10 Most Oblivious TV Law Enforcers

If these guys are the Police's best and brightest, god knows who they bust down to traffic.

While in reality we (for the most part) feel that we can rely on those who protect and serve us, if you live in a television show, I wouldn't hold out much hope of that. Police officers on TV tend to be a special type of incompetent where they will miss everything important that's going on. If the main character is a villain, you can bet the writers will bend over backwards to ensure they're one step ahead of the law at all times. How is this accomplished? By making the law enforcers completely idiotic when it suits the narrative, it's easier to make the police dumber than to make the criminal more intelligent. This leads to some rather ridiculous situations: your sibling is a serial killer/drug kingpin? Who'd have thought? Oh wait, maybe you should have as you've been developed as the best detectives in your respective forces. Of course there would be no drama without these narrative decisions; as viewers we love the chase. It's not unfair to say however, that sometimes you're left scratching your head at how these officers jump between being super efficient badasses and someone who couldn't spot a crime occurring two inches in front of them. Occasionally though they're just plain bad at their job, let's investigate both cases. As I'll be discussing the plot of various television shows be aware of SPOILERS.

10. Clancy Wiggum €“ The Simpsons

The ultimate parody of inept police work Commissioner Clancy Wiggum is a shining example of how not to do the job. He's lazy, dim-witted and highly incompetent; struggling to solve even the most basic crimes that occur in Springfield. Rarely seen without a doughnut in hand, and is every stereotype of American policing rolled into one. He has recently been promoted to police commissioner despite his complete ignorance to the laws he is meant to uphold. The fact is, he only became chief as his disgruntled predecessor announced he's give the job to the next person he saw, who happened to be Wiggum. When called upon to perform his duty to protect and serve he's very reluctant to work, often heard saying things like: 'I'd rather let a thousand guilty men go free than chase after them'. The fact that he wields such authority must be a scary thought for Springfield's residents although if you have financial means, he isn't above taking a bribe to look the other way. Parodying police has become commonplace in animation but The Simpsons got in there early and created one of the most beloved if useless cops on television. Although he'd struggle to tie his shoes if it wasn't for his loyal companions Lou and Eddie, Clancy Wiggum's ineptitude is always a joy to watch.

9. Sgt. Harrison Yates €“ South Park

The mountain town of South Park used to be patrolled by Officer Barbrady €“ the epitome of terrible policing €“ but more recently this has changed. Now when the situation calls for help from law enforcement you're more likely to see Sgt. Harrison Yates spring into action. As the highest-ranked detective in the Park County Police Force, he is often called upon to solve a variety of surreal crimes. While he's clearly passionate about his work, as is evidenced in his interactions with his wife, he's immensely gullible and believes in the paranormal. This leads him into trivial investigations while he is more than happy to let others like the Hardly Boys or Mysterion solve more important crimes for him. When you get down to it though, as is the case with all grownups in the South Park universe, he's ignorant to the majority of what's happening around him. His investigative methods are certainly questionable: dressing as a prostitute and performing depraved acts to catch men soliciting sex, not acting on Ike and his teacher's relationship ('...nice') and spending hours in the lab figuring out let from right. It's all hilarious stuff and continues the grand tradition of mocking the police.

8. Futurama €“ URL & Smitty

Living in the future doesn't mean you're going to get a better class of police officer. In fact, if you consider Futurama's URL and Smitty, it's quite the contrary. They're good friends who enjoy giving out excessive beatings and abusing authority. While they do get results on occasion, most of the time it's luck that hands them their culprits. It's a case of the two of them being oblivious to the bigger picture, being overly focused on their standing in the community as enforcers of the law while believing themselves to be infallible. The most frequently seen members of the New New York Police Department, they are certainly an odd couple. URL is a robotic peace officer with a voice like a 70's soul brother who was presumably built to fight crime while Smitty became a cop because his father owned a restaurant where people wouldn't pay for their meals. With limited backstories to draw conclusions from it's the actions which speak for the characters, and luckily there's plenty to go from there. They aren't in the show constantly but when they are they always make an impression and when they're not wrongfully accusing people of crimes, they're usually arresting Bender for some sort of theft. They're never able to hold him for long of course but they are generally able to get a few solid hits in with their lightsaber-batons before he escapes.

7. The Following €“ Ryan Hardy's Task Force

While we're waiting for Season 2 of this psychological thriller, it seems like as good a time as any to look at where Ryan Hardy's supposedly elite task force went wrong. Kevin Bacon stars as Hardy, the stereotypical burnt out detective who has alcohol issues and a fragile psyche, all very original stuff. Plus, he an't run too fast after being stabbed in the heart. The main members of his team are Shawn 'Iceman' Ashmore as Mike Weston, a young FBI Agent who wants nothing more than to impress Hardy and Annie Parisse as expert on cult behaviour, Debra Parker. Introductions out of the way, their goal is to find and apprehend Dr. Joe Carroll (James Purefoy) a dangerous serial murderer who is forming a cult of killers. Hardy wrote a book on Carroll after being the one to apprehend him the first time, so is brought into the investigation as a consultant. You would think that a team which seems to have all the bases covered wouldn't be too far behind the murderous author and his followers but you would be wrong. I'll buy into the fact that Carroll has been in prison a while and has had time to plan his state spanning revenge. What I can't accept is how gullible the FBI is in dealing with him. Lots of people die because of silly mistakes such as searching a woman but somehow missing the deadly eye stabbers in her hands or gathering people in a community center without checking anyone although a murder cult is at large. We're meant to buy into a big cat and mouse game but for the most part the cat hasn't even caught the mouse's scent. It becomes hard to watch when the show is so one sided you almost find yourself rooting for the villain.

6. X Files €“ The Police

So as to maintain the premise that only FBI agents Fox Mulder and Dana Scully encounter the paranormal, the majority of the events they investigate are out in the sticks. This accomplishes a number of things €“ including increased isolation and peril €“ but perhaps most importantly it allows all the police to be incompetent hicks. The officers that our favourite FBI duo encounters are for the most part unhelpful and occasionally even confrontational. They play on the jurisdictional issues that a lot of American cop shows like to remind us is a thing but above all they just act like idiots. Even when given proof that something out of the ordinary is going on they simply shrug and declare that these city folk don't know what they're talking about. Most of the cases they embark on would have been solved in half the time if they had the cooperation of the local police force but as they are seen to be muscling into ongoing investigations the reception is always hostile. This nearly gets Mulder and Scully killed in the episode 'Teliko' when an unhelpful police operator shows no compassion for the danger they are in. I know the whole point of the X-Files is that Mulder is the only true believer in the paranormal for the majority of the show's run but surely at least one of the 'hick' police forces would have been a little more accommodating when asked nicely by the FBI.

5. Prison Break €“ The Prison Guards

Being that prisons are full of criminals it's not too much of a stretch to imagine those that work who developing some of those unsavoury tendencies themselves. There's plenty of stories of this occurring all over the world and Prison Break's writers decided to run with the idea, making practically every guard in Fox River Penitentiary dangerously corrupt. It was taken to this extreme to justify Michael Scofield's attempts to free his brother Lincoln Burrows without glorifying prison escapes. The guards stole from, attacked and were generally awful to everyone they encountered and this power is what made them miss the blindingly obvious escape that was being planned right in front of them. With them being so oblivious to everything going on, Scofield is able to wander in and out of his cell pretty much at will through a hole in the wall. Stuffing some pillows under the sheets to fool people into thinking you're sleeping might be appropriate in a comedy, but somehow it actually works in this, a maximum security penitentiary. Series One of Prison Break sees Scofield escape after a mere month of incarceration, soundly beating Andy Dufresne from The Shawshank Redemption's plan by 18 years and proving how ridiculously inept the guards at Fox River really were. He didn't even have to crawl through a river of sh*t, for god's sake.

4. 24 €“ The CTU

While some may see this as a tenuous link, allow me to explain why the CTU fall squarely under the detective category. Their entire job revolves around investigating and preventing terrorist attacks, so the sleuthing skills required for this are self explanatory. They are supposedly the last line of defence between those loony extremists and mainland USA, so why do they miss so much of what's happening? If the whole point of their being is to identify terrorist threats then how come they only ever seem to become aware of them a day before they occur. If they actually did their jobs then Jack Bauer could sit and enjoy some alone time without having to pistol-whip his millionth villain into bloody oblivion. While it's undoubtedly fun to watch Bauer destroy everything that looks at him the wrong way, it shows a serious failing within the agency that they need to keep setting him these 24 hour deadlines. It's not just that they miss these teeny little terror cells and bomb threats, they've been infiltrated on numerous occasions. We're meant to believe they're the best at their job when they allow their headquarters to be gassed from within? I call shenanigans on their credentials.

3. Sherlock €“ Lestrade

Used as a device to show that although they're incompetent, the police can also be nice; Lestrade is Sherlock's main contact within the force. There's nothing particularly bad about him and I bet if he wasn't put in a room with the World's Greatest Detective (Holmes not Batman) he'd actually seem rather good at his job. However, the issue is that he's always in Sherlock's proximity, which by comparison makes everyone else look like a complete cretin. Lestrade marvels as Sherlock comes up with clues which eventually crack the mystery, but you can't help but wonder if he would have been relegated to cold cases if our regular force had been in charge. This may seem like an unfair position to take but it even gets to the point where the police get annoyed that Sherlock is better than them. It only takes a bit of persuasion for Lestrade to ransack 221B Baker Street out of professional jealousy. However law enforcement are presented in a Sherlock Holmes adaptation, they must always be two steps behind. But still, this doesn't excuse their ineptitude in this modern take on the sleuth, where they released the terrifying Jim Moriarty even after a verdict by a clearly tampered jury, or believed Sherlock was committing the crimes he's been trying to solve. I mean, come on guys. While we're lead by the arm to make it seem like this could make sense to Lestrade and the whole force for that matter, take a step back like Sherlock and you'll see it's really just a case of bad policing.

2. Breaking Bad €“ Hank Schrader

He's the best agent the DEA has to offer and yet can't figure out his brother-in-law/drug kingpin despite so many opportunities to do so. He started out in the show as loud, macho comic relief and although his character was able to develop throughout the show's run, his investigative skills sure didn't. It can, and I'm sure will be argued that as Walt was a member of his family, Hank had a bit of an emotional blind spot. I can get behind that, but there are numerous incidences where it would have been prudent to at least spend five minutes following up a lead. Events like Walt's disappearances and his changing behaviour which he explained away using cancer should have started some sort of curiosity. Really early on there's the sequence where Hank inspects Mr. White's chemistry cupboard and discovers that there are items missing and although he scolds Walt, he pretty much just laughs it off. In the end he finds out Heisenberg's identity through Walt's hubris, not by any great detective work. As he grunts away on the toilet and finds the killer clue in Walt Whitman's Leaves of Grass you can't help but wonder if this should have happened a long time before. If he could sniff out Gustavo Fring, the most careful man in crime, it's just ludicrous that it took him five seasons to bag Walter White.

1. Dexter €“ Miami-Dade Homicide

With the notable exception of Sgt. James Doakes, Miami-Dade Homicide is probably the most inept collection of detectives ever put to screen. Despite Dexter repeatedly saying he has no idea how to interact with people, everyone gets along with him and think nothing of his unexplained absences and late night boating. No one ever suspects the socially awkward, blood obsessed forensics guy unless the plot is running low on villains for him to kill. I could have focused solely on Deb as she's meant to be the best detective on the force, yet never suspects her emotionally bankrupt brother until she literally walks in and catches him in the act. She's not the only guilty party here though; the whole department frequently prove to be dangerously inept. Even when they bring in outside help in the form of serial killer hunter Frank Lundy he fails to catch Dexter, barely even suspecting him because he's too busy trying to get into Deb's pants. Everyone in the homicide unit is either an emotional wreck or a weirdo, the only way the writers could think to develop characters was to either have them become self-destructive, marry each other or both. Angel and Quinn were too busy being mismatched partners to care much about actual police work and everyone else was in some sort of bitchy high school conflict. On second thought, I don't blame the characters here €“ the writers never gave them a chance. What do you think? Have I missed any dim detectives? Share your thoughts below!

Contributor
Contributor

A pop culture mad writer from the North East who loves films, television and debating them with whoever will listen. Follow me on Twitter @Johno_Patterson