10 Serious Moments From Sitcoms

dwwd

People can go into sitcoms wanting very different things. The very fact that something has been labelled a situation-comedy means that it strikes a balance between two very different worlds; that of drama (where we seek interesting stories and characters) and that of comedy (where we often prioritise our emotional response over any continuous emotional attachment, hence the sketch show format).

To me, the best sitcoms have always been the ones that make you hurt with laughter but also cry with joy. You attach yourself to certain characters not just because we find them funnier than others on screen, but because we want to see them happy themselves. As bad as Blackadder was, and he was extremely terrible to the majority of people he came across, we wanted him to succeed in his endeavours.

Unfortunately this list is going to look at the other end of the spectrum. For as the sitcom has potential to make you care more than you expected going in, it can also hurt you by delivering a sudden, canned-laughter haltingly serious smack of drama while you€™re trying to lighten your mood. And let€™s face it, we love it. There isn€™t anything quite like your favourite show coming out of left field with an emotional body blow and these ten entries did it best. (My apologies for some entries not having videos attached, the internet does not always easily oblige, but those that do have clips attached are at the bottom of their entries)

Let€™s begin with...


10. Scrubs €“ Ben Sullivan Dies

10 ben

And you thought the Sixth Sense had ruined the whole €˜he€™s dead the whole time€™ schtick? Nope and of all the shows to pull it off, it€™s the one based in a hospital. Brendan Fraser, perhaps best remembered as €˜that guy from the Mummy films€™ (sadly, rather than his role in Crash) appears for a few episodes as Ben Sullivan, brother of Jordan and best friend of Doctor Cox. He joshes around for a while until they do a serious angle where he gets treatment for leukemia. Then he isn€™t seen for two series before the series three episode €˜My Screwup€™, where JD informs Doctor Cox that a patient has died and JD€™s skills are doubted more than usual for the entire episode. Constantly berated by Doctor Cox, Ben is the only one who manages to talk him into forgiving JD before we find out that Ben was the patient all along, and the two of them attend Ben€™s funeral at the episode€™s end.

http://youtu.be/k1dV1lhmouA?t=3m15s

It might be easy to say you can see this kind of thing coming, but the episodes does a great job showing Ben while covering up that he€™s dead the whole time. It€™s only when you re-watch the episode when you realise nobody except Doctor Cox talks to Ben. It manages a sneaky piece of misdirection when Elliot turns her back to stop Ben€™s antics (joking around behind her) but she actually doesn€™t see anything at all. We even get Doctor Cox to the graveyard without the audience catching on. The whole main cast are going to throw a birthday party in a park for Doctor Cox€™s son, Jack and the dialogue is filled with lines like €œwe€™re making sure everything€™s ready€ and €œare you going to show up later?€


9. Only Fools And Horses - The Boys Get Rich

time on our hands Del Boy and Rodders conquered the British TV screens through the €˜80s with their swindling ways to try and make it rich. The attitude of €˜this time next year we€™ll be millionaires€™ was the constant undercurrent for the show even through all of its romantic and family based storylines, which yielded more than it€™s share of comedy gems. Del Boy falling through the bar is still astonishingly funny. Alas, we€™re not just here to laugh and it was the 1996 Christmas episode Time On Our Hands that finally gave the Trotter boys the millions they wanted. It€™s oddly quite satisfying to see them find their fortune. Del Boy€™s money making efforts weren€™t always right and certainly not always successful so when he luckily happens upon an 18th century Harrison marine watch while clearing out a garage, everything seems to have come up peachy. They sell the watch, getting over three million pounds each and we get a nice little montage of them living the life of luxury. But not all is well. Del Boy, Rodney and Uncle Albert meet back at the flat in Peckham one last time before they sell it on and Del Boy wants to keep on trading. He can€™t enjoy his retirement and wants the excitement of his old life. It€™s the classic case of the thrill being in the chase rather than the capture and there€™s a real sadness to the line €œTrotters Independent Traders has ceased trading€.

8. Friends - They Leave The Apartment Empty

8 friends You know a show ending is a big deal when people across the globe feel it. The finale of Friends wasn€™t just massive in America (with a whopping 52.46 million people making it the fourth most watched show finale ever) but over here too, with E4 launching a big campaign for people to watch the end. We watched the cast grow up not only on screen but in real life too from a ragtag group of misfits struggling to get by in the city with their crappy jobs to responsible adults with marriages, careers and kids. Well, maybe not Joey. The last episode has its share of laughs, especially seeing Rachel squabble with a pre-Community Jim Rash about the amount of phalanges the plane has, but the last scene is surely a tear-jerker, no matter if you watched it live or on one of the countless repeats. Like the previous entry, we have our gang looking around their old home, but let€™s face it. The finale of each character in Friends is much more earned than Only Fools and Horses. The Trotters found the watch by luck, but Chandler, Phoebe, Monica, Joey, Ross and Rachel lived through years of change to get to the point where they€™re all ready to leave each other behind. Chandler and Monica are adopting their kids, Phoebe€™s married Mike, Ross and Rachel finally got it together. And Joey? We can only imagine what wacky, hilarious and spinoff-worthy adventures he got up to.

7. The Simpsons - And Maggie Makes Three

7 simpsons

Years and years ago, before The Simpsons was this monumental, never-ending force that might just outlive us all, it was simply the best comedy show on television. As little as the show€™s characters have progressed (admittedly not every show needs this, with South Park adopting a similar strategy) the antics of Homer and his family always made us laugh. The rebellious Bart, straight-A Lisa and grounded Marge form a brilliant circle to surround the madcap adventures of fan favourite Homer. But what about the smallest Simpson? Maggie barely has any lines in the over-twenty year history of the show, so how do we spotlight her when the inevitable flashback episode rolls around in the form of And Maggie Makes Three?

In heartbreaking fashion, it would seem. When Bart and Lisa ask why Maggie isn€™t in the family photo album, we flashback to Homer and Marge safely and happily raising two kids. Homer has paid off his debts and quits his job at the nuclear power plant to have his dream job working in a bowling alley. It isn€™t much, but Homer relishes it. So what happened? How did the perfect family dissolve into the world€™s favourite dysfunctional one? Maggie was born.

Once Maggie comes along, Homer can€™t support a family with three kids. He€™s forced to quit the bowling alley and go back to his old job at the power plant, where Mr. Burns forces him to crawl through a cat flap and places a large plaque in front of his work place reading €œDon€™t forget: you€™re here forever€. It€™s a tremendously sad moment where, for all intents and purposes, Homer€™s life has been ruined. Is this why Maggie isn€™t in the photo album? No. It€™s because all of Maggie€™s pictures are at Homer€™s workplace, blocking out sections of the plaque to now read €œDo it for her€.


6. Blackadder Goes Forth - Going Over The Top

ba3.JPG

Blackadder is some of the finest comedy the BBC has offered. It brilliantly navigates a different historical period every season which prevents the show from becoming predictable and supplies an ever changing set of characters, settings and plot possibilities. One thing in the history books you can€™t escape from, however, is death. The finale of each Blackadder manages to off at least one of the main characters and when Blackadder Goes Fourth brought our favourites to the Great War, we knew the end was not going to be pretty.

In fact it was beautiful and touching. Teased throughout the rest of the season, the finale seals the fates of Blackadder and his friends. They€™re finally going over the top. When Blackadder€™s plan to escape by pretending to be mad comes up short, the men line up in the trenches. Baldrick, like always, has a cunning plan, but this time it will have to wait. All that€™s left is to see Blackadder, Baldrik, George and Darling run out in slow motion, a quick look at the empty trenches and the last images are of a peaceful poppy field.

Not bad considering this classic moment was constructed because the final scene looked unconvincing on the artificial set. Rather than the intended use of a straight forward take, the post production team slowed the footage down, added the music and then grabbed the images of the poppy field to make arguably the greatest show finale in TV history.


5. The Office €“ Michael Leaves

5 office The US version of The Office had a rocky start, falling early into the trap every American adaptation faces, too similar a product seems like a senseless reshoot and too different loses the purpose of it being an adaptation. Season two and three, however, firmly cemented its style and character dynamics in their own way and it went from strength to strength. It also had its fair share of classic moments. Pam and Jim€™s wedding is awesomely silly and romantic and I genuinely love Michael and Holly ending up together. But once Michael and Holly get engaged, Michael announces he is leaving. The next couple of episodes are something of a retrospective (though thankfully not resorting to a clip show) of Michael€™s relationships with his co-workers, them even writing a song for him working out how many minutes he€™s worked there for (9,986,000 which is lovingly followed by €œthat€™s like watching Die Hard 80,000 times€). When it comes time for the big goodbye, however, Michael chooses to leave a day before his official last day. The office jokes they€™ll give him a proper goodbye tomorrow and Michael takes one last look at them before silently leaving forever. It€™s a tremendously emotional exit because Michael is so often inserting himself into other people€™s business and wanting to be the centre of attention. Often, obviously, this is inappropriate and comedic but now the attention turns to Michael as he leaves, he shuns the spotlight and ducks out early. Michael even reminds us, as it was so easy to forget while watching the show, that the whole thing is a documentary being filmed, so he naturally takes off his microphone. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yZ-a1csRWhQ The last image we have is that of Pam hunting Michael down before he gets on his plane, them hugging and Pam watching the plane take off.

4. How I Met Your Mother - Season One Finale Come On

4 Marshal

Before it seemingly abandoned the unique premise that set it apart from typical sitcoms (and became one itself), How I Met Your Mother seemed to be on the way to becoming quite a dramatic canned laughter comedy. Following Ted recount the story of how he met his soul mate, even if we all ended up liking Marshall and Barney a lot more than him along the way, gave us the end of the story meaning we were constantly guessing how the events in the show fit into the endgame. In season one Ted is infatuated with Robin and, despite numerous signs that he should just give up, does everything he can to try and win her heart, including the finale€™s wonderful yet still hokey moment of Ted performing a rain dance to cancel Robin€™s camping trip which actually works.

It€™s a classic rom-com moment crammed into a sitcom, rain and all (rain makes anything more dramatic) which is all well and good but the real impact of this episode comes from the Marshal-Lilly relationship. As Ted ends his season-long pining for Robin in triumph and thinks he€™s met the girl of his dreams, he takes a cab ride through NYC and arrives back at his apartment with a smile on his face €“ and his best friend alone holding his ex-fiancée€™s engagement ring. It€™s a tremendous gut-punch for a show whose very premise is founded on finding true love to end its first season with breaking up its most stable relationship (Lilly and Marshal). And all of it set to Bloc Party€™s bittersweet song, €œModern Love€.


3. Diff€™rent Strokes €“ Dudley Is Almost Molested

3 diff Diff€™rent Strokes maybe isn€™t the most recognisable show to us Brits, but when a show starts an episode with a message explaining that they€™re about to feature ideas of paedophilia, it kind of has to make it onto a list of serious sitcom moments. In fact Diff€™rent Strokes had a habit of featuring €˜very special episodes€™ in which serious topics were dealt with. From hitchhiking and bulimia to epilepsy and kidnapping, it seems nothing was off limits to be used in a Diff€™rent Strokes episode. Of course, it manages to still dish out comedy moments in the middle of teaching you a lesson, but in The Bicycle Man, child main characters Arnold and Dudley befriend Mr. Horton, a bicycle shop owner. Mr Horton then proceeds to show the boys x-rated cartoons and magazines, gives them wine to drink and takes photographs of the boys with their shirts off. Just writing this makes me uncomfortable and you can tell the studio audience don€™t really want to laugh at the jokes packed into the script. Watch the scenes if you want, but even if you don€™t, just know no other sitcom ever quite got as dark as this. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pHHe4zKdZuI

2. Fresh Prince of Bel Air - Papa€™s Got a Brand New Excuse

top-5-seriados-the-fresh-prince-of-bel-air-got-sin-01 Can a great performance be called such when the actor is meant to be playing himself? Regardless of what you think of Will Smith€™s acting capabilities, he can play Will Smith very well. The Fresh Prince of Bel-Air was a smash hit and it€™s hard to find someone in their twenties that can€™t sing the theme song on command (double points if you know past the first verse into the album version). What a lot of people forget is that the show had some quite dark moments, ranging from Will getting shot to Hilary€™s fiancée dying in a bungee jumping accident while he proposes to her on TV. The best moment, however, falls somewhere between getting mugged and somebody dying. In €˜Papa€™s Got A Brand New Excuse€™, Will€™s dad, Lou, comes back into his life after Lou abandoned him as a child. And that€™s just the premise. The final scene sees Lou walking out on Will€™s life again, but this time he doesn€™t get such a clean break. Will is expecting to take a long trip with Lou and sees right through his ploy of needing to €˜take care of some business€™. What follows is Will going off on an emotional tirade of showing how he€™s grown up without his dad and he€™ll keep on going, becoming a far better man than his father before showing just a tiny chink in his resolve with €œHow come he don€™t want me, man?€

1. Futurama - Luck of the Fryrish and Jurassic Bark

1 fry It really is too close to call. Futurama pulled off two of the best endings to sitcom episodes of all time and this is totally disregarding any of the smaller ones in the show€™s history. These just happen to include us finding out Hermes was meant to disassemble Bender due to him being made faulty but defying his job to save the infant Bender€™s life and Fry spelling out €œI love you, Leela€ in space. That€™s right. The show that had a character move the very stars themselves to spell out a love letter somehow topped itself. Twice. Both of them involve Fry in an episode long search for a piece of his past life and realising he won€™t get them for very different reasons. Luck of the Fryrish sees Fry seeking his lucky seven leaf clover and ending up consumed with anger as his brother, Yancy, appears to have stolen the clover and the life Fry should€™ve had in the past. He even appears to have taken Fry€™s name when a biographical film shows the life of a Phillip J. Fry who was the first man on Mars. Furious, Fry takes off for the gravesite to take back his clover and finds that Yancy has in fact named his son Phillip in Fry€™s honour after he was frozen. The grave to Phillip J. Fry II reads €œNamed for his uncle, to carry on his spirit€ and Fry leaves the clover with his nephew as €˜Don€™t You (Forget About Me)€™ plays. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=A5peiLlHdvo It€™s a tossup for biggest unexpected tearjerker between this and Jurassic Bark, wherein Fry seeks to clone his old dog, Seymour, which has become fossilised. When the process starts and Fry learns Seymour died aged fifteen, twelve years after Fry was frozen, he decides Seymour lived long enough to forget him and he should just move on. Cut to the most heart wrenching thing imaginable, a montage showing Seymour never left the outside of the pizzeria Fry worked, even as the world around him grows older and he finally rests his head and closes his eyes. If that doesn€™t get you, then I€™m afraid you have no soul. What do you think? Any classic sitcom moments missed off the list? Which sitcoms right now have the biggest gut-punch potential. Leave any and all comments below.

In this post: 
Friends
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

A Cinema and Photography graduate whose media exposure has amounted to little more than an amateur comics society podcast and a one minute radio discussion about cantaloupe melons. Reader of Vertigo, watcher of Doctor Who, lover of everything film. Tweet in his direction @Story24