10 Netflix Original Shows Cancelled After One Season

For better or worse, these shows didn't survive past their debut...

Gypsy 2017
Netflix

Netflix have always had a serious flaw when it comes to letting some of their TV shows come to a natural end, with fan favourites Santa Clarita Diet, Glow, The OA, various Marvel series and many, many more biting the dust prematurely over the years.

But although these losses were tough to bear for many fans, they at least got a few great seasons to strut their stuff before the streaming giant pulled the plug.

The same cannot be said for the following 10 shows, however, each of which were axed after (and in some cases during) their first season's debut.

Whether they were cut loose because of lacklustre critical reception, irreconcilable creative differences, high budget demands or simply a lack of faith in the material, every show on this list was cancelled before they properly got a chance to take-off.

Of course, not every show on this list was destined for major success, but regardless of what could have been, few shows deserve to be removed from audiences' lives at such an early point in their run...

10. The Irregulars

The Irregulars
Netflix

It might seem like forever ago now, but back in early 2021 The Irregulars aired to positive reviews and a strong audience reception, with many critics commenting on its strong cast work and narrative potential moving forward.

Unfortunately, the adventure series didn't get a chance to realise said potential, because Netflix axed it from their roster after its debut, and is so often the case refused to give a reason behind the cancellation.

An excellent, spooky riff on the work of Sir Arthur Conan Doyle, the show followed a group of teenagers living in Victorian London alongside Dr Watson, solving crimes seemingly linked to the supernatural.

Given its exciting premise, inventive genre-mixing and the top-pier work of its predominately young cast, it's difficult to say what could have caused the show to see its time cut so short, but it's safe to say it was a bad move all the same.


9. Turn Up Charlie

idris elba turn up charlie
Netflix

You can be forgiven for forgetting Idris Elba's comedy-drama Turn Up Charlie existed at all, since it came and went with a whimper before slipping into obscurity.

The story of a struggling DJ who agrees to nanny for his famous best friend, the fun dramedy features Elba firing on all cylinders, whilst the writing around him fails to match his effortlessly cool star power.

Cancelled after its first season, the show was cut loose with a statement from Netflix reading:

Turn Up Charlie will not return for a second season. We're especially grateful to star and executive producer Idris Elba, who turned his passion for DJing into a witty, heart-warming comedy series... We look forward to continuing our relationship with Idris on future projects.

Though the statement gave no reason behind the cancellation, the show had received pretty poor reviews for its derivative story and writing during its short-lived run, so it's a safe bet that's what caused things to go wrong.


8. V Wars

V Wars Netflix
Netflix

Starring Vampire Diaries favourite Ian Somerhalder and set in a world fractured by an increasingly deadly clash between humans and vampires, V Wars seemed poised to be a big hit for the streaming service.

Add to its apocalyptic setting and star appeal its unapologetic violence and dark tone, and it seems on paper that V Wars really should have been a massive success.

Alas, this was not the case. Despite semi-decent audience numbers and its clear potential, the horror series was cancelled after one ten-episode season, marred during its short run by poor reviews aimed at its acting and wonky tone.

In-keeping with their practice of staying hush-hush about why certain shows were axed, Netflix haven't said anything about V Wars' demise, but the show's reviews really speak volumes.


7. Gypsy

Netflix Gypsy Naomi Watts
Netflix

A psychological drama series starring Oscar nominee Naomi Watts as a therapist who manipulates her patients and interferes with their lives behind their backs, with a Fleetwood Mac theme song re-recorded by Stevie Nicks? What could go wrong?

As it turns out, basically everything went wrong with Gypsy, a series that showed great promise but was rightly savaged by critics due to its preposterous premise and heavy-handed melodrama.

The cancellation of the show after its first season was quite complicated behind-the-scenes, mind, since the producers were under the impression they'd get a renewal and already had much of a second season written and ready to go.

Netflix's views on the show's unceremonious end basically came down to the fact that they needed to cancel more shows because they had too many in the pipeline at once. Besides, considering how genuinely poor Gypsy was, ending it early was probably a good call in the long run.


6. The Dark Crystal: Age Of Resistance

Dark Crystal
The Jim Henson Company

The Dark Crystal's cancellation is an inexplicable one even by Netflix's standards. Featuring an all-star cast, fantastic visuals, awe-inspiring puppeteer work and a great story, the show seemed poised to run for years before its shocking axe.

A prequel to the 1982 Jim Henson fantasy flick Dark Crystal, the show was met with widespread critical acclaim, noted for its excellent fan service and the inspired work of its cast, which included the likes of Mark Hamill, Nathalie Emmanuel, Taron Egerton, Anya Taylor-Joy, and Andy Samberg amongst many, many others.

The main speculation doing the rounds about the show's cancellation is to do with the cost, since Netflix tend to measure a show's value based on how many viewers it achieves versus the price tag attached to production.

Looking at the show's expansive world-building and effects, it's fair to say the show was deemed too expensive to keep running, though this doesn't feel entirely fair considering it had just won an Emmy and scored so highly with critics.


5. I Am Not Okay With This

I'm Not Okay With This
Netflix

A quirky and original coming-of-age comedy-drama about a young woman who discovers she has telekinetic powers, I Am Not Okay with This was at once a clever supernatural series and a touching portrait of friendship and teenage hardships.

Unfortunately, the series ran for only seven of its planned eight-episode first season, with production shut down by the COVID-19 pandemic back in August of 2020.

Receiving strong reviews all aimed at its progressive themes and the performances of former It co-stars Sophia Ellis and Wyatt Oleff, the show's cancellation was met with great upset from fans.

Worse still, although there had been no official renewal for another season, it was strongly believed the series would get another instalment, so much so that writing had practically finished on the next chapter. Hopefully Netflix will find room for it in the future.


4. Everything Sucks!

Everything Sucks
Netflix

Often fairly compared to fellow one-season hit Freaks and Geeks, Everything Sucks! took place in an American high school in the mid-90s, following two groups of misfit students as they navigate the complexities of growing up and finding themselves.

At once a witty deconstruction of 90s teen culture and an affecting portrait of complex issues such as sexuality, mental health and romance, the show was mostly well-received for its themes and the stunning work of its young cast.

According to reports, Netflix's algorithm for recording audience numbers found that few people were finishing the ten-episode season, and saw no room for a bigger audience in the future.

This cancellation particularly hurts for fans because it ended on a major cliffhanger, and much of season two had already been mapped out to act on it. Everything sucks, indeed.


3. The Society

The Society
Netflix

The Society's premise is the stuff potentially great shows are made of, recalling the likes of Lost and Lord of the Flies as a group of teenagers attempt to survive in a town cut-off from the outside world after most of its population disappears.

Sporting great work from its committed cast, some intriguing mysteries and effective plot twists, the drama was a critical and commercial success, prompting Netflix to renew it for a second season.

Following its renewal, however, the streaming service were forced to reverse their decision due to the pressures of the COVID-19 pandemic, and filming - which was set to begin just a month after the announcement - was indefinitely put on hold.

In their official statement (released alongside their decision to cancel I Am Not Okay with This), Netflix made a point of thanking the cast and crew for their work, and rather tragically have said nothing about possibly bringing the show back somewhere down the line.


2. The Get Down

The Get Down
Netflix

Created by acclaimed filmmaker Baz Luhrmann and featuring a cast including the likes of Justice Smith, Yahya Abdul-Mateen II and Jimmy Smits, The Get Down was a roaring musical drama chronicling the rise of hip-hop and disco in 70s New York.

Noted for its ambitious scope and historical significance, the series' first season was split into two parts, ending after twelve episodes and costing an eye-watering $120 million to produce.

Behind-the-scenes, creative differences had slowed production early on, and it's said the series was only split into two to accommodate some changes in the writing room.

Despite the hardships, Luhrmann later went on record to enthusiastically proclaim:

To be honest, we have already developed the opening of the next season. Sony and Netflix have been very driven about having a second season. There has been no question about that. They really want it.

When the show was axed, though, he took to social media to say The Get Down was cancelled because he couldn't commit to it anymore, though it's fair to say the budget and creative friction had something to do with its final fate, too.


1. Tuca & Bertie

Tuca and Bertie
Netflix

Tuca & Bertie, with its anthropomorphic animals, adult humour and intelligent drama, was compared to fellow Netflix property BoJack Horseman right out the gate, but quickly proved to be a fun and refreshing show far removed from other shows in its vicinity.

Starring Tiffany Haddish and Ali Wong as two bird-women tackling the difficulties of their lives, the show received very positive reviews for its inventive and surreal animation style, and its ability to explore issues such as trauma and identity.

True to form, Netflix didn't announce why the show was being cancelled after just one season, but unlike others on this list Tuca & Bertie at least had a happy ending.

Nearly a year after its initial cancellation, the series was picked up by Adult Swim and renewed for a second, equally well-received instalment, and as of this writing a third season is currently in development. You love to see it.


Contributor

I get to write about what I love, which is cool. You'll typically find me in front of a TV, or hunkered down behind a book, or dreaming of things far away. Be good to each other. Find my other writings here: https://allthethingsineversaid.substack.com/