10 Movie Stars Who Appeared On Are You Afraid Of The Dark (Before They Were Famous)

Ayad Gif No show within any 90's kid's childhood delivered the scares better than Are You Afraid of the Dark. Sorry, Goosebumps - you were good but nowhere near as frightening. The introduction alone was enough to give one nightmares and is arguably the scariest part of the entire show. For those of you who slept through the 90's - or were unfortunate enough to be born in the new millennium - the premise of the show is that a group of kids dubbed the Midnight Society gather around a campfire to tell bone-chilling tales of horror. The series is presented in true anthology style as each episode focuses on one member's story and very often focused on an issue they were facing in their reality. It's quite entertaining, and blissfully nostalgic, to go back through the episodes and re-experience the terror firsthand. You'll notice plenty things that are new to you, but one of the more interesting things you'll notice are a few familiar faces. Are You Afraid of the Dark, like any anthology series, featured a variety of guest spots by famous actors and actresses. The difference here is that they weren't yet famous. To see what some stars were up to in their pubescent days click next to begin.

10. Jewel Staite

--> --> Jewel Every fanboy's dream girl, Jewel Staite is well known for her starring role in Joss Whedon's short-lived, but wildly entertaining, space western Firefly. She went on to become a staple in another sci-fi series, Stargate Atlantis and had many guest spots in other shows such as Supernatural and Warehouse 19. It's no wonder the nerds love her but before she became the Leia of their dreams she appeared in two episodes of Are You Afraid of the Dark. In "The Tale of Watcher's Woods," Jewel played a bad girl who gets stuck at summer camp. Her character comes complete with a habit for smoking despite being only eleven at the time and appearing in a show marketed towards children. Talk about scary. Exactly one year later she made another appearance in a more flattering role as an aspiring painter. In "the Tale of the Unfinished Painting" an evil art teacher lures young artists into working on unfinished paintings using enchanted brushes that trap them in the work. If you're a Jewel fan these are two episodes you should definitely check out. Though the acting may seem rather, well, childish, at first when you compare the two, in which she plays two very different girls, you can see how her acting really shines. Jewel recently appeared in five episodes of AMC's The Killing but no future projects have been announced.

9. Melissa Joan Hart

Joan Hart-->--> Before she was a teenage witch with a knack for trouble, Melissa Joan Hart played on Nickelodeon's Clarissa Explains it All. Though the series didn't project her to fame it was a decent start and Nickelodeon did their best by casting her in an episode of Are You Afraid of the Dark in 1993. What makes Melissa's appearance on the show so interesting is that the character she plays is cold and somewhat of a bully. Melissa hasn't touched a role like this since so it's quite fascinating to see her display her acting chops at such a young age. The story is "The Tale of the Frozen Ghost" in which Melissa plays the babysitter to a young boy sent to stay with his elderly aunts. Her role is akin more to a nanny - why such a young girl would have such a position is beyond us - as she travels and lodges with him as well. The culprit behind the episode is the ghost of a young boy who froze to death, and Melissa's character has no qualms about teasing the protagonist for his belief, and fear, of ghosts. Funny how her character is naturally so cold in an episode tied to this theme, but perhaps it's just that we perceive her as a tad more cruel than she actually is as we're used to seeing her in friendlier roles. Melissa is currently starring in Melissa & Joey alongside the eldest of the Lawrence brothers - Joseph.

8. Ryan Gosling

--> --> Goslings Pretty boy Ryan Gosling has far more than his good looks going for him. Having given amazing performances in films such as Lars and the Real Girl, Drive, and Half Nelson it could be said he's one of the greatest actors of his generation. However, far before he was amazing critics in these films, or seducing lonely women in the wildly overrated The Notebook, a young Gosling made his acting debut in one of the best episodes of Are You Afraid of the Dark - "The Tale of Station 109.1" The story centers on Gosling's character's younger brother - a morbid boy with a fascination for the macabre. Things turn upside down for the boy when he hears the ominous broadcast of Station 109.1 and is mistaken for a dead man. Also featuring a guest appearance by Gilbert Gottfried as the radio host, the boy is coerced into entering the afterlife before his time and Gosling has to step up to save him. It's also worth noting that one year later Gosling made an appearance in the Goosebumps episode Say Cheese and Die - one of the most popular of the Goosebumps series. To see Gosling before he became a heartthrob you should definitely check out these early performances. However, Ryan shows no sign of slowing down with films being released this year and projects announced for next year as well.

7. Mia Kirshner

--> --> Mia Kirshner There are many roles Kirshner may be known for be it her sexy Catholic schoolgirl dance in Exotica or her role as incestuous slut Catherine in Not Another Teen Movie. What many fans best remember her for, however, was her flip-floppy role as bisexual/lesbian Jenny Schecter in Showtime's The L Word. It seems that no matter what role she's most associated with one thing is for certain - they're all defined by a strong sexual charge. Before Mia grew into this archetype, however, she was featured in a more innocent role on Are You Afraid of the Dark. The episode "The Tale of the Hungry Hounds" featured Kirshner as a young girl who becomes possessed by a deceased aunt when she finds her old jockey uniform. Beckoned by some intangible force, the girl and her cousin enter a portal to another realm in which Kirshner's character becomes obsessed with "feeding the hounds." The episode isn't among the most memorable of the series but is worth watching to see a young Mia Kirshner give an ambient performance. Mia is currently starring in sci-fi series Defiance which has just announced a second season set to premiere next year.

6. Aaron Ashmore

Ashmores While his twin brother Shawn was appearing on the big screen as Iceman in the X-Men films, Aaron Ashmore made his home on the small screen as Jimmy Olsen in the WB's Smallville. Though Shawn's role garnered him more attention Aaron refused to slow down with starring roles in Veronica Mars, Warehouse 13, and Lost Girl. What many may not know is that Aaron received a bit of a head start in acting having appeared in the episode "The Tale of the 13th Floor" in 1993. Playing - of all things - a twin brother to the female protagonist, Aaron's character visits the abandoned thirteenth floor of their apartment building only to discover it has some new, quirky residents. It turns out that the twins aren't as related as they believe in an amusing twist. Aaron later went on to star in another episode during the short revival in 1999, "The Tale of the Lunar Locusts" this time appearing alongside the massively popular Tara Lipinski. Aaron continues to play on Syfy's original series, "Warehouse 13" and his character has garnered a great deal of positive attention when the character was revealed to be gay. No matter whom Aaron is playing he has proven he has the skill to pull off the performance and can thank Are You Afraid of the Dark for giving him his start.

5. Eddie Kaye Thomas

--> --> Eddie Kaye Thomas Best known for his role as Finch in the raunchiest of teen comedies Eddie Kaye Thomas became personified as the class geek. That was until he banged Stifler's mom and his geek status quickly elevated to cool. But Thomas was cool years before American Pie hit theaters having made his acting debut in a 1994 episode of Are You Afraid of the Dark. In "The Tale of the Curious Camera," Eddie's character comes across an old Polaroid whose pictures foretell misfortune for its subjects in a plot eerily similar to a popular Goosebumps tale. The episode isn't entirely original and follows a rather predictable plot but if you're a fan of Thomas it's one you'll definitely want to check out. It's interesting to note that another entry on our list, Ryan Gosling, starred in the very episode of Goosebumps this one resembles. Thomas recently appeared in American Reunion alongside former castmates and currently voices Barry on American Dad. His next film, The List, is currently filming and set to premiere next year.

4. Hayden Christensen

--> --> Hayden Christensen Making a big splash playing Anakin Skywalker in Star Wars: Attack of the Clones, Hayden Christensen became one to watch despite the new trilogy lacking more than just a decent script. With his charming good looks Hayden's acting was the last thing on the minds of his audience. Before he became well-known for whatever it is he's known for - be it his roles or his good looks - Hayden made an appearance on the 1999 revival of Are You Afraid of the Dark. In "The Tale of Bigfoot Ridge" Hayden plays a teenage boy who joins his sister on an expedition to find her missing friend after she skied off into an isolated mountain area. Things aren't as they seem, however, when the two finally meet the missing girl who has aged well beyond her teen years. According to the aged girl an evil creature is responsible and will be coming back to finish the job. Though certainly not the best of the series it does incorporate a creepy, isolated feel and is definitely one to watch if you're a fan of Mr. Anakin Skywalker. Christensen hasn't been seen since 2010 but currently has quite a few projects in the works. All are either filming or in pre-production and each is set to premiere in 2014.

3. Neve Campbell

--> --> Neveveveveevevevevev The literal Queen of Scream - Neve Campbell gained her popularity as the enduring protagonist of Wes Craven's slasher spoof though she was screaming on film prior to its release. Released the same year as Scream in 1996 were The Canterville Ghost and The Craft making Campbell no stranger to the horror genre. In fact, she had already done a few roles in the mystery and paranormal genre prior to her appearance on Are You Afraid of the Dark but none are so worthwhile as her appearance in "The Tale of the Dangerous Soup." This story is among the strangest the series has to offer featuring recurring antagonist Dr. Vink. When Vink opens a new restaurant and charges a hundred dollars a bowl for his mysterious soup his employees can't help but wonder what his secret is. When one waitress sneaks a taste Vink doesn't take to it lightly and shows the young girl the ingredient - fear. Neve and her less-than-appealing costar must stop Vink before he makes soup of them all. Be prepared for some eerie fun and one of the most disturbing endings of the entire series. Seeing a young Neve Campbell pre-Scream is just the proverbial icing on top. Campbell showed us she's still a survivor having appeared in 2011's Scream 4. In 2012 she appeared in a miniseries based on the Titanic and has a few projects announced for the upcoming year.

2. Tia And Tamera

Tiatamera It can be argued that these sassy sisters were made famous before their guest appearance on Are You Afraid of the Dark. Sister, Sister premiered in 1994 but didn't take off until it was picked up by the WB the same year the twins appeared in the episode "The Tale of the Chameleons." Rather than playing twins as the two have become known for, Tia plays the protagonist while Tamera portrays the evil being that takes on her form. In the episode, a young girl is bitten by a chameleon - played wonderfully by an iguana - and it takes on her shape while causing her to revert to its form. She has to find a way to change back and convince her friend which is the real one in order to stop the evil chameleon's plans to change their family and friends. The episode is a classic in the series and features one of the darkest endings the show has ever aired. If you enjoyed Sister, Sister or are just fans of the Mowry twins in general it's one episode you must see. Tia Mowry has been keeping busy starring in BET's The Game which ended in 2012 and has now debuted a new show with Nick at Nite titled Instant Mom. Tamera's last acting job was last year in made-for-tv movie Christmas Angel. Both are keeping busy raising children of their own.

1. Jay Baruchel

--> --> Jay Funny guy Jay Baruchel grabbed our attention playing in comedies such as Knocked Up and Tropic Thunder. He would go on to grab leading roles in films like She's Out of My League and The Sorcerer's Apprentice while voicing protagonist Hiccup in viking tale How to Train Your Dragon. Jay kept busy in his younger years as well, and could be called the king of Are You Afraid of the Dark guest appearances having made a total of four playing a different character in each. His first was in the terrifying "Tale of the Dead Man's Float" in which he has a small role as a boy that drowns in the school pool. This was Jay's acting debut and he obviously enjoyed the experience going on to feature in three more episodes when the series was revived in 1999. In "The Tale of the Zombie Dice" Jay plays second fiddle to a gambling protagonist under threat of being made a human pet. He later had a small part in "The Tale of the Walking Shadow" in a plot involving a haunted play. "The Tale of the Time Trap" sees Jay take the lead role in his last appearance on the show in a story about a malevolent genie with an all-so-common "be careful what you wish for" motif. If catching Jay in all of these appearances is a bit overwhelming for you stick with "The Tale of the Dead Man's Float." His appearance may be incredibly brief but the episode itself is among the top five of the entire series and has left many children fearing the swimming pool. Baruchel has been voicing Hiccup in Dragons: Riders of Berk for Cartoon Network and two sequels to How to Train Your Dragon have been announced. He will also have a role in 2014's remake of RoboCop and is starring in upcoming flick Don Peyote alongside Anne Hathaway. What other old shows feature some top stars before they were famous? What were some of your favorite episodes of Are You Afraid of the Dark? There's plenty to discuss so hit the comment section below!

Contributor
Contributor

Articles published under the WhatCulture name denote collective efforts of a number of our writers, both past and present.