10 Television Shows That Hated Their Own Fanbases
Don't worry about packing your sun cream, there's a whole lot of shade coming...
If you get a solid fanbase to root for your show, you can stay on the air for years! Your ratings go up, you trend on Twitter every time a new season or episode is released and get to enjoy the feelings of people appreciating your art.
So, with all that said, any showrunner, actor or crew member should be eternally grateful to their fanbase, right?
Well, you have to take into consideration the fact that not all fanbases serve you well. Maybe they love your show at first but then seemingly forget it exists and your ratings plummet to the point of cancellation. There's also the ever-present existence of toxic fanbases that gatekeep your show, fight with other fandoms and give you and your precious series a bad name that you can't control.
Those are pretty good reasons to hate your own fanbase.
But there are also some showrunners, some writing teams, and even some privileged actors that pettily hate the fanbases of their tv shows for seemingly no good reason. And they're not afraid to show it, whether that be through subtle dialogue, callous character deaths or completely unsubtle, downright rude public outbursts.
10. Supernatural - Constant Meta Shadiness
The long-running horror tv show Supernatural is known for many things (one being how long-running it actually was), but probably one of its most controversial aspects is how meta the show can get.
Of course, there is nothing inherently wrong with a show that plays with meta-comedy (Community did that very well until it didn't, but we'll get to that.) There was just something about the meta episodes of Supernatural that seemed to rub some fans the wrong way... and for good reason.
While the series dips its toes in the meta-pool constantly throughout its run, it is the show's introduction of the Supernatural book series that managed to make its self-referential nature a little bit sour.
Meta works when you're poking fun at yourself because self-awareness is endearing, but this ribbing becomes less fun when it's at the expense of your dedicated fanbase. The introduction of the fan-worshipped novels led to the introduction of the Supernatural fanbase in the show, which could have been so cool...
But the series doesn't exactly show them in a positive light. The fans are portrayed as creepy, obsessive sadsacks that Sam and Dean look down on. They ship the brothers together, they're pushy and possessive of the material and one fan consistently sexually harasses Sam, going as far as to put a love spell on him! Don't even get me started on the musical episode!
It was very clear from the constant negative depictions of the fanbase that the showrunners were less than happy about their avid viewers.
9. Community - Is It Really The Audience's Fault That Your Show Died?
Community, one of the best sitcoms of recent memory, had some high highs that's for sure. Comparatively though, it also had some extremely low moments. Yes, we can blame the messy behind the scenes rivalry between Dan Harmon and Chevy Chase. We could also place blame on the toxic workplace showrunner Dan Harmon has himself admitted to having festered. But there is something to be said for the financial struggle the show continually found itself in.
By the final season's air, it was pretty obvious that we were watching a series dead in the water. Community, having regained Harmon as showrunner the season before, had just been cancelled by NBC; something all involved felt was a long time coming. But thanks to the fans' outcry of love, Yahoo Screening picked it up.
But the season we got felt off. Yes, it was nowhere near the monstrosity that was the Harmon-less season 4, but it just didn't feel right. The jokes were abstract in an incomprehensible way, the characters were all at rock bottom, and the high concept original episodes had been replaced with rehashes of popular past ones. It felt as though Harmon and the writers resented being renewed once again.
This all culminated in a series finale that revolved around firing shots at fans that desperately wanted more and at the actors that had left the show unceremoniously, with each character picking holes in the concept of a season 7. So much for fans bringing back their favourite show.
8. You - You're Not Supposed To Like Joe!
This one doesn't have to be perceived and interpreted through the show's dialogue, You's literal star has gone on record to state his disdain for fans of the Netflix thriller. Course he doesn't hate all of You's fan's, just the thirsty ones.
You see, Penn Badgley, the lucky man who landed the role of psycho stalker Joe Goldberg, is not the ugliest of serial killers. In fact, he's pretty darn sexy. This, obviously, isn't a surprise to any tv and film watchers as Hollywood seems jam-packed with the world's best-looking creatures. Look no further than the geeky-girl-in-glasses-until-she-gets-a-makeover trope.
But the problem with You lies in the attractiveness of its star, although this wouldn't be a problem if fans weren't so freaky.
All of this to say, instead of being repulsed by creepy Joe and his sinister internal monologue, fans were as unhealthily obsessed with him as he was with his prey.
Badgley has repeatedly shut down fans on Twitter, Instagram and even in press interviews, telling them that they're interpreting the show wrong. At this point, you can clearly hear the hatred and resentment in his witty yet blunt responses online.
7. Lost - The Fans Made It Run Too Long
Lost is often considered a bad show, but when it first began its potential was palpable and immediately people were sure it was going to be one of the best shows ever made. So what happened?
Well, the main problem with Lost was that it got, well, lost, in its end game. Around season three, the story progression seemingly halted and episode after episode became nonsensical filler for a story that seemed to have stopped progressing.
And I'm sorry to tell you, it was all your fault. No, not you specifically, the royal you. The fanbase. It was just too big!
Lost was planned from start to finish when it was originally pitched to networks, and it was only supposed to run for a few seasons, Twin Peaks style. But the network got greedy because they'd never seen a fanbase so massive. Lost was a literal cultural phenomenon!
So, all of a sudden, stories were having to be made to extend its run and there are only so many flashbacks you can pull out of your ass before you scrape the bottom of the toilet clean.
The creators to this day begrudge how they were pushed into extending the show. And let's be honest they are right to be, the fans were desperate for the series to keep going, but then got mad that it wasn't as good anymore and continue to s**t on it even now for the mess it became. Not the best fanbase really.
6. Supergirl - Toxic Fanbase Or Queerbaiting?
If you've dipped into the Supergirl fandom for more than ten seconds then you've heard of Supercorp. For those of you that have somehow avoided the show and its dedicated fanbase, Supercorp is a fanmade ship between main characters Kara and Lena. Kara, the powerful Kryptonian Supergirl, and Lena, her best friend and sister to supervillain Lex Luther.
At the beginning of the show, fans and the cast and crew got along swimmingly, everyone was on the same side and were all rooting for the same things. That was until Lena Luthor was introduced in season 2. Immediately fans were enraptured by the chemistry between the two actresses and the fanfiction community was changed for good.
The only problem was that Lena hadn't been introduced to become Kara's love interest. In reality, another actor had been introduced to fill that role: the Supergirl actress's now-husband Chris Wood. And while the two were getting to know each other in the romantic sense, off-screen and on, fans were campaigning for Supercorp to become canon.
The showrunners and cast did not like that. In fact, beloved members of the cast came under fire after openly bashing the ship and its followers during an interview. And while the cast members in question eventually gave a begrudging apology, the fact that Supercorp never became canon (the show ending as I write this) proves that they never seriously considered the fans' opinions.
5. Pretty Little Liars - An Audience Too Smart For The Writers
By the end of Pretty Little Liars' 7-season run, there were lots of issues. Questions left unanswered, plot holes left unfilled and clues left on the cutting room floor in lieu of shocking twists. The latter pretty much caused all the other problems, and it's all because of the writers desperate need to be smarter than the fans.
The first 5 seasons somehow managed to get away with the ludicrous story, including the fact that 47 episodes all take place in the span of one month (work that math out). But the A reveal in season 6 finally put the nail in the coffin.
You see, fans of Pretty Little Liars were dedicated. They spent countless hours watching the show, picking apart every clue and then going online to share theories with each other. Leading up to the reveal, every clue had been cross-referenced and dissected to the point where fans knew more about the show than the showrunner and writers did, and they had a pretty good idea of who A was.
The writers did not like that! They'd written themselves into a corner and had no way out, they desperately wanted to outsmart their audience over everything else. So they created a nonsensical, plot-hole-heavy and downright offensive A reveal.
And when fans called them out on their truly terrible efforts, pointing out how it literally did not make sense timeline-wise, the showrunner attempted to gaslight them into believing they hadn't watched what they thought they had. It was a narcissistic mess.
4. Teen Wolf - Yet Another Case Of Queerbaiting
Yet another case of queerbaiting that ended up isolated the fan's from their favourite show.
Teen Wolf was a hit MTV teen drama in the 2010s. A show beloved by many for several different reasons including endearing characters, juicy drama and iconic ships. Ships like Scallison, Stydia, Stalia and Sterek. But one of those ships is not like the other. You see, Sterek, the cutsie nickname given to the pairing of Stiles and Derek, only truly existed in fanfiction. On the show, the two characters never actually get together at any point.
Now obviously, fan-shipping of two characters that never get together isn't uncommon. People see what they want to see and we all look for different things when watching a show. But this was different. You see, the showrunners and actors were well aware of the fans' favourite ship, but unlike the adverse reaction the Supergirl crew had to the ship, Teen Wolf seemed to embrace it.
Subtle clues seemed to start popping up, suggesting that maybe Stiles wasn't completely straight, and more and more scenes between the two characters were written into the show. For a minute there, fans really thought they were gonna get what they wanted.
But then, it all stopped, the characters were paired up with beautiful women and that was the end of it. Fans figured out that the showrunners had used them, and their wants, just to get good ratings. They never really cared about them at all.
3. Agents Of S.H.I.E.L.D - Hashtag Controversy
Twitter may have been the only thing keeping this world together recently when the Facebook blackout hit, but usually, it isn't known for being particularly helpful.
We've all used hashtags in our tweets, it's a great way to sum up your witty comments while obnoxiously attempting to get strangers to acknowledge you. But notoriety isn't always the best attention to gain, and that's a lesson the Agents Of S.H.I.E.L.D fans learnt the hard way.
You see, tv fans love an anti-hero, and usually, the shows are quick to appease them. But when S.H.I.E.L.D showrunners wrote the character, Grant Ward, they weren't really planning a redemption story for him.
Ward was a character that had ties with Hydra and was all-around shady, but fans looked to his abusive childhood as an inclination of his inevitable redemption. But the writers were going to cave into the fan pressure, in fact, when the hashtag "I stand with Ward" started to trend on Twitter, they only stuck to their guns with more determination.
The showrunners wrote into the show a direct reference to the Twitter debacle. Kara, a character that was in an unhealthy relationship with Ward, literally said the line "I will always stand with Ward" only to be shot and killed by him before he joins Hydra for good...
That's one way to deal with pushy fans.
2. Doctor Who - The Shade Is Real
Doctor Who has run for a long time, and has racked up quite a dedicated fanbase during that time. With fans dipping in and out over decades and decades, you're gonna meet a few duds. But surely you'd realise that the few don't represent the many. Well, the Doctor Who showrunners haven't figured that out yet.
You see, much like the previously mentioned Supernatural, Doctor Who has dabbled in meta humour that ended up hurting fans.
Doctor Who is very guilty of inventing characters that very obviously makes fun of the fanbase. You have Whizzkid who was a direct reference to newer fans that weren't alive to watch the original season but who claim that the show "is not as good as it used to be" while still being obsessed with it. And if their stance on those kinds of fans wasn't obvious enough, the brutal demise of Whizzkid for sure solidified their views.
You then have Doctor fangirl Osgood, a sympathetic and beloved character in the fanbase, who was also brutally murdered in the show, showing that the writers found the fans disposable.
And there are so many more occasions of the show sassing the fans, like snarky comments, sly references and evil villains based on certain outspoken fan groups.
1. Heroes - "Saps And Dipsh*ts"
In this circumstance, we don't need to look for subtext in the show's scripts. The show's creator went on the record to air his distaste for his audience.
For those seasoned tv watchers, you will remember the transitional period television went through not so long ago when serial tv started moving over to streaming and on-demand. Back then, most showrunners, writers and cast members that worked on network television begrudged streaming. We see it time and time again when technology advances, people are hesitant to accept the new because they believe the old ways are the best, most authentic ways. So when ratings started to dip for traditional shows, most of the teams working on them felt bitter and angry towards streaming.
Well, that was not the case for Heroes showrunner Tim Kring.
Kring was infamously quoted at an event that he thought the fans that watched his show in real-time were: 'saps and dipsh*ts'. Of course, this did not go down well. Heroes had been in hot water for some time at this point, with crashing ratings and incomprehensible storylines. But this was the nail in the coffin for the show and led it to its inevitable demise.