10 Reasons You Should Give Agents Of SHIELD Another Chance

In the spirit of trying to convince some lost souls to come on home and see the light...

When Marvel announced that its first live-action television series set in their cinematic universe would be a S.H.I.E.L.D. show created by Joss Whedon and starring Clark Gregg as the Avenger's Agent Coulson, anticipation quickly reached a fever pitch. The pilot episode's ratings clearly reflected Marvel's estimation that the world wanted a TV show from them, but as the figures rapidly petered off it became uncomfortably obvious that maybe it just wasn't this show they wanted. There are many factors that can be pointed to that explain Agents Of S.H.I.E.L.D.'s disappointments, possibly the biggest of which is that it's the first of its kind, and the fact it was always going to have a lot riding on it meant that the many fingers controlling the series - the showrunners, ABC, Marvel, even parent company Disney - were always going to have their way with its pies. Whedon's inconsistent involvement with AoS, too, may have been a factor - though he co-wrote and directed the pilot, he's only ever had a creator/executive producer credit on the other episodes and left his brother (and relative TV production newbies) Jed Whedon and Maurissa Tancharoen in charge of the ship along with former Angel writer/exec Jeffrey Bell. Though Whedon has a better track record with endings than beginnings when it comes to TV shows (Buffy is barely recognisable as the show we've come to adore for the first half of season 1), perhaps a bigger presence from the man would have resulted in a series that knew what it wanted to be instead of the sometimes sloppy, always not-quite-there show we got. But here's the thing: Agents Of S.H.I.E.L.D. has really found its feet in recent episodes and looks set to get better and better, and it seems like a great shame that half of its original audience has abandoned it when it's getting so good. So in the spirit of trying to convince some lost souls to come on home and see the light, here are 10 things we now think that AoS has that it didn't when it started. Warning: Spoilers ahead for Captain America: The Winter Soldier and Agents Of S.H.I.E.L.D. up to the latest episode.

10. It's Not The Same Show It Was Last Year

To say that Agents Of S.H.I.E.L.D. was considered something of a misfire in its earliest days would be a huge understatement: overly snarky banter, broadly drawn characters and a weirdly impersonal aesthetic didn't help the painfully obvious fact that a weekly TV show just didn't have the budget and studio power behind it to allow it to join the ranks of the Marvel Cinematic Universe proper. Add to that the painfully forced nods to the MCU (constant mentions of New York, members of the Avengers and other characters we're familiar with but rarely see) and an early lack of anything approaching an overarching story that anyone could hang on to and Agents Of S.H.I.E.L.D. was quickly starting to look like it really didn't matter. However, with more and more episodes focusing on the Centipede program, Coulson's resurrection and mysterious Big Bad The Clairvoyant the series has come along in leaps and bounds to start looking like one big story featuring characters we now care what happens to and that actually feels like it's going to have an impact after all.

9. We Know (And Like) The Characters Now

Each member of the main cast was met with a generally lukewarm response when the series bowed, with the exception of the already fondly-regarded Agent Coulson, and the show's next few episodes didn't to much to change that opinion for the better as they were mainly plot-heavy affairs; high on action, low on character-building. Many an unkind word has been said about each of the characters: Agent Ward's bland, cookie-cutter action hero; Fitz and Simmons, too quirky and sleight to actually matter; Skye, the most annoying of the bunch, taking Whedon-snark to new, almost parodic heights and showing a cockiness that didn't endear so much as enrage fans; even May, generally the most well-received of the new cast due to her consistent badassery, suffered from a lack of deep characterisation that gave her near-Michonne levels of shallow scowliness. Thankfully, for the most part all of those issues have been resolved. Ward and May have been able to show softer sides to themselves through their relationship with each other and to their fellow crewmates; May with Coulson and Ward with Skye, both demonstrating that they are capable of pulling off an interaction that doesn't end in a kick to the face. Fitz and Simmons have both been given expanded roles on the team and have each separately been a central focus of certain episode, and their true worth has certainly been illuminated when their lives are put in danger. Even Skye, the most maligned of the cast, has learned a few lessons in humility and generally toning her attitude down - and it certainly doesn't hurt that her backstory has been expanded to a point where we're more capable of feeling empathy for her. Put simply, the more we see of these characters, the more it is to like and care about them.

8. The World Is Richer And More Complex

At first, all we really saw of S.H.I.E.L.D. was the inside of the show's designer jumbo jet, which made the show's world feel much smaller than was likely Marvel's original intent. There was the occasional crime scene populated by faceless S.H.I.E.L.D. agents and the odd cameo from Maria Hill or Nick Fury (but only in the first two episodes), but on the whole AoS initially came off as a simplistic sci-fi procedural instead of the world-expanding adjunct to the more bombastic MCU films we'd been led to expect. In hindsight, it seems foolish to have expected a full world bursting with life from the show's first few episodes, as all television series need some time to expand their mythos, characters and storylines, but Agents Of S.H.I.E.L.D. eventually followed through on its promise after all - if a little later than most would have preferred. We've seen a great deal of world-xpansion in the last couple of months, from the introduction of several new S.H.I.E.L.D. facilities and a few recurring faces, from Victoria Hand to the more familiar Agents Sitwell and Blake. Even the villains have been explored further, with the manipulative Raina becoming the main focus of Coulson and co.'s troubles and even older characters coming back (Sif, Michael Peterson) in ways not a lot of fans would have predicted. It's starting to feel like there's much more going on in Marvel's TV world than meets the eye, and we might just be about to discover what that is...

7. Those Early Plot Seeds Are About To Sprout

Remember all those irritating episodes from the start of the season that seemed to be setting up villains or plots for future episodes that never came through on the promise (Graviton, anyone)? Remember how Michael Peterson (J. August Richards) showed up with powers in the first episode, never to be seen again until he showed up half a season later and became one of the most interesting characters on the show? Well, if they can achieve that kind of success with a seemingly throwaway character, just imagine what they can do with everything else: Coulson's resurrection still has questions that need answering, especially in regard to the blue alien (that's probably a Kree if Phil and Sif's conversation in her episode is anything to go by) that's connected to both him and Skye, whose 0-8-4 status is still an unresolved mystery that looks like it's about to be blown wide open by the season's end. Granted, some of the seeds that were planted early on were more like damp squibs than explosive revelations but the show's current track record for coming through on promises has been pretty good so far, even if there have been a couple of missteps with the likes of The Rising Tide and Centipede along the way.

6. The Big Bad

This week's episode saw the reveal of the major villain who's been plaguing our eponymous agents since day one: The Clairvoyant aka Thomas Nash (played in a short but creepy cameo by the inimitable and immobile Brad Dourif), who's the mastermind behind the Centipede program and rent-a-bad-guy Ian Quinn's nefarious doings. Or is he? There were some definite shadows cast over whether or not Nash was really the Clairvoyant or just a patsy set up by the definite article to throw S.H.I.E.L.D. off his scent. He did have Deathlok bring them right to him, after all. But it's not like any answers are going to come from Nash any time soon, as the whole exercise was too much for Ward and he put a bullet in the gurning, wheelchair-bound fella. There was some headway made toward the Big Bad's true identity, though. The episode saw not one but two betrayals from agents: the first from Melinda May, who 's been spying on Coulson from the beginning for reasons we know not, but it's easy to imagine them not being so heinous as to kick her off the team (she is a fan favourite, after all); the second from Victoria Hand, who seemed intent on blowing everyone but Coulson out of the sky shortly after the team sussed out that the Clairvoyant is almost definitely an agent of S.H.I.E.L.D. Whether Hand's the head honcho herself or just another surrogate remains to be seen, but we'd bet on the latter as there are still six episodes (and a few more revelations) to go before the season's end. If the threat is coming from inside S.H.I.E.L.D., how high up does it go? And does it have anything to do with a certain terrorist organisation from a recent Marvel movie...?

5. The Winter Soldier Will Have Insane Consequences

Captain America: The Winter Soldier changes everything for S.H.I.E.L.D., and if the MCU is truly a shared universe then Agents Of S.H.I.E.L.D. will be completely different and way more complex after the events of that movie. Definite spoilers ahead... Let's start with the small stuff first: No more Sitwell! The loveable if inscrutable bald fella turned out to have been an agent of HYDRA mid-way through The Winter Soldier and ended up being killed off by the title character, breaking the hearts of the ten or so fans who actually knew his name. Of course, that didn't stop him from appearing in this week's episode of AoS €“ two weeks after the film opened in the UK €“ but that's easily explained by the MCU timeline placing the events of the series between Avengers and The Winter Soldier, which reportedly takes place around two years after the Battle of New York. Perhaps we'll see Coulson simultaneously mourning his friend and cursing the fact that he never knew of his treachery. Speaking of HYDRA, there's the small matter that S.H.I.E.L.D. had been infiltrated by its agents from its creation and as a result is rotten to the core. With it being disbanded by Fury €“ who goes into hiding at the end of the film €“ what will that mean for Coulson, his team and all the other agents around the world? It would seem cheap to keep season 2 pre-Winter Soldier as Marvelites have come to expect a certain degree of continuity and authenticity between properties, so we might see Coulson's team being part of a new organisation or flying solo come next autumn (if the show's renewed, that is), but the safer bet is likely on S.H.I.E.L.D. remaining intact in some form or other so that ABC don't have to change the series' title...

4. Coulson's Stopped Playing By The Rules

In the first half of the season Agent Coulson stuck to S.H.I.E.L.D. protocol near enough most of the time, only bending the rules on special occasions when he thought there was no other choice. As we all know, stories about people who follow rules aren't as interesting as those about folks who break 'em. Skye's the one member of the team who consistently breaks the rules, but she's usually brought back down to earth by the rest of the cast, with her incapacitating Agent Sitwell at the Hub being probably the most outrageous abuse of the pecking order she's guilty of. Well, now Coulson and the rest of the team have caught up, and Phil's ramping things up a notch. Determined to find out the truth of his resurrection, he had the team break into a restricted-access bunker and kill the two men guarding it, resulting in the whole compound coming down around their ears. (When are they going to get called up on that, by the way? I'd imagine Hand, Nick Fury or Maria Hill would like to have some stern words with Coulson when they find out...) Now Coulson's not just the affable company man he started out life as in Iron Man. He's got his own mission that doesn't necessarily align with what S.H.I.E.L.D. wants, and that means there's gonna be conflict. And conflict, as we know, is never a bad thing.

3. They Might Be Sneaking The Hulk In

As mentioned before, Sif made an appearance in a recent episode that tied into Thor: The Dark World, making her the third Asgardian to crop up on Agents Of S.H.I.E.L.D. among a whole host of other characters from both the Marvel Cinematic Universe and the comic universe proper, with some juicy casting details floating around for future episodes. We've had Agents Sitwell, Blake and Hand as well as big guns Fury and Hill, who are all well and fine, but the news that got the internet all atwitter a couple of weeks ago was the casting of Heroes' Adrian Pasdat as Glenn Talbot. For those who don't know, Talbot served under General Thunderbolt Ross and was one of the Hulk's major antagonists, both in trying to kill him and steal the affections of Betty Ross. With a previous nod to Bruce Banner's foe from The Incredible Hulk, Emil Blonsky (aka Abomination), in an earlier episode and the news that Pasdar will likely feature in more than one episode (gotta love that continuity), it's looking more and more like the worlds of S.H.IE.L.D. and the Hulk are getting closer than ever...

2. It's Ramping Up To A Killer Finale

As if the last point wasn't enough to convince you that Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D. has a ton of excitement all stored up for us, the story's getting so focused and intense now that a satisfying climax is almost inevitable. With Skye's murky origins and superhero potential still not revealed yet (but still being heavily hinted at every episode) and the show's fondness for focusing on her for moments of great discovery and emotion, there's bound to be more shocking moments for her character to come. The same can be said of Melinda May, who was just recently revealed to be spying on her teammates for as-yet-unnamed S.H.I.E.L.D. authorities who'd rather Coulson didn't find out the true extent of what happened to him in 'Tahiti'. That's bound to get out sooner or later, and it'll surely change the entire dynamic of the cast. Then there's Coulson himself, who's already wading into deep waters against both the Clairvoyant and S.H.I.E.L.D. itself, and it would be a huge surprise if he got out of the season unscathed. But there's one element of Season 1's ending that hasn't really been touched on yet, despite it being probably the most exciting thing about the show for nerds and fans of ludicrous plot twists and cruel character development alike. That thing's name is...

1. DEATHLOK!

Yep, you guessed it. Agents Of S.H.I.E.L.D. really threw everyone for a loop when they brought Mike Peterson back as a reformed semi-villain only to blow him up and replace most of his body with robotic parts to transform him into one of Marvel's weirdest and best-loved (if not that well-known) cult characters, Deathlok. He's been forced by the clairvoyant to do terrible things in order to survive and keep his son, Ace, out of harm's way, and every time we see him, Peterson becomes more machine than man with new parts and new orders. The fact that Mike's mind is still more intact than he'd like to admit, despite his declarations that "Mike Peterson is dead!" shortly before stomping on an agent's chest or firing a missile from is forearm, makes the prospect of his character all the more horrifying to consider and fascinating to watch. That the writers and producers are willing to put a character through such torture is proof that the show is capable of being much darker than many gave it credit for in the first half of the season, and despite the patently silly nature of Deathlok, it's really very encouraging to see Agents Of S.H.I.E.L.D. really throw itself into telling his story. It bodes well for their future treatment of other familiar characters and proves that AoS can work as long as it knows what story it's trying to tell. Well, that and proving that Deathlok is cool as f**k. Finding out what'll happen next with Peterson is one of the major draws of the series right now, and we've a feeling Agents Of S.H.I.E.L.D. isn't in the business of letting us down any more.

Contributor

Film history obsessive, New Hollywood fetishist and comics evangelist.