10 Sci-Fi TV Shows That Wasted Great Characters

The writers owe these characters an apology!

Gotham Jerome
Fox

Sci-Fi TV is a universe filled from cover to cover with some of the most remarkable characters you'll ever find. Whether you're playing with massive concepts like space travel or smaller, more believable ideas though, a series is only as good as its cast.

You can love properties like Doctor Who or Sense8 for their wicked action or broad concepts, but it's the loveable people who inhabit those worlds that keep it fresh. Aliens are a dime a dozen, but The Doctor is something special. This is why shows need to nail their characters down with the force of a Hadron collider.

For the most part, big sci-fi shows tend to understand this balance, as they populate their projects with plenty of eye-catching personalities. Still, even the biggest masterpiece has its flaws.

The following ten characters are the ones that got away, the ones who seemed like they could have given their shows a healthy dose of flavour but were misused and misguided, resulting in disappointment. Sure, many of these shows are still great, but that doesn't save them from wasting these fantastic faces.

--

This list will contain spoilers, so be warned!

10. President Loki (Loki)

Loki Series President Loki
Marvel Studios

Loki seems like a great jumping-off point, as while the show was popular and well-received, it still felt like a heaping pile of missed opportunities. Even at its best, it was missing an extra dose of that signature Marvel charm, which could be seen in the wasted characters. Names like He Who Remains and Judge Renslayer are up there, but one that really slipped through the cracks was President Loki.

This variant came along and instantly filled the screen with the classic Loki trickster vibe fans fell in love with. Hiddleston was once again milking every moment and chewing the scenery like a rabid goat on lettuce. He was fun, nostalgic and entertaining, and then he got his hand chomped off and never came back.

While the show was juggling a lot, it was a waste to avoid a full showdown between these Loki variants. Not only would it have been deliciously fun, but it would have been the perfect way to show how far the central Loki had come since he became embroiled with the TVA, literally fighting a version of his former self.

Fans deserved less awkward romance and more evil Loki fun!


9. Jenny (Doctor Who)

Doctor Who The Doctor's Daughter Jenny
BBC Studios

Ah, Jenny, the infamous daughter of the iconic Doctor. She's off somewhere in the universe right now, running her little heart out, but will fans ever get to see it? No, of course not!

"The Doctor's Daughter" was a fun and compelling episode of this long-running series that explored the idea of war, cloning and misunderstanding. But, the biggest takeaway was Jenny, a clone created from the Tenth Doctor's DNA. As the biological offspring of The Doctor, she had a lot to live up to, and she certainly made a great first impression.

Jenny was fun, curious, determined and overall, brilliant. She was a real chip off the old block. However, while the episode's ending saw her venturing off into space, ready to explore the cosmos and seemingly poised for a return to the series one day, fans never saw her again.

Of course, there's further evidence that the show messed up by not bringing her back, as the character has appeared in comics and audio series outside of the main canon and has been a delight in them all.


8. Players 069 And 070 (Squid Game)

Squid Game 069 And 070
Netflix

In a year full of shocks, Squid Game's sudden rise as the most popular show of 2021 was undoubtedly among the most surprising. But despite being one of the year's biggest accomplishments, it suffered from a host of issues. Of all its shortcomings, the misuse of these characters really stood out.

Plenty of background characters lacked spotlight in Squid Game, but players 069 and 070 were chief among them. Seeing people betray each other in this show was par for the course, but the tragedy of a married couple trying to wade through it together was utterly compelling and something that could have been explored way more.

This was especially noticeable after player 069 outlived his wife and was arguably responsible for her death. The show set up the really fascinating idea of a man battling on whilst full of guilt, but rather than exploring his grief in a meaningful way, he was quickly killed off via suicide.

In the end, this incredibly compelling conflict and horrifying thought became a simple punchline for one of the infamous VIPs, laughing at his number 69 moniker. What a waste!


7. Libby (Lost)

Libby lost
ABC

Lost is a modern TV masterpiece and a classic show at the same time. Despite that, it's hardly known for capitalising on all its best pieces, quite the contrary in fact. It was a show riddled with abandoned stories and lacklustre payoffs, which lead to plenty of characters suffering.

The show had no shortage of wasted figures (such as Ilana, Ana Lucia and Mr Eko) but, Libby was a real sore spot for viewers. She made a quick impression thanks to her relationship with Hurley and mysterious past, but was torn out of the show before viewers could get some depth from her.

Her lack of a flashback episode irked fans at first, but soon turned into a brilliant plot point after you found out that she spent time in the same hospital as Hurley. This mystery led fans to believe she would be fleshed out and that her backstory would be exciting. But then, she was killed off by Michael before anything was answered, leaving a tantalising carrot dangling on a stick.

While the show did attempt to deliver some answers in the season six flash-sideways narratives, it was too little too late.


6. Natira (Farscape)

Natira Farscape
SyFy

What do you get when you combine space exploration with the Jim Henson company? Plenty of awesome alien creatures, of course.

Farscape was an underrated gem of a show that explored almost every corner of the cosmos. However, while the series had a boatload of cool characters, this sublime and scaly Saltici was a cut above the rest, and thus, it's a real shame that she cut and ran.

Natira was the ruthless criminal leader of a Shadow Depository who became embroiled with the crew of the Moya over a few episodes. While she started as a clear antagonist, the lines became a blurred as she worked alongside the lead, Crichton, to save herself from the devilish Scorpius. However, before he could help her escape on the Moya, she left him for dead and was never seen again.

Bringing her onto the Moya would have let off some real fireworks, as her violence, confidence, and almost aristocratic tendencies would have brought some venomous spice to the crew. Her sudden departure from the show also left a juicy mystery that was never answered. I.e., where on Earth did she go?


5. Andrew Gilbert Mills - Agil (Sword Art Online)

Agil Sword Art Online
A1 Pictures

Now seems like the perfect time to talk about Sword Art Online, as this is the very year in which the show takes place. 2022 may not have NerveGear in real life yet, but what it does have is plenty of missed opportunities, so it's got that in common with SAO at least.

Sword Art Online is a show filled with colourful characters who all seem to revolve around the main protagonist Kirito. However, while these supporting figures get some fun designs and decent screen time, the same cannot be said for this hulking man.

Andrew Gilbert Mills (otherwise known as Agil in the SAO game world) provides something that no other character in the show does, and that's maturity. In the sea of young faces and small bodies, he's the beefy/adult figure who has so much potential when it comes to being a mentor figure and keeping the show from feeling all the same.

Sadly, as the series progressed, he got pushed more and more to the background, essentially devolving into a basic bartender. You could replace his role with a nameless character, and it wouldn't make a difference.


4. Adelai Niska (Firefly)

Niska Firefly War Stories
Fox

It's typically considered blasphemy to talk ill of the beloved cult classic Firefly. But, to be fair, the criticism here isn't that this character was bad; quite the opposite, it's that he deserved more screen time.

Niska was an utterly creepy and intimidating antagonist. His psychopathic tendencies made him incredibly frightening, and the weirdly polite/quiet performance from Michael Fairman made that all the more unsettling. However, his minor appearances felt like a missed opportunity.

His build-up in "The Train Job" painted a great picture of a terrifying man, and when he showed up in "War Stories", he delivered. But, the character ended up taking a backseat to the drama between Mal and Wash, which was a bit of a letdown. Here was a character so scary he could have been the overarching villain of the first series, but instead, he was a one-off appearance.

Of course, there's no way of knowing that the character wouldn't have eventually stepped up to the plate had the series not been unjustly cancelled. But, even so, it's a shame fans didn't see more of him in the season.


3. Barbara (Stranger Things)

Stranger Things Barbara
Netflix

It seems that even now, so many years since the debut of Stranger Things, fans are still talking about the show's lack of love for Barb. This unfortunate girl was unceremoniously kicked out of the now huge Netflix series, and viewers are far from being over it. It's one of the most infamous cases of making a great character, then killing them off too soon.

So, what made Barbara Holland so special? Well, in this show full of monsters and young teens, she was easily one of the most relatable characters. Her caution, kindness and general lack of confidence made it easy to root for her and gave Nancy a supportive figure to lean on. What did she get for all that? Murdered by a Demogorgon, that's what.

It's easy to see how Stranger Things could have utilised this character better. She could have been a big asset to helping the central cast navigate The Upside Down and still had so much more to give. Plus, her intense and sudden popularity (lest anyone forget the Justice For Barb movement) just showed how much of a missed opportunity she was.


2. Kuiil (The Mandalorian)

Mandalorian I Have Spoken
Disney+
I have spoken.

The Star Wars franchise is hardly unaccustomed to making loveable characters with iconic catchphrases, but Kuiil still felt exceptional. He was a hardened figure who'd suffered from a sordid past and felt truly weathered, but brought the right kind of gentle, mentor-like energy to season one of The Mandalorian.

There was so much to love about this guy, including his excellent performance (Nick Nolte on voice and Misty Rosas for the body), eye-catching design and general writing. He acted as the perfect contrast to Din Djarin and a wonderful protector for the ever beloved Grogu.

Unfortunately, despite doing everything right, he ended the season as a victim to two Imperial Scout Troopers whilst protecting Grogu. His death certainly did tug at the heartstrings, but that didn't stop it from feeling like a huge waste. There was still so much more he could have given, and there's no doubt he would have been a great asset in season two.

Let's also not forget that he was killed off-screen, leading to the reveal feeling anticlimactic. That's just adding insult to injury.


1. Jerome (Gotham)

Jerome Valeska Gotham
Fox

Jerome is infamous, to say the least. He was a bright spot in Gotham's acting department thanks to the compelling performance from Cameron Monaghan, but the writing side of that coin wasn't as shiny. There was also the elephant in the room that asked, "so, is he the Joker, or not?".

The character came along as a mother-killing carny who found himself tied up in Arkham Asylum before eventually breaking out and living life as a quasi-Clown Prince of Crime. Then, he was killed off, and it seemed the confusion was settled. But then, he was resurrected, and the mess just kept going. Then, in another baffling choice, he got killed off again and was succeeded by his brother Jerimiah. Overall, like many things in Gotham, it was rather confusing.

While he was certainly electric on screen, the writers never seemed to want to commit to him. Of course, the series was disavowed from calling him The Joker, as they weren't permitted to by DC. But, still, this character would have ended up being run into the ground no matter what his name was.


In this post: 
Gotham loki
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor

Michael is my name, overanalysing comedy is my game! Anime, wrestling, TV, movies and video games all live in my head rent free!