10 Most Underrated Buffy The Vampire Slayer Scenes

These scenes from Buffy the Vampire Slayer deserve much more recognition...

spike buffy
Mutant Enemy

Buffy the Vampire Slayer is an odd show. It’s a mixture of horror, fantasy, drama, and comedy that’s held together by exceptional characters, quirky dialogue, and plenty of thrilling plotlines.

The show’s unique identity is key to its popularity, and fans still love to talk about their favourite moments from the gang’s adventures in Sunnydale. Of course, certain scenes stand out more than others. The end of each season always features an unforgettable battle, and there are also some episodes – like ‘Hush’ and ‘Once More, With Feeling’ – that are packed with iconic scenes.

But there are plenty of other scenes that don’t get enough recognition. Indeed, some of the best moments involve simple yet compelling conversations between the central characters, touching upon themes such as loss, isolation, and responsibility. Other underrated scenes have a more relaxed and humorous tone, providing the audience with a healthy dose of comic relief.

Given how many episodes there are, underrated scenes aren’t uncommon when it comes to Buffy the Vampire Slayer. And whilst every fan will have their own opinion on the matter, the following scenes are undeniably brilliant.

10. Willow Kisses Oz (Season 2, Episode 15)

Oz Willow Buffy
Mutant Enemy

In the fifteenth episode of Season 2, the gang are kept busy by a rampaging werewolf. They soon learn that Oz – Willow’s new love interest – is the werewolf in question, and they manage to take him down with a tranquillizer gun.

The episode ends with an adorable exchange between Oz and Willow, and this scene is a great example of the show’s ability to merge the supernatural with the everyday. Oz talks about managing his condition, whilst Willow assures him that she still wants to go out with him.

Alyson Hannigan is particularly good here, delivering her lines with plenty of cutesy mannerisms. And just when you think the episode is about to end, Willow bounces back into view and exchanges her first kiss with Oz. It’s the perfect end to the episode and leaves the audience with a warm sense of satisfaction.

Whilst there are plenty of other Buffy scenes that include some cute dialogue (especially during the early seasons), the end of this episode is the most adorable moment in the show.


9. Giles Teams Up With Spike (Season 4, Episode 12)

Giles has a tough time in Season 4. Following the destruction of Sunnydale High, he finds himself unemployed and without a sense of purpose.

His situation becomes even worse in the middle of the season when Ethan Rayne turns him into a Fyarl Demon. Giles is desperate to find help, but – most unfortunately – he can only speak Fyarl, and there’s only one person who can understand what he’s saying: Spike.

Despite their conflicting personalities, Spike and Giles have terrific chemistry during this episode. When they first encounter each other, they exchange some amusing dialogue before Spike agrees to offer some assistance for the price of $200. Their comedic partnership continues to entertain as Spike takes the wheel of Giles’ car and struggles to keep the vehicle under his control.

Though Giles and Spike have had plenty of conversations before, this spontaneous partnership maximises their offbeat chemistry. It’s just a shame it doesn’t go on for longer.


8. The First Evil Envies Our Heroes (Season 7, Episode 20)

Buffy Spike touched
The WB

Throughout Season 7, our heroes are pursued by the First Evil, a villainous entity that manipulates the living by transforming into ghosts of the dead. This entity – as the name suggests – has no redeeming qualities. But towards the end of the season, something rather strange happens.

As our heroes get together for a night of intimacy, the First Evil watches on and, rather than denouncing their actions, admits to feeling envious. It’s a small moment, but it takes the audience totally off guard – in a good way. Up until this point, the First Evil hasn’t shown an ounce of humanity. Its sole purpose has been to manipulate others into doing evil deeds. Yet in this scene, it vocalises something that all human beings experience on a regular basis: envy.

Whilst this isn’t enough to make us feel sorry for the First Evil, it’s certainly an intriguing part of the episode that’s rarely acknowledged by the Buffy fanbase.


7. The Gang Discuss Willow’s Rescue (Season 3, Episode 19)

Buffy the Vampire Slayer
Mutant Enemy

Towards the end of Season 3, the Scooby Gang break into Sunnydale City Hall and steal the Box of Gavrok, a mysterious chest containing thousands of spider-demons that are essential for the Mayor’s transformation into Olvikan. Unfortunately, Willow gets captured, and the gang discuss their options back at the library.

Buffy believes they should give the Mayor the Box of Gavrok in exchange for Willow. Wesley – the new Watcher – disapproves of this plan, insisting that the box must be destroyed. An intense argument then follows, but the conversation soon comes to an end when Oz – Willow’s boyfriend – gets to his feet and smashes a vase in frustration, forcing Wesley to drop his objections.

Watching Oz assert his authority like this is very satisfying, as he’s normally the calmest member of the group. But in this scene, he forces Wesley to abandon his heartless diatribe and demonstrates just how much he cares for Willow.


6. Tara Rejects Her Family (Season 5, Episode 6)

Buffy Tara Family
Mutant Enemy Productions

Tara first makes an appearance in the middle of Season 4, and though she strikes up a close relationship with Willow, she struggles to fit in with the rest of the group…at least to begin with.

In the sixth episode of Season 5, Tara’s family arrive in Sunnydale and demand she returns home immediately. Later, we learn that Tara’s family created a fake legend, which claims that all the women in their family have demonic powers. With a little help from Spike, the gang soon discover the truth, and Tara – despite her family’s persistence – refuses to leave.

This is a watershed moment for the young witch. By rejecting her toxic family and embracing the Scooby Gang, Tara is able to move on from her past and accept her true self. Amber Benson’s performance is fantastic here. She nails the transition from guilt and sorrow to relief and happiness, making us adore her even more than usual.

Tara’s arc may not be as remarkable as some of the other characters, but this scene doesn’t disappoint in terms of emotional impact.


5. Buffy Tells Tara She’s Sleeping With Spike (Season 6, Episode 13)

Buffy the vampire slayer
Warner Bros.

The Slayer goes through a tough time in Season 6, especially in Episode 13. Following some magical trickery by Warren and his two minions, Buffy is duped into thinking she’s committed murder. And though she eventually learns the truth, this traumatic experience does nothing to improve her troubled mind.

At the end of the episode, Buffy has an emotional exchange with Tara and reveals that she’s sleeping with Spike. Buffy struggles to articulate her feelings as tears roll down her face and Tara does her best to offer some words of comfort.

The performances from Sarah Michelle Gellar and Amber Benson are great, but the writers also deserve credit for taking a risk. Most of the time, the show ends with a sense of closure, a revelation, or a cliff-hanger. But this time, we’re simply left with Buffy’s emotional breakdown.

It’s a bold and unpleasant way to finish the episode, but it leaves a lasting impression upon the audience.


4. Giles Threatens Principal Snyder (Season 3, Episode 2)

At the end of Season 2, Principal Snyder expels Buffy from Sunnydale High, and he still refuses to let her back in when she returns at the start of the next season.

Giles, determined to fix this problem, confronts Snyder directly. The two of them have a passive-aggressive exchange in the principal’s office. Though it’s a short conversation, you can feel the tension in the room as they do their best to undermine each other – it’s clear that they both share a sense of mutual hatred. But despite how good the dialogue is, the most memorable aspect of this scene is more physical.

As the principal attempts to leave, Giles pins him against a filing cabinet. It’s a joy to experience the principal’s expression of shock and fear, especially because he’s normally so smug and condescending. And as for Giles, it’s thrilling to watch him abandon his polite demeanour and force the principal into compliance in such a physical way.


3. The Knights Of Byzantium Attack The Caravan (Season 5, Episode 20)

Buffy the Vampire Slayer The Knights Of Byzantium
The WB

Towards the end of Season 5, the Scooby Gang are forced to leave Sunnydale when Glory learns that Dawn is the Key. Unfortunately, Glory isn’t the only one who’s interested in Dawn. Hellbent on destroying the Key before Glory can get to it, the Knights of Byzantium pursue the gang away from Sunnydale, which leads to one of the best action sequences in the entire show.

What’s great about this scene is how relentlessly intense it is. From the moment the knights make an appearance, the gang are placed under a terrifying amount of pressure. Spike – unable to expose himself to the sunlight – is forced to stay inside the caravan, leaving Buffy to do most of the fighting on her own. Giles, meanwhile, does his best to ram the caravan into their attackers while the others try to remain hidden.

The gang’s sense of desperation is wonderfully balanced with patches of humour – Anya whacking one of the knights with a frying pan is particularly amusing. And then, just when you think they're safe, Giles is hit by a spear, causing the caravan to crash in the middle of the road. It’s a fitting end to a terrific action sequence that deserves as much – if not more – recognition than some of the season finales.


2. Faith Has Fun With Spike (Season 4, Episode 16)

Faith as Buffy with Spike - Who Are You?
Mutant Enemy

In the middle of Season 4, Faith wakes up from a coma and is determined to get revenge on Buffy. After a furious fight in the Summers’ household, Faith activates the Mayor’s device, causing the two Slayers to switch bodies.

Faith, now free to roam around in the body of her nemesis, enjoys herself by slacking off patrol duty and heading down to the Bronze. After a brief dancing session, she bumps into Spike, which leads to an unforgettable conversation.

At first, Faith has no idea who she’s talking to, but when she figures out the identity of the blonde-haired vampire, she does not hold back. As well as making a mockery of Buffy’s moral code, Faith teases Spike by getting up close and personal:

“I could ride you at a gallop until your legs buckled and your eyes rolled up. I’ve got muscles you’ve never even dreamed of. I could squeeze you until you popped like warm champagne, and you’d beg me to hurt you just a little bit more. And you know why I don’t? Because it’s wrong.”

It’s rare to see Spike looking so uncomfortable. Normally, he’s the coolest guy in the room, but in this scene, he struggles to maintain his composure as he’s teased and humiliated by the Slayer. Though the entire episode is full of highlights, this little exchange is the standout moment.


1. Buffy Tells Spike She Went To Heaven (Season 6, Episode 3)

Buffy The Vampire Slayer Spike
Mutant Enemy

Following Buffy’s death at the end of Season 5, Willow comes up with a plan to bring her back. With the help of some Vino de Madre and the Urn of Osiris, she successfully performs a resurrection spell, causing Buffy to wake up inside her own coffin.

But Buffy’s comeback doesn’t go smoothly. She feels disconnected from the world around her, and she can’t even bring herself to speak at first. Though she improves as time goes on, she still feels isolated from her friends, and at the end of ‘After Life’, Buffy tells Spike the truth:

“I was happy. Wherever I was, I was happy. At peace. I knew everyone I cared about was alright…Time didn’t mean anything. Nothing had form, but I was still me…And I was warm. And I was loved. And I was finished…I think I was in heaven.”

At last, we understand why Buffy feels so isolated from her friends. If it wasn’t for their intervention, she would have remained in heaven, free from the burdens of the real world. It’s an emotional revelation backed up by a superb delivery from Sarah Michelle Gellar and a moving score to go along with it.

Some fans believe the show should have ended with Season 5, but brilliant scenes like this prove just how wrong they are.


Harry Potter Or Buffy The Vampire Slayer Quiz: Who Said It – Hermione Or Willow?

Harry Potter Hermione
Warner Bros.

1. “I Know A Spell When I See One. I've Read All About Them."

Contributor

Love to read and write. Have an unhealthy obsession with Harry Potter. Enjoy running up hills.