10 Scrapped Ideas For Star Trek: Enterprise Season 5

We were robbed, I tell you. Robbed! The fifth season of Star Trek: Enterprise could have been GREAT.

Archer Borg
Paramount

By now, we all know that Star Trek: Enterprise was the first live-action Star Trek series to be cancelled since the Original Series, back in 1969. This left a bitter taste in the mouths of Trekkies but also had the secondary effect of retroactively making the show seem like the red-headed stepchild of the franchise. Oh, that's the one that was cancelled, pass on that!

However, with enough time passing, Enterprise is finally getting a reappraisal that it deserves. This leads us to look at what the plans for the fifth season that never happened actually were. With whispers of returning characters, beefed up ships, and more tie-ins to classic Star Trek, it sounded like they were gearing up for their best year ever.

Showrunner Manny Coto undoubtedly raised the bar when he joined the series, and his ideas for the next year sounded absolutely fantastic. There were even plans to re-introduce an alien race that had only appeared in the Animated Series, thanks to the kind permission of SciFi author, Larry Niven.

Although a fifth season may never materialize, here are some of the best ideas that we never got to see.

10. Regenerating The Borg Queen

Borg Queen
Paramount

Star Trek: Enterprise managed to do the seemingly impossible in its second season. Regeneration made the Borg properly frightening again, thanks to a combination of smart writing, tight directive, and Brian Tyler's outstanding score for the episode. As this episode was a real success, Manny Coto wanted to revisit the Collective, while still keeping Star Trek canon intact.

Alice Krige was approached with a view to returning to Star Trek again. She had previously played the Borg Queen in both Star Trek: First Contact and Star Trek: Voyager. In the proposed fifth-season episode, she would appear as a Starfleet technician who came into contact with the Borg, thanks to the events of Regeneration. This would serve as an origin story for this particular Borg Queen.

As shown in Star Trek: Picard, any drone can become a Queen, so this fits canon as well - she need not necessarily be the same individual physically encountered by Jean-Luc Picard or Kathryn Janeway, yet could still very much bring the menace that she brought in the movie and Voyager's last episode. This is one of the many shames of Enterprise never receiving a fifth year.


9. Revisiting The Cloud Minders From Stratos

Star Trek Stratos
CBS

The Cloud Minders is a third season episode of The Original Series, which is surprisingly good, despite the poor ratings that the season received. It depicts local apartheid on the planet of Ardana, where the wealthy and elite live on Stratos, the city in the clouds, and the greatest example of anti-gravity engineering, according to Spock.

Manny Coto has stated on several occasions that he had plans to include a mini-arc of Enterprise visiting the planet. As Stratos was the Federation's main supplier of Zenite, it stands to reason that either Archer could have made first contact with the planet on behalf of Starfleet, or T'Pol could have informed them of its existence.

The original design of Stratos was sketched by Matt Jefferies, though never finished. The remastered episodes of the Original Series finally depicted the city in all of its glory, standing as one of the most beautiful locations in all of early Star Trek. The city did in fact make several cameos in Star Trek: Deep Space Nine. It appeared on screens in the replimat, alongside Risa, advertising both as popular holiday destinations.


8. An Entire Season In The Mirror Universe

Star Trek In A Mirror Darkly
CBS Media Ventures

The fourth-season two-parter In A Mirror, Darkly was a brilliantly fun story set entirely in the Mirror Universe. It served as both a prequel to Mirror, Mirror and as a sequel to The Tholian Web, depicting what exactly happened to the original USS Defiant. All of the cast got a chance to have fun with their characters, though the ending, which sees Hoshi take control of the Defiant and crown herself Empress of the Terran Empire was a tantalizing way to leave the audience wanting more.

Manny Coto had two ideas on where to go with this. The first, which was common to both, was that Hoshi's story needed to be followed up. The audience knew that by Kirk's time, the Terrans and Vulcans were the unquestioned rulers of the Alpha Quadrant, sporting technology identical to the Defiant, so the stage was set to show Hoshi's bloody rise to power.

Another idea, one that would have taken the above and gone berserk with it, was to have an entire season devoted entirely to the Mirror Universe. In a way, Star Trek: Discovery would borrow this idea, with almost half of its first season spent over there.


7. Thundercats

Star Trek Kzinti Jimmy Diggs
Jimmy Diggs/Glitchwerks 2005

In Star Trek: The Animated Series, writer Larry Niven loaned his creation, the Kzinti, to the franchise. They are effectively giant cats, any of whom could have been played by an actor in the shape of a Star Trek Into Darkness Klingon. They are honour-bound, and have made another appearance in Star Trek since, though in name only. In Star Trek: Picard, Riker says that they have had a little trouble with the Kzinti on Nepenthe.

For the fifth season of Enterprise, writer Jimmy Diggs designed a Kzinti ship that would have been a part of the story 'Kilkenny Cats', written by Manny Coto. This would have brought them into modern Star Trek, though of course, it didn't pan out.

There is a little mercy in this. In 2005, CGI had not truly advanced to a level of quality that would have allowed them to appear. While the Xindi Insectoid race was a great design, as were the Xindi Aquatics, there is the inevitable coldness that accompanies early CGI characters on a television budget, lest we even speak of the Gorn from In A Mirror, Darkly.


6. T'Pol Gets The Saavik Treatment

Star Trek Tpol
CBS

We were introduced to T'Pol's mother, T'Les, in the fourth-season episode Home. This episode was a little like Enterprise's take on Family, the fourth-season episode of the Next Generation. Both followed drawn-out periods of strain for the ship and crew, both saw crew members returning home, and both featured crises for them to face. Here, Trip was introduced to T'Les, which is stressful, to say the least.

However, T'Pol's father never featured in Enterprise, as he had died an uncertain number of years previously, sometimes before 2154. He was described as a stranger with whom T'Les fell deeply in love. Manny Coto had a twist planned.

T'Pol's father would turn out to have been a Romulan agent, operating on Vulcan. This would make T'Pol half-Romulan, which would go some way toward explaining why she was given to bouts of emotion, more so than the audience was used to. This had originally been proposed as the backstory for Lt. Saavik in Star Trek II: The Wrath of Khan but was dropped by Leonard Nimoy going into the next film. As the fifth season was a chance to further explore the Romulans, this would have been a perfect chance to explore T'Pol's loyalties.


5. The Birth Of The Federation

Star Trek Enterprise
CBS

One of the great unexplored periods of Star Trek's history surrounds the birth of the Federation itself. We have seen the beginnings of Starfleet, through the eyes of Archer and his crew. The adventures of the NX-01 were both exciting and a little frustrating, as there were elements of history that it couldn't tackle, not without running into the roadblock of canon.

The fifth season was potentially going to feature the birth of the Federation or at least that the groundwork would have been laid. The events of the fourth season brought the Andorians, Tellarites, and Vulcans closer together. They, along with humans, are the founding members of the Federation, so the process by which they became even closer allies was there to explore.

When Star Trek: Discovery began, the Federation was already pushing 100 years old, so there is a blank space between the two shows that would have been wonderful for the fifth season of Enterprise to depict. While there was a brief shot of Archer walking up to deliver a speech at the ceremony in These Are The Voyages, that episode was set ten years after the events of the fourth season. There are still plenty of stories left to be told there.


4. Continuing The Temporal Cold War

Star Trek Enterprise
CBS

The Temporal Cold War took up much of the first and second seasons of Enterprise, but the audience never truly warmed to it. With falling ratings, the Xindi Arc was introduced as a way of both spicing the show up, and washing away this plotline. When the show was renewed for a fourth season, Storm Front was created to wrap the storyline up once and for all.

Except, it didn't. There were still dangling plotlines that had gone unresolved. One such issue was - who exactly was the 'Future Guy' that had been speaking to Silik the whole time? Well, there were a couple of different directions that this could have gone in.

First, was that the shadow would turn out to be a Romulan agent, attempting to influence events of the past to protect the Empire in the future. This would tie into another entry on this list. Another idea was that the shadow would be revealed as Captain Archer himself. How exactly this would have come about still remains a mystery, but it would certainly have been a bit of a twist in Star Trek's history.


3. Whispers Of The Romulan War

Star Trek Enterprise
CBS

This leads on from the entry about the Temporal Cold War and about the 'Future Guy'. One idea was to have him revealed to be a Romulan agent, interfering with events in the past to protect the Empire in the future. The end of the Romulan arc in the fourth season promised that we would see them again, then of course we never did.

Had the show received a fifth season, the beginnings of the Romulan War would have been explored. It had long been established that before the events of Balance of Terror, the Federation and the Empire engaged in a brutal war, though never saw each others' faces. Enterprise cleverly acknowledged that the audience knew what they looked like, bringing them into the fourth season.

This could easily have allowed them to return in the fifth season, and even in later seasons again. The Dominion War had spanned two seasons of Deep Space Nine, so there was precedent to allow a multi-season war arc, especially with one of the greatest frenemies that Starfleet ever faced. As the events of the Romulan War led to consequences that continued well into the future, exploring it here would be the perfect opportunity to see exactly how bad this conflict got.


2. Requiem For A Flint

Star Trek Flint
CBS

Requiem For Methusaleh was a third-season episode of the Original Series, featuring the character of Flint, as he was then known. He was originally a human male, though he was immortal, living through thousands of years of human history. Along the way, he lived many, many lifetimes and even adopted the identities of some of Earth's greatest names.

He lived as King Solomon, Alexander the Great, Lazarus (said to be the basis of the story of resurrection), Leonardo da Vinci, and Johannes Brahms. Through all of this time, he saw the barbarity of human nature so, when he was finally able to do so, he left the planet to reside on Holberg 917G. It was there that the crew of the Enterprise encountered him, and Dr. McCoy confirmed that he was, finally, dying.

Manny Coto felt that he was an underutilized idea that deserved to be developed. He could easily come into contact with the crew of Enterprise without spoiling the timeline, as he had often posed as other identities. He could even reveal himself, requesting that his true nature be kept a secret. It was also possible that the Vulcans knew of him, as they wouldn't necessarily reveal their findings to Starfleet right away.

What is known is that he was at least aware of the birth of the Federation, meaning he could have been active on Earth around this time. There is nothing to suggest that he couldn't have been a key player in the drafting of the Federation Charter itself, which would have brought him into direct contact with Jonathan Archer.


1. More Shran!

Star Trek Shran
CBS

Jeffrey Combs needs to receive star billing on at least ONE Star Trek show, though we would be more than happy to see him lead all of them. However, this very nearly came to pass on the fifth season of Star Trek: Enterprise. He appeared in the show as a couple of characters, but his Andorian Commander Shran was his most popular by far.

Over the four years that the show did receive, he popped up at least once a season, if not several times more. Going into the fifth season, Manny Coto said that he would probably have been joining Archer's crew. He may not have joined Starfleet itself, but taken on a role rather like T'Pol's had been in the first season, a representative and observer for Andoria.

This, along with the rest of the entries on this list, are the cruelly tantalizing tastes of what could have been, had the show been given the full seven-year run that the Next Generation, Deep Space Nine ,and Voyager all received. Declining ratings, slashed budgets, and the mood of the times all combined to hurt the show. But those ideas are still there and, in this age of revivals and remakes, there is nothing to say that Alex Kurtzman won't give the show another shot.


Watch Next


In this post: 
Star Trek
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Seán is the host and head writer/presenter for TrekCulture, as well as a writer/presenter on WhoCulture and WhatCulture Horror. He has authored two novels, dozens of short stories, and hundreds of articles for WhatCulture. He holds a Master of Arts in Creative Writing from University College Dublin. As part of his work with TrekCulture, Seán has been invited to participate in collaborations with Roddenberry Entertainment, as well as contributing to several Star Trek community projects. An avid fan of Star Trek, Doctor Who, and the horror genre at large, Seán's expertise has helped develop these channels to the successes they are today. As host of the Ups & Downs series on TrekCulture, Seán has become internationally recognised for his positive yet critically informed approach to reviewing every episode of modern Star Trek, ensuring he is one of the go-to voices in the Trek community. Favourite Quote to describe himself: "I'm serious about what I do, just not always about the way that I do it"