10 Reasons Why We’ve Already Given Up On The Gotham TV Show
With Smallville taking 10 seasons for a costume reveal and Arrow being a glorified male calendar photo-shoot, what hope does Gotham have?
Everyone loves Batman, but it takes years to put together a Batman movie and fans hungry for more are left waiting and waiting while Warner Bros and DC create the next epic starring The Dark Knight. The solution? Create a weekly Batman TV show! Enter Gotham, which is a TV show set in Gotham City... but without Batman?! TV shows have been getting more and more popular over the years as the quality has gone up and services like Netflix allow viewers to watch on any device they want, wherever and whenever. Both Disney (owners of Marvel) and Warner Bros (owners of DC) have seen the increasing popularity of superhero movies and decided to fill the gaps in between movies with shows like Marvel's Agents of SHIELD and the forthcoming Daredevil, Luke Cage and Iron Fist shows, and DC's numerous series' like Arrow and the forthcoming Flash, Constantine, and - arguably the most anticipated - Gotham. But while fans cheered at the announcement of having a TV series starring Jim Gordon that was based upon the critically acclaimed Gotham Central comics and/or Year One, once the initial excitement died down, the reality set in, and that - based upon various news stories coming out about the show - makes Gotham look like it's going to be just terrible. So why will the Gotham TV series likely bomb? Read on...
10. DC's Dismal TV Show Track Record

9. The Leaked Pilot Script 1: Awful Writing
A second draft of the pilot script was leaked a couple months ago which was full of worrying indications of how bad the series looked to be. The premise of the pilot is new-to-the-force Jim Gordon getting partnered with jaded, corrupt cop Harvey Bullock to solve the double murder of the Waynes, leaving their only son Bruce an orphan. As they go through Gotham searching for clues, numerous Batman references crop up and the pilot reveals it is nothing but a giant cheeseball. Among the many howlers in the script were the corny gangster phrases like "mopes," "loonybirds," "skell huggers, "sugar bunnies," and "a cool glass of milk". Is this supposed to be a comedy? What kind of gangster talks like a cartoon character? Or is this a period piece/parody of classic gangster movies? Gone is the well-spoken butler Alfred Pennyworth, replaced with a cockney geezer. The line from the script that stands out is: "Oi! Master Bruce! Stop playing silly buggers! Get your bloody arse down off there!". Um... ok...was this role originally written for Dick Van Dyke? And then there's Jim's fiancée Barbara, who says the line "Jim, you are the cleverest, bravest, goodest man in Gotham" which is the dictionary definition of exposition. The examples of lazy writing for the pilot script reveal a lack of any kind of freshness or originality in the concept to this series. If this is the direction the show is heading, it might well be the worst thing Batman-related since 1997's Batman & Robin.
8. The Leaked Pilot Script 2: Characters, schmaracters!

7. Time To Get Confused

6. Budgets Over Expectations

5. Gotham Central, Centrally Flawed

4. Adaptation Problems

3. Where Are The Bad Guys?
Every hero needs a villain so who's going to be Jim Gordon's nemesis? In the comics it's essentially Joker, the man who murdered his wife and crippled his daughter, which also makes him a closer friend to Batman, though he helps the Dark Knight out on nearly every costumed crazy. But there's no Joker in Gotham yet. There's no Poison Ivy, as she's just a kid, as is Catwoman (Catgirl?). Penguin is a two-bit thug. Riddler is a coroner. So if the colourful bad guys you know, the ones people are tuning in to see aren't there yet, who will Gordon face? Random street hustlers, drug dealers, cartoony mob guys? Yawn. Maybe he fights corruption within the force, which might be interesting might, because you can only do this storyline for so long before it gets dull but isn't especially Batman-y. And the villain does need to be Batman related because this is a Batman-esque show. That leaves the Falcones and Maronis; the mob families from books like The Long Halloween, Year One and the 2005 Nolan movie, Batman Begins. But cops vs. gangsters? What a cliché! And it's not appealing enough to bring in the Batman crowd or keep it for long anyway - and while a lot of villains appear here before they become villains, it's widely accepted that the costumed villains don't begin to appear until Batman comes onto the scene so, at least 10 years away then. There's no strong villain presence in this series a bit like the lack of a strong hero, which brings me to...
2. An Unlikely Hero For A Reason

1. The Bat In The Room
