10 Shows That Prove BBC Three's Cancellation Is Actually A Good Thing

Everything from Danny Dyer searching for UFOs to the downright despicable Hotter Than My Daughter.

When it was announced earlier this year that BBC Three would cease broadcasting as a channel, the media response was predictable. Some of it focused on the better end of the channel€™s output- including documentaries such as Our War, or comedy like Him & Her- but most of it attacked its worst excesses, in the form of lifestyle programmes like Snog Marry Avoid. The thing about BBC Three is that it was an easy target. As a channel for young people, it was never going to have the critical admiration of its loftier sibling, BBC Four, and most of its critics were not equipped to understand the appeal of a bitchy supercomputer that gives fashion tips. That critical perception of the channel wasn€™t entirely accurate, but it did make it seem like the obvious choice to shunt online. That said, there were more than a few occasions when cancelling BBC Three seemed like a good thing. And these are they:

10. I Believe In UFOs: Danny Dyer (2010)

You can imagine why this one-off was commissioned- UFO documentaries always draw in a few million credulous souls. One of those souls being professional Cockney Danny Dyer, usually to be found making lists of Britain€™s deadliest men. Until this one-off documentary, he had shown no interest in UFOs or aliens. Thank Gort he did, though, because this is the best worst thing BBC Three has ever broadcast. After a symbolic passing of the torch from Sir Patrick Moore, our restless cosmic pioneer heads to America (€œUFO capital of the world€ in his words) to prove his completely baseless opinions. He tries to play the hardman with various balding UFO enthusiasts (€œWhat a mad cat!€ he says about a man with his t-shirt tucked into his jeans), but it doesn€™t take much to render him slack-jawed in confusion. If you can pull off a fake alien bobbing about in blurry camcorder footage, fine, but he€™s equally eager to conflate a fleck of dust on a telescope lens with final proof of extra-terrestrial life. Dyer€™s passion and willingness to accept anything at face value (€œSo I did it. I finally saw an unidentified flyin€™ object.€ he concludes after seeing some nondescript lights) turns potentially hackneyed fare into a genuine voyage of discovery. Hats off to him- not many people would be brave enough to pick up a paycheque for any old tat. I mean exposing themselves to ridicule on national television.

9. Great Movie Mistakes (2010-)

Every channel needs filler, and there are only so many times you can repeat Family Guy (actually, best not tempt fate). That doesn€™t excuse the joyless Great Movie Mistakes, which has lingered on the margins of BBC Three like a pub quiz bore on a party cruise. Nobody wants it there, and nobody acknowledges it, but every once in a while you lock eyes, and realise that one day, that€™ll be you. The format is recession-bustingly simple. Bloopers from familiar Hollywood movies are played and a funny person narrates. The original funny person was Robert Webb, whose career has benefitted from a mysterious decree that he will always be in work, despite being Coldplay€™s idea of a good comedian. More recently it€™s been the sketch troupe Pappy€™s, and the show now has a framing device that removes the sense it was cobbled together five minutes before airtime. Unfortunately, Pappy€™s are Coldplay€™s idea of a funny sketch troupe, but even George Carlin would struggle to wring laughs out of the changing direction of Nicolas Cage€™s forelock. We all like spotting the occasional blooper- it makes us feel superior to people who earn our wage in thirty seconds- but Great Movie Mistakes sucks the fun dry. It tries to be a laugh, like that pub quiz bore after a few tequilas€but you still saw it sitting in the lifeboat, crying bitter tears because Taylor Lautner€™s chinos go from crimson to maroon between shots. And that€™s something you never wanted to see.

8. Torchwood (2006)

Torchwood wasn€™t just a Doctor Who spin-off that originally aired on BBC Three. It was very much BBC Three€™s idea of what Doctor Who should be. So instead of a largely sexless space Jehovah travelling through the fifth dimension, we had a team of generically troubled sex-bunnies investigating mildly weird things in Cardiff City Centre. In this sense, Torchwood actually had more in common with Snog Marry Avoid than the children€™s own show that adults love. In this sense, it was also terrible. The problem was that creator Russell T Davies assumed an adult version of Doctor Who meant gratuitous sex scenes and€well, more gratuitous sex scenes. Many an episode was disrupted by a pointless hook-up between protagonist Captain Jack and the Welsh one/the speccy one/the other Welsh one/the wonky mouthed one/the alien of the week (mix and match until credibility is broken). Bracing fare for a thirteen year old boy whose idea of raunch was a JPG of Jessica Alba€™s head teetering precariously atop some porno hardbody. For the rest of us, it felt like Davies was clumsily inserting naughty bits into otherwise generic, b-pile Who scripts. The move to primetime BBC One allowed RTD to nail the concept, and the six part mini-series Children of Earth felt like a properly adult take on Doctor Who€™s themes. BBC Three€™s genre output also improved immeasurably, although the sight of panto icon John Barrowman grunting his way through endless quickies didn€™t exactly set the bar high.

7. Most Annoying People (2006-2011)

By the mid-00s, TV€™s great obsession with elephantine, supposedly definitive lists (Top 100 Movies, Top 100 Albums, Top 100 Numbers) had been thoroughly derided, but the format wasn€™t dead. Like a threatened insect, it hid in the danker corners of the EPG and sprouted claws, crawling out annually in BBC Three€™s Most Annoying People. Appropriately named- for the wrong reason- Most Annoying People was a rundown of media fly-by nights who had riled the public at large over the course of the year. To do this, Three enlisted a cohort of desperate stand-up comedians who would die happy to be remembered as fly-by nights. Never has the term €˜talking head€™ been less apt- these wretches gibbered, simpered and shrieked the jokes they€™d been fed, all in the hope that at least one jaded Yuletide punter would remember them in time for their mediocre Fringe show. Difficult targets like Jim Davidson and Nick Griffin seemed scarily reasonable compared to these poor wraiths. As for the triumphant €˜Most Annoying People€™, none were half as bad as their vapid tormenters. Amy Winehouse, 2007€™s winner, was jokily chastised for drunken antics, because it€™s not like anyone ever died of alcoholism, is it? 2011€™s winner was the London rioters, a strangely reactionary decision from the channel of Sun, Sex and Suspicious Parents. And few people can remember 2008€™s champion Agyness Deyn, let alone muster impatience with her. In chasing the media dragon, BBC Three became the very thing they claimed to hate- annoying.

6. Hotter Than My Daughter (2010-2011)

When The Daily Mail wanted to criticise BBC Three, shows like Snog Marry Avoid were held up as a €˜shameless waste of the licence fee€™. Now, while such programmes have an element of the freak show, they do the job of catering to their young, female-centric viewership, and usually contain an empowering message. That said, there€™s an exception to every rule, and in this case that would be Hotter Than My Daughter. Hotter Than My Daughter was about putting women in their place. Across fourteen episodes that somebody felt worthy of commissioning, the show€™s monologue at femininity ran thusly: €˜Middle aged woman in a cocktail dress? You look like a stripper. Wear a cardigan instead. Young woman who likes t-shirts? Stop dressing like a ten year old boy. Start dressing like the mannequins in Topshop.€™ It was all presented breezily enough with plenty of footage of your mum on the razz, but there€™s no getting away from how dubious the basic premise was. Throughout, the mother and daughter relationship was constantly portrayed as fractious, and the solution as the capitalist fantasy of a Miss Selfridge€™s gift voucher. No attempt was made to address potentially more serious issues dividing these women. Just as long as they ended up dressing age appropriately, everything was right with the fairer sex and the credits could roll. And you wonder- what problem could The Daily Mail possibly have had with any of that?!

5. Two Pints Of Lager And A Packet Of Crisps (2003-2011)

From the lumpen title to the mad-for-it theme tune, Two Pints lurched through Three€™s schedules like a zombified Gallagher brother. In both form and content, it was about ten years out of date. Quick tip- if you€™re going to write a sitcom about twentysomethings, it would probably be helpful to avoid the formula of every other crappy studio comedy from the last half century, i.e. characters bellowing one liners at each other, eruptions of canned laughter underscoring their every moronic Northernism. The premise of the show? Hard to say, since by series three it felt like it had been with us since the Reformation, but going to the pub and nookie were standard plot elements. That€™s what young folk do, int it? Although the cast here only just resembled young folk. There was Ralf Little, previously the silent one in The Royle Family, justifying that earlier creative decision. €˜Sparking€™ off him was Will Mellor, who has always and will always look like that. Two rubbish girls from Hollyoaks and Sheridan Smith- who actually managed to build a career after this- rounded out the forgettable fivesome. It lumbered on till 2011, by which time Him & Her had demonstrated the correct way to do this sort of thing. The tragedy is that not one of Two Pints€™ millions of viewers can remember a single joke from seven infuriatingly blokey series.

4. Russell Howard's Good News (2009-)

What we have here is humorous clips, from the news, interspersed with gags from the host. It€™s not a particularly new format, nor is it particularly compelling, yet it€™s run to eight series with a ninth- presumably the last- to air next year. The credit/blame for this must fall on the man in the title, Russell Howard. Howard epitomises the modern comic. He purveys that type of post-Gervaisian politically incorrect humour which is pretty much standard nowadays, but he does it in a relentlessly chirpy fashion, never challenging or undercutting the expectations of the viewer. In other words, he wants us to like him, to the extent that many shows end with some heart-warming news item that he earnestly refuses to take the pee-pee out of. Even his appearance, which is the same as any twentysomething man in a student union, screams conformity. Because of this, we have a topical comedy programme that manages the rare feat of completely bypassing satire. Howard never mocks politicians for their deeds- in fact, most of the time he comes up with completely spurious joke that he actually has to explain to the audience. Who laugh anyway. All of this is why he€™s the channel€™s biggest star. It also says a lot about BBC Three, a channel that too often appears relevant in only the most superficial ways. And that€™s the reason it was the first head on the chopping block, which is bad news for Russell Howard, really.

3. Lee Nelson's Well Good Show

BBC Three did itself no favours anointing Lee Nelson as its de facto mascot. His omnipresence confirmed the broadsheet stereotype of a broadcaster ruthlessly pursuing the lowest common denominator. More damning, though, was that it resulted in zero laughs. Not even a jaded cackle. Which begs the question- why Lee Nelson? Because€because Lee Nelson was really Simon Brodkin, a multi-award winning stand-up comedian. With comedy culture dominated by mop-headed oafs, it€™s gongs- not, y€™know, actual comic ability- that determine merit, although to be fair on him, Brodkin isn€™t terrible. He€™s enthusiastic, his timing is decent, and at least he€™s not an Oxbridge wiseguy. On the debit side, Lee Nelson was literally just Ali G without satire. He was a white man who acted like a black man. What was then known as a chav, and is now known as, er, Britain€™s growing underclass. Brodkin€™s only experience of same was when his taxi took a wrong turn through a (slightly) rough part of town en route to him introducing Hard Fi at the O2 Academy. Probably. Regardless, it€™s all a bit iffy. All a bit class war-y. Which is probably why BBC Three did push him so hard. For the zappucino guzzling executive hive-mind, a backwards cap and happy slapping signified topicality, while the complete lack of comic innovation allowed it to be background telly for self-aware chavs. And in its deeply clapped out way, the show represented an authentic missive from the soft cruelties of coalition-threatened Britain. So yeah. QUALITEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

2. Sexy Beasts (2014)

Sexy Beasts is BBC Three€™s magnificent apotheosis and its dizzying plummet into the abyss. So ingeniously banal in conception, and so overwhelmingly mediocre in execution, it can only be interpreted as an act of seppuku committed by a legion of gak-crazed commissioning editors. It€™s also the only time Satan has been incarnated as a socially inept Geordie bodybuilder, which is exactly how the channel had to die. It consists of two ideas smooshed together and pursued with autistic determination. That first idea barely constitutes sentient thought- €˜it€™s a dating show, right?€™ The second is just witless- €˜but they€™re wearing make-up, yeah?€™ Which would be passable TV if the make-up weren€™t rubbish. But it is. It makes Guy Pearce€™s old man mask in Prometheus look like the definition of verisimilitude. On a show like this, where it€™s the central conceit, it ruins the implied tension. We€™re supposed to believe that one of these nomarks might be John Merrick€™s inbred cousin, but the prosthetics conform so closely to their faces you can tell they have to memorise a phone book€™s worth of numbers before a night out. BBC Three clearly applied the gimmick because simply filming hotties on dates has already been done by Channel Four. It could still have been funny and surprising, but the unconvincing make-up- not to mention a rote structure- makes it predictable and tedious. Admittedly, the two episodes broadcast were only pilots, but with the channel now marking time, why bother diverting resources to a series?

1. Horne And Corden (2009)

Our titular funsters step into the studio as teachers, which is funny because they€™re dressed in funny clothes and the studio audience laughs because they think it€™s funny. From the preamble it sounds like they€™re going to teach sex ed. And then they say more funny things and you think maybe there€™s going to be a big funny twist and the sketch will go in a completely unexpected direction. Which it does, when Corne and Horden ritually behead each other with rusty kebab skewers. Which it does, when they roll down a blackboard to teach the kids how to draw a penis. And it€™s funny, because the studio audience laughs, and it has two chalk-drawn testicles and a chalk-drawn shaft. But for some reason Crom doesn€™t know what the helmet of a penis looks like, even though the point of the sketch is that they are teaching kids to draw penises. It looks a bit like a chicken drumstick, which is wrong and not good but still maybe funny but not really because it€™s dire and thought up in about twenty seconds and I€™m not talking about the sketch I€™m talking about the whole programme and the awful bit where Horda runs around and is fat and the awful bit where Com is a gayman or Superman or whatever and draws a penis that looks like a chicken drumstick on a blackboard in front of kids. Horne and Corden starred Matthew Horne and James Corden. It ran for six episodes.

In this post: 
BBC Three
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

I am Scotland's 278,000th best export and a self-proclaimed expert on all things Bond-related. When I'm not expounding on the delights of A View to a Kill, I might be found under a pile of Dr Who DVDs, or reading all the answers in Star Wars Trivial Pursuit. I also prefer to play Playstation games from the years 1997-1999. These are the things I like.