10 Reasons Angel Is Better Than Buffy

Spin-offs are always inferior to the original? That wasn't the case with Angel and Buffy.

Buffy Angel
Mutant Enemy Productions

Let's get one thing straight right off the batt: Buffy the Vampire Slayer was an incredible, groundbreaking TV series and may have been the first time when a TV adaptation of a movie actually surpassed the original film. Joss Whedon's series of a teenage girl who is chosen to be the principle warrior against the forces of darkness managed to wow viewers week after week with incredible characters, great storytelling, and some of the best dialogue on TV at the time.

From the beginning of the series, one character really captured viewers' imaginations - Angel, the vampire who had been cursed with a soul to suffer for his violent actions. The tragic romance between Buffy and Angel has become legendary in the world of television. And following the third season, Whedon made the decision to break the couple up and give Angel his own spin-off.

Whenever a TV show spins off one of its popular characters, it's a risky move and it doesn't always go well. Even the best spin-offs never really reach the heights of the original series.

But Angel was the exception to the rule. While Buffy tended to flounder a bit after the third season and never really seemed to find its footing after leaving behind Sunnydale High School, Angel managed to be an amazing mix of drama, horror, characterization, and humor.

10. A Better Lead

Buffy Angel
Mutant Enemy

Angel was never the most dynamic character when he was on Buffy. If anything he could be a bit one-note: a stoic, dark, brooding love interest. And that was fine when he was a supporting character. But once the decision was made to give him his own show, it was clear some changes had to be made.

Whedon has said that Angel was the hardest character to write, which is probably why there was more depth added to him when his solo series began. The writers introduced some more personality for him. The premiere episode shows an Angel who was increasingly disconnected from the humanity he was supposed to save.

Over the course of five seasons, Angel developed in interesting - and sometimes surprising - ways. In many ways, this is thanks to the great performance of David Boreanaz. He was able to inject a sense of humor into the brooding vampire and even gave him a sense of self-consciousness.

While Angel became more dynamic and interesting in his show, as Buffy's series went on, she seemed to go in the opposite direction. Buffy became a more rigid character, even bordering on annoyance in the later seasons. Towards the end of BTVS, Buffy was actually one of the least interesting characters.


Percival Constantine is the author of several novels and short stories, including the Vanguard superhero series, and regularly writes and comments on movies, comics, and other pop culture. More information can be found at his website, PercivalConstantine.com