10 Reasons Why We’ve Already Given Up On The Gotham TV Show

With Smallville taking 10 seasons for a costume reveal and Arrow being a glorified male calendar photo-shoot, what hope does Gotham have?

Gotham Logo Everyone loves Batman, but it takes years to put together a Batman movie and fans hungry for more are left waiting and waiting while Warner Bros and DC create the next epic starring The Dark Knight. The solution? Create a weekly Batman TV show! Enter €“ Gotham, which is a TV show set in Gotham City... but without Batman?! TV shows have been getting more and more popular over the years as the quality has gone up and services like Netflix allow viewers to watch on any device they want, wherever and whenever. Both Disney (owners of Marvel) and Warner Bros (owners of DC) have seen the increasing popularity of superhero movies and decided to fill the gaps in between movies with shows like Marvel's Agents of SHIELD and the forthcoming Daredevil, Luke Cage and Iron Fist shows, and DC's numerous series' like Arrow and the forthcoming Flash, Constantine, and - arguably the most anticipated - Gotham. But while fans cheered at the announcement of having a TV series starring Jim Gordon that was based upon the critically acclaimed Gotham Central comics and/or Year One, once the initial excitement died down, the reality set in, and that - based upon various news stories coming out about the show - makes Gotham look like it's going to be just terrible. So why will the Gotham TV series likely bomb? Read on...

10. DC's Dismal TV Show Track Record

For some reason, when it comes to the small screen, DC do not produce anything worth watching - they produce garbage. The Superman TV series, Smallville, took the potentially awesome idea of a young Superman slowly discovering his powers and managed to turn it into a cheesy high school dork-drama where Clark was kept out of the costume until the very end. It was the most tenuous of connections to a Superman show fans would actually want to watch. Then there's Arrow, a series which is so ashamed of its comics progenitors that it won't even put "Green" in the title, which is yet another hammy show that takes itself way too seriously and comes off as just silly and embarrassing (look at the promos of guys with their shirts off €“ is that supposed to make comics fans want to watch and bring in straight male viewers, one of the largest demographics?). That Gotham is to follow in the footsteps of these awful shows does not inspire confidence that it will be any different or better than them. It looks like it'll turn into another unwatchable DC TV show crapfest.

9. The Leaked Pilot Script 1: Awful Writing

character_bio_576_alfred5 A second draft of the pilot script was leaked a couple months ago which was full of worrying indications of how bad the series looked to be. The premise of the pilot is new-to-the-force Jim Gordon getting partnered with jaded, corrupt cop Harvey Bullock to solve the double murder of the Waynes, leaving their only son Bruce an orphan. As they go through Gotham searching for clues, numerous Batman references crop up and the pilot reveals it is nothing but a giant cheeseball. Among the many howlers in the script were the corny gangster phrases like "mopes," "loonybirds," "skell huggers, "sugar bunnies," and "a cool glass of milk". Is this supposed to be a comedy? What kind of gangster talks like a cartoon character? Or is this a period piece/parody of classic gangster movies? Gone is the well-spoken butler Alfred Pennyworth, replaced with a cockney geezer. The line from the script that stands out is: "Oi! Master Bruce! Stop playing silly buggers! Get your bloody arse down off there!". Um... ok...was this role originally written for Dick Van Dyke? And then there's Jim's fiancée Barbara, who says the line "Jim, you are the cleverest, bravest, goodest man in Gotham" which is the dictionary definition of exposition. The examples of lazy writing for the pilot script reveal a lack of any kind of freshness or originality in the concept to this series. If this is the direction the show is heading, it might well be the worst thing Batman-related since 1997's Batman & Robin.

8. The Leaked Pilot Script 2: Characters, schmaracters!

Besides the coma-inducing dialogue, the leaked script also revealed how poorly conceived the show's characters are in this version of Gotham. Oswald Cobblepot is introduced as a low level goon working his way up the criminal ladder. This interpretation ignores the fact that the Cobblepots are established as one of the founding families of Gotham and are as rich as, if not more so, than the Waynes. Why would Oswald settle for starting at the bottom rung of the ladder when his power, wealth and ego would dictate otherwise? (That's not enough forgetting that one of the characters says of Oswald that he "looks like a penguin" €“ gah!) There are other references to Batman's more famous rogues like the comedian telling bad jokes in a club, which might hint at the Alan Moore Joker origin seen in The Killing Joke where he was originally a failed stand-up comic. And Gordon and Bullock come across a young girl called Ivy with a fondness for plants €“ which ignores the fact that Poison Ivy's real name is Pamela Isley. But then again this doesn't seem like a smart show, so it has to spell things out for the viewer. The worst characterisation is with regards our hero, Jim Gordon, who's written as an open-mouthed, naïve fool who's shocked at the prevalent crime in Gotham. This isn't his first day as a cop, so why should he be surprised at the level of crime in Gotham? Hasn't he heard anything about how terrible crime is in Gotham? Is he not a man of the world? Is he a complete idiot? Gordon is an intelligent, practical, and highly moral man who wouldn't be shocked at the crime and corruption in Gotham because that's not his character. At least in the comics €“ in the TV series? He's a nitwit. And that's not a character an audience can get behind.

7. Time To Get Confused

For some reason, Gotham is going to be similar in style to the Gotham Central comics with one major difference €“ Batman won't be in it. However, Bruce Wayne will. A 10 or 12 year old Bruce Wayne. What's that famous Hollywood phrase about not working with kids... Why is Batman not in a show about Gotham and why is he a child? What's so important about showing the origins of characters before they become interesting? It's not. But crucially, once Bruce grows up and becomes 21-22 (about the age he is in Year One when he becomes Batman), Gordon will be in his 40s, Bullock in his 50s (if not 60s), Montoya in her 40s/50s, and everyone else €“ his rogues gallery - will be much older. What's heroic about a young twenty-something in prime physical health going up against middle-aged geezers? Nothing. Setting it in the past is just baffling €“ it's a time when none of the characters become at all interesting, nor is it a time when the most interesting person in the DC Universe, and the whole reason anyone would watch this show, Batman, becomes Batman.

6. Budgets Over Expectations

The producers of Marvel's Agents of SHIELD complained recently that viewers expected too much from the series; that they went in believing they were getting a Marvel movie every week - which just wasn't feasible given the budget they had (though in actuality, the reasons why viewers didn't respond to Agents of SHIELD were fundamental flaws; characters you didn't care about, storylines that didn't make sense, bad writing, etc.). The reason why the focus is on the Gotham City Police Department AND is set before Batman and the many costumed villains appear is to keep budgets down. Take a gander at the TV schedules and you'll see a dozen or more cop shows €“ why? Because they're cheap to make and are quite popular. Gotham looks to be another cop show in the mould of CSI/Law and Order/Every Generic Cop Show. With cop shows, you don't need flashy special effects, office sets are cheap, and locations tend to be limited and readily available, especially in a city that could easily be replicated. But do Batman fans want to see a cop show/police procedural or do they want Batman? Of course it's the latter. So it doesn't matter if you come up with a way to set a show in Gotham and make numerous references to Batman within it €“ it's still a cop show/police procedural. Fans of the comics don't want CSI: Gotham, they want Batman. Gotham won't give them that €“ but they will give them cameos of a kid with a sullen expression and his cockney butler in between Gotham PD poring over case files and eating donuts. Exciting!

5. Gotham Central, Centrally Flawed

Gotham looks to be inspired by the award-winning comic series Gotham Central by Ed Brubaker, Greg Rucka and Michael Lark. It focuses on the Gotham City Police Department and their perspective on the crimes in Gotham perpetuated by villains like the Joker, Mister Freeze, Firefly and so on, plus their relationship with Batman. It's an interesting premise but the way it came off was flawed in one major way: none of the characters were interesting. Characters like Montoya, Bullock and Gordon made brief appearances but the cast was made up of generic cop characters €“ I can't even name them, despite having read the series, because they're so forgettable! Moreover, in most of the Gotham Central storylines, when things got too out of hand the writers had the deus ex machina of Batman, where they could send him in to save the cops and put down any threat single-handedly. It underlined just why Batman is more famous than any of the cops and why he's more interesting to read about than any one of them. And yet, should the producers choose to follow Gotham Central's setup, these are the characters who look to make up the majority of the screen time in Gotham. Granted, it looks like Gordon and Bullock are going to be getting more face time, but who's looking forward to a dull police procedural featuring a cast of nobodies playing nobodies? And that's basically Gotham Central in a nutshell.

4. Adaptation Problems

Besides featuring a cast of boring police non-characters, Gotham Central did have some high points but these were in relation to Batman and the villains he fought. The first story features Mister Freeze killing some GCPD detectives and the best story of the series, Soft Targets, features the Joker setting up timed sniper rifles around the city to kill Gotham officials (a storyline Christopher Nolan used a lot of in The Dark Knight). The problem here is that there is no Batman €“ Bruce Wayne is a 10-12 year old €“ and there is no Mister Freeze, Joker or any of the brilliant rogues gallery. Penguin is some two-bit street thug and not a crimelord, while Ivy appears to be a pint-sized urban gardener. So the one hook that the Gotham Central series had that worked €“ ordinary police going up against Batman villains €“ isn't in Gotham. Why bother setting this in Gotham at all then? The reason Gotham City is an interesting place is because of the performance artist villains and Batman €“ neither of which are in this series.

3. Where Are The Bad Guys?

Gothamcentral5 Every hero needs a villain €“ so who's going to be Jim Gordon's nemesis? In the comics it's essentially Joker, the man who murdered his wife and crippled his daughter, which also makes him a closer friend to Batman, though he helps the Dark Knight out on nearly every costumed crazy. But there's no Joker in Gotham yet. There's no Poison Ivy, as she's just a kid, as is Catwoman (Catgirl?). Penguin is a two-bit thug. Riddler is a coroner. So if the colourful bad guys €“ you know, the ones people are tuning in to see €“ aren't there yet, who will Gordon face? Random street hustlers, drug dealers, cartoony mob guys? Yawn. Maybe he fights corruption within the force, which might be interesting €“ might, because you can only do this storyline for so long before it gets dull €“ but isn't especially Batman-y. And the villain does need to be Batman related because this is a Batman-esque show. That leaves the Falcones and Maronis; the mob families from books like The Long Halloween, Year One and the 2005 Nolan movie, Batman Begins. But cops vs. gangsters? What a cliché! And it's not appealing enough to bring in the Batman crowd €“ or keep it for long anyway - and while a lot of villains appear here before they become villains, it's widely accepted that the costumed villains don't begin to appear until Batman comes onto the scene €“ so, at least 10 years away then. There's no strong villain presence in this series €“ a bit like the lack of a strong hero, which brings me to...

2. An Unlikely Hero For A Reason

Jim Gordon is the protagonist of a show called Gotham. What's wrong with this picture? There's no Batman, yes, but Gordon also isn't that interesting a main character €“ that's why he's a supporting character in a larger story. Granted, Gordon plays a major part in arguably the greatest Batman book of all time; Year One, and his story is brilliant. But Year One is a four-issue story arc and Gotham is likely to be a 10-20-odd episode season. Gordon's simply not going to be fascinating for that long. And Year One was also interesting because we got to see Bruce Wayne becoming Batman €“ which we won't see in Gotham because he's a 10-12 years old! Gordon does become more interesting later on when he becomes Commissioner. His wife gets killed and his daughter gets crippled by Joker, he becomes a major component of the No Man's Land storyline when Gotham becomes an abandoned city left to criminal gangs, and in numerous other Batman stories. But all of these things hinge on Batman and his villains being present. Because Gotham takes place before either exist, we're left with a naïve cop with none of the major adversities that shape his character happening yet and don't look to happen anytime soon. In other words, he's a main character not worth watching. A Batman origin story is interesting; a Jim Gordon one is not.

1. The Bat In The Room

By far the biggest problem in a Gotham TV show is the massively felt absence of the character who put Gotham on the map: Batman. Producers have tried to go around this problem by shoving in a token kid to play Bruce Wayne, but that's not what viewers want to see €“ Gotham needs the Dark Knight just like he needs Gotham. It's understandable that producers might not be keen to include Batman because of various problems €“ the cost, plus would the TV show mirror the movies, meaning would they need Ben Affleck to be in the TV show making cameos, or would they cast someone different and throw the proposed DC Universe of TV shows/movie synergy out of whack? But Batman and his rogues are the only aces that could make Gotham a winning hand. Even if Batman doesn't speak and they get a body builder in the outfit to stand in the background, that'd markedly improve interest in the series. It would also mean the inclusion of the villains €“ Joker, Riddler, etc. would all come into play as the icons they are, not dreary prototypes of the antagonists they will be. Bottom line is viewers are going to watch Gotham expecting to see Batman and instead they're going to get a kid and a handful of referential characters like a weird cockney butler, a thieving 14 year old who likes cats, and a number of weak nods to characters they care about in the very early stages of becoming the beloved characters. Gotham can't be Gotham without Batman €“ only Batman can save Gotham and without him, the series will definitely fail. Do you think Gotham will be successful? Are you looking forward to the show? Let us know in the comments below!

In this post: 
Batman Gotham
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

I reads and watches thems picture stories. Wordy words follow. My blog is http://samquixote.blogspot.co.uk , and if you want to see all the various places I contribute to, or want to send me a message, you can find links to everything here: http://about.me/noelthorne/#