10 Secret TV Pilot Episodes You Didn't Know Existed

Games Of Thrones, The Big Bang Theory & more we almost SO different!

Big Bang Theory
CBS

We've all heard of the elevator pitch: the 10-second presentation you make to investors to try and sell your dreams. Whether that be a new gadget, or an app idea or maybe even your own novel, you need a convincing elevator pitch if you want to sell your passion project to the world.

Well, in the land of television, the pilot episode works as its own elevator pitch. It's a way for showrunners to present their idea to studios, hoping that they'll see it and buy their hard work and turn it into a mega-hit tv show.

But seeing as a pilot episode is a lot longer than 10 seconds, a studio can love your idea while finding issues in the episode as a whole. Sometimes they'll book your show with the agreement that you'll take on board their criticisms and change some things around before airing. Or they give you a second chance to pitch the idea again, reworking the pilot completely.

So that means there are dozens and dozens of unaired pilots of popular shows just existing in the world with people having no idea they're out there! While some of these unaired pilots become almost as infamous as the show itself, others stay hidden for years... until today.

10. 30 Rock - From Sketch Show To Sitcom

Dratch 30 Rock
NBCUniversal Television DIstribution

30 Rock was conceived in the mind of Tina Fey while she was the head writer on Saturday Night Live. She believed her experience behind the scenes was unique enough to warrant its own tv show, and boy was she right!

However, originally 30 Rock was planned to be a lot closer to SNL than it came out being. In the first pilot, the show had more of an SNL vibe, with quick flashes of scenes and more of a focus on the sketches that happen on The Girlie Show (the tv show that Fey's character works on). Another leading factor into the SNL-esc feel was the hiring of legendary SNL alum Rachel Dratch as the star of The Girlie Show.

Once the pilot was complete, Tina Fey and the other producers decided to move 30 Rock further away from Fey's previous job. They did this by focusing more on Fey's character and what she gets up to behind the scenes. They also recast Dratch's character with a more traditional sitcom actress Jane Krakowski; instead of a character actress like Dratch.

SNL fans were gutted when the apparent original conception of the show was leaked, as they felt cheated by the left turn Fey made when tinkering with the pilot.


9. Charmed - The Other Phoebe

Charmed Phoebe
WB

Oftentimes, a roughly made pilot episode is created as a basic pitch to television studios, meaning that many details are less thought out or crassly executed. This can result in script differences, set and prop changes and even character switches. For Charmed's initial pilot, all of these things were present.

Firstly, the episode was only 30 minutes long, 17 minutes shorter than what we usually expect from Charmed and because of this, many crucial scenes were left out completely. Some of the small set and prop differences include the iconic Halliwell Manor being called "The Warren Manor", and The Book Of Shadows being much less extravagant in looks. Most probably as it was just supposed to give the studio an idea of what it could look like.

The biggest differences, however, were casting ones. First, the character of Daryl the cop didn't exist at all, so there was no back and forth, witty banter between Daryl and his partner Andy to bring comedy to the episode.

On the topic of Andy, not only was he barely in the episode, he was played by a completely different actor. And finally, the beloved character of Pheobe was originally played by Lori Rom, but she quit shortly after the show was picked up due to religious conflict, and Alyssa Milano was thankfully brought in to take over the role.


8. Desperate Housewives - Last Minute Change

Desperate Housewives
ABC

Imagine spending months auditioning during the pilot season for 10 maybe 20 different projects, forgettable dramas, sitcoms etc, and then you make it the second round of auditions for the season's hottest new show. Then you get the third round, the fourth, you start doing chemistry readings and camera tests and you feel like maybe, this year, you actually have a chance of booking a role; on a good show no less!

And finally, you get the call that you've booked the pilot, you're ecstatic and you put everything you have into filming the episode, only to find out that the show has been ordered to series... and you're not a part of it. God, that must suck.

While Desperate Housewives often showcases heartless and cold characters, it was the studio executives that were really the heartless ones here. Because while most reshot pilot episodes feature maybe one casting difference, the Desperate Housewives one featured three.

Two of the male heartthrobs of the show, Rex and John, were portrayed by completely different actors, which must have sucked for the men but at least the characters were only in the main cast for season one.

But by far the most major casting change came with the role of Mary Alice Young, the show's narrator and integral part of the show. Initially, Sheryl Lee played the part, but she didn't please the studio gods and was cut. She must still be rolling in her Mary Alice grave knowing how famous the show became.


7. The Munsters - Once, Twice, Three Times A Munster

The Munsters
CBS

Besides the iconic titular Munsters, the most memorable part of the show was that it was shot in black and white, giving the show its signature quirky feel. So it's odd to find out that the original pilot was shot not only in colour but with a bright and whimsy pallet. The change to black and white was what made sure The Munsters and The Addams Family were always synonymous with each other.

This fact is especially ironic when considering the addition of the character Lily Munster in replacement of Phoebe. You see, Phoebe was originally the matriarch of the family and was played by Joan Marshall, but once the initial pilot was filmed and sold to a studio, the producers decided that the character was too similar to The Addams Family's matriarch Morticia.

So Joan was axed and Yvonne De Carlo was brought in. The character was not only renamed, but reworked in the makeup and wardrobe department too. After the tinkering of the mother character, and a recasting of the youngest Munster Eddie, the pilot was shot once again, but not much is known about this second unaired episode.

The pilot that finally did air was a much longer, black and white version of its two previous tries, and the show quickly became a classic.


6. Buffy The Vampire Slayer - Where's Our Willow?

Willow Rosenberg Buffy The Vampire Slayer Dopplegangland
Mutant Enemy

Buffy The Vampire Slayer will go down in history as one of the greatest shows that has ever graced our tv screens for many reasons. It had iconic costumes, trailblazing episode concepts and incredible characters. One of these aforementioned characters was Willow Rosenberg, a nerd turned badass witch that made history with her same-sex relationship.

This relationship, her adorable characterisation and her multi-layered performance were all accredited to the brilliant actress Alyson Hannigan. So it's terrifying to think that she wasn't even part of the original pilot.

Initially, the episode featured actress Riff Regan in the role of Willow, who was said to have rubbed the studio executives up the wrong way, portraying the wallflower-esc character as a whiny and immature school girl. Thankfully Willow was taken another look at and the legendary Hannigan was cast in what became her career-defining role.

The change of actresses wasn't the only difference between the two pilots though. The original was only 30 minutes long in length rather than an hour, and most bafflingly, the character of Angel was nowhere to be seen and Sunnydale High was named Berryman High - a lot less ironic.


5. Bob's Burgers - Daniel, Gene And Louis

Bobs Burgers Test Pilot
Fox

The three Belcher siblings in the show Bob's Burger's are one of the highlights of the cartoon. Louis, the youngest, is a mischievous, smarter-than-her-years anarchist that constantly gets the group into trouble.

Gene, the middle child, is a mommy's boy with rhythm in his bones and food in his belly. And Tina, the eldest, is a sad sack, boy-crazy tween that lets her younger siblings rule her life more often than not.

But the original pilot featured a slightly different combination of siblings. Tina was initially written as Daniel, the Belcher's eldest son. Weirdly though, his pilot storyline was exactly the same as Tina's, with Daniel having a mysterious rash in his crotch area. The actor that played Daniel carried on with the show as Tina, so despite common belief, the character wasn't intentionally gender-bend cast.

Other differences stemmed from the fact that the creators had next to no money to create the cartoon and so it was drawn very roughly, with the characters having wonky eyes and genital-looking noses. Another disturbing feature was that Bob wore a tank top, creepily showcasing his extremely hairy body to the world.

It's also fun to note that before the first pilot was made, and the show was just a concept, the creators concieved the Belcher family as cannibals, which was obviously shut down but it did inspire the plot for the pilot episode "Human-Flesh".


4. The Inbetweeners - Baggy Trousers

Inbetweeners Jay
Inbetweeners

In probably the most dramatically different original pilots on this list, The Inbetweeners takes the cake with its 80's set version of the show named Baggy Trousers. You heard that right, the comedy was called Baggy Trousers originally, after the Madness song of the same name that released in 1980.

The show was in essence what The Inbetweens became, with four awkward, outcast, teen boys struggling through school, except with less cultural relevancy as The Inbetweens due to it being set 20 years earlier.

There isn't much known about Baggy Trousers. What we do know is that the characters all had different names and were portrayed by different actors and that 3 of the 4 boys followed the same character archetypes. Except for Jay, who didn't exist at all, in any way, but Jay's actor James Buckley actually was in the unaired pilot as a character named Neil.

It's unknown why the show wasn't picked up until it was reworked for the present day, but my guess is that it had something to do with the audience demographic being able to relate more to teens in the 2000s than in the 1980s.


3. Game Of Thrones - Worst Unaired Pilot In History

Game-of-Thrones Jon-Snow
HBO

Since the release of the book, Fire Cannot Kill A Dragon, many details about the behind the scenes of the most popular series of the last decade, Game Of Thrones, have come out about what happened on set. Including how awful the unaired pilot was.

This isn't just an isolated opinion either: it's something that crew members, the show makers, the cast and George R. R. Martin all agree on.

Some of the major issues included tacky costuming, like how Lena Headey's character Cersei was dressed like "a medieval Dolly Parton" and that Tyrion had a terrible wig on (which can be seen in a scene or two of the aired pilot).

Another serious issue was the confusing storylines that just weren't portrayed clearly enough to the audience. For example, viewers were unable to pick up on the fact that Jaime and Cersei were actually siblings. And, unbelievably, Emilia Clarke did not play Daenerys Targaryen in the unsuccessful pilot, another actress played the character!

The episode was reshot, but roughly 15% of the unaired pilot was put back into the one we saw, and that is why there are discrepancies when it comes to some of the characters' hair and make-up.


2. Big Bang Theory - Kaley Who-oco?

Big Bang Theory Original Pilot
CBS

Back when Big Bang Theory was dominating pop culture, rumours about the unaired pilot were everywhere. Telling the story of a successful pilot with one major problem: the character of Penny was played by a bad actress, and that Kaley Cuoco came in and saved the show.

Well, I hate to tell any fans that believed that rumour, but it's not entirely true. Actually the original, unaired pilot was completely different to the one we eventually got to see, and that was the problem. Yes, it is true that Cuoco wasn't a part of the unaired pilot, but the character Penny didn't even exist in the original! The only main characters that did exist were Leonard and Sheldon.

In fact, after the episode was first presented to studios, the creators were told that the two nerdy roommates were the only thing that actually worked with it and that to sell it they'd have to change everything else.

So, it was back to the drawing board, and the two female leads, Katie and Gilda, were written out of the show and Raj, Howard and Penny were written in with the 3 actors being brought in to portray the eclectic bunch. And the rest is history.


1. Avatar The Last Airbender - Nickelodeon Is A Hero

Avatar The Last Airbender Aang
Nickelodeon

The unaired pilot for Avatar The Last Airbender was made just to pitch the show to Nickelodeon, and therefore wasn't created with the care, funding or talents of the actual show.

The shorter version that was made, was roughly constructed, but it truly demonstrated how special the show could be with a big studio's backing. Thankfully Nickelodeon could see the potential and ordered the show to series.

One of the differences from the show included Mae Whitman's character being called Kya not Katara; fans will recognise that name as it was later given to the character's mother. Another crucial difference was a side plot that saw then-villain Zuko kill the unagi and keep the head as a trophy. A way of showing his coldness that ultimately didn't work with the redemption story the showrunners had planned for him.

But the biggest change came in a casting decision. The unaired pilot unbelievably featured Hannah Montana's Mitchel Musso as the main character Aang, but he was of course replaced with the voice actor we all know and love: Zach Tyler Eisen.


Watch Next


How Well Do You Know Netflix TV Shows?

Stranger Things Barb
Netflix

1. Name This TV Show

Contributor

Lily thought it was about time she wrote Top Ten lists for people other than herself. She also owes her dog a lot of money so she thought it was about time to pay her dues. There is no tv show she likes that she hasn't seen at least twice.