10 Overlooked Buffy The Vampire Slayer Episodes That Are Secretly Classics
With so many classic episodes to choose from, it's easy to overlook these absolute corkers.
Across seven densely packed seasons, Buffy the Vampire Slayer was an absolute tour-de-force of drama, horror, and finely-tuned scissor kicks.
Centering on the exploits of the quick-witted, super-strong valley girl Buffy Summers and her never-ending battle against the forces of evil, the show gave us some truly unforgettable storylines and expertly written characters that have found themselves permanently preserved in the highest pantheon of pop culture.
Many of the show's episodes have gone down in history for their innovative narrative design and forward-thinking momentum, but amongst stalwart classics such as Hush, The Body, and the undeniably epic The Gift, there are many lesser-known episodes that still manage to encapsulate the show's core ethos in strange and exciting ways.
Said episodes are the subject of this list, and whilst they may find love within the die-hard fan community, they will likely be lost on more casual viewers. Be they comedy stories of lust, or hard-fought battles against powerful foes, the episodes featured here typically get overlooked when the discussion of the show's best episodes are hotly debated over a couple of beers.
Best sharpen those stakes guys, because things are about to go bump in the night.
SPOILERS AHEAD!
10. Him (Season 7, Episode 6)
Him has the honour of being the last standalone episode before season seven knuckles down and becomes an all-out apocalypse storyline, and what a treat it is.
Him tells the story of a high-school student RJ whose lucky varsity jacket has the ability to charm any woman it comes into contact with - as such, this means that Buffy, Dawn, Anya, and Willow all fall under its spell and soon find themselves resorting to extreme measures to win his heart.
Despite its inherent silliness, the episode still manages to touch upon heady themes and really does hark back to the early seasons where supernatural shenanigans were always metaphors for the trials and tribulations of being a teenager. Whilst Willow resorts to magic, Anya to robbing a bank, and Buffy to violence (a-la rocket launcher), it's Dawn's decision to try and end her life that really pummels you in the feels department - turning what is an otherwise lighthearted affair into something much more meaningful and poignant.
For what is a supposedly disposable episode, Him is the last great-hurrah for the show's comedy and drama elements to shine before settling in for a truly dark and epic finale.
9. Ted (Season 2, Episode 6)
Considering the show is called Buffy the Vampire Slayer, the titular bombshell spends quite a lot of time fending off evil robots over the course of its seven seasons.
Although of all her battles against malicious machines, the episode Ted is undeniably the best. Bringing the horror much closer to home, Buffy has to contend with her mother's new boyfriend - the titular Ted - who instantly charms everyone around him. All except for Buffy of course, who is immediately wary of any man who seeks to woo her mother.
Buffy's suspicions are soon confirmed when Ted reveals a more sinister side, one that stalks and threatens Buffy when everyone else's backs are turned. Although despite her pleas, nobody believes that Ted is anything less than perfect.
What elevates this episode amongst the other standard 'Monster of the Week' fare is just how relatable and downright terrifying the scenario is. The subsequent reveal that Ted is in fact a killer robot may be a little too silly for some, but taken as a whole, Ted is a fantastic episode that managed to get under the viewer's skin in a way that no other episode managed to.
8. Primeval (Season 4, Episode 21)
Let's face it, season four of Buffy is a complete mess - an unusually sloppy entry to the series canon that was marred by behind-the-scenes issues and a general lack of focus.
As a result, this season's main arc felt secondary to everything else. Yet despite this, its penultimate episode Primeval is a real highlight that rarely gets the credit it deserves.
Focusing on the Scooby Gang's final battle with the cybernetic-demonoid Adam, this episode goes back to what made the previous seasons so great and made a last-ditch attempt to resolve The Initiative storyline in a satisfactory way.
The explosive battle within The Initiative expanded on season three's large-scale set-pieces in spectacular new ways, the core-four Scooby Gang members get their time to shine, and even Riley doesn't suck in this episode - so it's a win all round.
For many it's too-little-too-late, but for all of its sins, Primeval is a fantastic episode that's merely tarnished by what came before it. It's the closest that season four comes to matching the dizzying heights of previous seasons and an indicator of what this season could have been if those at the reigns had a better idea of what to do.
7. Dirty Girls (Season 7, Episode 18)
Whilst season seven as a whole gets a mixed response from fans, the inclusion of Caleb has always been seen as one of its highlights. The sadistic, misogynistic preacher - who is played to callous perfection by Nathan Fillion - is a strong contender for the show's nastiest villain and his introductory episode cements his place as one of Buffy's most fearsome adversaries.
From the harrowing opening scene where he stabs a Potential Slayer before pushing her out of a car, to the climactic battle where he effortlessly murders a few more Potentials before popping Xander's eyeball, Caleb truly shakes up the show's foundations for the better.
His introduction is sharp, shocking, and quietly iconic, but outside of the (un)holy man's mean-spirited shenanigans, there's a lot more to love in this episode - most notably Faith's return to Sunnydale, which leads to several great scenes between herself and Buffy in which they put behind their differences in the pursuit of the same goal.
The only downside is that it feels like it should come earlier in the season, but despite it all feeling a little rushed, this is a potent episode that never fails to get a visceral reaction out of fans.
6. Life Serial (Season 6, Episode 5)
Love it, or hate it, there's no denying that season six is brimming with creative ideas and that it took the show in a bold new direction. Perhaps one of the best examples of this is Life Serial, an episode in which Buffy attempts to secure a regular job but finds that she can never quite escape the forces of evil.
Absolute rotters The Trio make it their mission to mess with Buffy at every conceivable turn, ruining any chance she has at working a normal job. Their methods range from ill-timed demon attacks, to trapping Buffy in an endless retail time-loop where she must complete a seemingly impossible task in the name of customer service - the latter of which we can all agree is a fate worse than death.
Above all else, it's the humour in this episode that stands out, juxtaposing the show's more campy and whimsical elements with a more slice-of-life feel that works beautifully. (That and Buffy's customer-service breakdown montage is pure comedy gold.)
Throw in the reveal that demons play poker for kittens and the beginnings of Buffy's self-destructive relationship with Spike and you've got a stellar episode that tends to fly under the radar.
5. Gingerbread (Season 3, Episode 11)
Season three of Buffy is full of wall-to-wall bangers, so it's easy for some episodes to slip through the cracks. Gingerbread is one such episode, one that took the show's signature snarky humour and thrust it into more absurd and uncomfortably dark territory.
Upon surprising Buffy during one of her routine patrols, Joyce happens upon the corpses of two small children. This shocking discovery leads Joyce to start a crusade against the occult forces that plague Sunnydale - with a particular focus on high-schoolers that show a keen interest in the dark arts.
What seems like a feeble attempt to address an ongoing problem soon becomes something much more sinister when the ghosts of the murdered children begin to exert their influence over Joyce and convince her to form a lynch mob and burn all local witches at the stake.
Naturally, Willow becomes a target and even Buffy herself falls victim to Joyce's deranged crusade, leaving Oz, Xander, Giles, and Cordelia to save the day in their typical bumbling fashion.
What makes Gingerbread such a classic though is that despite the overly dark plot, the show's trademark humour is out in full force, making this one of the show's most quotable episodes.
4. Showtime (Season 7, Episode 11)
One of Buffy's defining characteristics is her typically unyielding spirit in the face of immeasurable odds, and Showtime is undoubtedly one of the finest displays of her innermost strength.
After suffering a nasty defeat at the hands of the Turok-Han in the previous episode, Buffy picks herself up and strives to prove to everyone that she is the hero that they need in their war against The First.
Displaying all of her wits, cunning, and skills in combat, Buffy - with the help of Willow and Xander - stage a demonstration for any of those that doubt her leadership skills. She lures the Turok-Han into an empty construction site and a savage battle begins. Things do look a little hairy for Buffy at the start, but she ultimately comes out on top.
What makes this episode so special is that it's truly the point where we see that no matter what, Buffy will not allow her spirit to be broken. After so many hardships and powerful foes that have broken her previously, it's so great to see her grab the bull by the horns and slice its ugly head off.
3. Forever (Season 5, Episode 17)
Forever is in the unfortunate position of being the follow-up to The Body, an episode that never fails to break viewer's hearts no matter how many times they see it. Whilst it can't match the sheer emotional assault of its predecessor, Forever acts as the perfect hangover showing us how the lingering effects of grief can be just as traumatic.
The episode doesn't shy away from grim reality and focuses on Buffy's best efforts to remain strong for the sake of those around her, whilst Dawn seeks to use dark magic to restore their mother to life.
Much like The Body, Forever is light on action but doesn't lack any of the intensity. Both Sarah Michelle-Gellar and Michelle Trachtenberg deliver knock-out performances throughout and their pain and suffering is never anything less than gripping and heartbreaking in equal measure.
It all culminates in one of the show's most emotionally charged and frankly exhausting finales, but one that's so incredibly necessary for both characters to grow and move on from the tragic loss of their mother. Whilst The Body may get all the praise and attention it rightly deserves, Forever will always be quietly brilliant in its own way.
2. Normal Again (Season 6, Episode 17)
Episodes such as Normal Again can quite often fall flat on their face, but leave it to the Buffy writers to craft a "what if this was all a hallucination?" scenario that's ultimately quite believable.
After being poisoned by a demon, Buffy begins hallucinating that she's a patient in a psychiatric ward. Her parents are both there - alive and well - and she's quickly told that she's been in a state of delirium for the last six years, ranting and raving about being the Chosen One.
These hallucinations soon become too intense and Buffy confesses to Willow that she had previously been sectioned when she first learned of her Slayer calling and ruminates on whether or not the past six years were all a fantasy.
This makes for some incredibly gripping and genuinely uncomfortable viewing as Buffy begins to succumb to her delirium and is lead to believe that the only way to be healthy again is to murder those around her.
It's certainly one of the show's darkest outings, and one that has the audacity to never reveal the truth, leaving us to wonder if the entire show had been a fabrication of Buffy's broken psyche.
It's bold, disturbing, and genuinely quite brilliant.
1. I Only Have Eyes For You (Season 2, Episode 19)
Coming at a time when the story is at its darkest, I Only Have Eyes for You is an atypical monster-of-the-week episode that seamlessly wedges itself into the main arc - focusing on the ghosts of a high-school student and his former teacher and lover, who night after night possess the students and faculty of Sunnydale High and make them reenact their tragic final moments.
Whilst that premise alone is worthy of inclusion on this list, what truly elevates this amongst the rest is in how the ghost's turmoil manifests within Buffy and Angelus, completely flipping the script and acting as poignant commentary on their dynamic, both in terms of their undying love for one another, as well as the moral implications of their relationship.
Acting as something of an omen for the heart-breaking series finale, this episode's sharp writing is bolstered by two award-worthy performances from Sarah Michelle-Gellar and David Boreanaz, both of whom completely throw themselves into the material, culminating in some of the finest drama the show has ever produced.
It may get overshadowed by the more emotionally resonant season finale, but there's no denying that it's one of the best episodes of the show's entire run.
Watch Next
Buffy The Vampire Slayer Quiz: Who Said It – Spike Or Drusilla?