10 Plot Holes You Haven't Noticed In Stranger Things

Sometimes Stranger Things' plot gets a little Upside Down...

Stranger Things is, without a doubt, one of the most popular shows in the world right now.

The Netflix original series first made its presence felt back in 2016, when it really caught us all off-guard. Since doing so, it has enjoyed a tremendous amount of success, going on to become one of the streaming service's biggest hits and amassing a legion of devoted fans in the process.

Three seasons into its run, and it shows absolutely no signs of relenting. And if you take a moment to think about it, it's clear to see why it remains such a hit. With its thrilling plot, engaging characters and unique emphasis on nostalgia, Stranger Things is the perfect blend of genres and tones, using something old to give us something new - and it almost always succeeds in doing just that.

That being said, it isn't perfect. While the writing has always been of an incredibly high standard, quite a few inconsistencies and plot holes have raised their heads over the past few years - and no matter how much you try to understand them, they just don't make sense.

With that in mind, let's take a look back at some of the ones you probably didn't notice.

Please be aware, this post contains heavy SPOILERS for Stranger Things season 3.


10. Material Girl

Stranger Things Season 3
Netflix

Eleven and Max's impromptu shopping trip to the Starcourt mall was both one of the most touching and aesthetically-pleasing moments of Season 3, as it gave us a chance to get to see El enjoy life like any teenage girl should, while also piling on all the '80s nostalgia that we could have hoped for.

However, as the two girls showcased their new outfits and posed for fashionable photographs in an epic slow-mo Material Girl montage, did anyone actually stop to think how any of them managed to afford all of this?

Sure, maybe Max had some change to spare, but could a teenager who, as far as we know, didn't have a job really have afforded all of that? And something tells us that Hopper wouldn't have lent El any money, considering that he didn't want her out in large crowds.

Out of context, it may not have been that noticeable but, as this played out parallel to Mike's inability to afford anything that the store had on offer, it stuck out like a sore thumb.


9. There Will Be Blood (Or In This Case There Won't)

Stranger Things Will
Netflix

As Nancy and Jonathan began to learn more and more about the Demogorgon throughout the first season, they figured out that, despite its unpredictably scary nature, there was one definitive thing that would summon it: Blood.

This, however, was a fact that we had learned earlier than even they did, as it targeted Barb after she cut her finger at Steve's house and feasted on an injured deer. Adding to that, the creature would later be drawn out when Jonathan cut his own hand and when Eleven killed all of the lab's agents by making them bleed from their eyes.

That, however, appears to contradict the very foundation of the story itself: Will Byers' disappearance. When Will was targeted by the creature, he hadn't injured himself and he wasn't bleeding - and this, of course, begs the question: Why did the Demogorgon target him?

Sure, you could argue that it was disorientated because it just broke out of the lab, but why then did it consistently target Joyce in her own home, and Nancy in the woods? There wasn't a drop of blood in sight for either of these scenarios, so what brought it out?

Like we said, the creature is unpredictable, but given that the writers went to such an effort to push the blood philosophy on us, it seems a little strange that there were so many gaps in it.


8. The Dog Days Are Over... Apparently

Stranger Things Chester Byers
Netflix

Remember Chester? You know, the Byers' family dog that barked endlessly at the shed in the garden and essentially sent Joyce and Hopper in the right direction at the beginning of their search for Will in the first ever episode of Stranger Things? Yeah, well, neither do the writers apparently.

The beloved family pet vanished from existence without a trace, as he was nowhere to be seen throughout the second and third seasons and there has yet to be a single reference to him. Not to ask the obvious question but, what actually happened to him?

Noah Schnapp suggested last summer that the dog had died off-screen and that we might see a grave for him during Season 3 but, as far as the most devoted fans are aware, there was no grave in sight.

Thus, the mysterious case of 'The Vanishing of Chester Byers' continues...


7. Horsin' Around

Stranger Things Season 3 Steve Harrington Horse
Netflix

One of the major narratives in Season 3 revolved around Steve, Dustin and Robin's attempts to decode a secret Russian message, and while they successfully translated it, they found themselves unable to figure out what it actually meant or where it was coming from. That is, until Steve recognized the music in the background of the broadcast to be the melody that played over the mall's horse ride Indiana Flyer.

Undoubtedly a real jaw-dropper of a moment that was both effective and enlightening, but if you stop to think about it for longer than three seconds, the flaws begin to show.

First of all, if the Russians were broadcasting from their lab, which was probably a mile below the surface, there is absolutely no chance that the music from the horse ride would end up on the transmission - and, if anything, this so-called interference certainly wouldn't be that clear.

Speaking of clarity, the other option is that a Russian soldier actually broadcast from the mall floor and just so happened to be standing beside the horse when they did so. But given that they were attempting to be covert about the whole thing, it's highly unlikely that they would have authorised anyone to do this in a place that was literally at the public heart of the town.

The horse seems like nothing more than a tool designed to get Steve and co. to figure out that the Russians were in Hawkins but, given that they literally worked above them, surely the writers could have come up with a less problematic way to do so.


6. Silent Russians

Stranger Things Grigori Terminator
Netflix

While Hawkins found itself in the midst of yet another attack from the residents of the Upside Down, it was also the unexpected source of an experiment carried out by evil Russian soldiers - who were undoubtedly the human antagonists of Stranger Things 3. Now, while the fact that the Russians managed to inconspicuously infiltrate Hawkins raised a number of eyebrows - especially when you consider that they had the not-so-sublte Grigori with them - this also made way for a bigger issue.

How on earth did they not only manage to infiltrate Hawkins, but construct their gigantic drill machine and, oh you know, build a freakin' tunnel underneath an incredibly public place without anyone ever discovering their presence? Where did they get the resources to make it happen? How did any of them come and go as they pleased?

Sure, we know that the Russians' affiliation with Mayor Kline worked in their favour, but that doesn't mean that viewers should have to suspend their disbeliefs when it comes to this storyline... shouldn't we be saving that for the supernatural elements?


5. No Explanation For Will's Fake Body

Stranger Things Will Upside Down
Netflix

The disappearance of Will Byers rocked Hawkins to its very core and resulted in the community coming together in order to find him and, when it was revealed to the public that he was dead, they came together again to mourn him - so it's probably safe to assume that his miraculous return from the dead would have caused a lot of buzz in town.

While the writers utilised multiple time jumps in order to skip all the logical explanations, the second season did feature a newspaper clipping about 'The Boy Who Came Back To Life'. So, yes, obviously Hawkins knows that Will Byers is back, but why was this used to paint him like some kind of outcast and weirdo? He didn't die... he was lost. It was the town that assumed he was dead, simply because the fake body washed up in the quarry.

Just how did Hopper, Joyce and everyone involved explain away the fake body? And why was nobody asking questions about it? It's not like this sort of thing happens regularly in Hawkins... right?

Then again...


4. The Dead Don't Talk (And Neither Does Anyone Else)

Stranger Things Season 3
Netflix

That eerie grim ward of Hawkins Memorial Hospital may be best-remembered for Nancy's Season 3 ordeal with the slimy, sludgy blob-like mini Mind Flayer, but let's not forget that the entire floor was littered with the dead bodies of doctors and patients - dead bodies that literally nobody other than Nancy and Jonathan seemed to notice.

Now, you could suggest that the investigations and reports on the mysterious deaths took place off-screen but, given that the town's July 4 holiday bash wasn't cancelled, that is highly unlikely. Moreover, on the post-showdown Cutting Edge report in the season finale (a month after the events of Season 3) that detailed all of the mysterious unexplained happenings in Hawkins, there was no mention of mass murder in the hospital.

While it's clear that the Duffers are keen to keep the dark secrets of the Upside Down hidden from the public, this was a real oversight. It was already pretty convenient that nobody was around outside the hospital to see monster explode onto the ground after Eleven sent it hurtling out the window, but are we really supposed to believe that not a single person noticed all of the dead patients and doctors on the ward? Don't these people have families? At the very least, wouldn't someone have come looking for one of them?


3. The Starcourt Fire

Stranger Things Season 3 Starcourt Mall

Much like the previous two entries, the Starcourt Mall fire in the Season 3 finale was used as another attempt to cover up the existence of the Upside Down and shield the public from the knowledge that, yes, monsters really did exist. However, also like those two entries, there were plot issues here that just didn't make sense.

First of all, what actually started the fire? The fireworks that the kids threw at the Mind Flayer in the final battle did leave a few small fires burning, but considering the size of them and how isolated they were, they surely couldn't have erupted into the building-burning monstrosity in the short amount of time that it took the authorities to arrive.

You could then argue that Joyce and Hopper's successful mission to blow up the Russians' drill was responsible but, considering it took place miles below the surface and the kids remained in the mall for a good while after they did so (with no sign of any larger fires), it seems highly unlikely.

Then you have the fact that they framed the Starcourt fire as the cause of death for the 30 lost souls who fell victim to the Mind Flayer but, again, wouldn't someone related to one of those 30 people have come looking for them in the days beforehand? And, perhaps more obviously, how on earth would the government agents have shifted the remnants of the Mind Flayer's massive carcasse without being seen? At the very least, wouldn't the fire-fighters have seen it?


2. Friends Don't Lie

Stranger Things Season 1 Mike Eleven
Netflix

Eleven and Mike's relationship has, without a doubt, been one of the high points of the whole series but the pair have never been more adorable than they were in Season 1, as the former taught his telekinetic friend about the norms of childhood. And perhaps the most important lesson he ever taught her was what it means to be a friend.

Way back in the second ever episode, 'The Weirdo On Maple Street', Eleven seemed confused by the term "friend", literally going as far as to directly ask him: "What is friend?". Mike responded by breaking down the notion of friendship for her - a conversation that paved the way for the now iconic "friends don't lie".

However, if you watch the season back, you'll notice that this wasn't the first time that El had heard the term.

During a flashback in Episode 6, 'The Monster', the young girl was frightened by all of the people surrounding her in the lab and, in an attempt to soothe her fears, Dr. Brenner told that they were "all friends". Furthermore, at the beginning of Episode 2, Mike told her that he used his walkie to chat with his friends.

As El never responded to either of these prior statements with confusion, it seemed like she had already grasped the notion of what friends meant, so why then did she suddenly question Mike over the term in his basement?


1. The Other Gates

Stranger Things Eleven Upside Down
Netflix

The Demogorgon's presence was felt on Hawkins due to an encounter with Eleven that was so earth-shattering, it opened a tear in our very dimension. That tear bridged the gap between our world and the Upside Down, and it was simply known as 'The Gate'. And so, when the Upside Down began to manifest topside, Eleven concluded that she had to close the Gate in order to stop it - a task which she completed to perfection. The only problem is that this wasn't the only gate.

Throughout Season 1, the Demogorgon used and created multiple gates in order to break through to the real world. Remember when it tore through Joyce's wall? Yeah, well that was a gate. What about how it emerged from the trees? That was also a gate. And then, of course, you have the middle school wall which it broke through before the final battle of Season 1 - the same gate which Eleven re-emerged from shortly afterwards.

While you could argue that those gates probably closed up on their own, that doesn't explain everything. First off, why do they close on their own when the original one didn't and, more importantly, now that we know there are other Demogorgans in the Upside Down, why didn't one them use their very own gate to break through between Seasons 1 and 2?

With all that in mind, it just seemed a little too convenient that there was so much emphasis placed on this one gate. Sure, it was, in a sense, the Master Gate, but it certainly wasn't the only one.

-

Which plot holes did you spot in Stranger Things? Tell us in the comments below.


Watch Next


Stranger Things Quiz: How Closely Were You Watching Season 3?

Stranger Things Season 3
Netflix

1. What Was The Name Of Hawkins' New Mall?

Contributor
Contributor

Michael Patterson is an experienced writer with an affinity for all things film and TV. He may or may not have spent his childhood obsessing over WWE.