10 Most Meta Doctor Who Moments EVER
These are the moments that stand out from the show - for standing out from the show!
As hardcore Whovians, we all love Doctor Who, but we do sometimes tend to take it a little too seriously- and who can blame us? It's the greatest show in all of time and space, it deserves the utmost respect and recognition! However, it's important to remember that Doctor Who is also pretty silly, and that's half the charm. The show's creators are keenly aware of this, and as such, Doctor Who frequently pokes fun at itself, laughing at its shortcomings or simply reminding the viewer that they're watching a TV programme, sometimes breaking the fourth wall entirely to make sure everyone knows that it's self-aware.
These are the times Doctor Who got meta, the moments when the show was hyper-aware of its own existence and took a little time out to laugh at itself and wink at the viewer in an endearingly self-referential way. Some might say these meta moments ruin the immersion, but on the contrary, we think they add to it. If the Doctor is aware that they're in a TV show, who knows? Maybe they're out there somewhere watching along with us. Feel free to drop by any time, Doctor. There's a bowl of fish-fingers and custard with your name on it.
10. Time Crash
What could be more meta than two iconic Doctors taking the absolute mickey out of each other? This 2007 Children in Need special was penned by the King of Meta himself Steven Moffat, and it features Fifth Doctor Peter Davison crossing paths with Tenth Doctor David Tennant when their TARDISes collide, making for a magnificently meta mini-episode.
What makes this work so brilliantly is that the Tenth Doctor remembers being the Fifth, but the Fifth Doctor has no idea who the Tenth Doctor is, leading to some outrageous comedy. The Tenth Doctor is absolutely loving it, taking every opportunity he can to poke fun at his past, and by extension, fans of the classic series. There are well-meaning jabs at the Fifth Doctor's costume, his brainy specs, his trademark celery, and the fact that he's noticeably older than he was last time he appeared on-screen. The Tenth Doctor doesn't get off too lightly though, as the Fifth Doctor finally works out who he is with a brilliant joke at the fanbase's expense: "Oh no... You're a fan!"
This delightful special is made even more meta by the fact that Peter Davison is officially David Tennant's father-in-law, after Tennant married Davison's daughter Georgia, who happened to play the Tenth Doctor's biological daughter Jenny. Just like the Doctor himself, the meta moments in this episode aged very well.
9. LINDA
Love and Monsters may be widely regarded as one of the most excruciatingly poor offerings in the show's history, but if you look beyond the cringeworthy Abzorbaloff it's actually something of a meta masterpiece. The whole thing is Russell T. Davies' love letter to the show's fandom, and what better way to show your love of something than by making fun of it?
Enter the London Investigation 'N' Detective Agency, or LINDA for short. They're a group of people united by their encounters with The Doctor, who meet regularly to discuss their shared fascination with the mysterious Time Lord. In other words, they're a Doctor Who fan club... in Doctor Who. This is a brilliantly meta way of poking fun at fans and their quaint little gatherings, but it's also really sweet. The members of LINDA quickly become close friends, sharing food and stories and even starting their own band. It's a lovely celebration of Doctor Who fandom, and you can tell that Russell was writing the episode from a place of love having been a lifelong fan himself.
But the meta aspects of this story are also eerily prescient: the introduction of the obsessive and controlling Victor Kennedy into the group ruins the magic, and could be said to represent the bad apples within the Who fandom who nowadays are increasingly making themselves known. Monsters, the lot of them.
8. The Fourth Doctor's Acute Observation
In this self-deprecating moment from Destiny of the Daleks, the writers decided to lampshade the show's minimal budget and limited array of filming locations. Having installed a randomizer in the TARDIS to help him evade The Black Guardian, the Doctor lands in a mystery location. Thanks to the randomizer, they could be anywhere in the entire universe! What marvels and wonders await outside those doors? The possibilities are truly infinite! Sadly, however, the budget is not.
Romana opens the TARDIS' viewing port to see where they've landed, and she's greeted with the most disappointing of sights: a dull grey cliff-face, just like most other alien planets in the series. The Doctor, however, is jubilant at this most comforting view, exclaiming joyously "Oh look, rocks!" before the viewing port closes again. This brilliantly acknowledges the recurring joke among fans that every alien planet in Doctor Who looks pretty much the same, since the limited budget means they're all filmed in quarries. This is in fact Skaro, home planet of the Daleks, but it could easily be mistaken for any old unremarkable asteroid. The Doctor's excitement at seeing the same thing for the millionth time drives the self-deprecation home and implicitly thanks the viewer for suspending their disbelief.
7. The Twelfth Doctor's TARDIS Reaction
One of the more prevalent and enjoyable tropes in Doctor Who is the reaction of a new companion as they step into the TARDIS for the first time. There have been many "it's bigger on the inside!" moments, and while some have been more subversive than others, none have been quite so self-referential as that of the Doctor himself.
When the Twelfth Doctor crosses paths with River Song, he soon realises that she doesn't recognise him, allowing him to get up to all kinds of mischief without her knowing he's the Doctor. She soon decides to borrow the TARDIS and take him along for the ride, allowing the Doctor to act out his own ideal version of the TARDIS introduction scenes we've all grown so accustomed to: "Finally, it's my go!".
What follows is a brilliantly self-aware scene in which the roles are reversed, with the Doctor acting as a companion. Peter Capaldi acts his socks off, unleashing his inner fanboy with a hilarious speech that puts other TARDIS introduction scenes to shame:
"My entire understanding of physical space has been transformed! Three-dimensional Euclidean geometry has been torn up, thrown in the air and snogged to death! My grasp of the universal constants of physical reality has been changed forever."
A final nod to the camera as the Doctor explains how he's "always wanted to see that done properly" is the oh-so-meta cherry on top.
6. The Three Doctors
Multi-Doctor stories are always a treat, especially when it comes to self-referential meta moments that lovingly make fun of the show's history. The very first multi-Doctor story has one of the best examples. 1973's The Three Doctors features the first three Doctors interacting with each other, and it's simply marvellous to see. Sadly however, while Patrick Troughton and Jon Pertwee made full appearances, First Doctor William Hartnell had to limit his part to appearing on a television monitor, filmed separately with cue cards due to his declining health.
Despite this compromise, the First Doctor makes a big impact, lauding it over his future incarnations like an amused armchair critic, watching them through a screen just like a viewer would in a fantastically meta way. "Oh, so you're my replacements!" he quips, and insults the bickering pair to show them who's boss, calling the Third and Second doctors "a dandy and a clown" respectively. "Have you done anything?" he smirks wryly, making it clear that as the original incarnation he is surely the best. This comes across as a way of poking fun at fans who always complain when the Doctor regenerates, which may seem like a modern phenomenon but actually happened as far back as 1966 when the Second Doctor was cast, with a number of complaints questioning why the respectable old Doctor had been replaced by a young fool. Some things never change, eh?
5. The Bootstrap Paradox Speech
Excellent two-part story Under the Lake/Before the Floor relies on a famous paradox to make its resolution work, and what better way to explain said paradox than the Doctor giving an explanatory speech in advance directly to the viewer? The pre-credits scene of the second episode consists entirely of a monologue delivered to-camera by the Twelfth Doctor, explaining the Bootstrap Paradox to the viewer as if we are his companion (a fan's dream come true) by discussing an example involving Ludwig van Beethoven.
But it's not just the fact that the Doctor is talking to the camera that makes this scene a masterclass in meta. He's explaining the ending of the episode in advance, assisting the viewer in understanding the very story they're about to watch, even going so far as to tell them to google the bootstrap paradox. Amusingly, googling "bootstrap paradox" now brings up this very scene as the first video result. Just to cement this as an iconic meta moment, the Doctor begins playing Beethoven's Fifth Symphony on his electric guitar, which then transitions into an awesome rock rendition of the Doctor Who theme music, reportedly performed by Capaldi himself. Why can't every episode start like this?
4. The BBC Continuity Announcer
Seventh Doctor adventure Remembrance of the Daleks was set in November 1963, which any fan will recognise as the month and year that Doctor Who appeared on our screens for the very first time. It seems the show's creators couldn't resist using this to their advantage by sneaking in a cheeky meta reference to the show's airing. In Episode 2, Ace just misses the very first episode of a brand-new science-fiction television programme on the BBC.
As she leaves the room, the camera zooms in on a television set with a BBC ident on display, as a continuity announcer says the following:
"This is BBC television, the time is quarter past five and Saturday viewing continues with an adventure in the new science fiction series Doc—"
Unfortunately (though of course deliberately) the rest of the announcement is cut off by a change of scene, but even casual viewers will understand that this is a meta joke in reference to Doctor Who itself. Science-fiction, Saturday, November 1963... it all adds up! This has pretty massive implications, as it implies that Doctor Who exists as a TV show within the show itself. So how come the characters have never acknowledged it? Maybe they've never seen it! I doubt the Doctor has a TV license...
3. Missy Roleplays As The Doctor
The two-part finale to Series 10 is one of the best and most immersive stories in the show's history, so it's only fitting that it begins with a fourth-wall breaking, suspension-of-disbelief shattering scene in which Missy roleplays as the Doctor, mocking him and the show in the process. "Hello" she says, stepping out of the TARDIS, "I'm Doctor Who". Just a few minutes in and Missy has already gone meta, referring to herself by the name of the programme rather than the character, reflecting the way the actor who plays the Doctor is often credited as "Doctor Who". She takes this joke even further when she states that Doctor Who is the Doctor's real name, simultaneously poking fun at fans who get riled up when the Doctor is referred to that way and at the obsession with the Doctor's true identity.
Missy goes on to introduce her "plucky assistants" in a hilarious tear-down of Doctor Who's formula, calling Bill "Exposition" and Nardole "Comic Relief". As if that wasn't meta enough, when an alarm sounds Missy remarks "Oh, someone's watching!" in a knowing reference to the viewer's role in this self-parody. This is one of Missy's finest moments, one of many in which the first female Master paved the way for the first female Doctor, Jodie Whittaker, who's unfortunately not quite so brilliantly self-aware as Missy is here.
2. Every Time Anyone Says "Doctor Who?"
In a show as mercurial as Doctor Who, there is one unrelenting constant: every time the Doctor introduces themselves, there's a pretty good chance they'll be met with the knowing reply "Doctor Who?" Whenever a character asks this, the viewer is reminded of the show they're watching, and it would take a very sour grump not to crack a smile at the sheer cheesiness. It's always a fun little wink at the audience when a piece of media refers to its own title, but this recurring meta catchphrase is on a whole other level.
A number of slight variants have appeared over the years to subvert expectations (including personal favourite "Doctor What?") although we're yet to see a "Doctor Whom?" which seems like an obvious missed opportunity. Writers, get on that immediately. Moffat, being as meta-obsessed as he is, took this running gag and tried to see how far he could push it in Series 6, when he turns it into a plot point in the ongoing series arc. At the end of the finale, head-in-a-box Dorium Maldovar warns the Doctor of a number of impending threats, the most ominous of which is the question itself:
"The First Question. The question that must never be answered! Hidden in plain sight! [...] Doctor Who?"
This ultimately culminates in the Series 7 finale The Name of the Doctor, which again subverts the setup by smartly keeping the Doctor's true identity a secret, allowing the running joke to continue.
1. The First Doctor's Festive Greeting
The seventh episode of The Daleks' Master Plan is the closest thing the classic series has to a Christmas Special, and the First Doctor relishes in the opportunity to show off his Christmas spirit with a festive greeting not just to his companions but also to us, the viewers. After wishing Steven and Sara season's greetings, the Doctor turns directly to the camera, raises a glass, and says "Incidentally, a Happy Christmas to all of you at home!"
This has got to be the most meta moment in the show's history, as it's the only time the Doctor appears to display explicit knowledge of being on TV. He's conscious that he's in a television programme, and that people are watching his adventures from the comfort of their living rooms. There's no other way to explain it, he must be fully aware that he's a fictional character. There are no other characters in the place of the camera that he could be talking to, and he's clearly not talking to himself because he addresses the viewer directly. It's awfully nice of you to wish us a Happy Christmas, Doctor, but why must you torment us with this cursed knowledge? Nobody knows for sure whether this line was in the script or a mischievous bit of clever improvisation from William Hartnell, but either way, once you've experienced this fourth-wall breaking meta moment the Whoniverse will never be quite the same again.