plan to outmatch the Romulans by ignoring the Treaty of Algeron was less than solid, and, as a result, a good number of the crew of the Pegasus who stood up to him ended their lives as a rock. Unfortunately, in this case, they weren't just going through a phase!
One might be tempted to say that such a fate is still better than the one afforded These Are The Voyages… A certain Floridian would no doubt agree. However, no matter the method by which Commander Riker made his conscience-assuaging decision, it wasn't going to bring back anyone from inside that asteroid. Everyone who hadn't picked up a phaser to defend the unworthy Pressman had died 12 years earlier.
In 2358, when a test of the experimental (and illegal) phasing cloak went horribly wrong aboard the USS Pegasus, only eight of the crew — including Ensign Riker — who didn't join the rebellion made it off the ship with Pressman alive. From the vantage point of a coward's escape pod, it then looked as though the Pegasus was destroyed in a warp core explosion.
In fact, what they'd seen was plasma from overloading relays igniting in space. The damaged USS Pegasus then drifted in a phased state, only for the cloak to fail at the worst possible moment, killing everyone who had remained on board. The rest was covered up and classified, until Riker faced his very own kind of 'rock and a hard place'.
5. Death Is Better Than Small Talk — Baryon Sweep Bye-Byes
Had Captain Janeway been there, she would no doubt have designated Commander Calvin Hutchinson "a bit of a windbag". Of course, the smallness of his talk doesn't mean he deserved to be shot dead without so much as a saddle to defend himself, but, you know, eventually there is only so much one can say about the weather and the mating habits of the Arkarian horn fowl before disruptors are drawn. And, no, I will not call you Hutch!
At least back on the Enterprise-D in Starship Mine, there was no time for idle chit-chat — get to the point or get hit by the baryon sweep! That was indeed the fate of most of the trilithium resin thieves after barber Mot — *correction, Captain Picard — disabled their field diverter. In fact, Picard had already nerve pinched and sedated one of the meddling mercenaries, Devor, (see Tim Russ), presumably still sleeping when the sweep got to him, and wasted no time setting a Jefferies tube trap for Satler. All we heard was a scream as the latter was being hit face first by a deadly wave of green.
Picard then proceeded to crossbow another, Pomet, and turned Ten Forward into a gunpowder gauntlet. Head mercenary Kiros managed to escape, but not before Picard had ensured she would meet a highly explosive end. That's really rather a lot of killing for a Starfleet captain, although arguably, he wasn't left with too much of a choice. Plus, at least it finally gave the crew of the Enterprise-D something to talk about!
4. T-Cell Hack, Breaks The Ensign's Back — Ensign Dern
When the Captain's away, the progressively de-evolving crew will play… and kill. Don't forget kill! All it took was a teeny tiny synthetic T-cell sent to fight off Lieutenant Barclay's Urodelan flu for all aboard the Enterprise-D to turn to mayhem and murder in Genesis. With an arachnid, proto-hominid, and whatever Worf was, amongst others, roaming about, it's a wonder there weren't bodies lining the corridors. As it happened, there was only one confirmed death. Enter the introns; exit Ensign Dern.
Since everyone was going back to the wild ways, Dern's death was particularly savage. It's never stated who killed the conn officer, but proto-Riker was only in the other room! It would have had to be someone with the ancestral strength to break an upper spinal column "in three places," as per Data's in situ autopsy report. Just spitballin' here, but that also makes pure concentrate of Klingon, Worf, a suspect, too.
Not only did Doctor Crusher's hack lead to broken back, poor Ensign Dern, technically 'No Name,' unless you watch the end credits or read the script, also suffered severe lacerations to his chest and neck. By the 'I didn't sign up for this' look on his face, eyes wide-open in horror up to the ceiling, and the amount of blood, those wounds were made before death. His console hadn't done too well out of it either!
3. I Shot A Spooky Doppelgänger Of A Man — One Picard, Another Enterprise-D
In some mythologies, the appearance of your ghostly double is considered to be a harbinger of death. I suppose, in this case, death depends on who was the omen for whom. Things were already messed-up from the very beginning of Time Squared: Doctor Pulaski was clearly expecting an omelette, but Riker made (rotten) scrambled eggs instead!
It was out in the middle of nowhere, for Starfleet and the Federation at least, that the Enterprise-D bumped into the ashen-faced "facsimile" of Captain Picard from six hours in the future. Suffering from some major 24th century jetlag, dazed and confused whilst his body clock realigned, this 'other' Picard spent his final hours alive in a semi-unconscious, nightmarish state being shouted at by himself aboard the ship, his ship, he'd seen destroyed not long before.
In order to 'end the cycle,' the non-temporally displaced Picard barely hesitates in grabbing a phaser from the handily located, and hardly secured, shuttlebay locker. Picard shoots his other self dead without batting an eyelid and then goes back to the bridge to leave Doctor Pulaski with the mess. More effed-up still than all that, O'Brien then has to bear witness to his dead Captain?! Why? Isn't he going to suffer enough?
2. The Polymerisation Experiment — Lieutenant Hagler
There are yet more spooky goings-on for the crew of the Enterprise-D in Schisms: Riker's having trouble sleeping, and it's not because of his cooking; Geordi's losing connection; Mot's losing his grip on the scissors, and Data's losing his chronometer. Warm milk's not going to solve this one, Doctor!
A Polymer's Doom
Then we went to a room for some time and observed,
Why a handful of crew from the ship were perturbed.
By the clicks and the ominous light overhead,
We did miss the lieutenant not tucked up in bed.
That's not quite the poetic heights of Data, if heavily inspired by the android's slightly soporific verses, but hopefully you get the point. Lieutenant Edward Hagler probably just wanted some peace and quiet in his fancy pyjamas, but instead he was kidnapped and experimented upon by a gang of Solanogen-based lifeforms from subspace. Whatever they did to him, his "blood was turning into a liquid polymer" by the time Doctor Crusher made it to his quarters.
The last we saw of Hagler he was heavy heaving through his blue-grey deoxygenated face. We only know he died because Riker remembered to mention that fact near the episode's end. Not much of an epitaph, certainly not very poetic, but definitely messed-up!
1. Flaw In The Floor — Lieutenant jg Van Mayter
In theory, In Theory should just be remembered for its dictionary definition of a double entendre on the part of Data: "Lieutenant D'Sora just gave me what could be considered a very passionate kiss in the torpedo bay." However, whilst the rub of the plot is the deadpan android's algorithmic try at a relationship, the rest of the intrigue centres on the exploration of a dark matter nebula — the Mar Oscura — and the mysterious occurrences aboard the Enterprise that result.
Aside from Picard having to tidy up his ready room, and from Spot suddenly getting a cat-flap, there was little overly alarming about the odd incidents at first. That is until Lieutenant jg Van Mayter suffered one of the worst fates imaginable — she became a meme. No, seriously though, she died! Let's spare a thought, also, for whoever had to put the observation lounge back in order.
In joining Commander La Forge and Ensign Thorne to go check out potential structural damage between decks 36 and 37, Van Mayter found out exactly what was between decks 36 and 37 — organ and bone-crushing death! Don't worry though, Data has now confirmed his hypothesis at least! The high amounts of dark matter in the nebula were causing "gaps in the fabric of normal space," meaning that the floor had basically just opened up and then closed back around Van Mayter. All we heard was her agonising screams, before Geordi and Thorne rounded the corner to find only half of the very dead lieutenant popping up out of the carpet!