10 Sci-Fi TV Shows That Wasted Incredible Premises

Great ideas don't always translate so well...

Flash Forward
ABC

Having a strong and original central premise for the audience to invest in is the key to any show's success, especially in the world of Sci-Fi. Finding a story that is both innovative and engaging is something each entry on this list was able to conjure, but unfortunately due to a variety of reasons were unable to make the most of their cracking premise.

The range of strong premises here range from clever spinoff ideas, great new ideas revolving around time travel and the creation of the unlikeliest of protagonists. Each entry had the possibility of exploring their truly original and outstanding premise for multiple seasons if delivered in the style the premise demanded, but many shows on this list barely lasted a season.

While poor acting, low budgets and poor scripting often contributed to the shows wasted potential, a common theme with each entry was the poor tonal choices. Several entries on this list took itself far too seriously for a show that should have been great, campy fun, while other shows listed needed to done down their excessive elements to fully utilise their great initial concepts.

So kick back and reflect on what could have been, as we look at those incredible premises that Sci-Fi Tv shows totally wasted.

10. Torchwood

Torchwood poster
BBC Studios

Ah Torchwood, what could have been. The idea of a Doctor Who spinoff that explored how humans interacted with aliens when the Time Lord wasn't on Earth was an extremely exciting one. With Who show runner Russell T Davies also leading the way here, it seemed like it would be impossible for the show to fail. Oh, how wrong we were.

The premise for the show was actually set up in the first two seasons of the rebooted Doctor Who, with charismatic companion Captain Jack Harkness permanently brought back to life at the climax of Christopher Ecclestone's one season as the Time Lord. The 'seedy' origins of the Torchwood organisation which Captain Jack rebuilt was explored in great detail through David Tennant's first season, including its creation by Queen Victoria.

Unfortunately Torchwood got off on the wrong foot with the pilot episode and never really recovered from there. Rather than concentrate on the world of possibilities of how mankind deals with their aliens visitors, the show tried way too hard to distance itself from the successful show it had spun off from.

That may not have been a disaster in itself, but the show tried so hard to be edgy and 'adult', that it failed to have any soul. The characters were all so mean spirited and the feel of the show was so downbeat that it was hard to invest in any of the so-so alien threats put forward. It's a real shame, because the premise was a ripper.


9. Hard Sun

Hard Sun
BBC

The premise for this critically panned and generally unwatched Sci-Fi product was actually a gem. Jim Sturgess and Agyness Deyn played British Police officers Charlie Hicks and Elaine Renko, who in the midst of their investigations find out a horrifying secret- the world will be destroyed in five years time.

A story that followed a pre-apocalyptic rather than post-apocalyptic world was as strong a premise for a new show as one could hope for. The premise was not only original, but could easily have been used to explore how Earth's citizens dealt with their imminent demise and how Governments would react to the ensuing panic.

Unfortunately rather than explore these broader issues, the show proved to be nothing more than a convoluted B grade chase story, with various 'dark forces' attempting to kill off the officers so that the apocalyptic event could remain secret. The show plays out like the boring opening sections of the film 2012, while leaving out any of the exciting bits and adding a truckload of exposition.

It's a great shame as the storyline had so many strong possibilities, but the show runners unfortunately decided to go down a more obvious, cliched and uninteresting path instead.


8. Ghosted

Ghosted Fox Tv Show
Fox

This supernatural Sci-Fi Sit-Com from Fox looked like the perfect show to sit back and have a few good laughs at in the style of the Men in Black franchise. Hopes were elevated significantly when first rate comedians Adam Scott and Craig Robinson were cast as the two leads, lifting hopes that the show could be a success.

The story explores the characters of Max Jennifer and Leroy Wright, a professor and police police officer played by Scott and Robinson respectively. The pair are 'kidnapped' by an MIB style organisation The Bureau Underground, who set them on a task of crucial importance. The task for these two mismatched partners is to investigate supernatural activities that threatens to wipe out human existence.

Unfortunately the comedy pairing of Scott and Robinson fails to fire, with lame jokes and a distinct lack of chemistry from the pair holding the show back. Having Scott reign in his normal energetic persona and depict him as a nerd is a strange one, that really limits the show's comic potential.

On top of this is a lame romantic subplot between Scott's character Max and co-worker Annie, that is explored in an un-engaging and unhumorous manner. It also takes up a stack of screen time at the expense of the more interesting supernatural events occurring around them.

All hopes of the show hitting its straps as the first series continued was quickly diminished, a boring subplot about a mole existing inside The Bureau Underground removing any remaining interest in the show.


7. Seven Days

7 Days
UPN

Some of the best story ideas comes in its simplicity, and they didn't come any better than the wonderful premise for this Sci-Fi Drama. The premise saw an experimental teleport being made operational that transported our protagonist, Frank, seven days into the past to stop catastrophic events before they occurred.

Frank, portrayed with real verve by Jonathon LaPaglia, was an intriguing lead man due to his contrasting moods, his uber confident persona hiding his issues with depression. The pilot episode is spectacular, with Frank heading back a week in time in an attempt to stop the murders of the US and Russian Presidents. The next episode managed to raise the stakes once more, as Frank used the teleport to stop a virus being spread that would kill 98% of the world's population.

Of all the shows on this list, this is one that wasted its great premise by going too hard too early. Having saved the Presidents of the world's two superpowers and then saving mankind from an extinction level event, the show simply gave itself nowhere to go. Each episode following this felt insignificant in comparison, and the ratings suffered accordingly.

The self-contained stories of each episode proved to be a flaw, with the show becoming something you'd watch if there was nothing else on, without ever being the must watch product the premise promised.


6. The 4400

The 4400 Summer Glau
CBS

This show from the 00's that borrowed themes of The Bermuda Triangle and Close Encounters of the Third Kind, managed to kick off proceedings in engaging enough fashion. The premise saw the return of 4400 missing persons, all who were abducted from different periods across time, but return with no memory of what has occurred to them and without ageing a day.

Adding even more interest to this premise was the fact that some of the returned humans had returned with special powers. The idea of different members of the 4400 using their powers for negative reasons, combined with the increased fears and reactions of modern society towards the returned humans, was extremely exciting and explored well in the shortened first season.

Unfortunately, like our previous entry, the show moved too quickly and dug itself a hole it couldn't get out of. The final reveal of the first season unveiled that the humans had not been abducted by aliens as expected, but were instead taken by mankind of the future. Revealing the mystery so early in the show's run proved a dud move, the audience having little reason to stick around as the narrative possibilities dried up.

While the show remained critically praised throughout its tenure, the show was cancelled after four steady but not spectacular seasons and declining ratings throughout. The show was by no means terrible, but considering its outstanding premise it couldn't help but feel like a bit of a let down.


5. The Highwayman

The Highwayman
NBC

A truly bonkers premise set up for this 1987 Futuristic TV series, was equally parts camp and inspired. The show followed Sam Jones character 'Highwayman', one of a group of futuristic US Marshals who tracked down vicious criminals. The Highwayman travelled in a large black, computerised truck that helped him track down notorious criminals on a weekly basis.

The darker 'Knight Rider meets Mad Max' style premise could have been a hoot, a combination of epic action and great campy Sc-Fi fun. The pilot episode for the series had the Highwayman's truck turn invisible thanks to its stealth capabilities, another great over the top idea, that unfortunately went missing as the show progressed.

Sadly the show was a bust, horrendous acting and cliched scripting turning the show into a bad joke without the campy fun. The lack of a big budget required to make the concept a success was a major issue, the adventures becoming very same-same as the show's sole season dragged on.

There were numerous issues with the show's execution, including an awful and ill thought out attempt to cash in on the recent success of Australian film Crocodile Dundee. The casting of Australian Rules footballer Mark 'Jacko' Jackson in the key role of Jetto proved to be a disaster, Jackson's fiery off screen demeanour no doubt leading to Directors being too scared to make any constructive criticism of his woeful attempts at acting.


4. Manimal

Manimal TV Show
NBC

When it comes to awesome premises, they don't come more bizarre and brilliant than this 1983 show. As the title unsubtly suggests, the show explores the life of a man who has the ability to turn himself into an animal. Depending on the requirements of the episode, Dr. Jonathon Chase would transform into a bird or panther, while occasionally popping into other forms such as a shark.

The show was appropriately cheesy in style, but without the humour that was required to make such a fun but silly premise work. Each transformation from man to animal was drawn out in excruciating detail, with actor Simon McCorkindale looking like he was extremely constipated while changing from human to animal.

The stories were all lightweight 'police detective' stories of the week, when the concept was really crying out for a more comic book feel. The Manimal really needed some more otherworldly type villains to take on rather than the goon of the week served up here, as there was never any real sense of threat.

The acting isn't much either, Melody Anderson delivering a performance worthy of a pantomime as Chase's best friend, detective Brooke Mackenzie. Simon McCorkindale fails in the other direction as the Manimal, giving a consistently dull and lifeless performance for a character that just had to be played over the top.


3. Flash Forward

flash forward
ABC

If there was ever a TV pilot that got fans excited about a new show, it was most definitely Flash Forward. The show followed the moment when (nearly) every citizen on Earth 'blacks out' for a period of 137 seconds, with each person envisioning how their life would look in six months time. Be it a return to alcoholism, the instigation of an affair or no vision at all, the prospect of seeing what lies ahead in life proved a truly exciting and innovative premise.

The opening episodes of the series were actually quite decent, with our protagonist detectives chasing down those responsible while trying to avoid the fates that awaited them. There wasn't any real weak link in the acting either, with Joseph Fiennes strong as FBI agent Mark Bedford, whose visions contained crucial information in regards to the mystery.

Sadly the show just didn't seem to know which direction to head in, becoming bogged down at the very point it should be driving forward. The decision to have an FBI agent kill himself to avoid his fate was probably meant to act as a game changer that opened up possibilities, but instead managed to undo the whole concept, with the 'forward visions' that the show was built around now meaning nothing.

The biggest issue that the show runners just couldn't overcome was that the audience literally knew what was coming, meaning it was tough to build up suspense to an exciting end point because we had already seen it.


2. Manifest

Manifest NBC
NBC

This 2019 Drama nearly grabbed top spot thanks to having the widest discrepancy between quality premise and woeful execution. The premise is somewhat like Lost, but if anything, actually had more potential due to its grounding on Earth and Avengers Endgame like scenario. Sadly the show is a bit of a car crash, with cliched plotting and terrible acting the order of the day.

The premise sees a passenger flight take off from Jamaica, and after encountering a storm, seemingly land a few short hours later at their destination point, New York. Then comes the ripping twist, with the reveal that the plane has actually landed five years in the future, with the flight presumed crashed and the passengers dead.

The exploration of the passengers reintegrating into society alongside the investigation of what actually happened seemed a setup for spectacular results. Sadly, the show proved to be extremely pedestrian, with acting that wouldn't be accepted on the cheesiest soapie and the most cliched scripts known to man.

Melissa Roxburgh plays lead detective Michaela Stone, a passenger from the flight who hears mysterious messages in her head that prove to be important information. The scenes in which Stone hears the voices are unintentionally hilarious, Roxburgh's limited acting skills combined with lazy scripting making for the most ham-fisted television you'll see.

Every big moment in the script is signposted a mile off, while we care less and less about the fate of the surviving passengers the more time we unfortunately have to be in their company.


1. Man From Atlantis

Man From Atlantis
Atlantis

The winner, or should I say loser, for top spot on this list goes to this truly awful 1977 Sci-Fi bomb starring a pre-Dallas Patrick Duffy. Duffy's character, who is given the name Mark Harris, is an amnesiac who is believed to be the last survivor of the civilisation of Atlantis.

Harris has a series of unique abilities, including superhuman strength, the ability to breath underwater and physical traits that allow him to dive to the extreme depths of the Ocean. After being nursed back to health after arriving on Earth, Harris assists the US Navy on a number of missions, taking on various villains with uniquely aquatic plans.

While the premise set the show up for some great B-grade action and fun, the show took itself way, way too seriously, and ultimately became laughably bad for all the wrong reasons. Duffy clearly had a lot to learn on the acting front, bringing zero charisma to the role and a seeming lack of awareness that the show should have been campy fun.

Attempts at a love story between Harris and Belinda Montgomery's Dr. Elizabeth Merrill are excruciating, always matched by an equally painful music score. The costume designs for the various villainous creatures are bad for even 1977 standards, and look like rejected costumes from the Doctor Who classic era.


Watch Next


In this post: 
FlashForward
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor

While he likes to know himself as the 'thunder from down under', Luke is actually just a big dork who loves all things sport, film, James Bond, Doctor Who and Karaoke. With all the suave and sophistication of any Aussie half way through a slab, Luke will critique every minute detail of films and shows from all eras- unless it's 1990's Simpsons episodes, because they're just perfect